Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Forest school only for 'select' children

543 replies

Eyelashesrgreat · 25/06/2022 05:18

Ds in Y3 and his school have recently 'selected' children from his class to go to forest school. The children do this weekly whilst the other children have to stay at school and do work. The children (selected) get to wear their own clothes that day and have treats.

The school did the same thing last year and ds wasn't chosen then. Ds has had a really difficult time recently at school and would have loved to have been selected for this activity. I asked his teacher if all the children will eventually get their turn at the forest school but she has said only certain children can go. AIBU to think this is a bit unfair?

OP posts:
CecilyP · 25/06/2022 09:28

MajorCarolDanvers · Today 09:07
Put your question to the school in writing. That way you will get a reply in writing.

Makes it harder to be vague that way.

Seems like the best plan.

NoNoNoooo · 25/06/2022 09:27

My child was selected for this and I am extremely grateful that she was as she really benefitted from it. She has dyslexia, ADD and has always struggled with the social side of school. I am also a single parent so the school received additional pupil premium funding for her.

Change123today · 25/06/2022 09:24

As a parent I completely understand if you feel that your child misses out & sometimes the unfairness of it all.

But I was once that child, the rotary club offered a week long trip with canoeing, swimming and other activities, team building type exercises etc it would offer two places to each school for year 8 pupil. I was selected had an amazing week and opportunity /experiences. I vaguely remember a few kids being a upset and parents complaining. I wasn’t a naught child quite average and shy!
No one knew that is was being given to the children the school knew lived in a deprived area and wouldn’t necessarily be given those opportunities. I’m old now but that trip 30+ years ago I remember so well it really did change my life at the time. It was an experience my parents could never have given me.

You don’t always realise why a child gets the opportunities. I know as a parent it is hard sometimes when you see your child not picked but you won’t know the whole story.

Summerwhereareyou · 25/06/2022 09:22

It's tricky for school because when other parents complain they can't say , tom goes because he has behaviour issue's etc it's all private.

Like pp says why wasn't my child picked for readings club!!
Why does anyone think there is a reading club??
For Great readers??

JudgeJ · 25/06/2022 09:22

Ardmano · 25/06/2022 05:31

Similar thing happened at my secondary. The kids from deprived backgrounds AND were disruptive in class (so not assessed on home income/ home life alone) were taken on exciting trips to do bowling, water parks, petting zoos whatever and it was never offered to anyone else.
I get that some kids might benefit from treats at school but don't they all deserve a turn or at least an alternative?

I'd definitely be asking for more info on selection criteria. Everyone benefits from time outdoors

'Twas ever the case, I recall 40+ years ago a girl saying that maybe she should be a pain in the arse then she could go sailing, climbing etc.! It was hard to get her to see the longer picture, that she would leave with something worthwhile to build her career on, oddly years later I met her at a teachers' conference!

turquoise1988 · 25/06/2022 09:21

@ladyvimes I agree with you! But that doesn't dispute the fact that it happens. It does still happen in some schools, and particularly small/rural ones.

Pumperthepumper · 25/06/2022 09:20

How can they learn to be in a class if they’re taught separately? Also, who is providing that one-on-one teaching time?

cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 09:20

I would reframe your question to the school, as a pp has said.

Ask ‘Forest School is an excellent initiative that I thoroughly support. What are the barriers to all children doing it - cost, staff, adult supporters, time, available areas and resources, transport - and how can I as a parent help the school to overcome these barriers to universal provision?’ Put the question in writing, and then see how you can help - could they take more children if you were able to accompany the group as a volunteer? Is it funding - can you fundraise?

AliMonkey · 25/06/2022 09:19

@Wheelz46 I’m curious as to how no other parents know your DS has selective mutism? Kids talk about other kids and pretty quickly my DS with SM was known as “the boy who doesn’t talk”. It wasn’t mean it was just kids saying it as it is. It would also have been obvious to any parents whose house or party he went to (though I always let the parent know beforehand once we’d gone past the parents staying phase - as I did not want them to think he was being rude and to know he wouldn’t ask eg where toilet was so to know to tell him and give him opportunity to go).

