Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or am I just old and out of touch?

264 replies

snowdropsandcrocuses · 24/06/2022 21:13

DD 15 has a group of friends consisting of all girls except one male. He's a lovely kid. I guess if I described him I would say good kid, loner, long hair, skinny. He's a nice boy but not particularly sociable.

So we're chatting about her friends and she says her male friend (we will call him Jack) is pansexual. I had to Google this to discover it meant he is attracted to both sexes. She then told me, in all seriousness, he is Aromantic.

I had to pause for a second and confirm she meant he does not like/do romance to which I got another honest, straight faced 'yes'

So wait, there is a 15 year old boy in your friendship group (all girls except him) that is attracted to both (all?) genders and is not interested in romance. In other words, he wants to shag but not date?

I swear I don't get it. She cannot see any irony in the term 'aromantic' for a teenage boy. And I want to stop the train and get off! WineWineWine

OP posts:
ExitChasedByABee · 25/06/2022 09:18

Like would that make me aromantic because I don’t conform to what mainstream media considers to be “romantic”? Or maybe I just don’t like flowers and dates? I just feel like what is considered normal romantic behaviour is subjective and based on specific cultural norms. For example, breakfast in bed is something I try to do on a daily basis, but for me it’s an expression of love but it doesn’t have romantic connotations because I’d still do that for friends and family who are staying over etc. Or even if I stay over at a relative’s house and they’re feeling under the weather, I’d make them breakfast and send it up in a tray etc.

That’s why I find the “aromantic” label confusing. If someone is in a relationship and has a sexual connection but it’s entirely devoid of romance, wouldn’t that be more of a FWB situation because there is no relationship? 🤔

WheresTheLambSauce · 25/06/2022 09:17

BracedlnEndIessJanuary · 24/06/2022 22:14

I thought pansexual = not fussy/will shag anything...it I am not very woke Wink
Demisexuals is another one Hmm only sexually attracted if have made an emotional connection first (no shag at first sight just for them, oh no).
Makes me yearn for Naomi Klein to write No Label.

Re: The demisexuality, it’s a fair bit more nuanced than that, I’d argue. It’s not just “no shag at first sight”, it can feel genuinely alienating & confusing when people around you talk about sexual attraction and how easily it appears to come to them. But there’s not a complete absence of sexual attraction like with asexuality either, it just takes years of trust and emotional intimacy before you feel anything.

It also makes dating quite a bit harder, from my experience. You want to put yourself out there to meet more people and form connections, but everyone else seems to be comfortable moving at a faster pace than you. How can they be comfortable with “making this A Thing” on the third or fourth date, when it’s taken you that long just to feel ready to hold their hand or share a kiss?

Maybe it’s self-image, maybe it’s lack of trust, maybe it’s a fun little bouquet of mental health issues that affect how I handle intimacy. But until I pull apart all the tangled threads that make up my psyche, demisexual/demiromantic is an idea that makes me feel a little less alone. And of course you don’t have to agree, I just wanted to share my personal view on it 💕

FiddlefigOnTheRoof · 25/06/2022 09:17

It’s basically akin to astrology, no?

It’s fine for people to get meaning from them, to use it to discuss their and others’ feelings.

But I don’t feel the need to be ‘supportive’ to some random’s internal feelings about sexuality and ‘romance’ (whatever the hell that is). Really couldn’t care less if someone declared themselves to be Demi sexual or bloody Pisces.

DizzyWhoreI8O4 · 25/06/2022 09:12

Be understanding and supportive to these ”new labels”

No, I'm not going to 'support' new labels which tell teenage girls that the feelings of men who want to shag around should be respected and accommodated, and if you don't you're ostracised/phobic.

Just like I'm not going to support things like lesbians being coerced into sex with male bodies for fear of being ostracised.

Bollocks to that.

Bednobsbroomsticks · 25/06/2022 09:12

Can you imagine what mumsnet will look like in 10 years time?

Trending...

My aromantic transgender gay husband doesn't want me anymore.

My husband just had our first baby and won't breastfeed our human

My mum was chucked out of a woman's changing room for having a womb

Lol. Personally I don't care what people are. Just don't bang on about it

balalake · 25/06/2022 09:11

I am not up to date with some of the terms that are used. Though saying 'like' in every sentence still seems to be current.

334bu · 25/06/2022 09:09

So friend is into one night stands with anyone with a heartbeat. Simples!

Darhon · 25/06/2022 09:09

I’ve kids the same age. In my youth there was a lot of tribalism round music. So you got a label in a different way. In terms of sexual identity, it was completely heteronormative.

I just see the current terms as the standard way teens go through their identity formation. And thank god, they are discussing other types of sexuality. I’m almost aghast nowadays if a teen tells me they are straight 🤣🤣🤣

Like us, they will mature, their brains will become less plastic and they will move into boring adulthood.

ExitChasedByABee · 25/06/2022 09:09

smallbeetle · 25/06/2022 08:31

Yes, so this label is just a way of legitimizing a guy who likes shagging around, but he can’t be criticized for hurting or using women as that is his ‘identity’. Shagging around is no longer something he does but something he is which cannot be critiqued or questioned. Right.

