Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Forest school only for 'select' children

543 replies

Eyelashesrgreat · 25/06/2022 05:18

Ds in Y3 and his school have recently 'selected' children from his class to go to forest school. The children do this weekly whilst the other children have to stay at school and do work. The children (selected) get to wear their own clothes that day and have treats.

The school did the same thing last year and ds wasn't chosen then. Ds has had a really difficult time recently at school and would have loved to have been selected for this activity. I asked his teacher if all the children will eventually get their turn at the forest school but she has said only certain children can go. AIBU to think this is a bit unfair?

OP posts:
kimfox · 25/06/2022 09:04

You can't be the only one who feels it is unfair, especially given the lack of transparency as to why some children are being given this and others are not. I would write to the chairman of the board of governors and encourage others to do the same.

LadyDanburysCane · 25/06/2022 09:01

Eyelashesrgreat · 25/06/2022 08:14

@donquixotedelamancha I can tell you absolutely there's no SEN and pupil premium for these pupils. Very affluent area and I know the parents very well.

I know pupils on PP that have very affluent parents. PP is not just for low income or SEN. It is for children who have EVER been “looked after” so children adopted through the state system for example. Also “service children” - even if the parent has now left the forces. Friends of mine adopted their daughter at six months old, they are very affluent and she is a very happy and well loved little 10 year old - gets PP though….

Stravaig · 25/06/2022 09:00

Fab graphic, @Sirzy

Stravaig · 25/06/2022 08:59

I disagree that children won't be able to understand why some of their peers have separate activities. Part of parenting is supporting children through the realisation that life is unfair, for those disadvantaged; and teaching them to be aware of all their privileges, for those who have more opportunities.

CecilyP · 25/06/2022 08:59

I'm not sure if this is the same with all schools, but once you are on the PP register at mine, you don't come off, even if you win the lottery and end up living in a gigantic country estate. This is because evidence shows that even if a family has financial difficulties for a short time, the effects on a child's education can be long-term.

It would be the same for all schools but, presumably, OP has known the families since before the children started school, so knows that PP is unlikely to be the case.

toomuchlaundry · 25/06/2022 08:58

Or maybe all children could go but not have any school books because that is the stark choice many schools are having to make

Sirzy · 25/06/2022 08:56

Perhaps the OP could offer to help school fundraiser to cover for all pupils to be able to access it?

toomuchlaundry · 25/06/2022 08:56

@Kennykenkencat don’t think I would want to send my child to a school that segregated SEN pupils like that. SEN pupils are not one homogeneous group, they all have different needs

CulturePigeon · 25/06/2022 08:56

Red Helen - why does OP need to know or not know about 'issues in the class'? She's simply making the point that FS ought to be for everyone.

Some people are making out that it's bizarre behaviour for parents to question or speculate about the rationale for these decisions, taken by the school. What kind of schools have you experienced? Of course parents and children are very sensitive to this kind of thing - children come home and moan, and parents can't answer their questions. School obviously isn't going to explain, so of course it will become a contentious issue. I just don't know what planet some folk are on!

toomuchlaundry · 25/06/2022 08:54

@CulturePigeon are you expecting the teachers/TAs to go with the children in the school holidays?

Do parents begrudge that some families get their school trips/residentials subsidised?

LadyDanburysCane · 25/06/2022 08:53

In my last school it was the children with Pupil Premium that did Forest School. That’s how it was paid for.

my Current school doesn’t have forest school but the PP children do get to do some activities that simply aren’t offered to the other children. It’s one of the things that funding is for.

Kennykenkencat · 25/06/2022 08:52

LadyPenelope68 · 25/06/2022 06:53

@Eyelashesrgreat
The SENCO herself told me that there are two children with SEN
Utter rubbish! 🤣🤣🤣🤣
No SENCO would tell you that. You’re making yourself sound more petty and pathetic every time you post.

I knew how many SEN children were in both my dc’s classes. I was told by the teacher’s and also they were all sat at one group of tables so you could count who was in what group.

