Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Forest school only for 'select' children

543 replies

Eyelashesrgreat · 25/06/2022 05:18

Ds in Y3 and his school have recently 'selected' children from his class to go to forest school. The children do this weekly whilst the other children have to stay at school and do work. The children (selected) get to wear their own clothes that day and have treats.

The school did the same thing last year and ds wasn't chosen then. Ds has had a really difficult time recently at school and would have loved to have been selected for this activity. I asked his teacher if all the children will eventually get their turn at the forest school but she has said only certain children can go. AIBU to think this is a bit unfair?

OP posts:
justfiveminutes · 26/06/2022 08:20

GlitterSparkley · 25/06/2022 05:41

Not fair at all. Should be all kids or none. I wouldn’t be at all happy if DDs school did this

This is bullshit. Inclusion involves providing what SEN children need in order to level the playing field. Do you want the hearing loop, the guide dog, the wheelchair because it should be every child or none? No, just the stuff that looks fun? Forest School is an intervention for those that need it. You don't need to know why they need it.

manicflamingo😎 · 26/06/2022 07:18

Blu3Butt0n · 26/06/2022 06:05

manicflamingo

Our school buys it in for a small group. No way would there be the time or money for the whole school to do it. There are many interventions that would benefit all in school. Outside of school some kids miss out on many beneficial experiences others take for granted.

That's different to how I understood the OP's situation - I am saying if a school invests in establishing a Forest School on their site everyone should have the opportunity to access it (this might be for differing amounts of sessions).

If a school dedicates part of its's budget to sending smaller specifically identified pupils to an external FS provision - or buys in for that same group for specific reasons that's different.

manicflamingo😎 · 26/06/2022 07:14

toomuchlaundry · 26/06/2022 07:07

@manicflamingo😎 i got the impression the children were going to a Forest school provision, not an area in the school dedicated to Forest school. Yes, if a school has a trained Forest school teacher and an area in the school grounds I would expect most pupils to have access, but if a school was using an external provider then funds would probably make it more likely to be used for intervention purposes.

As your time as a governor have you not seen some pupils have reduced timetables in the school with maybe a day a
week at Forest School or similar Provision to help them access education and reduce the chance of them being a school refuser for example

I interpreted the original post as that school had set up a Forest School not that they were accessing a Forest School provision elsewhere. The latter is very different. I have seen, and do support different approaches to learning, timetables and support offered to individual children based on what they need. I also think if a school invests in having a Forest School (actually on their site) it should be for everyone at the school (not necessarily in equal time measures)- because it has been shown to have such broad benefits and because it is a huge financial investment.

I think we agree then in fact?

toomuchlaundry · 26/06/2022 07:07

@manicflamingo😎 i got the impression the children were going to a Forest school provision, not an area in the school dedicated to Forest school. Yes, if a school has a trained Forest school teacher and an area in the school grounds I would expect most pupils to have access, but if a school was using an external provider then funds would probably make it more likely to be used for intervention purposes.

As your time as a governor have you not seen some pupils have reduced timetables in the school with maybe a day a
week at Forest School or similar Provision to help them access education and reduce the chance of them being a school refuser for example

Runnerbeansflower · 26/06/2022 06:19

If anyone feels their child's needs are not being met in school, then raise that with the school. Push for a formal assessment if you think it is needed.

DD was an in year move to her current school, her previous one wasn't interested in understanding or meeting her needs.

Current school did 6 hours of assessments before she started, she had a personalized timetable from day one, plus identified adults who spent time building a relationship with her. They started the EHCP process after half a term, which involved a bundle of evidence from the school plus various specialist assessments. It was approved at the highest level of funding within 6 months.

This is an ordinary state school (in financial terms), made extraordinary by their ethos.

But please stop complaining about the provision other children get to meet their needs. If your child doesn't need 'interventions' to learn then congratulations, they are ahead of DD and numerous other children in their opportunities and life chances.

Blu3Butt0n · 26/06/2022 06:05

manicflamingo

Our school buys it in for a small group. No way would there be the time or money for the whole school to do it. There are many interventions that would benefit all in school. Outside of school some kids miss out on many beneficial experiences others take for granted.

Runnerbeansflower · 26/06/2022 06:02

Would you apply that logic to other interventions?