So now I am curious is whether an actual difference between an “aromantic” and a “player”? Because when I Googled the definition of an aromantic person, I found that it’s part of the 'A' on the LGBTQIA+ spectrum and that an aromanic person can still feel sexual attraction, but they might not identify with the way romance is often presented in current media and culture.

But it could all be to do with how romance is portrayed in mainstream media? Like the whole going on dates and sending flowers etc. are seen as romantic gestures. I’ve never been interested in that and I know several who are and many who aren’t. I just feel like what is even the definition of “romance” because even “love” has different means and connotations based on context. What I think is romantic might not be considered romantic by others for example.

PumpkinSpicedLatte22 · 25/06/2022 09:08

I'm convinced they're just making up words at this point

CaptainMyCaptain · 25/06/2022 08:57

nahnothanks · 24/06/2022 22:16

It might be ludicrous to you, but that’s likely because you’ve never heard it before and you can’t identify with it.

I think it’s great that kids and teens have so much awareness and open dialogue around different sexualities and gender identities now. I didn’t come out as bisexual until I was in my 30s because when I was a teenager, and a young adult, I didn’t even know it was genuinely a thing (because everyone just laughed at it). It would have made a difference if people were accepting of it when I was 15.

Gentle support costs nothing and can mean everything to a kid of that age. You could just be accepting and not grumble about it. What are you afraid of? What difference does it make to you if someone can describe themselves in a way that makes them feel comfortable in their own skin?

Great post.

Teenagers are just figuring out who they want to be and using words we've never heard of before. When I was in my teens (late 60s/ early 70s) nobody even dared come out as gay at least they can be more open about it now. Some of my grandsons' friends have given themselves labels like this but I wonder if it as much about avoiding sexual commitment rather than shagging everything in sight. Just keep listening and let them work it out for themselves. As long as each individual relationship is conducted with respect and consideration what's the worst that could happen? Respect and consideration including contraception and avoiding STDs of course and if someone did get pregnant - well it's not exactly new is it?

ExitChasedByABee · 25/06/2022 08:56

@AllAloneInThisHouse What about me? You were being condescending to another person, telling them that they’d understand “now”. only if they’ve bothered to “learn and be respectful” which I thought was both unkind and not very open-minded of you. Hence the reason I quoted your words back to you as it’s actually something I agree with. We need to be able to be more open-minded and kind and discuss things without people sneering.

AllAloneInThisHouse · 25/06/2022 08:52

@snowdropsandcrocuses

Yes, you are old and out of touch.

SuziSecondLaw · 25/06/2022 08:50

I have two teenagers, if I've never heard of something they mention, I ask about it.. I'm not struggling to understand anything so far.

It's a bit like those personality types, or love language etc.. Not something I care about, but some people do and that's fine.

curlymam · 25/06/2022 08:38

@MattDillonsEyebrows I understand what you're saying but it's not something I've grown out of as I've gotten older and (hopefully) wiser. I still only feel sexual attraction towards DH. If a new guy started in the office and I wanted to jump his bones then obviously I'd re-evaluate, but with all the information I have this is who I am.
I think some of the confusion comes from people's understanding of sexual attraction in this context. It's not just I don't want to have sex with strangers, it's that I literally don't feel anything for anyone. No twinges, no butterflies, never horny, no thoughts of that guy from Bridgerton when I'm alone. I genuinely found it quite frightening.

AllAloneInThisHouse · 25/06/2022 08:36

ExitChasedByABee · 25/06/2022 07:47

@AllAloneInThisHouse To quote your own words back to you you “Have you thought about being more open-minded and kinder person?”

Yes.
Now, how about you?

honeybushbunch · 25/06/2022 08:36

AllAloneInThisHouse · 25/06/2022 08:11

Well, be usefull then.
Be understanding and supportive to these ”new labels” (these things have always existed, only now being more talked about).
Stop sneering and looking down on your nose, thinking you know everything, when clearly you don’t.
I mean help is most of these comments?

It’s you who seem to be doing most of the sneering, tbh.

If these microlabels are all so necessary, why have they only been invented on tumblr in the last five years?

This is an entirely internet manufactured trend, quite separate from being gay or bi, and it isn’t actually very healthy to be obsessing about labelling yourself all the time. I know a fair few young people for whom it causes great anxiety and mental health distress around constant self-examination and trying to fit in; whose labels and pronouns change all the time and who seem exhausted by it all.

And really, it is quite silly to call oneself “catgender” or whatever, isn’t it (and I do know a couple of young women who do). I’ve seen lots of microlabels that genuinely are a bit ridiculous - anime related for example, or silly stuff like “Neptunian” - which have been thought up on the internet by teenagers and really have no relationship whatsoever to the experiences of people who have struggled with marginalised sexualities. (Some might in fact find it quite offensive; these are for the great part not kids who have ever experienced any actual real social marginalisation about their sexual identity, and it’s also trivialising and reducing actual oppression to play at it with microlabels, no?) But it’s not “sneering” to have a bit of amused perspective about what is a teenage fad for things that older people have a bit more life experience about.

