Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish I was rich?

161 replies

antelopevalley · 24/06/2022 23:24

Not mega-rich. But to own an ordinary house and have half a million in the bank rich.
I have no family beyond DP and the kids. It would be so lovely to have a really good safety net, and to choose not to work when life is tough.

OP posts:
Oceanus · 27/06/2022 13:56

Money doesn't bring happiness or common sense but I wouldn't mind being an unhappy fool sipping champagne and eating good chocolate, while waiting for sb else to do the cooking, sitting in my fancy schmancy massage chair (imported from SK)! Though, it seems a husband could do the same job!

Oceanus · 27/06/2022 13:53

ToldItToTheBees · 25/06/2022 08:29

I would settle for enough to scrape me out of the debts I accrued due to going through family court.

If you have many debts, you might find it useful to consolidate them. My flatmate did that and instead of paying several amounts here and there, she started paying just one amount which was smaller than the initial ones put together.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 27/06/2022 13:51

I’m French, hence my user name which is being used to mean “Born Woman”, while being a play on “Femme fatale.”

Hilarious. But not something I'd know just from your username. There's someone on here called Nanny Ogg and I'm pretty sure it's not actually her.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 27/06/2022 13:50

No-one is claiming that a labourer on a construction site should earn more than a skilled surgeons just because their job is physically more demanding.

maybe not. But if i had a skilled surgeon for a daughter, I wouldn't tell her she is working harder than a labourer on a construction site. Or indeed working harder than the person who comes in after she's finished and mops the blood off the floor and autoclaves her instruments. What I SAID was

"just because someone has more money than you doesn't necessarily mean they worked harder for it".

I find it hard to see what anyone has to disagree with there.

FemmeNatal · 27/06/2022 13:48

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 27/06/2022 13:46

I’ve seen many people using it as a real-world example, and no, it wasn’t being used as a metaphor, it was being used as an example. I understand that you think it’s funny to try to make fun of the English of someone for whom it’s not a first language, but it isn’t, it’s just crass.

Oh come off it how on earth would I know what your first language is. Your English on this thread is perfect as I'm sure you know. I'm not psychic.

And I'm sorry but it is a metaphor. It clearly is if you read the book. Because obviously it is not a like for like comparison. But even if it was your e.g. isn't fair because it's not like for like. The difference would be say a pair of Docs (£100+, last forever) vs a pair of the weird plastic boots you can buy for a tenner in Sainsbury's and last you 6 months if you're lucky. He was a policeman, not a style maven. No-one's saying high-fashion office shoes hold-up better than any given work boot.

I’m French, hence my user name which is being used to mean “Born Woman”, while being a play on “Femme fatale.”

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 27/06/2022 13:47

Sorry that should have said 'obviously it's not a like for like comparison with the real world because it's a pseudo-medieval magical reality with a made-up currency'.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 27/06/2022 13:46

I’ve seen many people using it as a real-world example, and no, it wasn’t being used as a metaphor, it was being used as an example. I understand that you think it’s funny to try to make fun of the English of someone for whom it’s not a first language, but it isn’t, it’s just crass.

Oh come off it how on earth would I know what your first language is. Your English on this thread is perfect as I'm sure you know. I'm not psychic.

And I'm sorry but it is a metaphor. It clearly is if you read the book. Because obviously it is not a like for like comparison. But even if it was your e.g. isn't fair because it's not like for like. The difference would be say a pair of Docs (£100+, last forever) vs a pair of the weird plastic boots you can buy for a tenner in Sainsbury's and last you 6 months if you're lucky. He was a policeman, not a style maven. No-one's saying high-fashion office shoes hold-up better than any given work boot.

antelopevalley · 27/06/2022 13:43

Everyone could always make more money. I could work three jobs, 110 hours a week and never see my children at all. I would get more money even if the jobs were minimum wage. But no one would do that for minimum wage unless they really had to.

OP posts:
FemmeNatal · 27/06/2022 13:42

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 27/06/2022 13:38

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen But you literally just said in your post above that you could earn more but don't want to work that hard

Seperate issue. A care worker works fucking hard but they don't make as much money as a mid-level office worker. I once had a job proofreading applications and got paid £25kpa - for being able to read and spell. On my arse. All day. Whereas there are social workers on less than that having to read and see things that would live in my nightmares for years, working all the hours god sends and still being called negligent, on less money than that. Or you have people like the hon Rees Mogg who is making more money by the half hour than he will ever "earn" as an MP from investments his family made before he was even born (happily for him protected from tax in various offshore accounts). Is he working harder than an HCA?

You are twisting the words of those that you disagree with here to argue against a point that no-one was making.

It’s not about how physically hard the work is, or just about how many hours you do, the contention is that there is a route to earn more with the right training, gaining of skills, and with putting in the effort in the right direction.

