Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be conflicted by the crackdown on 2nd homes

329 replies

chairz · 24/06/2022 16:23

I complete understand the problems they cause & do agree with a higher levy but thenI have used holiday cottages lots of times in the past & plan to in the future.

OP posts:
altmember · 25/06/2022 12:22

It's an issue, but it's a complicated one, and I've not seen any serious ideas suggested that would fix it. I live in Cornwall so I'm very familiar with the problem.

Most new builds aren't bought by second home owners, because they're not in the 'right place'. Generally the touristy/second home hotspots are in the centre of the quaint little villages (mostly the coastal areas round here). The pressure of second homes won't be alleviated by simply banning new builds from being them.

And there are two types of second homes - those that are bought as investments (and let out), and those that are bought purely for private use by their owners. At least the ones that are let out (on AirBNB etc, who are being wrongly blamed for the issue), at least offer the positive that they are bringing in a regular churn of tourists to the area, with all the consequential spending and trade that they generate. The worst part of the problem is the private second homes, where their owners come and visit for the occasional weekend get away or a week in the summer, but the rest of the year they sit completely vacant. And even when those second home owners do come down and use their places, they don't generally do the touristy things - they're not out spending money like someone who's down here for their annual holiday. They come for the quiet get away and tend to stay in their houses much more.

House next door to me is a holiday home owned by a middle aged couple who live several hours away. They only visit once or twice a month at most, and never stay more than two nights. Sometimes we don't even see them for 6 to 8 weeks. While they're down here they do a bit of gardening, go for walks, and sit in and watch tv. They don't use the local shops down here, not even the supermarkets, as they usually bring a weekend supply of food with them. Their holiday home ownership entitles them to the same 'local passes' that many tourist attractions offer for local residents, so even when they do go out, they're not paying full price for admissions in the way that proper tourists would.

Tourism trade is so very seasonal - there are a couple of months of chaos in the summer, spring and autumn ticks over, and the depths of winter are almost dead. The advantage of houses as holiday lets is that they are usable all year round. So while camp sites, holiday parks, traditional b&b's and small hotels, and most purpose built holiday accommodation are all closed during the winter months, at least holiday let houses are still there providing winter holiday accommodation, which keeps a trickle of tourism flowing through the winter.

You've got to realise that most second home owners are pretty wealthy, so any financial disincentive you put in place (stamp duty, council tax premiums etc) is like water off a duck's back to them. It does set the bar a little higher and might price out the average joe investors who buy to let out as holiday lets, but the worst culprits will still be able to afford their private second homes and won't be deterred at all.

The biggest underlying issue is the same one that causes a lot of the social issues in the UK - central government seems unable to see anything outside of the M25/South East. Politicians are out of touch with reality and they have no appreciation of what life is like beyond that (even in the own constituencies many of them). Never mind the far flung corners of the country that are living in relative (or genuine) poverty.

As an example, all the municipal leisure centre's in Cornwall are managed by a leisure operator that's based in London. They have absolutely no idea about how to run the centres down here, it's all done as though they're aimed at the same inner city/urban market as the up country ones. Their prices are based on London prices, so as you can well expect, that's put most potential users right off. The leisure centres are now massively underused and going into contraction - closing early, or closing down completely. The leisure operator has made them unprofitable and is reneging on their contract to run them, handing them back to the local authority in a terrible state.

And it's because house prices are so inflated in other parts of the country that it allows people to so easily release equity and afford to buy second homes in (what were) the cheaper locations. Devon went through this years ago - probably because it was more accessible whereas Cornwall was a bit too far away for most people to consider for second homes as weekend getaways. Now Devon is fully saturated and transport/roads improved, it's pushed the problem further west.

Dobbysgotthesocks · 25/06/2022 12:20

Court paperwork arrived for me this morning. I will be officially homeless in less than a month.

Why

Because my house will be used as an Airbnb from now on.

There is nothing for me to rent within a commutable distance to my business.

