Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish I was rich?

161 replies

antelopevalley · 24/06/2022 23:24

Not mega-rich. But to own an ordinary house and have half a million in the bank rich.
I have no family beyond DP and the kids. It would be so lovely to have a really good safety net, and to choose not to work when life is tough.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
socialmedia23 · 07/12/2022 15:50

I was born in a rich family. BUT in my experience, if you are making that half a million pounds out of nothing, you generally need to work in a high stress job. That was how my parents did it. Your expectations grow. A modest house in an average uk town isn't enough. or even workable esp if you are working all hours, you need to live somewhere near to canary wharf.

Half a million in the bank plus the cost of an average uk house (300k) converts to a terraced house in zone 3. And then you have childcare to contend with. You feel like you need to support poorer family members because they don't have your good fortune (my parents supported grandparents). You feel like you need to give your kids a good education because you can't imagine not having this kind of job so you spend money giving them all the tools.

Yes you don't need all the things that I just stated but at the same time, if the reason you are rich is because you work in this high stress job or have this high stress/risky business, what is the point if you can't even give your kid advantages or live in a nice area. And of course your purchasing power is small compared to billionaires and multimillionaires so you don't feel 'rich'

my parents worked from 9 am to 11 pm daily for the first 10 years of my life.

Footballmyarse · 07/12/2022 15:41

I was rich once.

Then I lost everything, ended up on benefits at once point. Now at least own a home (in a shithole), but will probably be on the bottom of the pile for the rest of my life.

I am NOT happier. Fuck that shit.

People always expect me to say I am happier now for some ridiculous reason that only exists in their own heads.

Life was far better with a big house in a posh village, a range rover on the drive and not having to worry about every last penny.

Christmascandycane · 07/12/2022 15:31

I am judged more now for what I have than I was when I had nothing. Why not just judge me for who I am instead?!
Comments such as "I expected you to be posh but you are so down to earth". "I thought you would be up your own arse but you're nice"... thanks, not.

I have a magic house that turns trades people in to bad mathematicians when they come to quote so it is very time consuming sifting through chancers.

My true friends are the ones that were there before my life changed.

(Just to clarify, I didn't marry into wealth. It was personal growth)

I have people wanting to be friends with me to try and validate the illusion of their wealth. It is pathetic because they have no idea or care of other peoples struggles and I have no desire to befriend them and their ignorance.

I refuse to forget my beginning and therefore I help others. I know what it feels like to be hungry. I remember making a shrivelled quarter of a red pepper in my fridge last me 3 days.

To say it isn't beneficial in some ways would be a lie but it isn't what many have told me they imagine it to be.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 07/12/2022 12:18

It’s interesting as I’ve never been on either end of the spectrum, only in the middle. Which is very lucky for me not to have been poor.

Im not financially safe in the way you describe in the OP though - definitely have to always keep working to keep afloat as kids are expensive and I have a high mortgage. This is partly due to having to live in a certain area though.

NewToWoo · 07/12/2022 08:21

DeePlume · 24/06/2022 23:50

I used to be rich, now I am not but I am about a million times happier than I was. Simple life is happy life.

Please tell us more. I find this sort of insight so valuable.

Christmascandycane · 07/12/2022 08:16

Well I have lived on both ends of the spectrum and it is eye opening for sure.

JamSandwichWithNutella · 07/12/2022 08:08

I think it’s possible for most people. DH and I have tripled our income in the last 7 years through payrises and having a small business which doesn’t actually take up a lot of time.

Snowpaw · 07/12/2022 07:33

Most of the wealthy people I know couldn’t just stop work if they wanted to - they are in high pressure careers where people depend on them and they have lengthy contractual obligations and long term projects. This is the reason they’re paid so well, and with that comes an enormous pressure and long working hours.

SpicyFoodRocks · 07/12/2022 06:14

Money does eliminate many worries. That can’t be argued with.

We are both high earners. Though not banker level.

One question is would you want to do those kinds of jobs for the huge salaries? Certainly I would not want a job in banking as it’s not the kind of job I would find rewarding and aspects would not sit well with me morally. I have bright academic kids and I would be disappointed if they ended up in some jobs in the City. I don’t want the life I have seen friends have, who are bankers or partners in City law firms. Not for me or my husband or my teens. No way.

Hugely well-paid jobs (I am talking 300k plus) often require people to work crazy hours, especially at the start. Not see their kids. Fly abroad for meetings. Be at the beck and call of demanding clients 24/7. That’s not a life I would want for my family ever.

