Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or am I just old and out of touch?

264 replies

snowdropsandcrocuses · 24/06/2022 21:13

DD 15 has a group of friends consisting of all girls except one male. He's a lovely kid. I guess if I described him I would say good kid, loner, long hair, skinny. He's a nice boy but not particularly sociable.

So we're chatting about her friends and she says her male friend (we will call him Jack) is pansexual. I had to Google this to discover it meant he is attracted to both sexes. She then told me, in all seriousness, he is Aromantic.

I had to pause for a second and confirm she meant he does not like/do romance to which I got another honest, straight faced 'yes'

So wait, there is a 15 year old boy in your friendship group (all girls except him) that is attracted to both (all?) genders and is not interested in romance. In other words, he wants to shag but not date?

I swear I don't get it. She cannot see any irony in the term 'aromantic' for a teenage boy. And I want to stop the train and get off! WineWineWine

OP posts:
88milesanhour · 25/06/2022 04:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Because these miserable keyboard warriors are still wiping the backsides of the kids who are having to navigate all of this.... I honestly couldn't care less how my daughter identifies or what her sexual preferences are and will love her and support her regardless. However maybe I really AM miserable and middle aged coz I just wish kids would spend more time just enjoying their childhood and being innocent for as long as they can and then when they get older just exploring their sexuality and enjoying first boyfriends/girlfriends/theyfriends without having to worry about a label (which may or may not change as they grow up) defining their whole sense of identity or wellbeing. Maybe I just 'don't get it' but I honestly think this is making most kids fundamentally more unhappy and more stressed... or maybe it's a symptom of them being unhappy and stressed who knows... either way for most level-headed parents it's actually quite scary

SeaToSki · 25/06/2022 03:08

S0upertrooper · 24/06/2022 22:54

I read that as aromatic and assumed he wore a lot of perfume 😬

I mis read it the same way as you, but interpreted it as… wasnt so keen on personal hygiene (like many teenager boys I know) and could maybe use an application of soap, deodorant and maybe some perfume too!

Boxowine · 25/06/2022 03:05

When I was that age there was a very popular song called "find em, fuck em, and flee" . I thought that was pretty awful but now apparently we are to understand that these poor young men were just misunderstood Aros.

What a bunch of bullshit. That males who like to fuck with no emotional strings attached are now to be earnestly described as aromantics. A marginalized sub group if you will.

The menopause has really put a damper on my sex drive. The good news is that makes me asexual, or ace. We have our own flag and everything.

anon12345anon · 25/06/2022 02:37

Minster2012 · 24/06/2022 21:45

I'm afraid I have no advice. But now I get why my DH has No interest in romance... he's not a lazy DH he's just Aromantic 🤔

GrinGrin

JaneJeffer · 25/06/2022 02:02

Why on earth do a bunch of middle aged or older Internet warriors think anyone gives a sh1t what they think about how anyone, or whatever age, identifies?
Why do you think anyone gives a shit what you think?

PrincessCarolyn · 25/06/2022 01:57

Excited, think I might be greysexual. Well, that or the men in my life are all mingers. One or the other. Would explain a lot.

UniversalAunt · 25/06/2022 01:56

‘a bunch of middle aged or older Internet warriors’

With respect, less of the ageist bollocks & lazy age based stereotyping.

kingkingmayo · 25/06/2022 01:36

you are not alone and having a gay son myself, i also dont get it the world is moving too fast for people like you and me. I had a very victorian upbringing with life centred around the church.
If my grandma bless her soul was alive now she would get a coronary heart attack for sure just trying to work out all these new terms flying about.

i just google things now !

HangingOver · 25/06/2022 01:35

Yes, but you’re Not Allowed to have that “identity” so don’t tell the identity police your plans

Bit mad innit. I don't see how it can be prejudice to not fancy transwomen...I just don't, can't help that. Transmen and non-binary people who were born female I find super attractive tho.

SpacePotato · 25/06/2022 01:27

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

honeybushbunch · 25/06/2022 01:22

HangingOver · 25/06/2022 01:18

Blimey, there's a label for everything these days! I would date men, women and transmen but not transwomen....do I get a special name? 😃

Yes, but you’re Not Allowed to have that “identity” so don’t tell the identity police your plans 😂

TheWayoftheLeaf · 25/06/2022 01:21

Yes so it means he's willing to have sec with any gender but doesn't feel romantic relationship vibes towards anyone.

Basically, he'll fuck anyone but won't love them.

HangingOver · 25/06/2022 01:18

Blimey, there's a label for everything these days! I would date men, women and transmen but not transwomen....do I get a special name? 😃

honeybushbunch · 25/06/2022 01:17

TeaKlaxon · 25/06/2022 00:58

That whole post sounds like it is also arguing against gay and bi people adopting the ‘label’ and the identity.

After all, in your example, you’re suggesting that the potential change in sexual orientation (or perhaps realisation that the original sexual orientation was never real or right in the first place) is an argument against adopting labels.