I will be living in my car. With cancer

riesenrad · 25/06/2022 12:12

I think it is wrong that residential properties are taken over as second homes or holiday homes. There was a thread on here recently about a lady who will be made homeless because her landlord is selling up - with hundreds of thousands of empty homes, and then second homes, nobody should be in that position. We DO have enough houses, we just don't manage them properly.

bellac11 · 25/06/2022 12:07

AppleCharlottie · 25/06/2022 11:54

I had a flat originally in London...the tourists are basically the only thing making something of the town, if we didnt have visIitors the insular and backward nature of the thinking in the towns would take over.

Can't believe I just read this!

Definitely believe it, its well known that the incomers are the ones that have invigorated, revitalised the area and challenged the corruption in the local councils which effectively continued to destroy the place while lining their own pockets.

Octomore · 25/06/2022 12:02

To be clear, by my the way, when I use the word "locals", what I mean is someone who lives and works full time in the community.

They don't have to have been born there, or have family going back 3 generations, they just need to be currently living and working as a member of the community. They could have come from abroad, or the other end of the country - it doesn't matter.

This isn't about xenophobia or little-Englandism, but about sustaining healthy communities.

Octomore · 25/06/2022 11:57

AppleCharlottie · 25/06/2022 11:54

I had a flat originally in London...the tourists are basically the only thing making something of the town, if we didnt have visIitors the insular and backward nature of the thinking in the towns would take over.

Can't believe I just read this!

And they wonder why "DFLs" have a bad reputation 😂

(I grew up in London, so not anti-londoner at all, but that poster was a very bad example of one!)

Octomore · 25/06/2022 11:55

Yeh, but taking the tourists out won't make it a healthy mixed economy, would it?

That might be a good argument if I was arguing to remove tourists. But I'm not.

I'm arguing that an area shouldn't be allowed to lose the critical mass of locals (and therefore housing for those locals) that will sustain the community.

Upthread, I suggested that holiday lets should need permits, and that councils should cap the number of permits. Priority should be given to those holiday let properties which don't actually have permission for full-time residential use, and so couldn't be a local home regardless.

faffadoodledo · 25/06/2022 11:54

Intheflicker · 25/06/2022 11:53

No one should have two homes until everybody has one

Yep

AppleCharlottie · 25/06/2022 11:54

I had a flat originally in London...the tourists are basically the only thing making something of the town, if we didnt have visIitors the insular and backward nature of the thinking in the towns would take over.

Can't believe I just read this!

Intheflicker · 25/06/2022 11:53

No one should have two homes until everybody has one

Octomore · 25/06/2022 11:51

how does GPs surgeries come into it, are tourists registering for the week that they are on holiday?

GP surgeries close when there aren't enough local residents to sustain them, which means worse service for those that remain.

Although, tourists do use walk-in centres etc. I presume this is what the poster referred to, as she didn't actually mention "GPs".

faffadoodledo · 25/06/2022 11:51

People are confusing holiday lets
with second homes. There's an arguement that both are bad for local economies, but second homes are the more toxic. Second homes are empty most of the year and add nothing to the local economy except property inflation. Holiday lets at least give locals and income. Holiday lets needed the Covid grant; second home owners decidedly didn't!

Maireas · 25/06/2022 11:50

Octomore · 25/06/2022 11:49

Honestly just ask yourself whether you would like YOUR area to be solely dependent on a single, low paying, seasonal industry.

You wouldn't, would you? You definitely want a healthy, mixed economy in the area you live, so why begrudge people in tourist areas who want the same?

Yeh, but taking the tourists out won't make it a healthy mixed economy, would it?

Octomore · 25/06/2022 11:49

Honestly just ask yourself whether you would like YOUR area to be solely dependent on a single, low paying, seasonal industry.

You wouldn't, would you? You definitely want a healthy, mixed economy in the area you live, so why begrudge people in tourist areas who want the same?

bellac11 · 25/06/2022 11:46

SnapDog · 25/06/2022 10:52

@BoredZelda - I live in a tourist area that was doing just fine, in terms of visitor numbers, before every man and his dog decided to do AirBnB.

