I’m actually pretty horrified about random parents helping in the office and the information they’re getting hold of…..
Im an advocate for every child in my class. The child with diagnosed autism, the child with undiagnosed but potential signs of autism, the one showing clear signs of dyspraxia, the one receiving speech therapy, the ones who are surrounded by support to do well, the ones who are not, the children who do their best each day and the ones who have no motivation. The children who's parents have separated, the anxious, the over confident, the completely undisciplined, those who are EAL….and those who just carry on.
One of my PSHE intervention groups were playing Buckeroo and Uno the other day and came back to the literacy lesson and caused a flurry “that’s not fair” comments amongst the rest. I explained that it wasn’t just about playing, so there was no need for their comments, and believe me that group will also have to catch up in a different way with the work (true, I had to spread the missed lesson out under the guise of “extension” to cover it). Children won’t grasp why some children are removed for added extras or interventions and will go home and say they are missing out, and yes many need to learn that they have a serious advantage already and basically shouldn’t want to qualify for these groups / trips etc.
We operate a Draw and Talk club for which we invite children to who are going through something like divorce or bereavement. We’ve had complaints that other children are missing out on this “art club”. I get it, parents won’t realise it’s purpose and think they’re child who loves to paint can’t join in. It greatly benefits the children who do go. Maybe others would also benefit but not everyone can and we also use feedback like this to see how to meet others needs too.
This is why the OP needs to find out the reasoning behind the choosing. Is it PP funded? Is it for SEND children? Is it to aid listening skills and communication? Is it just a great extra for children that could benefit the most in various ways? Is it for those they school feel have worked hardest? Is it for high achievers? Is it an award for achievement and effort? Is it completely funded by the PA and random? Forest school can really benefit so many children which is why I would also be a bit upset in this situation if something that ran throughout the year couldn’t be split to give everyone a go because this particular activity is so broad . But OP needs to ask the question.