Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Forest school only for 'select' children

543 replies

Eyelashesrgreat · 25/06/2022 05:18

Ds in Y3 and his school have recently 'selected' children from his class to go to forest school. The children do this weekly whilst the other children have to stay at school and do work. The children (selected) get to wear their own clothes that day and have treats.

The school did the same thing last year and ds wasn't chosen then. Ds has had a really difficult time recently at school and would have loved to have been selected for this activity. I asked his teacher if all the children will eventually get their turn at the forest school but she has said only certain children can go. AIBU to think this is a bit unfair?

OP posts:
Kennykenkencat · 25/06/2022 10:34

frami · 25/06/2022 09:48

I work with kids with SEN there are many in the group but only 2 have EHCP this is probably what your SENCO means when she says that only there are only 2 SEN kids in the school. (I question whether she should even be telling you this.)

Additional needs can take many forms my daughter is highly intelligent, perfectly behaved, outgoing etc but has qualified for additional support throughout her time in education (currently at University). Why? because she has a hidden physical disability which is only known to whom it concerns or she chooses to tell. Hence I am not stating what it is on a public forum. Don't assume you know all about the children in you DC's. Ask if you think the selection is unfair, but accept you will only be told in the broadest terms.

I could never understand parents who would not tell a sole, some don’t even tell their child that the child has an SEN.
As people do know these “secrets”

Other children and other parents of SEN children pick up on stuff going on.

I have always been open and honest about why dc struggle with certain things so when they would see other children with similar issues they would ask them about it and share their issues. (Dds senior school had an hours joint discussion group each week for those who had SENs or suspected SENs where they would discuss their difficulties with certain problems they had been having and methods others did to overcome them)

greatblueheron · 25/06/2022 10:30

ChangingStates · 25/06/2022 06:21

I work in a school. We now have Forest school available to all children on a 2 year rolling programme. However when we started we were unable to fund staffing for the amount of time that was needed to give access to the whole school. For those 2 years it was a provision only for eyfs and for target children chosen because they were extremely vulnerable in terms of home life, needed alternative provision due to either learning / mental health / emotional needs - and I’m talking high need here, with fairly extreme issues. It was part of the behaviour/ mental health / learning plan for those children. Don’t make assumptions about the children who have been chosen, you don’t know their context.

We have had to make cuts in provision in other places to be able to afford to open forest school out to more children- it’s not cheap to provide qualified staff to run it- and even if they are school staff you still need to afford to release them from supporting learning elsewhere. Your school would probably love to have more children in forest school but budget may prevent it- school finances are fucked and the decisions around provision we are having to make are frankly depressing.

You could ask the school if they have any plans to expand access. You could, and definitely should, ask what support is available to help your son with his issues- we also ran self esteem groups, friendship groups etc for a wide range of children so there maybe a different type of activity or support he can have.

This is a very good outline of what I believe many schools follow when they offer programmes like this to only 'some' children.

I think most should be grateful their children aren't having the difficulties these children are having.

functionoverform · 25/06/2022 10:28

We have a similar scheme where I work (secondary). To be honest, I think the students picked to go out on these days end up much worse off as they (over the year) miss out on a few hundred hours of education, intervention etc. The students left behind don't get talked over by the seemingly confident/ naughty children and it is a joy to teach with no interruptions. Unfortunately this means the reading age / learning gap increases between those who are PP students and those who are not. So I guess it all depends how you look at it. But I imagine it is disheartening for the students not invited....

Teateaandmoretea · 25/06/2022 10:28

well presumably he is doing better than the children who need forrest school once a week

With all due respect you know nothing about it - why are you doubting what the OP is saying?

Her child is unhappy and the school is doing little to help. This does happen.

ofwarren · 25/06/2022 10:28

Eyelashesrgreat · 25/06/2022 06:31

When I say the children who have been chosen have no SEN issues I am totally correct. It is a very small school and there are 2 children with SEND issues. I absolutely know this, I feel that both times the list was drawn up that it is largely down to select people the teacher likes. I'm not saying my ds is more deserving than others bit just that it's fairer to let everyone have a turn at some point.

How do you know this?
My son is classed as SEN but he masks all day in school and only melts down when he's not in school.
Nobody who is not a teacher at the school knows what his issues are.

Teateaandmoretea · 25/06/2022 10:26

He's been there since reception, lost all confidence (from being a bright bubbly boy to a shadow of himself). I am considering moving him for lots of reasons but have hung on in there thinking it might improve after talks with the school. I'm not saying it's a 'dump' it's just been upsetting to see how sone children are favoured and others aren't.

OP rather than analysing the crap going on in that school move him. It’s the perfect time to do it before the holidays.

Cliquey village schools aren’t always the idylls that people imagine. My daughter was unhappy at a village school, so moved her to a large town primary. She’s happy and thriving now. I have zero politics to deal with, it’s awesome.

