Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be totally gutted for American women?

995 replies

Anothernamechangeplease · 24/06/2022 15:19

The US Supreme Court has reversed the Roe v Wade ruling. Millions of American women have lost their right to make decisions about what happens to their own bodies. Sad

I have never had an abortion and personally, I'm not sure if I ever could, but I have always been passionately of the view that individual women should be able to make that choice for themselves. It's awful that this right has been removed for so many.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Hornbostel · 24/06/2022 19:26

FreyaStorm · 24/06/2022 19:16

Either is fine with me.

Make a few examples and (some) people would soon start taking from responsibility, rather than using abortion AS contraceptive.

Ever seen the brutal reality of a medical abortion? It should be more widely publicised (perhaps in schools). Might work better at lowering abortion rates than an actual legal ban 🤷🏽‍♀️

Have you ever seen the brutal reality of rape? Or r@pe as you call it, which shows just how seriously you take it.

FreyaStorm · 24/06/2022 19:26

This reply has been deleted

We've removed this post as we don't feel this has any place in a civil debate.

Anothernamechangeplease · 24/06/2022 19:25

Brideandprejudice · 24/06/2022 19:17

I'll do my best to answer. Just because I don't support abortion everyone somehow expects me to be an expert, I don't recall stating I was such.

  1. I would be happy to pay because I have the means. But in the vast majority of abortions where the child was simply unwanted, that should fall on the parents.

  2. No, again in my opinion people who knowingly risk pregnancy should be willing to care for the product (baby) of that risk.

  3. Of course men must be forced to provide support to their children, the how I am no expert on.

  4. I believe that the decision in such horrific circumstances where you must choose the life of the mother or the child must be made as individuals. I think either choice results in a loss of life which is a tragedy.

I'm as entitled to my opinions as anyone else and I don't understand women who are supposedly in support of women's rights, attacking other women. They are in fact only interested in the rights of women who agree with them.

So you think that the parents of the unwanted child should be responsible for looking after it. In other words, you would sooner condemn thousands of children to lives of potential poverty, neglect and abuse, perhaps with parents who are too young/too sick/too mentally unstable/too trapped in a cycle of poverty/substance abuse/abusive relationships etc to be able to care for them properly, than you would allow the woman to make a rational decision about what she does with her own body? Quite apart from the massive impact on the mother's physical and emotional health, this is no life for am innocent child.

You think that pro-life is the humane approach, but the reality is that you have no fucking idea.

OP posts:
Thebeastofsleep · 24/06/2022 19:25

Brideandprejudice · 24/06/2022 19:17

I'll do my best to answer. Just because I don't support abortion everyone somehow expects me to be an expert, I don't recall stating I was such.

  1. I would be happy to pay because I have the means. But in the vast majority of abortions where the child was simply unwanted, that should fall on the parents.

  2. No, again in my opinion people who knowingly risk pregnancy should be willing to care for the product (baby) of that risk.

  3. Of course men must be forced to provide support to their children, the how I am no expert on.

  4. I believe that the decision in such horrific circumstances where you must choose the life of the mother or the child must be made as individuals. I think either choice results in a loss of life which is a tragedy.

I'm as entitled to my opinions as anyone else and I don't understand women who are supposedly in support of women's rights, attacking other women. They are in fact only interested in the rights of women who agree with them.

So because I don't want to get pregnant, I shouldn't have sex with my husband? (Point 2).

LaughingCat · 24/06/2022 19:24

Not unreasonable at all - I have been in pieces about it all day. How can they call themselves the Land of the Free when they’ve just taken away free choice for millions of women? Despicable.

Gilead · 24/06/2022 19:24

A bunch of cells at approximately eight weeks.

To be totally gutted for American women?
Wouldloveanother · 24/06/2022 19:23

Brideandprejudice · 24/06/2022 19:17

I'll do my best to answer. Just because I don't support abortion everyone somehow expects me to be an expert, I don't recall stating I was such.

  1. I would be happy to pay because I have the means. But in the vast majority of abortions where the child was simply unwanted, that should fall on the parents.

  2. No, again in my opinion people who knowingly risk pregnancy should be willing to care for the product (baby) of that risk.

  3. Of course men must be forced to provide support to their children, the how I am no expert on.

  4. I believe that the decision in such horrific circumstances where you must choose the life of the mother or the child must be made as individuals. I think either choice results in a loss of life which is a tragedy.

I'm as entitled to my opinions as anyone else and I don't understand women who are supposedly in support of women's rights, attacking other women. They are in fact only interested in the rights of women who agree with them.

  1. how would you establish whether the children are ‘unwanted’? Why should the child suffer because of the attitude or actions of the parents? Isn’t that why you oppose abortion in the first place?
  2. again - you’re happy for children to be brought up by unfit parents who may neglect or even harm them. Why concentrate on keeping them safe in the womb, but give up on them once they’re out?
  3. how would you force this given so many men don’t pay the maintenance they are legally obliged to do?
  4. which would you choose? Your daughter or grandchild? Which?
all or your responses confirm my suspicion that your support of banning abortion is to punish the parents rather than because you truly care for the life and welfare of the kids. You want the kids well-being to be a lottery based on the actions of their parents, while also saying ‘all lives are valued, just because the parents have been irresponsible it doesn’t mean the fetus should be terminated’.

it makes zero sense?