TeaKlaxon · 25/06/2022 08:31

3peassuit · 25/06/2022 07:48

I’m all for doing whatever makes you happy as long as no one is hurt but why do they expect everyone to want to know or care what they identify as?

This is no different from the bigoted argument that gay people shouldn’t be out because people shouldn’t want to know or care.

smallbeetle · 25/06/2022 08:31

HollowTalk · 24/06/2022 21:51

I'd just say, there have always been boys who just want sex and don't want a relationship. Say, we used to have a different name for them though.

Yes, so this label is just a way of legitimizing a guy who likes shagging around, but he can’t be criticized for hurting or using women as that is his ‘identity’. Shagging around is no longer something he does but something he is which cannot be critiqued or questioned. Right.

SummerPuddings · 25/06/2022 08:30

Seasoned with aromantic spices, thyme, rosemary, lavender? 🌿🧄🪴🍵😹

Skelligsfeathers · 25/06/2022 08:26

honeybushbunch · 25/06/2022 01:08

Also lolz to the “Straight people have never had to deal with their sexual and romantic preferences getting discussed in different scenarios because their preferences have never deviated from societal assumptions”.Throughout all of recorded history women’s sexual and romantic preferences and whether they are right or wrong or normal or abnormal or societally approved of or not have been up for discussion everywhere and every which way going.

The idea that “queer” people are uniquely oppressed by everyone wanting to know about, discuss and police their sexuality, but that straight women don’t experience this, is so laughable and historically ignorant it’s almost funny. On the very day Roe v Wade gets overturned; yet somehow the identitarians still think that “cis straight” women somehow enjoy great societal freedom from having their “sexuality discussed in different scenarios” …

This!!!!!

Foxgluv · 25/06/2022 08:24

she understood that for some of those children they were genuinely struggling with this issue but mostly she thinks it’s a fashion.

I was encouraged that she expressed that view but also worried that if she voices it in some contexts she’ll be dismissed as a TERF and accused of transphobia.
@Picoloangel I think this is a factor that some people on here don't want to admit or haven't had their eyes open to yet. There's also a trend to be the world's number one victim at the moment. This is happening from a very young age. It's becoming a societal norm. Before anyone nit picks I'm not referring to genuine cases.
The problem with having labels for labels is that you run the risk of using them incorrectly and then it's time for character assassination no matter how accepting you are.

What I don't get is, why does anyone need to know? As long as it's legal who cares what sexual interests other people have? Why this need for everyone to be 'Proud' about it and share loudly and ad nauseum with all and sundry?! That's the oddest part to me.
@PestoPasghetti Exactly. There's a fierce fight going on with people. Not for acceptance, for attention.
One of my close friends was like that. Came out when we were in school. Had only committed female relationships for almost 20 years until she married a man.

If a 15yo has the self awareness to be open about the fact they don’t want romantic relationships, good for them. It’s a hell of a lot more honest than the behaviour you constantly see from adults.
@nahnothanks the point being raised is that two conflicting statements were made about his sexuality. He's romantically attracted to both sexes, but isn't interested romantically. You wouldn't say you're straight and gay. I wouldn't put that down to having self awareness. It sounds like a child trying to navigate who they are, feeling like they have to label themself without really knowing. It must put a lot of pressure on.

MattDillonsEyebrows · 25/06/2022 08:23

curlymam · 24/06/2022 23:03

I identify as demisexual. I spent my teenage years very confused and upset as to why I didn't feel sexual attraction like "normal people". I thought I was asexual, until I met my DH and fell in love and discovered I was sexually attracted to him.
If this knowledge and understanding had been around when I was younger it would have been life changing.

@curlymam But if you'd not spent your teenage years confused and upset about that, it would have been something else. Teenagers by their very nature are confused and upset! They spend their lives trying to fit in but also trying to be individual whilst trying to pave their way in an increasingly scary world with hormone raging as their puberty settles down. I don't know a single person who went through their teenage years feeling' normal' therefore we all probably were.

Isn't is possible that you were in fact a completely normal teenager, and lots of other teenagers despite what they probably bragged about were the same and didn't feel sexual attraction?

Sexuality and sexual attraction is pushed on people so much, that it's become the expected norm. To give it a label just means that others who might not feel that way will feel as alienated as you did.

Also, the label you've given yourself is pretty awful as 'Demi' implies half or inferior. Does this mean you think you're inferior or only half sexual because the only bloke you fancy is your partner? I truly hope not, you deserve better than that.

Angelou79 · 25/06/2022 08:17

Pan sexual means you love the person regardless of gender/identity

zoomstyle · 25/06/2022 08:17

Well they've got to be something because then they get one of these lovely flags to help describe their personality innate gender identity.

If you don't have shiny exciting gender identity then you're boring old cis, with a grey flag to match. Who would want to be that?!

(I can't believe people are taking this nonsense seriously.)

Or am I just old and out of touch?
Or am I just old and out of touch?
Swipe left for the next trending thread