Not all schools suit all children, my older one was fine at the village one. It’s isn’t a dump or a crap school, but a few things just weren’t right. Including the mix of kids in my younger daughter’s year group.

5zeds · 25/06/2022 10:23

The OP's child isn't coping in school. He has been/is being bullied and has self esteem problems. well presumably he is doing better than the children who need forrest school once a week. You don’t know what the other children need. Demanding that everyone needs “the same” is the most childish and ridiculous suggestion. Honestly sometimes the level of ignorance on MN is horrifying.

Pumperthepumper · 25/06/2022 10:21

jacks11 · 25/06/2022 10:13

I’m not a fan of the trend towards prioritising some children over others for things that seem like extra fun/a treat- I do understand why it seems a good idea and limitations are often related to school budgets- but it creates division and it’s often the quiet/well-behaved children who just get on with things that get overlooked.

If there are to be criteria then schools really need to be quite transparent about it, rather than leaving parents guessing. The secrecy/not being clear about why some children don’t get to benefit from something (which is supposed to be great for all children) causes irritation. The school don’t need to be specific but without any clue it can look like special treatment for some to the detriment of others. If there is obvious reasoning- “we only have sufficient funds for x number per year/term to do y activity so we are limiting it to children who have some additional need for this activity due to a,b,c criteria”. No specifics and it won’t be more of a giveaway/revealing re SEN etc than having an additional TA for one child or a child spending some time in learning support base.

Transparency usually demystifies things and most people will accept a clear explanation, even if the disagree and might grumble a bit. And let’s face it, in some schools there are faces that fit and those that don’t, teachers aren’t always unbiased (my childhood headmistress always favoured the children of her/our local minister and to a lesser extent those whose parents had roles within the church/well known in church circles- it was painfully obvious) and some parents are extremely pushy and good at getting their own way. If the criteria were laid down, it would be more obvious to a parent that their child did/did not fit the criteria and stop a lot of irritation.

Of course some parents will still believe it is unfair- I think I would too and not be overly happy but I could at least see a logic.

They can’t have transparency in loads of ways though - they can’t say ‘we’re going to take some kids out to the forest, and the kids are chosen because they struggle with making friends and their parents are going through an awful divorce. Also some of them we think are probably autistic but we can’t prove it yet’.

ilovesushi · 25/06/2022 10:20

If it is part of supporting kids who are struggling emotionally or academically then that sounds fine, but if not, then it sucks. At my DCs primary a select group of the more high flying kids got to go to the beach one day while the others stayed in school and every year they sent a similar cohort for a day at a nearby independent school where they got to do science in proper labs and use all the facilities - probably some sneaky recruitment drive. My kids were never chosen and the whole thing was run in a very secret squirrel manner.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 25/06/2022 10:18

be grateful that your child is coping,

The OP's child isn't coping in school. He has been/is being bullied and has self esteem problems.

icelollies · 25/06/2022 10:16

YABU sorry, these children have SEN and are going into alternative provision because they can’t cope in the classroom.

the school sound like they are doing an excellent job in trying to be inclusive and find suitable provision for these children, which is expensive and likely underfunded.

be grateful that your child is coping, and that you can provide the special treats for them.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 25/06/2022 10:16

everything is out in the open at our school. We meet outside of school sometimes too and then parents sometimes help out in the school office when it's busy so they hear information there.

Are you in the UK? Because in the UK that is very unacceptable and would get a school in huge trouble. Confidential information shouldn't be disclosed to parent helpers.

mam0918 · 25/06/2022 10:15

I find it strange people saying in the 90s there was all these nice provisions for disruptive children.

I was classed as 'disruptive' due to my disabilty (I actually was just frustraiting by a lack of support and basicly bullying by teachers. They litrally singled me out sat me on a 'dunce' table alone facing the rest of the class because I physically couldnt keep up with the other kids. Example: I couldnt hold a pen so couldnt write properly there for 'wasn't completing work' etc....) and I was the kid left OUT of everything.

My mam had to fight tooth and nail to get them to let me join in anything and they would deliberately try to stop my mam finding out about school trip, dances, special 'fun' classes, play rehersals etc... until after they happened too.

C8H10N4O2 · 25/06/2022 10:13

Pumperthepumper · 25/06/2022 09:59

They hear information and then tell other people about it? Are you serious?

In a small village school or in a small village generally? Yes perfectly believable. Everyone knows everyone else's business.

jacks11 · 25/06/2022 10:13

I’m not a fan of the trend towards prioritising some children over others for things that seem like extra fun/a treat- I do understand why it seems a good idea and limitations are often related to school budgets- but it creates division and it’s often the quiet/well-behaved children who just get on with things that get overlooked.