DD and another girl get taught maths separately a couple of times per week for various reasons. I am sure that individual attention would benefit all pupils. So you are saying DD shouldn't get the support she needs because others (who are able to learn in the main class) don't get that?

durianeater · 26/06/2022 06:00

Sirzy · 25/06/2022 18:07

She has also said that she has been told there are only 2 pupils with special needs in the whole school. Given the national average is 15% of students having special needs unless it’s a very very small school I just don’t believe that. Even a school with only 20 pupils that would be significantly below abweage

I'm not commenting on the accuracy of what Op claims to have been told. I'm commenting on the repeated claims that the SENCO could be disciplined or even lose their job.

manicflamingo😎 · 26/06/2022 05:38

LadyDanburysCane · 25/06/2022 21:43

@manicflamingo😎 I’m assuming you aren’t one of our school governors! Ours all seem to understand that one of our children needs extra sessions with a very caring counselling trained TA. Her father passed away suddenly and violently at Easter. The family is not poor - in fact his forethought ensured they are actually rather well off BUT a 7 year old girl has lost her Dad and needs care and understanding from someone not involved. It’s not about physically equipping her, it’s about emotionally equipping her.

Personally I don't see a Forest School provision as the same as a 1:1 intervention for a child who has suffered a specific trauma. I would completely support that. Children who had not experienced that or other significiant trauma would not require that intervention/support. My view is that Forest School is an educational opportunity that is likely to benefit every pupil who experiences it- noting the broad success of such programmes in Scandanavian countries. There fore I think if a school sets up a Forest School it should, ideally, be available to all pupils with the focus on extra support being offer to ensure that all can access it fairly.

safclass · 26/06/2022 01:43

Blu3Butt0n · 25/06/2022 06:16

In our school we have this for children who get extra funding. No way could schools afford it gir everybody and the extra funding needs to be utilised for the children it’s allocated to.There are other therapies too and it’s entirely fair. Quite often these children miss out on a lot in life that others do, they will have to suck that up on a daily basis. Forest schools run everywhere. If you’re that bothered join a local one.

At my husband's school whole classes go out but in groups.They have staff trained up who do the sessions.
I don't think all yr groups do it but for those yr groups that do, ALL the children take part.

5zeds · 26/06/2022 01:31

How can anyone learn empathy if you shield them from ever experiencing disappointment, exclusion, or inequality? I think it’s an excellent thing for children to be treated differently to each other.

MichelleScarn · 26/06/2022 00:23

Too much adults there (long day!)

MichelleScarn · 26/06/2022 00:22

Absolutely understand as an adult the difference between equality and equity as an adult,however I think it's a bit sad all these virtue signalling adults so keen to sneer and besmirch kids for not 'getting this' at a young age and hoping they are upset and hurt at not getting access to things "because now you know what it's like".

That's just mean and takes away from you trying to show how much better you seem to think you are.

BoredZelda · 25/06/2022 23:30

My daughter went on a “select” school trip. She he no idea why she was chosen, and what the criteria was, but when she got there she realised they were all children who access the support base in the school for one reason or another. I’m sure kids look at her making things look so easy despite being disabled and wonder why she’d get this treat, but she has had a hell of a year and it was really good for her to let off some steam away from school.

People are rarely as straightforward as it seems, but if you genuinely have an issue with the school and believe there is something going on, raise it. Or move schools.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 25/06/2022 22:00

Eyelashesrgreat · 25/06/2022 12:22

I give up! Yes I do know, it's a very small school. I know the parents well, I know the children well. If someone farts everyone knows about it.

Oh come on, give it just a tiny bit of thought. You know what people choose to tell about themselves. You know what gossips with nothing better to do have whispered to you. You do NOT know everything, by a long shot.

DottyLittleRainbow · 25/06/2022 21:58

My youngest is struggling with pre-school, suspected ASD but no diagnosis yet. Being carried in screaming if we can get them into the nursery at all. It’s not the nursery itself before anyone leaps in on that detail. Really challenging as myself and DH work and it’s been such a struggle on top of their (and our) poor sleep. The nursery have a forest garden where they make sure there’s a space each day - to try and give the routine and because it’s quieter outside so less sensory issues. This has been an absolute godsend and I’m so grateful.

