Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be totally gutted for American women?

995 replies

Anothernamechangeplease · 24/06/2022 15:19

The US Supreme Court has reversed the Roe v Wade ruling. Millions of American women have lost their right to make decisions about what happens to their own bodies. Sad

I have never had an abortion and personally, I'm not sure if I ever could, but I have always been passionately of the view that individual women should be able to make that choice for themselves. It's awful that this right has been removed for so many.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
ReneBumsWombats · 26/06/2022 12:17

CoastalWave · 26/06/2022 11:29

Jesus. Read up thread. I've said many many times I'm not talking about the awful exceptions. There will always be awful exceptions.

I've read enough of your crap. You can't disown the huge problems in your statements by claiming "exceptions" that automatically just make them right.

You mention failed contraception right before lecturing about "better choices". It really is as dumb as the person who told rape survivors to say no!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 26/06/2022 12:14

The outcome for the baby is none of their concern, none of this is for the benefit of the child

So it would appear, from the almost total lack of replies to questions like "What about the future welfare of an unwanted child?"

As so often it's all very well striking positions, but to me they don't seem worth much if folk want to ignore the possible consequences

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 26/06/2022 12:11

Livingtothefull · 26/06/2022 12:02

You need to explain why you think this is 'silly'. No direct analogy is claimed here; merely the principle that in EVERY other context the right of an individual to have autonomy over their body is upheld, regardless of the implications for others.

Because it completely ignores the utterly unique situation of a woman and a child in utero. It ignores the fact that in this specific situation autonomy over the woman's body directly affects another living organism/ body/ potential body/ potential human. It completely fails to answer or address that point.

It's nowhere near being any sort of analogy. Use it if you want, I personally think it's silly and badly thought out.

Livingtothefull · 26/06/2022 12:02

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 26/06/2022 11:25

I'm fully pro- choice but that is such a silly analogy. It gets trotted out from time to time but it really isn't the gotcha some people seem to think it is.

You need to explain why you think this is 'silly'. No direct analogy is claimed here; merely the principle that in EVERY other context the right of an individual to have autonomy over their body is upheld, regardless of the implications for others.

Liesovertheocean · 26/06/2022 12:00

The outcome for the baby is none of their concern, none of this is for the benefit of the child. They just to have control/punish women if they don’t comply with their laws. It’s revolting.

SexyLittleNosferatu · 26/06/2022 11:57

CoastalWave · 26/06/2022 11:27

At 5 weeks an embryo has a heart beat. A Fetus feels pain at 20 weeks.

Imagine being so angry over NOT being able to murder babies.

Seriously.

You believe that an embryo at the 5 week stage is more valuable than a living breathing adult woman? That's honestly laughable.

I hope you are heavily involved in charities that work with children. I imagine every spare penny you have goes to these charities because after all, you just lurve the little sweet kiddies don't you. I cant imagine that you don't give a fuck once they're born. That would be terrible hypocritical and out you as a common or garden variety misogynistic cunt.

SexyLittleNosferatu · 26/06/2022 11:46

Funny how it's a child/baby as soon as a woman announces her pregnancy and posts her 12 week scan photo and throughout the entire pregnancy when wanted- but god forbid it's a baby if we're killing it

This is so basic. Such a sad attempt at a "gotcha". I'll explain in case you're very young or a bit...dense.

We know it isn't actually a baby. We call it a baby because when it is wanted it is our baby, the hope the future the person that baby will become is what matters.

I've had 2 miscarriages past 12 weeks. They weren't babies. There was no life on the bathroom floor either time. Looking back, realistically now it was just a bloody mess of cells and membranes. It was a potential baby to me and that's why I would say "I lost the baby". You'd have to be a monster to retort with "nah, you lost a bunch of cells". It's true though. There was no baby other than the potential one in heart.

You want to try and justify forcing women and girls to give birth and that was your weak ass attempt? Go back to Gilead Aunt Lydia and all shame on you.

Pumperthepumper · 26/06/2022 11:38

CoastalWave · 26/06/2022 11:28

Seemingly the people who are all FOR abortion as the same people who think vaccines should be mandatory.

That's the twist!

It’s absolutely bizarre that you’re this wound up about vaccines being pushed into people’s bodies, while arguing that people should have less choice around what happens to their bodies.

Squiff70 · 26/06/2022 11:36

You're arguing about failed contraception and "just saying no". Rapists don't care about contraception or women saying no.

I'm surprised nobody has said that the simplest solution to all these problems is obviously for ALL men to have enforced vasectomies after freezing their sperm to ensure they have an opportunity to become parents at a later date when the man and his female partner fully consent and know the possible outcome.

FFS.

Binkybix · 26/06/2022 11:35

I'm fully pro- choice but that is such a silly analogy

expand please on what is silly? Analogies are there to make a point not to be an exact comparison. It does have the element where we find doing something harder morally
than doing nothing even of the result is the same (it’s not because an embryo is not the same as a person)

ThickCutSteakChips · 26/06/2022 11:34

Imagine thinking so little of women that you believe that a 5 week old embryo is equal to a fully formed female human.

cakeorwine · 26/06/2022 11:31

CoastalWave · 26/06/2022 11:29

Jesus. Read up thread. I've said many many times I'm not talking about the awful exceptions. There will always be awful exceptions.

Have you now done your research and realised that there are now some States in the USA that have made the decision to totally ban abortion?