Ugzbugz · 24/06/2022 19:23

I hope their maternity rights change and all FATHER'S have the same responsibility if not full responsibility of these children born.

ThickCutSteakChips · 24/06/2022 19:22

No, again in my opinion people who knowingly risk pregnancy should be willing to care for the product (baby) of that risk.

What about in cases of rape?

What about in cases where contraception has failed?

You think women should be punished for daring to have sex don't you?

ThickCutSteakChips · 24/06/2022 19:20

I'm as entitled to my opinions as anyone else and I don't understand women who are supposedly in support of women's rights, attacking other women. They are in fact only interested in the rights of women who agree with them.

What rights are you being denied by this development?

You do understand that in a society where abortion is safe and legal, you are not forced to get one? Right?!

Pumperthepumper · 24/06/2022 19:20

Brideandprejudice · 24/06/2022 19:17

I'll do my best to answer. Just because I don't support abortion everyone somehow expects me to be an expert, I don't recall stating I was such.

  1. I would be happy to pay because I have the means. But in the vast majority of abortions where the child was simply unwanted, that should fall on the parents.

  2. No, again in my opinion people who knowingly risk pregnancy should be willing to care for the product (baby) of that risk.

  3. Of course men must be forced to provide support to their children, the how I am no expert on.

  4. I believe that the decision in such horrific circumstances where you must choose the life of the mother or the child must be made as individuals. I think either choice results in a loss of life which is a tragedy.

I'm as entitled to my opinions as anyone else and I don't understand women who are supposedly in support of women's rights, attacking other women. They are in fact only interested in the rights of women who agree with them.

And how are you forcing someone to care willingly for a baby they didn’t want and can’t afford?

Brideandprejudice · 24/06/2022 19:20

5) Support changes to the law that will serve harsher sentences on those who rape and rapes that lead to pregnancy? Would you support the death penalty for such a crime?
6) Support a change to the law holding men accountable for at least 50% of the medical costs associated with birth and any birthing injuries.

  1. Yes I support the prosecution of rapists and I believe we need much more severe punishments than we currently have, although I am opposed to the death penalty.

  2. Yes I would support men being liable for 50% of the costs, that's a good idea.

Wouldloveanother · 24/06/2022 19:19

Reallyreallyborednow · 24/06/2022 19:16

for those that are worried about the babies, do they not realise that this will lead to a massive rise in severely disabled children being born into an existence of pain and suffering for a few short hours if they’re lucky, years if not.

imo terminating a pregnancy that has issues so severe it won’t survive or have any quality if life if one of the greatest gifts a parent can give a child.

who’s going to pay for lifelong care? If the parents don’t have health insurance what then? Let the baby die? They hypocrisy…

i suppose they’ll have a consequential rise in the availability of infant organs though 🤷

Of course they realise this. It doesn’t affect them so they don’t care. They’re also the ‘not my tax dollars’ type, so of course they won’t want to pay for care. They want to create a miserable society to elevate their own privilege and enable them to feel even more smug about their luck life choices

Pumperthepumper · 24/06/2022 19:19

FreyaStorm · 24/06/2022 19:16

Either is fine with me.

Make a few examples and (some) people would soon start taking from responsibility, rather than using abortion AS contraceptive.

Ever seen the brutal reality of a medical abortion? It should be more widely publicised (perhaps in schools). Might work better at lowering abortion rates than an actual legal ban 🤷🏽‍♀️

It won’t. There is no way to reduce abortion without increasing the number of deaths. What’s the issue with using abortion as a contraception? Have you done it?

Gilead · 24/06/2022 19:18

@FreyaStorm Freya, are you prepared to adopt, to fund orphanages or do you just want to have a go at women who are perhaps carrying non viable babies, or babies who will be born with severe disabilities? Will you volunteer to take a night shift for those mums or blame them for not knowing this may happen. Are you going to lecture those who had contraception failures, hold the hands of those with mental health problems?
Thought not.

Ihatemyroad · 24/06/2022 19:18

This has set women back decades!

It doesn’t matter whether ‘you’ agree with abortion or not. Many women find themselves in a position eg as a result of contraception failure, through coercion, abuse or rape, where it is completely detrimental to their mental or physical well-being or both! What about the women in an abusive relationship who don’t want to bring a child in to that environment? The women who are trying to escape an abuser and be free of them to start again?

It is horrifying that in 2022 the rights of those women to choose their future has been removed.

Brideandprejudice · 24/06/2022 19:17

Wouldloveanother · 24/06/2022 19:06

@Brideandprejudice im willing to engage with you respectfully as I know many people who hold your views, and feel i ‘understand’ your position (even if I completely disagree with it).

let’s say all these babies are born. There will be a huge increase in teen mums, kids in poverty, very disabled children, neglected children, children placed in care, children whose dads are rapists… the list goes on.