Summerwhereareyou · 25/06/2022 09:19

We had this and it was the children who were sent and who constantly caused disruption in the class who were sent.
Unfortunately it didn't do a damn thing to stop issue's.
The help needed to go beyond that!

Ideally taught seperalty until they learned how to be in class, deep work with the parents so strategies followed through in both places.

(Dispatches)

Pretzerella · 25/06/2022 09:16

At my children's school all the infant department get to go in 5 or 6 week blocks. It relies heavily on parent volunteers to make it work though.

I would ask the teacher about it. DS3 came home in year 2 saying how he hadn't been picked for reading club, when I asked the teacher explained it was to encourage reluctant readers and DS didn't need it.

Newmumatlast · 25/06/2022 09:16

Blu3Butt0n · 25/06/2022 06:16

In our school we have this for children who get extra funding. No way could schools afford it gir everybody and the extra funding needs to be utilised for the children it’s allocated to.There are other therapies too and it’s entirely fair. Quite often these children miss out on a lot in life that others do, they will have to suck that up on a daily basis. Forest schools run everywhere. If you’re that bothered join a local one.

I agree. At the school I know that does this it is for children who have SEN. I understand why my child may feel it is unfair but it is a good teachable moment re checking privilege and how sometimes people look like they're getting more than you but its because they need it and that's ok

toomuchlaundry · 25/06/2022 09:16

Schools have to show how pupil premium funding impacts their PP pupils. Certain PP funding is attached to the pupil other funding doesn’t have to be specifically used for PP children but much easier to demonstrate how it impacts them if not used across the whole school.

Schools have to continually show data for SEN pupils and PP pupils

Morph22010 · 25/06/2022 09:15

LadyDanburysCane · 25/06/2022 09:01

I know pupils on PP that have very affluent parents. PP is not just for low income or SEN. It is for children who have EVER been “looked after” so children adopted through the state system for example. Also “service children” - even if the parent has now left the forces. Friends of mine adopted their daughter at six months old, they are very affluent and she is a very happy and well loved little 10 year old - gets PP though….

Pp isn’t for Sen, my child is Sen with ehcp and doesn’t get pp, it only applies to Sen if they meet the same criteria as any other child

CecilyP · 25/06/2022 09:15

’Unprofessional’?! It would be gross misconduct to discuss a child’s SEND with another parent, small school or not. The fact that the OP has been ‘told by the sendco’ is either untrue or a serious confidentiality issue that needs reporting to the headteacher!

The senco has simply told OP there are 2 children with SEN. She has neither identified them or discussed them. Isn’t this information in the public domain - ofsted reports and the like? The school doesn’t actually seem to discuss anything; that’s why OP is perplexed and her DS upset.

Stravaig · 25/06/2022 09:15

From an alternative persepctive, I'm happy to see that the forest school ethos has finally made it into mainstream education!

Much of what is considered progressive or best practice in modern nursery, primary and even secondary education spends decades incubating in the sort of alternative circles that mainstream parents like to sneer at. It's a process, a very slow process of assimilation and acceptance. Which will hopefully culminate in a universal embedded-in-nature experience as intended.

Onedayatatime24799 · 25/06/2022 09:13

I would say it will definitely be the children who have Pupil Premium.
Sadly a lot of parents seem to have a stereotypical image in their minds when it comes to this.
It's not true in reality.

FlatWhiteLover · 25/06/2022 09:12

PoleFairy · 25/06/2022 08:48

I don't think you are being unreasonable at all. It doesn't matter even if these kids are SEN, free school meals, gifted academically , not gifted academically etc. Etc. The children left behind (rightly or wrongly) will feel punished and not know why whilst they watch a specially selected group of peers go off on a jolly whilst they sit at a desk and do maths. How would you feel if with no explanation a group of your Co workers were given an extra weeks annual leave a year?

