Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be conflicted by the crackdown on 2nd homes

329 replies

chairz · 24/06/2022 16:23

I complete understand the problems they cause & do agree with a higher levy but thenI have used holiday cottages lots of times in the past & plan to in the future.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HikingforScenery · 28/06/2022 17:10

bellac11 · 27/06/2022 18:55

Poor owner, what a dilemma. They 'really' wanted a local to get it but were persuaded by the bullying nasty agent who held a gun to their head.

😂

AchatAVendre · 28/06/2022 12:46

Florenz Holiday homes should be banned outright. Nobody should be allowed to home multiple homes when so many people can't afford to own even one.

I also take this communist view to task.

My grandparents left a Scottish island for work and marriage (marrying your relatives isn't really a great idea). That island is now full of incomers who have the funds to not work full time for a living and set up craft shops and offer homeopathic remedies, etc.. Yet you are telling me that I cannot buy a second home to holiday in and retire to in an area which I have strong family links with (still family members living there), speak the dialect of and have deep rooted connections to, because I have managed to buy a tiny one bedroom flat in the horror that is Scotland's central belt and work for a living?

Staying in one place with few jobs and career prospects is something most of us don't get the opportunity to do.

The rules on second homes in Scotland are ridiculous anyway. A German person wouldn't have to pay the extra stamp duty or council tax for a second home because it would be their first home in Scotland, while a Scottish person buying in their own country would be punished for doing so (and therefore treated better by a foreign country for buying there instead). That is ridiculous.

AchatAVendre · 28/06/2022 12:28

Oh I've posted about this a lot. But second homes seem quite normal in other European and Scandinavian countries. So it seems to be yet another thing that British people are not going to be able to do with the money they earn and pay tax on. I hate staying in cramped hotel rooms or so-called apartments with no washing machine or proper cooker and much prefer self catering, but its breathtakingly expensive in the UK.

If a country can't even offer an incentive of affordable and decent holidays to its people in return for their hard work, (and affordable housing), then its not much of a standard of living, is it? Other countries seem to manage to be able to do both.

mast0650 · 28/06/2022 12:25

We’ve stopped renting ours out now, and just leave them for our own use. It doesn’t seem to have stopped some awful people still complaining about it though. I think it is much worse to own a second (or third!) home and not have it used as much as possible. That's a real waste!!

JustAnotherPoster00 · 28/06/2022 12:18

Personally think Meibion Glyndwr had the right idea

Taniwch dros Cymru

Fifthtimelucky · 27/06/2022 21:16

Sorry, posted too soon.

I pay council tax so my holiday home is not registered as a small business and I didn't get a grant during Covid. I do not let it out, except to friends and family - and usually I don't charge them anything other than asking them to pay for the electricity they used.

A friend who has a similar property on the same site is registered as a small business so doesn't pay council tax. She did receive the Covid grant, but I think that was fair enough as she normally rents it out a lot to holidaymakers and obviously she wasn't allowed to do that during the various lockdowns and she would have lost a lot of income.

Many councils are tightening up on the criteria for claiming you are a small business and I think that is a good thing.

Fifthtimelucky · 27/06/2022 21:10

One of the problems is that there are so many different variables and not all second holes are the same.

I have a second home. It's a wooden lodge on a holiday park and year round occupation is not permitted so I am not depriving any locals of a permanent home.

It cost well under the normal limit for stamp duty, but I had to pay stamp duty because there are no exemptions for second homes. I pay council tax. Frankly I don't see why I should pay more than the normal because I use hardly any council services - just the roads really. I don't have a rubbish collection because I pay for that separately as part of the site fees.

riesenrad · 27/06/2022 19:08

Also filling every square inch of spare land with affordable housing massively changes the infrastructure. Fewer school places, fewer GP appointments, fewer social services. The issue is the unaffordable housing we already have, not building more

Also very true. We have plenty of homes in the UK but many are empty and many are holiday homes. Bring them all back into residential use and we might not need to build any more houses on green field sites.

riesenrad · 27/06/2022 19:07

Florenz · 27/06/2022 12:33

Holiday homes should be banned outright. Nobody should be allowed to home multiple homes when so many people can't afford to own even one.

I don't disagree. There is absolutely no need for it. And being unable to wait until 7am for breakfast is the most stupid excuse for unethical behaviour I've ever heard! Anyway there are hotels which have mini kitchens.

Pumperthepumper · 27/06/2022 19:06

riesenrad · 27/06/2022 19:03

Well a B&B could be a family home (actually they often are) and a hotel could be flats. The land for a theme park could be used for a vast housing estate. Where do you stop with that argument?

