Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be totally gutted for American women?

995 replies

Anothernamechangeplease · 24/06/2022 15:19

The US Supreme Court has reversed the Roe v Wade ruling. Millions of American women have lost their right to make decisions about what happens to their own bodies. Sad

I have never had an abortion and personally, I'm not sure if I ever could, but I have always been passionately of the view that individual women should be able to make that choice for themselves. It's awful that this right has been removed for so many.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
HRTQueen · 25/06/2022 10:11

What shocked me watching the news was how many young people were celebrating. Young women who appeared to be from all different backgrounds. Educated women. This isn’t the usual crowd of people we see anti abortion protests

my family live in the states my young nieces having such restrictions over them today in 2022 is heartbreaking.

once again women being controlled it never ends we are always having our boundaries pushed our freedoms are not guaranteed

HRTQueen · 25/06/2022 10:09

What shocked me watching the news was how many young people were celebrating. Young women who appeared to be from all different backgrounds. Educated women. This isn’t the usual crowd of people we see anti abortion protests

my family live in the states my young nieces having such restrictions over them today in 2022 is heartbreaking.

once again women being controlled it never ends we are always having our boundaries pushed our freedoms are not guaranteed

JudgeJ · 25/06/2022 10:03

The same group of judges, the Supreme Court has recent;ly said that decades old rules in New York regarding the carrying of weapons is 'unconstitutional' so they're made it much easier to carry weapons. It's a pity that they don't care as much about children walking around as they purport to do about the unborn.

Lunar27 · 25/06/2022 10:02

Thanks. These are likely the same people who voted against Obama Care and don't actually care about the life of the baby but just some idealistic BS. No disrespect to religion but just the interpretation by these idiots.

greywinds · 25/06/2022 09:54

It isn't puzzling if you're familiar with the catechism of the Catholic Church - anti contraception, anti abortion, anti ivf, all cornerstones since the 1960s theology of the body.

Of course they'll be celebrating they see it as enshrining God's law and stopping murder.

speakout · 25/06/2022 09:53

Lunar27 · 25/06/2022 09:40

I'm just watching the BBC and understand (and support) the protests. However, what I can't understand is the celebrating from the anti abortion side (and especially seeing women there).

Why would another woman want to impose her views on another woman? Sure you might personally be against abortion but why support removing that choice from another woman? Puzzling.

I think these "pro lifers" feel they are advocating for the unborn- baby as they see it.
A foetus has no voice, and if it's mother will not support that right to life by seeking a termination then others must step in and be that voice.
Usually rooted in christain doctrine- the pro lifers feel they are speaking for the rights of the unborn- and that includes all foetuses, not just their own.

Lunar27 · 25/06/2022 09:40

I'm just watching the BBC and understand (and support) the protests. However, what I can't understand is the celebrating from the anti abortion side (and especially seeing women there).

Why would another woman want to impose her views on another woman? Sure you might personally be against abortion but why support removing that choice from another woman? Puzzling.

Threebutterflies · 25/06/2022 09:40

Regarding contraception- I have fallen pregnant whilst I was on the depot injection. I only realised when I had a miscarriage so obviously abit of a shock. I also fell pregnant after taking two morning after pills . The hardest decision I’ve ever had to make was terminating and I still deeply regret it. Point is contraception dosnt always work . You may be with some shitty partner who dosnt want to wear a condom. Then when you tell him your pregnant he wants nothing to do with it. Then you spend your life feeling like shit because of crap pro lifers tell you and you feel worse than some kind of murdering serial killer .

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 25/06/2022 09:38

CHIRIBAYA · 25/06/2022 09:30

So much suffering is going to follow. America is leading the charge back into the dark ages. A monumental setback for women and children.

Not sure about this.

Women's rights have been eroded all over, look at Afghanistan and Iran and how much women have lost there.

Look at Poland where the laws have recently changed.

CHIRIBAYA · 25/06/2022 09:30

So much suffering is going to follow. America is leading the charge back into the dark ages. A monumental setback for women and children.

JanisMoplin · 25/06/2022 09:30

Most women across the world either do not have access to contraception or are not allowed to take them or their partners won't wear condoms or they are effectively raped by them daily. But sure continue talking about your friend Kelly who sleeps around while forgetting to take a pill because that is your narrow little universe and you can't conceive of anything else. Me, I think that even if a woman has slept with all of Britain and taken no precautions at all, she still deserves to get an abortion.

Lunar27 · 25/06/2022 09:29

Sorry, I can't add much except to show solidarity.

I have such a love/hate relationship with America, and this just confirms my suspicion that the US does not value women. Their attitude to maternity leave is also disgraceful.

I find it ironic that a place that claims to care so much about the rights of a foetus, doesn't actually give two f*cks about it once born.

Pumperthepumper · 25/06/2022 09:25

It’s arguably men who need to be told not to make babies. How many threads have you seen on here saying ‘my partner’s ex tricked him into having a baby he didn’t want’ or ‘if a man didn’t want the baby he shouldn’t have to provide maintenance’? Those posters are always furious at the idea men who don’t want babies shouldn’t make them.

ChateauMargaux · 25/06/2022 09:24

One woman and 5 men voted to overturn the ruling, 1 man and 2 women voted against.

WHY DO WE STILL NOT HAVE EQUAL REPRESENTATION AND SHARE OF VOICE IN ALL AREAS WHERE DECISIONS ARE MADE?

Reallyreallyborednow · 25/06/2022 09:21

I just wish more women would take better, personal control over their contraception to prevent the need for so many abortions

how do you know they aren’t?

how do you know that women seeking abortions haven’t been taking personal control over their contraception, used it diligently, but still got pregnant, or been raped, or had a man sneak the condom off in the middle of intercourse?

how do you know it’s not some teenager who’s read on a forum or been told by peers that using two condoms is twice as safe, and got pregnant as a result?

i think women who don’t want to get pregnant do take control over their contraception.

prove me wrong…

ChateauMargaux · 25/06/2022 09:14

@Teaandtoastedbiscuits ... not just women of long ago.. the stpries told on www.facebook.com/InHerIrishShoes/ are a testament to what life without free access to abortion is like just 4 years ago and the reality in Ireland is that access to abortion remains restricted in practice.

greywinds · 25/06/2022 09:06

Of course women free of violent repercussions doing some sort of sex strike will lead to the rise of othered women with fewer choices selling sex, like in Victorian times.

This turning back the clock thing stinks from any political angle - the democrats have been spineless on the abortion issue for the duration too as they see the pro choice campaign as still too radical and vote losing.

I can't see the uk parallels on abortion itself. Scotland withholding ivf treatment for women without covid vaccinations was an attempt to control women's bodies in the interest of the foetus but much as I disliked it, not in the same league.

the80sweregreat · 25/06/2022 09:05

It is a backwards move but lots of women seem very happy with it :( ( on the news today )
This is what I can't get my head around.
Im glad some are against it but their voices will be muted I suppose. It's just More division.

DamnUserName21 · 25/06/2022 09:03

The 'just use contraception' argument has so many fallacies.

In many areas of the UK, it can be really hard to get a GP or practice nurse appt for contraception. Sexual health clinics are closing/few and far between. For coil and implant fittings, there's a lack of specially trained staff to put them in and you have an appointment wait if you can get one.
The pill is not suitable for all women (due to risk factors/other health conditions) and will not work if you're sick, on certain medications, or you miss doses.
Coils and implants can go wrong (and not all women can have them due to risk factors, health conditions, uterine physiology). There is the depo injection but you need to try to get an appointment for this and, again, it's not suitable for all women.

The MAP in the UK is quite costly---can be hard to get an NHS script. So if your choice is food for the week or the £13-25 for the MAP, what are you going to choose?

Just wear condoms, you say, but this is subject to your partner also---so many men refuse to wear them. So don't have sex then, eh?? Is it always consensual? What about the sexual coercion or pressure put on a woman to have sex. Having sex with one's DP is not always a real choice for a woman and for those saying 'just don't have sex' are a bit out of touch with reality

Added to which, NO contraception is 100%. Abortion is a fallback measure.

We are lucky in the UK that most contraception is free (for now). In the US, it is not so that is another barrier to access.

Teaandtoastedbiscuits · 25/06/2022 08:58

I'm Irish and the States was something to be looked up to when we were young. A lot of irish emigrated in the 80s and we always assumed for a better life. It beggars belief that those poor women are being treated the way that they are now. They are as badly off as the women in Ireland were 50/60/70 years ago.

SpinningTheSeedsOfLove · 25/06/2022 08:52

You can’t argue with anti-abortionist hardliners online.

Well you can, but it’s a waste of energy that may be, for example, better spent writing to our MPs about the common sense of preserving the UK system that we thankfully have.

Jott · 25/06/2022 08:47

Its not just for me. I don't think they should be allowed for anyone because I believe that the unborn child is a human life. There is no way to draw a line where one day it is and the next day it isn't.

A pregnancy not a child in the same way that a bag of flour and a box of eggs is not a cake. It has the potential to be a child but first it needs to grow and develop. During that period of growth and development it is entirely reliant on the body of the woman hosting it and because it is her body she gets to say whether or not she wants to host it. If she decides she does not want to have her body host a pregnancy then she had the right to interrupt that process both via contraception to stop it before it even begins or via abortion to halt the process once it starts. At no point is she killing a child.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 25/06/2022 08:46

Honestly, all women should slam their vaginas shut right now and refuse sex indefinitely. It’s the only way we are all completely safe from unwanted pregnancy. Punish all men.

Why do you see withdrawal of sex as punishment for men? Women enjoy sex and they should not have to deny sex to themselves.

Some of the judges in that panel were women, some of the most vocal anti abortion activists are women.

It's not that simple.

Jott · 25/06/2022 08:42

Honestly, all women should slam their vaginas shut right now and refuse sex indefinitely. It’s the only way we are all completely safe from unwanted pregnancy. Punish all men.

That'd be me boarding over my vagina then, were I an American woman. There'd be no chance I'd risk an unwanted pregnancy with no way out.

Telling women to "just say no" is not going to override the need for access to safe, legal abortion. "Just say no" implies that if a woman was to get experience an unwanted pregnancy then it's her own fault, she should have said no and kept her legs shut. That's the exact same attitude being touted by the pro-lifers - don't want a baby, don't have sex, and it's your own fault if you do.

Not all women are in relationships where they can just go on a sex strike. Not all women have control over their own fertility, control over how and when and where they have sex or with whom. For many women there is no option to say no.

Additionally there is a huge overlap between the people who support these anti-abortion laws and the people who think it is a woman's duty to submit to the sexual needs of men. Technically, marital rape is illegal in the US however different states have differing exceptions and loopholes. It is more difficult for a spouse-victim to prove that she didn't consent to her husband than it would be to prove non-consent with a stranger. Many states don't prosecute marital rape or they treat it as a lesser crime and offer couples counselling in lieu of criminal charges. Many states only consider it rape if force or violence is used, coercion and blackmail are not considered force, and a few state that a spouse who is drugged or unconscious cannot claim rape.

Then there are the MRAs and the Incels. Think they'll take a sex strike well? They already hate women for gatekeeping sex.

Bad shit happens to women who are perceived as willfully withholding sex. They can be attacked, raped, assaulted, and murdered for it.

We're not a carrot on a stick to dangle over the men. "Be a good boy and you'll get a fuck" demeans women and cheapens our sexuality down to the level of it being entirely transactional. It furthers the myth that women are the keepers of sex and control men's access to it, that men need to take that control back, and that then feeds back into all of the bullshit described above.

The kind of men who pass these laws will not be deterred by any sort of sex strike and neither will their supporters.

ChateauMargaux · 25/06/2022 08:24

I cannot bring myself to believe that this is true. Where is everybody???

Swipe left for the next trending thread