No-one is claiming that a labourer on a construction site should earn more than a skilled surgeons just because their job is physically more demanding.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 27/06/2022 13:38

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen But you literally just said in your post above that you could earn more but don't want to work that hard

Seperate issue. A care worker works fucking hard but they don't make as much money as a mid-level office worker. I once had a job proofreading applications and got paid £25kpa - for being able to read and spell. On my arse. All day. Whereas there are social workers on less than that having to read and see things that would live in my nightmares for years, working all the hours god sends and still being called negligent, on less money than that. Or you have people like the hon Rees Mogg who is making more money by the half hour than he will ever "earn" as an MP from investments his family made before he was even born (happily for him protected from tax in various offshore accounts). Is he working harder than an HCA?

changeornot · 27/06/2022 13:37

FemmeNatal · 27/06/2022 13:23

You think I’ve suggested that the playing field is level? Why? I’ve neither said it is not implied it. It clearly isn’t, as some children, sadly, will be born to the sort of parents on here that tell them they may as well not try. Sadly many will grow up believing it.

@FemmeNatal

I don't think that is what anyone is saying what they are saying is that you want your kids to go into the world with their eyes wide open!

A realistic view of the world.

I tell my kids that they will have to work harder at school that many of their peers, and be mindful of their career choices as they will not have a large inheritance, help to buy a flat when they are older.

Yes if my daughter says she wants to rich, I tell her that one of the easiest route (from what I have seen) is to do well at school and try to do something not glamorous, finance related etc... Start young, and keep going, apply for opportunities don't take rejection personally.

If she wants more freedom, learn something (ideally difficult and boring) that not everyone can do that is in high demand..

But that in itself is a privilege- that I live in a city and can see several routes to wealth. That I am giving her this advice.

Where the standard tabloid media advice everyone has an equal chance, if you just 'dream' hard enough. It is unrealistic. Route to a lot of shame, credit card debt and misery.

antelopevalley · 27/06/2022 13:35

@MaybeIWillFuckOffThen Thanks.

And all those saying is the message not to even try improving your life are missing the fact that I have improved my life and my children do not experience the kind of awful poverty my DP and I experienced as children. If I thought there was no point in trying, we would not have achieved that.

OP posts:
FatCatSkinnyRat · 27/06/2022 13:32

just because someone has more money than you doesn't necessarily mean they worked harder for it or are any smarter than you are

@MaybeIWillFuckOffThen But you literally just said in your post above that you could earn more but don't want to work that hard?

DaphneeBridgerton · 27/06/2022 13:30

antelopevalley · 27/06/2022 10:56

@DaphneeBridgerton Trust me it would. I have suffered a tragic bereavement. Life would be much easier if I did not have to be back at work within days to bring in the money.

I suffered a trauma and was able to take time off work to ‘recover’ … in fact I ended up closing myself off from the world, had too much time to think about things, developed terrible anxiety and other MH problems. I reckon I’d have been better of sticking to my usual routine. That probably wouldn’t happen to you. I’m just giving the other side of things, that’s all.

Zeus44 · 27/06/2022 13:28

antelopevalley · 27/06/2022 11:56

@Zeus44 you said the son of a council worker. Council workers can be well-paid.
If you mean he lived in a council house, one-third of people in Britain used to live in council houses. It really did not use to mean poverty.
And you totally missed the point. I was talking about how hard it was for me to drag myself into the respectable working class.
You are just another person from privilege pretending not to have any, and lecturing those who come from backgrounds you do not understand. I understand why people like you do it though.

Sorry OP but you haven’t got a clue. Many people lived in council houses but vowed to not be dependent on the council, I am in a comfortable position now through hard work. Looking out of my bedroom window when I was younger didn’t fill me with aspiration, knowing I didn’t want that did though.

Hope you manage to raise your expectations tho and actually put a plan in place to get there. Otherwise you’re just a time waster.

FemmeNatal · 27/06/2022 13:23

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 27/06/2022 13:20

Is this the lesson that is being passed on to your children, that they should just give up from the start, and not bother?

No the lesson for my children is for them to decide what matters most to them and to do what they need to do to get/maintain that, rahter htan assuming more money is always worth what you have to do to get it. And ideally also to give some thought to what contribution to the world at large they are best placed to make.

And most significantly to give them a very clear-eyed understanding of the fact that just because someone has more money than you doesn't necessarily mean they worked harder for it or are any smarter than you are (I'm looking at you Jacob Rees-Mogg). Or indeed any happier. Because the playing field simply is not level, no matter how much you might wish to insist that it is.

You think I’ve suggested that the playing field is level? Why? I’ve neither said it is not implied it. It clearly isn’t, as some children, sadly, will be born to the sort of parents on here that tell them they may as well not try. Sadly many will grow up believing it.

FemmeNatal · 27/06/2022 13:22

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 27/06/2022 13:16

@FemmeNatal

The original example of that just isn’t true though. A £10 pair of work boots will be well-made, with a thick sole that will last for years. A £1,000 pair of Church’s shoes will wear out far more quickly, and require re-soling and refurbishing once a year.

Oh dearie dearie me. I may never be rich, but at least I'll never be as leaden-headed as this either.

In the MADE UP WORLD with dragons and witches he was writing about, there were the two kinds of boots, which served as a metaphor (look it up) for the ways that poverty can end up costing more and having capital to invest can end up saving or making you money. FFS.