Also filling every square inch of spare land with affordable housing massively changes the infrastructure. Fewer school places, fewer GP appointments, fewer social services. The issue is the unaffordable housing we already have, not building more.

riesenrad · 27/06/2022 19:06

neither holiday destination be it cottages or lodges etc is helping the locals

I disagree, lodges cannot be used as homes as they are usually too small and may be part of a farm or vineyard or somewhere where the council says no residential use but you can have short term holiday lets. Very different from buying a house from over the heads of the sitting tenants in the example above.

riesenrad · 27/06/2022 19:04

Poor owner, what a dilemma. They 'really' wanted a local to get it but were persuaded by the bullying nasty agent who held a gun to their head

Indeed. Why are so many landlords and owners bullied by estate agents? Tail and dog and wagging comes to mind!

riesenrad · 27/06/2022 19:03

Purplebunnie · 27/06/2022 12:02

To all those congratulating yourselves on the fact you stay at holiday parks with caravans, lodges tents etc. That land could be used to build affordable homes for local so you are no better than the people who stay in cottages

Well a B&B could be a family home (actually they often are) and a hotel could be flats. The land for a theme park could be used for a vast housing estate. Where do you stop with that argument?

Octomore · 27/06/2022 18:56

The owner obviously wasnt that bothered, as noone forced him to take the cash offer.

Investors almost always come in with cash offers, while working families and FTBs need mortgages. In the majority of cases the mortgage goes through fine and there is no detriment to the seller in accepting that offer. If the owner wanted them to have it, he should have ignored the EAs advice.

bellac11 · 27/06/2022 18:55

Ginisnnice · 27/06/2022 18:51

Am very sad to say the most affordable house in our village , which a young family , who live ( rented) locally and have been waiting ages for a house they can afford . And want to send child local school... have had their offer rejected in favour of a second home cash buyer.
The owner really wanted a local to get it.. the agent advised to go with cash buyer as safer than a mortgage applicant. Ffs .

Poor owner, what a dilemma. They 'really' wanted a local to get it but were persuaded by the bullying nasty agent who held a gun to their head.

Ginisnnice · 27/06/2022 18:51

Am very sad to say the most affordable house in our village , which a young family , who live ( rented) locally and have been waiting ages for a house they can afford . And want to send child local school... have had their offer rejected in favour of a second home cash buyer.
The owner really wanted a local to get it.. the agent advised to go with cash buyer as safer than a mortgage applicant. Ffs .

SaySomethingMan · 27/06/2022 12:41

Purplebunnie · 27/06/2022 12:30

No I'm not saying no one should go on holiday unless you can afford to stay in a hotel/B&B for a week or two. Just pointing out a bit of hypocrisy. The problem is nowhere that locals can afford and neither holiday destination be it cottages or lodges etc is helping the locals.

I agree with you.

SaySomethingMan · 27/06/2022 12:39

OhmygodDont · 24/06/2022 17:05

We holiday in the U.K. in statics/lodges and on campsites we sometimes use hotels.
Not cottages and houses.

Surely, all those are built on land that could’ve been taken up by homes for the local community, instead.

Florenz · 27/06/2022 12:33

Holiday homes should be banned outright. Nobody should be allowed to home multiple homes when so many people can't afford to own even one.

Purplebunnie · 27/06/2022 12:30

CounsellorTroi · 27/06/2022 12:12

So you’re saying no one should go on holiday unless you can afford to stay in a hotel/B&B for a week or two?

No I'm not saying no one should go on holiday unless you can afford to stay in a hotel/B&B for a week or two. Just pointing out a bit of hypocrisy. The problem is nowhere that locals can afford and neither holiday destination be it cottages or lodges etc is helping the locals.

Thebeastofsleep · 27/06/2022 12:27

Purplebunnie · 27/06/2022 12:02

To all those congratulating yourselves on the fact you stay at holiday parks with caravans, lodges tents etc. That land could be used to build affordable homes for local so you are no better than the people who stay in cottages

That's not true. Lots of holiday park in Cumbria are built because planning permission for homes was turned down, multiple times.

My dad is freeholder of one such park (doesn't own the park, just the land) and he made multiple applications for properties on the land - affordable homes, luxury homes, different styles of homes, appeals etc and they just wouldn't budge. 150 log cabins on the other hand, no problem. Its a common issue.

CounsellorTroi · 27/06/2022 12:12

Purplebunnie · 27/06/2022 12:02

To all those congratulating yourselves on the fact you stay at holiday parks with caravans, lodges tents etc. That land could be used to build affordable homes for local so you are no better than the people who stay in cottages

So you’re saying no one should go on holiday unless you can afford to stay in a hotel/B&B for a week or two?

Purplebunnie · 27/06/2022 12:02

To all those congratulating yourselves on the fact you stay at holiday parks with caravans, lodges tents etc. That land could be used to build affordable homes for local so you are no better than the people who stay in cottages

thelastshadowpuppet · 27/06/2022 11:18

Higher council tax charges and a fee for an empty house will only be passed to holiday makers and renters and create an even bigger problem.

CounsellorTroi · 27/06/2022 10:54

Having a kitchen gives flexibility. It means that you can eat when you want and what you want.

I agree. The place we stay every year on Skye is ten miles away from the nearest pub and shop and a 1.5 hour round trip to the nearest supermarket. We do a supermarket shop in Fort William on the way, but we are there for two weeks so we obviously need to buy more food. We do eat out of course but it is also nice to have the option of a simple meal in.

Swipe left for the next trending thread