But for me, the difference is that I had choices. I had the brains, the background, the privileges to make my career choice and be happy with it. I chose to eschew a City career for something that I found rewarding and socially useful that was also well-paid. That was still lucky and not all down to my amazing skills and hard work. I am a very hard worker and have not called in sick for 30 years. But that’s partly luck too.

So many don’t have the chances. Yes there are a few lucky ones that people like to use as examples. But there are so many barriers to high-earning careers starting from the beginning of someone’s life. An abusive childhood, poverty, lack of role models, poor schooling, poor housing, lack of confidence, mental or physical illness, learning difficulties etc. These can affect kids’ achievements and aspirations in so many ways. It can take a lifetime to reverse the damage. And these issues can persist into adulthood. Also success in the workplace can be much harder to attain for minority groups; let’s not forget that in the City there is still racism, homophobic and sexism.

The few success stories don’t mean it’s possible for everyone (though it’s great to hear the positive stories and people deserve credit for their hard work). But it is in no way possible for many of those who have not had the same starting point as others. And it’s unintelligent and unimaginative to say otherwise.

MilkyYay · 06/12/2022 22:46

Most people who are rich are that way because they don't ever choose not to work, even if it gets tough.

DH and I have a lot (both assets & income).

We could live off either one of us income (both 6 figs). But we don't make that choice because we are always thinking about the safety net, what if one of was killed, what if one of us/both of us ended up with a debilitating condition and couldn't work, what if there's a huge recession, we're always trying to ensure we'd be financially secure/the kids are protected even if the worst happens.

Of course there's a huge amount of good fortune to give us the ability to have those choices at all. But in this position, we make the choices like overpaying mortgage, living off far less than we earn & saving a lot, and it results in us building up assets

bottleofbeer · 06/12/2022 22:20

We've been so poor we didn't have a pot to piss in. We didn't eat so the kids could. It was a huge issue and strain at the time.

Now we're fairly financially secure but just have different worries.

Dontwantanicknamethanks · 06/12/2022 22:20

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

antelopevalley · 06/12/2022 22:15

@Dontwantanicknamethanks Migrants are those with the money and personal resources to emigrate. Most give their kids a lot of support to improve their lives.

OP posts:
Dontwantanicknamethanks · 06/12/2022 22:04

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

RosaGallica · 03/07/2022 11:40

It sounds like you and I have a lot in common. I also come from poverty, worked, did what I was supposed to, passed the exams, looked for something to do with them and found something achievable for me that paid ok. Then had the rug pulled from under me. Had to watch while rising inflation in housing and minimum wage made all of my work meaningless. Sidestepped, tried again, same thing. Officially retrained, found myself with no other really open opportunities other than education which is a godawful employment sector, and one in which I no longer believe. It’s done nothing for me; most people I know did better without trying, just living off their relatives which I don’t have, or simply by being older and being able to access housing before that went out of reach.

The reality is the world has changed and is changing. We are in the middle of a highly turbulent industrial revolution and an even more turbulent economic revolution. I really feel that people don’t realise how much change it’s had! Just 20 years ago the idea of half a million in the bank being ‘reasonable’ wouldn’t exit - half a million would be wealth beyond dreams! A debt of a thousand pounds was a huge event, now we’re told 50k debt is fully acceptable.

Britain is not the same country I was born into. All that matters in this new version is that you come from the right family with practical and informational support, and money. All the things we never had op. Things need to change so much. There needs to be continual lifelong education and opportunities open throughout our lives now to adjust - all the things Blair talked of while making damn sure he put them out of reach for all.

The poster claiming we should all just become investment bankers and we can all do that was pathetic even by Britain’s standards of duplicity.

Rapunzel91 · 03/07/2022 10:56

I’d love a ‘small’ lottery win! I’d happily never work for an employer another single day in my life and use my time investing my win in shares (to grow the put), give my child all educational opportunities and activities she wants, go on multiple holidays, see my family more often and have a larger home (and a holiday home).

bliss!

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 28/06/2022 12:15

FemmeNatal · 27/06/2022 12:58

The original example of that just isn’t true though. A £10 pair of work boots will be well-made, with a thick sole that will last for years. A £1,000 pair of Church’s shoes will wear out far more quickly, and require re-soling and refurbishing once a year.

So many people here seem to have crossed the line from saying that it is hard to pull yourself up to saying that it’s not even worth trying, and that those who have must be lying about where they started. Is this the lesson that is being passed on to your children, that they should just give up from the start, and not bother?

Real world example -

I spent £40 on a pair of boots. they lasted one winter and were beyond repair and really hurt my feet.

I spent £150 on a pair of boots. I've had them about about £15 years and have spent £20 getting them resoled once. They still look great and are comfortable.