I’ve seen many people using it as a real-world example, and no, it wasn’t being used as a metaphor, it was being used as an example. I understand that you think it’s funny to try to make fun of the English of someone for whom it’s not a first language, but it isn’t, it’s just crass.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 27/06/2022 13:20

Is this the lesson that is being passed on to your children, that they should just give up from the start, and not bother?

No the lesson for my children is for them to decide what matters most to them and to do what they need to do to get/maintain that, rahter htan assuming more money is always worth what you have to do to get it. And ideally also to give some thought to what contribution to the world at large they are best placed to make.

And most significantly to give them a very clear-eyed understanding of the fact that just because someone has more money than you doesn't necessarily mean they worked harder for it or are any smarter than you are (I'm looking at you Jacob Rees-Mogg). Or indeed any happier. Because the playing field simply is not level, no matter how much you might wish to insist that it is.

changeornot · 27/06/2022 13:19

@antelopevalley Sorry - no wonder I'm poor 😂 I entirely agree with you - not @FemmeNatal

Yes there are so many people who emit the help they have got....

So they can tell you how hard they work

I think everyone can agree that to tell kids that they can have a good life- and their decisions matter.

BUT-- not everyone is going to be rich......

It's impossible but I do think EVERYONE should live in a society that enables people to have a decent road over their head, a bedroom for their kids. Food in the fridge. Not having to rely on food banks. A holiday once a year. Occasional treats, eating out etc..

This was achievable in the 90s- why is this becoming more difficult?

It kind of feels like you need to be RICH to afford a lifestyle that someone on very modest means could achieve in 1998.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 27/06/2022 13:19

Bearsan · 26/06/2022 08:26

I agree. It is certainly possible. We started with nothing. Problem is people want it instantly and without having to lift a finger or compromise in any way. It usually takes time, some discipline and effort.
Instead of starting and trying it's easier to blame everyone, come up with excuses and how everyone else has/had it easier whinging and continue as before.
Any financial discussion on here ends up with people accusing others of lying, patronising and all the excuses under the sun about why they can't work, save or take any financial responsibility because it's not their fault. Plus loads of anger and jealous accusations towards others who have something eg holiday homes, rental property, decent pension etc,. If you want it you have to make it happen.

It may be possible for some people, it isn't possible for everyone. If everyone was identically talented and driven they still couldn't all be successful. The system is a pyramid, there needs to be a lot of poorer people at the bottom...

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 27/06/2022 13:16

@FemmeNatal

The original example of that just isn’t true though. A £10 pair of work boots will be well-made, with a thick sole that will last for years. A £1,000 pair of Church’s shoes will wear out far more quickly, and require re-soling and refurbishing once a year.

Oh dearie dearie me. I may never be rich, but at least I'll never be as leaden-headed as this either.

In the MADE UP WORLD with dragons and witches he was writing about, there were the two kinds of boots, which served as a metaphor (look it up) for the ways that poverty can end up costing more and having capital to invest can end up saving or making you money. FFS.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 27/06/2022 13:14

@antelopevalley

But my life is better as an adult than I thought it would be as a child. And I am very happily married, and I know that is worth a lot.

This is amazing. And you did that. Again not telling you not to yearn after that comfortable cushion of not having to strive so bloody hard for everything, but make sure you also take some time to exult in what you've achieved because it's amazing ❤

antelopevalley · 27/06/2022 13:00

@MaybeIWillFuckOffThen Thanks for that. I had huge confidence issues when younger. Years of being looked down on by teachers and better off kids as a child and teenager took their toll. It took me years to build up my confidence as a result. And I agree I simply can't risk what we have already on starting up a business that could make much money.
But my life is better as an adult than I thought it would be as a child. And I am very happily married, and I know that is worth a lot.

OP posts:
FemmeNatal · 27/06/2022 12:58

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 27/06/2022 12:31

I hereby refer all to the Sam Vimes 'Boots' theory of economic unfairness as to why it is actually very hard to pull yourself out of poverty. Being poor is incredibly bloody expensive compared to coming from a 'modest' background. It's like trying to climb up a downward escalator instead of the stairs.

The original example of that just isn’t true though. A £10 pair of work boots will be well-made, with a thick sole that will last for years. A £1,000 pair of Church’s shoes will wear out far more quickly, and require re-soling and refurbishing once a year.

So many people here seem to have crossed the line from saying that it is hard to pull yourself up to saying that it’s not even worth trying, and that those who have must be lying about where they started. Is this the lesson that is being passed on to your children, that they should just give up from the start, and not bother?

antelopevalley · 27/06/2022 12:55

@changeornot I know plenty of better-off people take it for granted they can live rent-free with parents or they get a house deposit. I only realised that as an adult when I became friends with people whose parents had some money.
DP has an attitude of being really proud of how much we have achieved. His family are respectable but poor. His father used to eat bread and dripping regularly for tea so there would be enough food for the children to have a proper meal. He also worked from 13 years old and bought his own clothes from his earnings.
Our children should never have to deal with the poverty we both dealt with. But it would have been nice to give them things other people take for granted.

The other dirty little secret is how many people inherit lots of money. I see people retiring in their early fifties because of inheritances or suddenly buying a big house.

A lot of wealth is unearned.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread