Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Forest school only for 'select' children

543 replies

Eyelashesrgreat · 25/06/2022 05:18

Ds in Y3 and his school have recently 'selected' children from his class to go to forest school. The children do this weekly whilst the other children have to stay at school and do work. The children (selected) get to wear their own clothes that day and have treats.

The school did the same thing last year and ds wasn't chosen then. Ds has had a really difficult time recently at school and would have loved to have been selected for this activity. I asked his teacher if all the children will eventually get their turn at the forest school but she has said only certain children can go. AIBU to think this is a bit unfair?

OP posts:
liveforsummer · 25/06/2022 11:58

This happens at our school. It's for the dc who have additional support needs, behaviour problems, traumatic experiences/chaotic home lives etc. Obviously we don't advertise this as it singles out those children. Be thankful your dc isn't among those who 'need' it

PestoPasghetti · 25/06/2022 11:57

Ardmano · 25/06/2022 05:31

Similar thing happened at my secondary. The kids from deprived backgrounds AND were disruptive in class (so not assessed on home income/ home life alone) were taken on exciting trips to do bowling, water parks, petting zoos whatever and it was never offered to anyone else.
I get that some kids might benefit from treats at school but don't they all deserve a turn or at least an alternative?

I'd definitely be asking for more info on selection criteria. Everyone benefits from time outdoors

Yes, same here! It was called 'Life Skills' - they got to go out on trips every Friday while the rest of us were stuck in the classroom. How going to the zoo is a life skill I don't know...

ChocolatemilkBertie · 25/06/2022 11:54

I don’t think it’s odd to find this unfair. Lots of children get completely overlooked at school and this leads to their own “sinking” as time goes by.

Children in the categories described above: extra trips, things like Forest school, lots of small group activities and interventions, in many schools, lots of things given to distress (cards to leave the class etc)
Higher ability children: again lots of attention from extra small group times, always chosen to represent the school at events, chosen for sports events, probably get the better parts in plays, win the prizes etc.

Then you have this group in the middle who get none of the above. They’re not bright enough or well spoken enough or smart enough to be chosen to represent their school. They’re too shy to be given big parts. They’re just not quite fast enough to be chosen for sports. Too clever to have support in class but not clever enough to be spotted by the teacher and pushed. These children slip through the cracks way to often. Why can’t they go to Forest School?

If Forest School runs all year round, then it’s an activity where every child would benefit. Class should be split into 3 and a different group have it each term. No way is it fair that some children get to learn to build a campfire and do craft and have fun out in the woods while the rest are stuck inside doing comprehension. The benefits of Forest School are vast and it’s not just about helping children with SEN or behavioural needs. It gives children a chance to be children.

Im not against any program aimed at particular groups to help them flourish and achieve potential. Of course certain children need more things thrown at them.

But Forest School can have such a positive effect on everyone and this doesn’t sound fair. Life’s not fair, but this isn’t the same as giving everyone a medal for just turning up for Sports Day.

Sockwomble · 25/06/2022 11:54

You can tell who the Tory voters are on this thread.

Itisasecret · 25/06/2022 11:50

This happens in virtually every school at some level. It could be children with specific SEN who have targeted provision of funding. It could be pupil premium funding where children from deprived backgrounds are targeted with extra funding/provision because the research proves a very big equality gap. It could be they are pp because of ever 6. It could be that the school has select funding to support children who meet certain criteria.

Its not a case of every provision is for every child. The gap between pp children and those who aren’t is huge and widening every year.

Sirzy · 25/06/2022 11:48

do you know what is really unfair? Children having to miss lots of school because of their illnesses. Children having to struggle in school day to day due to their special needs. Children having to watch parents die. Children being left out of things because of their disabilities.

if taking part in a forest group with a selected group of peers helps redress just a tiny bit of that balance then fantastic.

CecilyP · 25/06/2022 11:42

CecilyP snd do you then pass that on to other parents? DS used to be able to tell me which table all the children were grouped on (I didn’t ask him for this info). Funnily enough I didn’t then stand at the school gates telling parents who were the children in the ‘bottom’ maths group.

Actually no, there were only a couple school mums (excluding the mums in my flats) that I spoke to on a regular basis.

Retrievemysanity · 25/06/2022 11:37

@ladyvimes you can’t possibly speak for all senco’s. There are some that absolutely would.

toomuchlaundry · 25/06/2022 11:37

Many children have Forest School or other alternative provisions written in their EHCPs /my plans to help them cope with school life. It is not always used as a treat but actually a way of getting them engaged with education

ladyvimes · 25/06/2022 11:37

InChocolateWeTrust · 25/06/2022 11:33

Similar thing I my DC school. They select children with additional needs or that are struggling at home etc.

This is absurd. It's completely unfair on the other children, who would all get something out of this, to only provide it to a few. It's a different matter when a specific educational intervention group is provided (eg specific intensive phonics support to those who need it) as that isn't exactly a "treat" that they would all enjoy.

I'd be fuming if they offered this to only a few at my school

So ignorant! Why is it unfair on children with specific learning, behaviour or emotional needs to be given extra support? Our whole society supports those who are worse off or struggling, why not children in schools specifically?
What if your child developed additional needs? Would you not want them to receive support? School aren’t just about academics. By the grace of god and all that!!

Princessoftheuniverse · 25/06/2022 11:36

Sorry. A group of children from a sports team.

Pumperthepumper · 25/06/2022 11:35

InChocolateWeTrust · 25/06/2022 11:33

Similar thing I my DC school. They select children with additional needs or that are struggling at home etc.