Why wouldn’t a SEN teacher tell you that information. It is also, in a lot of schools we visited for both primary and secondary given out as a number in schools and even broken down to year groups

CulturePigeon · 25/06/2022 08:51

@ladyvimes Gosh - you have put a lot of words into my mouth here!

I certainly don't begrudge anyone a go at FS My point is that is was always intended (from its origins in Scandinavian education) to be universal. The fact that it's not is a funding issue - and due to the bonkers demands of the NC.

If it has to be limited, this needs to be done with tact, and my point is: where children are in some way disadvantaged, these special extras are best done in school holidays for a number of obvious reasons.

It's totally disingenuous to expect youngsters to understand - especially when they're not allowed to know the rationale. And very naive to think that they and their parents won't question it.

As I said, I'm against 'special activities' in school time across the board - and Gifted and Talented is a particularly hurtful initiative, I think.

PoleFairy · 25/06/2022 08:48

I don't think you are being unreasonable at all. It doesn't matter even if these kids are SEN, free school meals, gifted academically , not gifted academically etc. Etc. The children left behind (rightly or wrongly) will feel punished and not know why whilst they watch a specially selected group of peers go off on a jolly whilst they sit at a desk and do maths. How would you feel if with no explanation a group of your Co workers were given an extra weeks annual leave a year?

essexmummy321 · 25/06/2022 08:48

Both my children have done forest school and the whole class has taken part every week, if only a select few had gone I'm fairly sure the rest of the parents would be up in arms.

RedHelenB · 25/06/2022 08:46

Yabvu here, how on earth do you know about any issues that others in the class have.

HelloThereObiWan · 25/06/2022 08:44

I get it OP, my DS's first school was a tiny village school where everyone knew everyone else's business and the teaching staff were friends with many of the parents etc.

Lots of posters don't understand how these schools work because they have no experience of that kind of set up, living in urban areas with a choice of school etc. But it absolutely can be the case that as a parent you know exactly which child has special needs etc.

Is there any chance on a couple of the forest school days you can keep him off and take him for a day out instead? Might make a point at least.

Hallyup89 · 25/06/2022 08:43

Eyelashesrgreat · 25/06/2022 06:31

When I say the children who have been chosen have no SEN issues I am totally correct. It is a very small school and there are 2 children with SEND issues. I absolutely know this, I feel that both times the list was drawn up that it is largely down to select people the teacher likes. I'm not saying my ds is more deserving than others bit just that it's fairer to let everyone have a turn at some point.

No, you THINK you know this. You'd look at my daughter and 'know' that there's no SEN issues. She doesn't have an ehcp, she's not disruptive, she's has good attendance, she's in the top sets etc. but she has crippling anxiety at times. She's the sort of child who would benefit massively from something like this. I highly doubt the school would just pick the 'favourites' without any justification.

Skelligsfeathers · 25/06/2022 08:43

Teachers do NOT choose children for this kind of thing because they like them best. This is such a tired argument.
The list will have been drawn up, with reference to set criteria- be that pupil premium, send etc- by the SLT and the teacher will have been informed.
You DO NOT know everyone's send details. You might THINK you do but you don't.

CecilyP · 25/06/2022 08:43

Sirzy · Today 08:18
School is automatically not a level playing field for a lot of children. Because of things out of their control. Instead of seeing things like this as being unfair think of them as a way of levelling the playing field a bit.

That seems reasonable and I’m sure no-one would begrudge children who have very little being given an extra treat. However OP knows her village, she knows the families in it and knows this simply isn’t the case.

ladyvimes · 25/06/2022 08:37

turquoise1988 · 25/06/2022 07:32

Is it a MAGAT (More Able, Gifted and Talented) thing?

There could be a whole host of reasons why particular children are chosen. It sounds like your DS 'fits' into a group that doesn't have SEN but isn't particularly academically able, hence the reason he may not be being chosen. Is his behaviour good? Is there any other reason you think he wouldn't be being chosen?

I understand as a parent that this doesn't seem fair.

For the people saying that there is no way the OP understands the criteria/hasn't had conversations with the SENDCO about the levels of SEN, I can quite dispute this. It feels outrageous, I get it, but in smaller village schools in rural areas, procedures and conversations like this are often much more laid back, to the point where they could even be considered a bit 'unprofessional.' Everyone knows everyone's business, whether right or wrong.

’Unprofessional’?! It would be gross misconduct to discuss a child’s SEND with another parent, small school or not. The fact that the OP has been ‘told by the sendco’ is either untrue or a serious confidentiality issue that needs reporting to the headteacher!

Walkaround · 25/06/2022 08:36

It is a shame if not all children get to try forest schools, as it is educational in itself and can enrich various parts of the school curriculum. Schools do not have the spare cash for pointless treats, though, and this school clearly doesn’t have the money or time to enable all children to benefit from forest schools.

The school has to have an educational justification that would satisfy Ofsted inspectors and the DfE, so the school will have reasons for picking the children it does that do not relate to whether the teacher likes them or not, and will have an educational purpose for what it is doing with the children who are not at forest schools. The OP hasn’t even said how well their child is doing academically. Is their child in one of the groups of children who ended up behind academically after the pandemic, or are they academically on track? SEN children are not the only children with extra needs - the national school led tutoring grant covers all children who fell behind in the pandemic. There are, basically, multiple possible reasons for different children having to be treated differently, but the OP only seems interested in the idea that forest schools is a treat or reward, which would be a ludicrous waste of money if it were.

As for cliquey schools, imvho, these are often schools with cliquey parents who gossip with each other and spread their nasty opinions around as fact, because they believe each other’s malicious gossip, whilst simultaneously assuming school staff are all liars. This sounds very much like the OP’s school. Where there is such a massive loss of faith in the school, this doesn’t seem like a tenable relationship- I think the OP should be looking around to see if there is an alternative school for her child, as she clearly has no trust in this one and is happy to believe parental gossip as gospel truth. Reality is likely to be more complex, but the damage has been done and trust is lost.

toomuchlaundry · 25/06/2022 08:34

School get more funding for some SEN pupils and PP pupils. Would you rather your child fell within one of those categories?

Some schools have managed their budgets/fundraising to afford Forest school. Others can only offer it based on the pupils additional funding. Some schools call activities Forest School even though technically it is not the actual scheme (they are not meant to do this). If your school has reasonable sized playing field they may have designated an area for Forest school and make this part of their curriculum

ladyvimes · 25/06/2022 08:31

CulturePigeon · 25/06/2022 08:18

I'm a Forest School leader and I would like to correct the PP who said 'You do know that FS is only for children with SEN!' No, it emphatically isn't just for SEN. It's for all children (secondary too, ideally) but funding and the horrible, over-crowded, dead hand of the National Curriculum makes its implementation across the board impractical.

It's for everyone, and believe me, adults could benefit too.

I think a lot of posters are wilfully misinterpreting the OP's point and ascribing all kinds of mean motives to her.

I wonder if schools realise how damaging these selective activities are to children's self-esteem? Gifted and Talented...awful! And my children were in it. Do them in the holidays.

It's very hurtful to other children and the fact that no-one is allowed or supposed to know the selection criteria just makes it worse. Children don't understand why they can't take part in a fun activity and no-one will explain it to them. Sometimes I think schools are the worst of all for understanding how children's minds work.

As a parent you need to explain that many children don’t get given the opportunities at home that they do. These school trips might be the only activity these children ever do due to lack of money, neglect, etc.
Im sure you take your children on outings or that they do extra curricular clubs but many pp children do not.
Why would you begrudge a child with additional needs extra experiences? As a forest school teacher yourself I don’t think you have any idea about many children’s home life or challenges!

Sirzy · 25/06/2022 08:30

This image shows why equality for all isn’t really equal

Forest school only for 'select' children
Swipe left for the next trending thread