Why would it be any different for a 16 year old to come out as gay than for a 16 year old to come out as pan?

Of course both 16 year olds have other attributes about themselves - they are not defined solely by their sexual preferences (defining their sexual orientation doesn’t imply otherwise); both might in the future decide their sexual orientation has changed, or was never pan/gay to begin with and they were mistaken (but so what?).

I assume you’re not claiming even gay people should not have labels, identities and communities? So why shouldn’t pansexual and other identities have the same?

I think you’re misunderstanding completely. It’s an equally valid viewpoint to think that your sexuality is not fixed or labellable and isn’t an “identity” at all - that in fact was the belief throughout most of history. You can be gay or lesbian or bi or straight and still not believe your sexuality is part of your “identity”, or indeed “identify” with any label. Lots of people are like that - more than you think, if you actually ask people.

Many people over the age of 30 who you assume are straight don’t actually fit that label at all. Some people like labels. Others don’t.You’ll find a lot of people don’t fit into the boxes if you get to know them better instead of assuming that you “clearly know” that most people on here are straight.

Your viewpoint is a really recent way of thinking about sexuality and identity, and it’s by no means the only one or necessarily the right one, either. It’s just one way of thinking. Assuming that everyone here is past it and ignorant because they don’t subscribe to the currently fashionable gender labels is your assumption.

wohmum · 25/06/2022 01:12

Laiste · 24/06/2022 22:27

''Unexpected baby in the "uterus haver" being the least of it.''

Sorry, i have a dark sense of humour, but that really made me laugh 😂

Me too!

honeybushbunch · 25/06/2022 01:08

Also lolz to the “Straight people have never had to deal with their sexual and romantic preferences getting discussed in different scenarios because their preferences have never deviated from societal assumptions”.Throughout all of recorded history women’s sexual and romantic preferences and whether they are right or wrong or normal or abnormal or societally approved of or not have been up for discussion everywhere and every which way going.

The idea that “queer” people are uniquely oppressed by everyone wanting to know about, discuss and police their sexuality, but that straight women don’t experience this, is so laughable and historically ignorant it’s almost funny. On the very day Roe v Wade gets overturned; yet somehow the identitarians still think that “cis straight” women somehow enjoy great societal freedom from having their “sexuality discussed in different scenarios” …

ScaredAdopter · 25/06/2022 01:04

honeybushbunch · 25/06/2022 00:58

All this is just a huge load of assumptions, lots of which are not true. And less of the “queer”, thanks. Lots of us have had that shouted at us as a nasty slur and don’t feel like reclaiming it; but that still doesn’t mean you can go about assuming everyone’s straight and “sneering”.

You could do with less of the making heteronormative assumptions yourself to be honest, and more of the being a bit more open to listening to others’ lived experiences.

If you’ve read the thread and not concluded that the vast majority of posters are straight and wouldn’t know a queer identity if it bit them on the backside, then you’re not reading the same thread.

Of course there may be some LGBT+ posters joining in the sneering - they’re not much different to the small minority of gay people who used to (maybe some still do?) sneer at bi people - but the vast majority of sneerers are very obviously straight and all of them are very wrong.

TeaKlaxon · 25/06/2022 01:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TeaKlaxon · 25/06/2022 00:58

honeybushbunch · 25/06/2022 00:50

So you’re assuming everyone here is heterosexual and has never questioned their sexuality? Nice one.

Don’t you think that (a) it’s pretty impressive that anyone can know their “micro-identity” anyway as a teenager with the usual limited life and sexual experience of that age; and (b) attaching a label like “demisexual” simply assumes that no-one else has similar feelings/experiences — when in fact, if you cared to ask, you’d find out lots of people do?

That’s way before we get to the fact that it’s a very recent thing to label and internalise behaviours as identities. Most people over the age of 25 tend to think of their selves as not reduced to collections of preferences or behaviours, many of which are actually undertaken in conjunction with other people, not just isolated within the self — as well as changing over time.

I might feel not very sexual at 25, feel roaringly so but very lesbian at 35, meet men I like at 40 who I want to shag but am not that in love with, then at 50 be mainly attracted to women romantically but less sexually, because I’ve met some like-minded women I get on with….The difference is that I don’t see any of those things as being part of my “identity”: they are experiences I have, in conjunction with the people I meet — but they aren’t some kind of essential aspect of my self. (If I thought they were, I’d be very confused all the time!)

That whole post sounds like it is also arguing against gay and bi people adopting the ‘label’ and the identity.

After all, in your example, you’re suggesting that the potential change in sexual orientation (or perhaps realisation that the original sexual orientation was never real or right in the first place) is an argument against adopting labels.

Why would it be any different for a 16 year old to come out as gay than for a 16 year old to come out as pan?

Of course both 16 year olds have other attributes about themselves - they are not defined solely by their sexual preferences (defining their sexual orientation doesn’t imply otherwise); both might in the future decide their sexual orientation has changed, or was never pan/gay to begin with and they were mistaken (but so what?).