This is absurd. It's completely unfair on the other children, who would all get something out of this, to only provide it to a few. It's a different matter when a specific educational intervention group is provided (eg specific intensive phonics support to those who need it) as that isn't exactly a "treat" that they would all enjoy.

I'd be fuming if they offered this to only a few at my school

I guess it depends on your idea of ‘fairness’. Is it fair that some children are born into homes with addiction issues? Is it fair that some children have sensory issues that make class setups difficult? Or are you assuming that every kid begins from the same starting point?

Princessoftheuniverse · 25/06/2022 11:35

Had this some years ago at DS ‘s school. A group of children from a taken out to a local activity centre. I asked if the others would be given the same opportunity at at another time. I was told that was the intention . It never happened unsurprisingly. I was a teacher myself at the time (elsewhere) and I thought it stank. It was nothing to do with underprivilege or confidence boosting either.

ladyvimes · 25/06/2022 11:34

Teateaandmoretea · 25/06/2022 10:41

Isn’t the number/ proportion of SEN on the OFSTED report anyway?

Yes the number in the whole school but no sendco would tell a parent the specific number of children with SEND in a specific class.

InChocolateWeTrust · 25/06/2022 11:33

Similar thing I my DC school. They select children with additional needs or that are struggling at home etc.

This is absurd. It's completely unfair on the other children, who would all get something out of this, to only provide it to a few. It's a different matter when a specific educational intervention group is provided (eg specific intensive phonics support to those who need it) as that isn't exactly a "treat" that they would all enjoy.

I'd be fuming if they offered this to only a few at my school

PriamFarrl · 25/06/2022 11:33

turquoise1988 · 25/06/2022 08:06

Echo what some other posters are also saying, because it is very relevant.

Children who are academically able can have SEN.
Children who are academically able can also be disadvantaged.
Children who are academically able can also be subject to child protection procedures.

OP, I do understand your point of view, whether I agree with it or not doesn't matter. Out of interest, if your child was one of the 'chosen few,' would you still have made this post?

The highest achieving child in my class (scored 100% on all tests last week) is undergoing a diagnosis of autism, is on FSM, and has a seriously troubled family history. The second highest achieving also has serious SEN issues. The third highest lives in serious poverty.

Sockwomble · 25/06/2022 11:32

"The money would be better spent on actual therapy and help for those who need it."

Forest school can be therapy. Likewise equine therapy etc.

RewildingAmbridge · 25/06/2022 11:32

I went to a bog standard state school in a fairly deprived area. I was on the MAGAT programme and we would sometimes get taken to activities other children didn't, largely because the majority of teacher time was spent dealing with difficult children, their parents, social workers even police and youth offending workers. So those of us who came from families who weren't well off but behaved, whose dads didn't come to parents' evening and threaten the English teacher, got our heads down and got on with the work, were largely ignored by necessity. The additional events were things like debate society at a local private school, trip to the local court to observe legal profession and magistrates, at gallery trips etc or they'd have guest teachers or lecturers come in and give us extra lessons after school or at lunchtimes. Cultural enrichment to say to us really, you can get out of this, look at the opportunities. I was head girl, did very well academically, was involved in sports and drama club etc, it probably would've looked like I was being chosen as a class pet too, but actually it was exhausting and stressful being in an environment that felt like lord of the flies on a daily basis. Where peers could only see the world on their doorstep and no further, where fights were common and people's parents went to prison on a fairly regular basis, those excursions and extra lessons gave me hope and sanity.

Walkaround · 25/06/2022 11:29

5zeds · 25/06/2022 10:10

@Walkaround SEN children are not the only children with extra needs say what now? SEN literally means special educational needs.

@5zeds It’s actually SEND, not SEN - and it is not only children on a school’s SEND register who may have additional needs. Pupil premium children are not automatically on the SEND register, but they are considered to have additional needs that justify extra funding. Do you think the OP’s child is on the school’s SEND register because she says he is anxious and being bullied? Do you think he is automatically on the register if he fell behind during lockdowns?

Sockwomble · 25/06/2022 11:28

OP If the SENCO has given out the information that you say she has, then she will be in serious trouble if someone reports it.

cottagegardenflower · 25/06/2022 11:25

Complain. It's unacceptable. Children should take turns if the class needs to be small, but everyone should be selected at some point

Cactuslockdown · 25/06/2022 11:24

This sort of thing happens all the time IME. It’s really unfair

BungleandGeorge · 25/06/2022 11:23

I agree with you because sadly often school don’t even know which students are having a difficult time. Children often go under the radar if they behave and try and work hard but can still be struggling significantly with SEN, family life etc. The money would be better spent on actual therapy and help for those who need it.

acquiescence · 25/06/2022 11:18

We have similar at our school, it is for children who have suffered a significant bereavement (parent:/sibling) or other trauma in their home life. My child sadly is eligible. Please try to be grateful that your child does not fall into the group.

YankeeDad · 25/06/2022 11:16

@Eyelashesrgreat I have only read your own posts, not the responses, so apologies if this is redundant with what others have written.

You said that your child is not thriving in this school, and that this is not only about the Forest School. You also said you are thinking about moving your child to a different school.

If that is the case, then I think those are the only facts that matter right now, and find another, more suitable school for your child that is where all your attention and focus should go.

While the current school might or may not have good reasons for choosing whom they choose for this Forest School (to the exclusion of your child), it sounds as though you cannot change how they operate, and putting energy into finding out whether they are good or bad reasons will not help your child to thrive, whereas moving him to a more suitable school will help him.

Swipe left for the next trending thread