  1. are you happy to pay a significant tax rise to support these children and (as much as possible) spare them a life of misery?
  2. would you be willing to adopt such children yourself? As in next year when the first cohort of babies are born?
  3. what would you do to penalise men for abandoning their children? Or wouldn’t you? How would you make them responsible for their part in fathering kids?
  4. would you be happy for your pregnant daughter to be denied abortion with a ruptured ectopic, as she bleeds out?

I'll do my best to answer. Just because I don't support abortion everyone somehow expects me to be an expert, I don't recall stating I was such.

  1. I would be happy to pay because I have the means. But in the vast majority of abortions where the child was simply unwanted, that should fall on the parents.

  2. No, again in my opinion people who knowingly risk pregnancy should be willing to care for the product (baby) of that risk.

  3. Of course men must be forced to provide support to their children, the how I am no expert on.

  4. I believe that the decision in such horrific circumstances where you must choose the life of the mother or the child must be made as individuals. I think either choice results in a loss of life which is a tragedy.

I'm as entitled to my opinions as anyone else and I don't understand women who are supposedly in support of women's rights, attacking other women. They are in fact only interested in the rights of women who agree with them.

FreyaStorm · 24/06/2022 19:17

*some, not from

brinkdrop · 24/06/2022 19:17

FreyaStorm · 24/06/2022 19:09

It’s a real shame that we don’t have a wide array of contraceptives available.

Oh wait.

And as for women who are r@ped and fall pregnant, that’s not the 99.999% of abortions taking place every day, so it’s a red herring.

No point arguing with this level of ignorance, but just so you know, you're fucking thick.

Reallyreallyborednow · 24/06/2022 19:16

for those that are worried about the babies, do they not realise that this will lead to a massive rise in severely disabled children being born into an existence of pain and suffering for a few short hours if they’re lucky, years if not.

imo terminating a pregnancy that has issues so severe it won’t survive or have any quality if life if one of the greatest gifts a parent can give a child.

who’s going to pay for lifelong care? If the parents don’t have health insurance what then? Let the baby die? They hypocrisy…

i suppose they’ll have a consequential rise in the availability of infant organs though 🤷

FreyaStorm · 24/06/2022 19:16

Pumperthepumper · 24/06/2022 19:10

Pro punishment then? Or forced vasectomies?

Either is fine with me.

Make a few examples and (some) people would soon start taking from responsibility, rather than using abortion AS contraceptive.

Ever seen the brutal reality of a medical abortion? It should be more widely publicised (perhaps in schools). Might work better at lowering abortion rates than an actual legal ban 🤷🏽‍♀️

outshinethemorningsun · 24/06/2022 19:15

also seeing it pointed out America has shitty maternity leave, no universal healthcare and high rates of maternal mortality for a developed country (particularly for black women)

Pippinbird · 24/06/2022 19:15

Wouldloveanother · 24/06/2022 19:06

@Brideandprejudice im willing to engage with you respectfully as I know many people who hold your views, and feel i ‘understand’ your position (even if I completely disagree with it).

let’s say all these babies are born. There will be a huge increase in teen mums, kids in poverty, very disabled children, neglected children, children placed in care, children whose dads are rapists… the list goes on.

  1. are you happy to pay a significant tax rise to support these children and (as much as possible) spare them a life of misery?
  2. would you be willing to adopt such children yourself? As in next year when the first cohort of babies are born?
  3. what would you do to penalise men for abandoning their children? Or wouldn’t you? How would you make them responsible for their part in fathering kids?
  4. would you be happy for your pregnant daughter to be denied abortion with a ruptured ectopic, as she bleeds out?

Absolutely!!!!! @Wouldloveanother

would you also @Brideandprejudice :

  1. Support changes to the law that will serve harsher sentences on those who rape and rapes that lead to pregnancy? Would you support the death penalty for such a crime?
  2. Support a change to the law holding men accountable for at least 50% of the medical costs associated with birth and any birthing injuries.
RevoltingHumanHead · 24/06/2022 19:15

FreyaStorm · 24/06/2022 19:09

It’s a real shame that we don’t have a wide array of contraceptives available.

Oh wait.

And as for women who are r@ped and fall pregnant, that’s not the 99.999% of abortions taking place every day, so it’s a red herring.

Oh wait.

I think a woman should be able to have an abortion no matter the situation in which she fell pregnant. Whether the sex was forced or fun. Her body, her choice.

howtomoveforwards · 24/06/2022 19:15

The rate of abortions will not decrease

I'm not sure that's true. There will be women who can't manage to get an abortion of the back street variety either because of finances or lack of contacts. There will be others unable to travel out of state, again due to finances. There will be more babies born which will justify, in some people's minds at least, this court ruling.

Those same people will ignore the number of babies born in less than suitable circumstances, the toll that takes on both mother and child's mental health both short and long term, the increase in funding needed for the number of children who end up in foster care, the illness that results in women because of the back street abortions, increased suicide rates in women forced to carry babies they don't want, and ultimately the increased death rate as a result of botched back street abortions. All women that will be impacted and very few children who will be better off as a result. I can't imagine there are many men who will be looking after these unwanted children or giving two hoots about the women who die.