I assume you’re not claiming even gay people should not have labels, identities and communities? So why shouldn’t pansexual and other identities have the same?

honeybushbunch · 25/06/2022 00:58

TeaKlaxon · 25/06/2022 00:52

Precisely.

’it’s no one’s business’

Apart from the dozens of ways in which our sexual and romantic preferences get discussed in different scenarios.

Straight people have never had to deal with that because their preferences have never deviated from societal assumptions.

What’s more, they have never had the need to identify other people with similar preferences as them in order to make sense of it or get support - 90% of people around them had the same preferences. The vast majority (until recently the only) depictions in media were of people like them. Those of us growing up queer - of whatever shade - needed to find others like us because it was the way to make sense of why we didn’t feel like society and media told us we should. And to form communities to combat the ignorant sneering so prevalent on this thread.

All this is just a huge load of assumptions, lots of which are not true. And less of the “queer”, thanks. Lots of us have had that shouted at us as a nasty slur and don’t feel like reclaiming it; but that still doesn’t mean you can go about assuming everyone’s straight and “sneering”.

You could do with less of the making heteronormative assumptions yourself to be honest, and more of the being a bit more open to listening to others’ lived experiences.

Foxgluv · 25/06/2022 00:58

nahnothanks · 25/06/2022 00:26

If you’re one of those people saying there’s no need for labels, and you’re also heterosexual and have never questioned your sexuality/gender… maybe you just can’t see the need for them because you are the norm?

No. I like a 'prefer not to say' on a questionnaire. There's nothing wrong with not wanting to be labeled.
You don't have to fit in that box of what you describe as 'the norm' heterosexual, never questioning sexuality to think that you don't have to be defined by a label. The labels at the moment seem to be sexual or gender specific.
It's fine to identify as yourself, as diverse and as complex as that might be. Thoughts and feelings change. Not everyone desires to be pigeonholed.

honeybushbunch · 25/06/2022 00:54

(I see there are even more posters on the thread now assuming we’re all straight! You couldn’t be more wrong; and that in itself shows the arrogance of this fad for labels and “identities”. Perhaps, if you cared to listen to some of the old mummies you assume are so ignorant about sexuality, you might hear something interesting and useful.)

TeaKlaxon · 25/06/2022 00:52

nahnothanks · 25/06/2022 00:26

If you’re one of those people saying there’s no need for labels, and you’re also heterosexual and have never questioned your sexuality/gender… maybe you just can’t see the need for them because you are the norm?

Precisely.

’it’s no one’s business’

Apart from the dozens of ways in which our sexual and romantic preferences get discussed in different scenarios.

Straight people have never had to deal with that because their preferences have never deviated from societal assumptions.

What’s more, they have never had the need to identify other people with similar preferences as them in order to make sense of it or get support - 90% of people around them had the same preferences. The vast majority (until recently the only) depictions in media were of people like them. Those of us growing up queer - of whatever shade - needed to find others like us because it was the way to make sense of why we didn’t feel like society and media told us we should. And to form communities to combat the ignorant sneering so prevalent on this thread.

honeybushbunch · 25/06/2022 00:50

nahnothanks · 25/06/2022 00:26

If you’re one of those people saying there’s no need for labels, and you’re also heterosexual and have never questioned your sexuality/gender… maybe you just can’t see the need for them because you are the norm?

So you’re assuming everyone here is heterosexual and has never questioned their sexuality? Nice one.

Don’t you think that (a) it’s pretty impressive that anyone can know their “micro-identity” anyway as a teenager with the usual limited life and sexual experience of that age; and (b) attaching a label like “demisexual” simply assumes that no-one else has similar feelings/experiences — when in fact, if you cared to ask, you’d find out lots of people do?

That’s way before we get to the fact that it’s a very recent thing to label and internalise behaviours as identities. Most people over the age of 25 tend to think of their selves as not reduced to collections of preferences or behaviours, many of which are actually undertaken in conjunction with other people, not just isolated within the self — as well as changing over time.

I might feel not very sexual at 25, feel roaringly so but very lesbian at 35, meet men I like at 40 who I want to shag but am not that in love with, then at 50 be mainly attracted to women romantically but less sexually, because I’ve met some like-minded women I get on with….The difference is that I don’t see any of those things as being part of my “identity”: they are experiences I have, in conjunction with the people I meet — but they aren’t some kind of essential aspect of my self. (If I thought they were, I’d be very confused all the time!)

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 25/06/2022 00:46

Literally nobody would bat an eyelid if a 12yo girl said she had a boyfriend, or vice versa

I would actually. If my daughter came home at the age of 12 and said she had a boyfriend, or a girlfriend, I would be concerned.

My daughter came out when she was 12 and that doesn't bother me at all. She fancies females. So what.

But if she told me she had a girlfriend at the age of 12, 12!!!! Yes I would bat an eyelid. Straight, gay, bi, nobody should be in a 'relationship' at that age.