If there are to be criteria then schools really need to be quite transparent about it, rather than leaving parents guessing. The secrecy/not being clear about why some children don’t get to benefit from something (which is supposed to be great for all children) causes irritation. The school don’t need to be specific but without any clue it can look like special treatment for some to the detriment of others. If there is obvious reasoning- “we only have sufficient funds for x number per year/term to do y activity so we are limiting it to children who have some additional need for this activity due to a,b,c criteria”. No specifics and it won’t be more of a giveaway/revealing re SEN etc than having an additional TA for one child or a child spending some time in learning support base.

Transparency usually demystifies things and most people will accept a clear explanation, even if the disagree and might grumble a bit. And let’s face it, in some schools there are faces that fit and those that don’t, teachers aren’t always unbiased (my childhood headmistress always favoured the children of her/our local minister and to a lesser extent those whose parents had roles within the church/well known in church circles- it was painfully obvious) and some parents are extremely pushy and good at getting their own way. If the criteria were laid down, it would be more obvious to a parent that their child did/did not fit the criteria and stop a lot of irritation.

Of course some parents will still believe it is unfair- I think I would too and not be overly happy but I could at least see a logic.

whyohehy · 25/06/2022 10:11

I think it's selecting kids that have additional things going on either with development or at home etc

cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 10:10

I would also say that it is extremely concerning that you as a parent consider this lack of information security ‘normal’, even positive. It means that the culture of the school and the community (who probably gloat about their lovely friendly and open school) is rotten throughout.

5zeds · 25/06/2022 10:10

@Walkaround SEN children are not the only children with extra needs say what now? SEN literally means special educational needs.

sjxoxo · 25/06/2022 10:08

Why can’t they take all kids?? What’s the point in only taking a few.. everyone would benefit from that time outside. x

Wishihadanalgorithm · 25/06/2022 10:07

You’re educating him off site, not your! Doh!

Wishihadanalgorithm · 25/06/2022 10:06

My DD is in Yr 3 and has been doing forest school for a term now. She did it in reception and Yr 2 as well. TBH, I would rather my DD was in school doing extra maths and English. We take her to the woods, build dens and all that jazz but that is in our free time. I want her learning things which I think matter more.

I think your school is being very unfair. In your position as you do want your dc to go to forest school I’d be taking them out for one afternoon a week until the end of term to do my own version of forest school. Tell his school your educating him off site if they need a register code.

The school is behaving unfairly and I would be writing to the governors to express concerns that there isn’t equal opportunity for the children. It may be the children going are PP kids but that shouldn’t mean other children should miss out all of the time. Obviously PP money is earmarked only for the use of those children so schools may find it difficult but this does appear glaringly unfair.

cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 10:05

Eyelashesrgreat · 25/06/2022 09:56

@chipsnmayo I appreciate your discretion but everything is out in the open at our school. We meet outside of school sometimes too and then parents sometimes help out in the school office when it's busy so they hear information there.

You should be raising merry hell about this. Head, Safeguarding lead, information commissioners, Ofsted, you name it - all should be made aware of the appalling failure to maintain appropriate information security in this school. I am beyond appalled.

LongLostTeacher · 25/06/2022 10:05

Hmm, I voted YANBU because I believe all children, regardless of SEN issues or social deprivation etc, benefit from time in nature. I would be surprised if your school just selects pupils the teacher likes as it is usually based on pupil equity funding or behavioural needs. It is not unreasonable for school to choose such pupils if there is limited funding.

But as I said, it is a rich experience for all children. Our country should be able to offer this to all children as a priority - the problem is the government values the wrong things and a policy to allow all children to attend forest school on a regular basis should be created.

Part of the reason I withdrew my children from school and now home educate them is so they can go to forest school and spend more time outdoors.

Kennykenkencat · 25/06/2022 10:04

toomuchlaundry · 25/06/2022 08:56

@Kennykenkencat don’t think I would want to send my child to a school that segregated SEN pupils like that. SEN pupils are not one homogeneous group, they all have different needs

Both my children were in the SEN groups.

There were different groups of tables based on ability.

FWIW it was a lovely school. The problems started when that school finished (didn’t go through from 4-11) and they had to move to another school which didn’t distinguish in the classroom which children had SEN

Any progress my Ds especially had made was lost and no distinction was made for different abilities when work and homework were given out and punishments were given for not completing work. Work that for Ds was impossible.

Goodmum1234 · 25/06/2022 10:04

Hate this shit! How unfair for all children. All should get a chance even if it’s once every month. That’s what our school did so all had an equal turn. Those children with pupil premium or send did other discrete things with a TA to support them but it was fairly done.
please complain to the head, then governors asking for their criteria for choosing. Also look at school policies for any quotes about fairness etc. please do this for your son and future pupils x

Swipe left for the next trending thread