Families have nowhere to go as the landlords have sold up - with little notice - to sell (to people who want second homes and who have pushed local prices up even more) or to use for holidays lets.

Now there are far too many tourists - it’s horrendous already, even walking through the local towns, and we aren’t in peak season yet. The drs surgeries and hospital can’t cope. The supermarkets run out of food. The fuel runs out on “changeover day” as the tourists fill up to go home..and there are are huge queues for the garages that have any left.

There are barely any waiters, chefs, bar staff.. so many small businesses stopped opening in the evening/reduced days last year because they didn’t have the staff to open, so they lost profit there. These staff no longer exist as they cannot rent accommodation locally. The businesses trying to stay open put their wages up to try and compete for the staff available. These businesses are not benefiting from the mass influx of tourists, they are struggling to stay afloat.

Business is booming for cleaners though!. Prices have increased from £12ph to £20ph in the last year. There is more to be made from cleaning holiday lets than there is from other jobs in hospitality… affecting local businesses who are already struggling for staff… and so on.

Where is this hugely popular tourist area where people who live there and also visit there as a tourist cant get petrol, food in the supermarkets and where theres no waiting or hospitality staff to provide services so presumably theres nothing for people to do?

Also how does GPs surgeries come into it, are tourists registering for the week that they are on holiday?

We live in a tourist area, we moved here to buy somewhere we could afford as we couldnt afford to buy a house in London, I had a flat originally in London, the tourists are basically the only thing making something of the town, if we didnt have visitors the insular and backward nature of the thinking in the towns would take over.

Octomore · 25/06/2022 11:35

Don't get me wrong - I like seeing tourists around. It makes the place feel very cheerful, as people on holiday tend to be happy. I say hello to the tourists I see around just as much as I do to my neighbours (this is normal behaviour up north, for those who find it odd!). I go on holiday to other areas, and I am also a tourist when I go away - so no prejudice here.

But I wouldn't want my area to be dependent on tourist income for survival. There is a critical mass of local people which is needed to sustain a healthy community and diverse economy. Right now, my area has that, but I would hate to see it tip the other way (as has happened in many other areas, such as Cornwall).

The kind of jobs that a tourist industry brings tend to be low pay, low skill, low prospects, low security. Casual seasonal work that is great for young people on their summer break, but not so good for someone trying to generate a secure income to raise a family.

Surely all this is obvious?

SnapDog · 25/06/2022 11:34

@BoredZelda and @Maireas - It is a good things. It’s important. I’ve never been negative about tourism, even when others are. I’m lucky to live somewhere beautiful and I want others to be able to enjoy it too.

But it’s unsustainable at the moment. There are normally 6 weeks when it is hard to drive anywhere or do anything. This year though, it looks like that already. There physically isn’t enough room for so many people to walk on narrow streets, not enough room in car parks for people to park. There is more and more accommodations available than before now on and more people choosing to stay in the UK.

It can’t be nice for people on holiday either. Would you want to stay somewhere where you feel like a sardine everywhere, are in gridlocked traffic if you want to go anywhere, and can’t eat out with your family as the pubs and restaurants have stopped serving due to lack of staff?

whiteroseredrose · 25/06/2022 11:32

coffeecupsandfairylights · 24/06/2022 17:22

Hotels
Pubs with rooms
B&B's
Static caravans on holiday parks
Campsites
Stay with family/friends

You can go pretty much anywhere in the UK without renting out a house or cottage!

Unfortunately none of which would suit us!

As a PP said, we want a kitchen wherever we go - which usually rules out hotels in the UK, B&Bs and Pubs with rooms. My camping days are over and my experience of a static was horrendous. Holidays are meant to be pleasurable not an endurance. Which is why we book Apartments or houses.

I agree my wish for a holiday doesn't trump someone's need for a home, but holidaymakers do bring money.

Now if UK hotels and B&Bs could be persuaded to include kitchens and family suites like abroad it would be a start.