But at the end of the day where is the funding going to come from? I am all for equality, however in reality that is impossible given how underfunded the education system is. These things are funded by PP, which I am assuming the OP's son doesnt recieve. Is it fair? probably not but the school does not have a magic money tree, so it is right that the most disadvantaged children benefit from this.

They had these types of things at my school which I wasnt entilted too, as a child it seemed unfair but as an adult I recognise that I had a fairly prileveged middle class upbringing so was far better off than the children from deprived backgrounds even without the odd activity provided by the school.

JustOldMe · 25/06/2022 09:10

My DD's school did this. Only found out when upset DD started complaining that some of the kids get taken to trips, get baking lessons, playtime, etc. Then asked her who the kids are and found out that they are all with additional needs and very difficult home lives. Had a talk with my DD and she understood the reason behind it- although, was still jealous every week.

anotherneutralname · 25/06/2022 09:09

Sirzy · 25/06/2022 08:56

Perhaps the OP could offer to help school fundraiser to cover for all pupils to be able to access it?

I like this solution based idea! Could you approach the school on the basis of “the FS looks like a great activity. Can we help fundraise so the whole class gets a chance to try it?”

If they say no it’s specifically for that group, personally I’d interpret that as “this is a targeted intervention for the small group to achieve something specific for them” and then I’d look at doing something outside school that was similar with my child. Have you considered cubs / scouts, which can also be great for confidence building?

That said, your child sounds really unhappy at school and it appears the school are not engaged in making things better for him. I would really look into changing schools, perhaps to somewhere a bit bigger with more friendship options.

Reekingpitofdoom · 25/06/2022 09:07

Blu3Butt0n · 25/06/2022 06:16

In our school we have this for children who get extra funding. No way could schools afford it gir everybody and the extra funding needs to be utilised for the children it’s allocated to.There are other therapies too and it’s entirely fair. Quite often these children miss out on a lot in life that others do, they will have to suck that up on a daily basis. Forest schools run everywhere. If you’re that bothered join a local one.

Out of interest, how much more does it cost? At my DCs school, all the class would go. The deputy head had training in forest schools so would accompany that class with the usual class teacher. They would take parent volunteers if any were available. The kids would go to a wooded area 10 minutes walk from the school. We live in a city with lots of little bits of woodland - is the cost about transportation to an appropriate place? I think DC’’s school wanted as many kids to go to justify the cost of the training.

MajorCarolDanvers · 25/06/2022 09:07

Put your question to the school in writing. That way you will get a reply in writing.

Makes it harder to be vague that way.

CulturePigeon · 25/06/2022 09:07

No - not the way I'm imagining (something more like summer camp with professional FS leaders, play leaders etc). Yes, I know this is not the way things are done at present, but then so much needs to change in primary education for things like FS to have any effect.

In Scandinavian countries FS was intended as universal for all children up to 6/7 and they don't do formal education until much later than in the UK. By this, I mean that all their education takes place in a FS - not in a classroom at all, but outdoors. Obviously, what is done in this country is a far cry from the original idea, but - even a little FS is hugely beneficial. It would need a sea-change for this policy to be adopted in the UK - we tend to like our small children to sit down and start writing very early indeed - oh, and to be tested too.

I'm uneasy about selective activities in primary schools which everyone could enjoy unless done very tactfully indeed.

Dreamwhisper · 25/06/2022 09:07

That's ridiculous. My DS's pre school does forest school and only a limited number can go so they simply rotate it and every half term it changes.

I would not be happy with this. If it was an application process with a first come first serve principle I'd get it a bit more but they're literally just picking children and leaving others out.

CecilyP · 25/06/2022 09:05

As a parent you need to explain that many children don’t get given the opportunities at home that they do. These school trips might be the only activity these children ever do due to lack of money, neglect, etc.

Thats fine, if that’s the case. But as OP knows that isn’t the case, she can’t really explain it, can she.