ThickCutSteakChips · 26/06/2022 11:30

CoastalWave · 26/06/2022 11:27

At 5 weeks an embryo has a heart beat. A Fetus feels pain at 20 weeks.

Imagine being so angry over NOT being able to murder babies.

Seriously.

Imagine wanting to force women to go through pregnancy and birth. Imagine being so gleeful about controlling women.

Yuk.

CoastalWave · 26/06/2022 11:29

ReneBumsWombats · 26/06/2022 11:11

Abortion isn't an option for failed contraceptives. Make better choices!

Are you a sock of the person who said rape victims should just say no?

Jesus. Read up thread. I've said many many times I'm not talking about the awful exceptions. There will always be awful exceptions.

CoastalWave · 26/06/2022 11:28

cakeorwine · 26/06/2022 11:22

I don't understand how someone can hold 2 opposing thoughts in their head.

There are people who don't want the Covid vaccine because it's their body, their rights - even though the vaccine could help save other lives

Yet the same people think abortion should be banned, even though a woman should have control over her own body, because they are 'protecting the life of the unborn child'

If the same person was asked some questions - such as "Do you think a person should have control over their own body?" , then the questions on vaccines and then the questions on abortion, I wonder if that would alter any responses?

Seemingly the people who are all FOR abortion as the same people who think vaccines should be mandatory.

That's the twist!

CoastalWave · 26/06/2022 11:27

At 5 weeks an embryo has a heart beat. A Fetus feels pain at 20 weeks.

Imagine being so angry over NOT being able to murder babies.

Seriously.

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 26/06/2022 11:25

Binkybix · 26/06/2022 10:56

It’s dreadful. If a women doesn’t want to use her body to grow the embryo then she should not be made to.

why don’t we go the whole hog and legislate to compel people who are a match to donate their kidneys to anyone who needs them? Save a life (and an actual person this time, not a bunch of cells) - check! Risk to the donor - check!

I'm fully pro- choice but that is such a silly analogy. It gets trotted out from time to time but it really isn't the gotcha some people seem to think it is.

cakeorwine · 26/06/2022 11:22

I don't understand how someone can hold 2 opposing thoughts in their head.

There are people who don't want the Covid vaccine because it's their body, their rights - even though the vaccine could help save other lives

Yet the same people think abortion should be banned, even though a woman should have control over her own body, because they are 'protecting the life of the unborn child'

If the same person was asked some questions - such as "Do you think a person should have control over their own body?" , then the questions on vaccines and then the questions on abortion, I wonder if that would alter any responses?

Livingtothefull · 26/06/2022 11:15

Binkybix · 26/06/2022 10:56

It’s dreadful. If a women doesn’t want to use her body to grow the embryo then she should not be made to.

why don’t we go the whole hog and legislate to compel people who are a match to donate their kidneys to anyone who needs them? Save a life (and an actual person this time, not a bunch of cells) - check! Risk to the donor - check!

Nobody is compelled to so much as give blood to save another human life, ie even when the risk to the donor is minimal. I am guessing that the reason for this is that such rulings would impact men as well, and we can't have that.

ReneBumsWombats · 26/06/2022 11:11

Abortion isn't an option for failed contraceptives. Make better choices!

Are you a sock of the person who said rape victims should just say no?

AclowncalledAlice · 26/06/2022 11:02

Abortion isn't an option for failed contraceptives.

That statement makes no sense. If a woman is using contraception it's because she doesn't want to get pregnant, so if that contraception fails (which, as you know, it does on occasions), then what? If the pregnancy is unwanted for whatever reason, then abortion is the only way to prevent it from progressing.

Pumperthepumper · 26/06/2022 10:59

CoastalWave · 26/06/2022 10:04

Happy to be corrected but my understanding is that they're not banning abortion. They're banning women just accessing it on a whim at any point during a pregnancy. From what I can gather from what I've read, you'll still be able to get an abortion before 12 weeks (depending on the state) - they're basically giving ownership to the different states.

WHY should women be allowed to just abort an otherwise healthy foetus because they're simply changed their mind?

You can get a safe abortion - at an appropriate time during the pregnancy - ie as early as possible.

It’s because the alternative is to give birth to a baby you don’t want. How do you make them want that kid?

Binkybix · 26/06/2022 10:56

It’s dreadful. If a women doesn’t want to use her body to grow the embryo then she should not be made to.

why don’t we go the whole hog and legislate to compel people who are a match to donate their kidneys to anyone who needs them? Save a life (and an actual person this time, not a bunch of cells) - check! Risk to the donor - check!

WooFighters · 26/06/2022 10:52

The cut off for abortions is 23 weeks in the uk, 24-27 in the USA.

That's a surprisingly early cut off point considering many women don't have their anomaly scan till later than 20 weeks due to demand on the system. That's three weeks to make a heartwrenching decision regardless of what you choose and how poor the outcomes might be if you choose to give birth. It's certainly not treated in the blase way some posters suggest, like a whim.
So infanticide being argued as the same as abortion is an absolute strawman.

BettyCake · 26/06/2022 10:50

So how are you going to support women to make better choices @CoastalWave ? Are you going to campaign for better education, better access to contraceptives, improved sex education,
money to be spent on maternity services and social care and improving foster care and early years support?
Telling women to make better choices is so fucking patronising. Pregnancy isn't always a choice and why is it always up
to the women to make better choices? Are you campaigning too for men to be educated about using contraception and not raping women? Thought not.

Swipe left for the next trending thread