Octomore · 25/06/2022 11:28

I live in a touristy area (northern national park), and tourists are welcomed here, but it's not our only industry. It's not even our biggest industry - there's obviously farming, but we have plenty of businesses operating in the local market town (one of which is the HQ site of a national company). Those currently provide more jobs (and better paying jobs) than tourism does, but if workers stop being able to afford homes in this area, that could change. And it wouldn't be a change for the better.

Aside from cafes/restaurants and things like the steam train, many of the attractions here are free - hills, rivers, waterfalls, crags. A tourist going walking in the hills isn't necessarily contributing that much in monetary terms (that's not to say they aren't welcome, but I think it's important to be realistic about the level of spending we're talking about).

There is plenty of accommodation (lots of people camp, and there is a campsite just up the road). B&Bs, glamping and accommodation pods/lodges are also popular.

The people who rock up on a Friday night to stay in their second home, their shopping already ordered for the weekend, contribute pretty much the square root of bugger all to the local economy.

Maireas · 25/06/2022 11:15

Good point, @BoBoredZelda - would people who live in tourist areas genuinely not want anyone coming to visit and spend money?

BoredZelda · 25/06/2022 11:14

Now there are far too many tourists - it’s horrendous already, even walking through the local towns, and we aren’t in peak season yet. The drs surgeries and hospital can’t cope. The supermarkets run out of food. The fuel runs out on “changeover day” as the tourists fill up to go home..and there are are huge queues for the garages that have any left.

Must be awful to have income from people who want to holiday in your area.

Maireas · 25/06/2022 11:13

CounsellorTroi · 25/06/2022 11:04

We stay in the same two bedroom cottage every year on the Isle of Skye. It’s 20 mins drive away from the nearest shop, an hour’s round trip from the nearest supermarket and school. Wouldn’t make an ideal family home.

Might be ideal for someone.
A person or couple who want to downsize after retirement? Selling their family home to do so?
You just never know.

CounsellorTroi · 25/06/2022 11:04

We stay in the same two bedroom cottage every year on the Isle of Skye. It’s 20 mins drive away from the nearest shop, an hour’s round trip from the nearest supermarket and school. Wouldn’t make an ideal family home.

SnapDog · 25/06/2022 10:52

@BoredZelda - I live in a tourist area that was doing just fine, in terms of visitor numbers, before every man and his dog decided to do AirBnB.

Families have nowhere to go as the landlords have sold up - with little notice - to sell (to people who want second homes and who have pushed local prices up even more) or to use for holidays lets.

Now there are far too many tourists - it’s horrendous already, even walking through the local towns, and we aren’t in peak season yet. The drs surgeries and hospital can’t cope. The supermarkets run out of food. The fuel runs out on “changeover day” as the tourists fill up to go home..and there are are huge queues for the garages that have any left.

There are barely any waiters, chefs, bar staff.. so many small businesses stopped opening in the evening/reduced days last year because they didn’t have the staff to open, so they lost profit there. These staff no longer exist as they cannot rent accommodation locally. The businesses trying to stay open put their wages up to try and compete for the staff available. These businesses are not benefiting from the mass influx of tourists, they are struggling to stay afloat.

Business is booming for cleaners though!. Prices have increased from £12ph to £20ph in the last year. There is more to be made from cleaning holiday lets than there is from other jobs in hospitality… affecting local businesses who are already struggling for staff… and so on.

BoredZelda · 25/06/2022 10:28

That isnt accurate

Holiday homes= no demand for schools, shops or GP or buses
They close and then no-one wants to live in a village without a school where 75% of the home are not lived in and there is no community.

The Ocado vans and the cleaning teams from the town 40 miles away show that they do not create local jobs (and you cant afford a £350K 2 bed cottage in rural Yorkshire on a cleaners wage)

It is accurate. If tourists can’t stay in an area, they won’t go there.

Holiday homes cause issues for sure, but to suggest that tourist areas will do just fine without them is false.

Swipe left for the next trending thread