I’d be devastated if another parent thought this was unfair and would rather we received no support at all just to keep things “equal”. I’d give anything for my child to run in happily and not need extra support. I’m so worried about how school will go next year and one of these worries is parents getting uptight about children who need extra support getting extra support, because “but my little Johnny would like that too” even if they may not need it.

Education should be equitable for all, that means all children have the same opportunity to fulfil their potential - some children need more support and nurturing in an educational setting than others, in order to achieve this.

Runnerbeansflower · 25/06/2022 21:48

Another friend is a secondary school teacher. She was incredibly proud that an ex-pupil swam for the UK in the Tokyo Olympics.

That pupil trained for several hours every school day, and had special permission to eat in class because that was the only way they could get enough calories for the training they were doing.

Obviously that was 'unfair' for the pupils who were not allowed to eat in class...

LadyDanburysCane · 25/06/2022 21:43

@manicflamingo😎 I’m assuming you aren’t one of our school governors! Ours all seem to understand that one of our children needs extra sessions with a very caring counselling trained TA. Her father passed away suddenly and violently at Easter. The family is not poor - in fact his forethought ensured they are actually rather well off BUT a 7 year old girl has lost her Dad and needs care and understanding from someone not involved. It’s not about physically equipping her, it’s about emotionally equipping her.

Morph22010 · 25/06/2022 21:40

This thread is exactly why I’m so glad I’ve managed to get my autistic child into a specialist school and he’s longer in mainstream , he now gets all the interventions he needs about managing emotions social situations etc, things that come naturally to other children so they don’t need specific lessons without some other parent wittering on that it’s not fair

Ted27 · 25/06/2022 21:33

@manicflamingo😎

do you understand anything at all about disadvantage?

Disadvantage is not just about economic disadvantage.
I didn’t need schoo to provide my son with wellies and a waterproofs - I can afford those myself.
But the idea that giving a child a pair of wellies and waterproofs would give him and the kids like him the same starting point is laughable and quite frankly demonstrates a staggering lack of understanding.

Sirzy · 25/06/2022 21:17

ladydanbury I posted similar picture earlier in the thread. But the “all children must be treated exactly the same” crew sadly aren’t interested. Obviously can’t look beyond their own child

LadyDanburysCane · 25/06/2022 21:09

Some people need to understand the difference between equality and equity…

Forest school only for 'select' children
Runnerbeansflower · 25/06/2022 20:57

5zeds · 25/06/2022 20:36

I’m so horrified a school governor could say or think that.😱😢

This.

Have been so shocked by this thread I have made a Mumsnet account to comment.

My teen DD is adopted and has numerous diagnoses as a result of her early life with her birth family, including PTSD. Struggles to learn at school because she is triggered into survival mode multiple times every day, and is exhausted by the time she gets home.

Is it 'fair' that she walks out of class whenever she wants without consequences? Shouldn't every child be allowed to walk out of class without consequences?

For DD, she hates being different. She sticks it out in class beyond what is healthy. School ENCOURAGE her to leave before she is overwhelmed and starts thinking of suicide.

If she walks out of class she goes to one of her specified adults, talks the situation through, has space to calm down, and they also support her to make up whatever she has missed by leaving the class.

Equality is NOT about every child being treated the same.

A friend's daughter has a full time 1:1 TA. How unfair is that? If one child has 1:1 adult, every child should have a 1:1adult.

Except my friend's daughter has a genetic condition that results in physical and learning disabilities. She is unlikely to live beyond her late teens/early 20s, and will never live independently.

If your child is struggling at school and needs more support then go in there and advocate for them.

But resenting the additional help available to children who are facing huge barriers that truly are unfair is incredibly selfish.

It isn't fair that DD's life has been changed for the worse by the abuse she experienced. It isn't fair that my friend's DD has disabilities and a life limiting genetic condition. Would you want to swap? Not only the pain of seeing what your child has to live with, but also the impact on your own life in meeting your child's needs?

neverbeenskiing · 25/06/2022 20:45

As a school governor I am appalled by this. A major educational opportunity should be inclusive and offered to all pupils in a cohort

As a school governor you are fundamentally opposed to evidence based, targeted interventions for children with SEMH issues or other additional support needs? As a school Safeguarding Lead, I find that apalling and would not work for a school where the governing body held such views.

5zeds · 25/06/2022 20:36

I’m so horrified a school governor could say or think that.😱😢