So, £170 over 15 years if you can afford £150 upfront. Or £600 if you have to buy the £40 boots every year...

bumpytrumpy · 27/06/2022 15:13

antelopevalley · 27/06/2022 12:10

@FemmeNatal I stuck at school and do not have a criminal record.

Did you have encouragement and help to stay at school and do your work. Did you have people close to you encouraging you to break the law or take drugs?

You are the one with no understanding of other peoples lives.

I think it's easy to argue between yourselves and difficult to understand others backgrounds from a few lines on the internet.

True example (me). Currently earn £75k ish. Very respectable nice house etc.

I would say I had an underprivileged upbringing: Homeless as a child, dad in prison, zero money, food banks and clothes banks were normal. 1 holiday to butlins in my whole childhood (paid for my a random uncle). I studied for my a levels sat in a skip on a council estate using textbooks stolen from Waterstones. Shoplifting was how I had anything beyond the most basic of food & clothing.

What hidden privilege helped me ..? Well I am white, not disabled, healthy, witty, intelligent. Those are all things I cannot control but absolutely helped me raise above the expectations for someone of my ilk.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 27/06/2022 14:20

But again, no-one is claiming any different, or disagreeing. Some low-value jobs are incredibly hard work, some high-value ones involve sitting in a comfortable seat directing others.

@FatCatSkinnyRat took issue with what I said and I was explaining to her. Not quite sure where you got involved tbh. Or why.

FemmeNatal · 27/06/2022 14:10

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 27/06/2022 13:50

No-one is claiming that a labourer on a construction site should earn more than a skilled surgeons just because their job is physically more demanding.

maybe not. But if i had a skilled surgeon for a daughter, I wouldn't tell her she is working harder than a labourer on a construction site. Or indeed working harder than the person who comes in after she's finished and mops the blood off the floor and autoclaves her instruments. What I SAID was

"just because someone has more money than you doesn't necessarily mean they worked harder for it".

I find it hard to see what anyone has to disagree with there.

But again, no-one is claiming any different, or disagreeing. Some low-value jobs are incredibly hard work, some high-value ones involve sitting in a comfortable seat directing others.

antelopevalley · 27/06/2022 14:09

@too people who are poor are more likely to have poor health as they get older than well-off people.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 27/06/2022 14:08

@ToldItToTheBees do not consolidate your debts without advice from someone like CAB or Step Change. Lots of people do this to make things easier and find themselves in worse problems.

OP posts:
changeornot · 27/06/2022 13:58

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 27/06/2022 13:50

No-one is claiming that a labourer on a construction site should earn more than a skilled surgeons just because their job is physically more demanding.

maybe not. But if i had a skilled surgeon for a daughter, I wouldn't tell her she is working harder than a labourer on a construction site. Or indeed working harder than the person who comes in after she's finished and mops the blood off the floor and autoclaves her instruments. What I SAID was

"just because someone has more money than you doesn't necessarily mean they worked harder for it".

I find it hard to see what anyone has to disagree with there.

The person working on the construction site may be working harder, and may of worked just as hard to get that job.

You have to be physically fit, to work on a construction site, it is very demanding.

Also being a highly skilled surgeon is incredibly competitive. Not everyone who works hard will get to be a doctor. Not every doctor who works hard will get to be a highly skilled surgeon.

Being a surgeon requires being innately intelligent, having an excellent education, being emotionally resilient as well as working hard.!

Not everyone will have the emotional resilience, great education or intelligence to do such a role however hard they work towards that goal!

TooManyPJs · 27/06/2022 13:57

HesterShaw1 · 25/06/2022 10:51

People who say "money can't buy happiness" have never been poor.

Money buys security and that's a massive contributor to contentment.

I've been poor. We are now "comfortable" money-wise but I no longer have good health having developed a chronic illness about 6/7 years ago. Was definitely much happier when I was poor and had relatively good health. If I could swap one for the other I definitely would. When people say you don't have anything without your health they are right.

5128gap · 27/06/2022 13:57

No one with a modicum of intelligence, who has genuinely gone from rags to riches could possibly believe that its something open to everyone. Those that have know what it really takes.
You can't have grown up in a disadvantaged community, lived alongside the people there, and harbour the belief that anyone with 'a plan' who works hard can become rich.
You can't have even a rudimentary knowledge of economics, and certainly not sufficient to suceed in business, and genuinely believe that wealth is an option for most people. How can it be? Who would do the low paid work?
So either some people very very stupid, are overplaying the humble nature of their own beginnings or are 'exaggerating' their current success. Either way, they are making fools of themselves and losing more credibility with every post.