Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be totally gutted for American women?

995 replies

Anothernamechangeplease · 24/06/2022 15:19

The US Supreme Court has reversed the Roe v Wade ruling. Millions of American women have lost their right to make decisions about what happens to their own bodies. Sad

I have never had an abortion and personally, I'm not sure if I ever could, but I have always been passionately of the view that individual women should be able to make that choice for themselves. It's awful that this right has been removed for so many.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
MurderAtTheBeautyPageant · 26/06/2022 19:01

there are some states that will no doubt be cross-examining women who've had miscarriages as to whether they've in fact had an abortion. there will always be deeper levels of control to be found. even the 'pure' women will be under scrutiny...

Trainbear · 26/06/2022 19:00

Maybe we can welcome them as refugees.

We do need people to replace the many retirees and the speak the same language, have an excellent work ethic. Many ethnicities and races in the US so cannot be accused of only wanting Whites.

JanisMoplin · 26/06/2022 18:58

I don't care if a fetus at 20 weeks feels pain, frankly. Or I care far less about that than I do about the mother. Women first, fetuses later.

ReneBumsWombats · 26/06/2022 18:52

CoastalWave · 26/06/2022 18:47

With the greatest of respect, how the fuck do you know that?! You have absolutely no idea what I do with regards to these type of situations.

I stand by my viewpoint. Abortion should not be available freely with no questions asked. It absolutely should be on a case by case review. The rights of the mother do not trump the rights of the unborn child who is carrying their own DNA.

My 17 week loss showed me that's it not a bunch of cells. You are growing a human being. It should not be on a par with taking medicine for a sore throat or ringing the doctor for migraine tablets.

I do give a shit about the babies.

I'm sorry for your loss, but it has nothing to do with other women's bodily autonomy. I've had losses too.

The rights of the mother do not trump the rights of the unborn child who is carrying their own DNA.

Yes they do. DNA is simply genetic coding, not a person. It would be quite something if a foetus wasn't carrying its own mother's DNA so I've no idea what's so significant about this. A foetus is a potential person, a mother is an actual person who would have to endure and live with her consequences of a forced birth. If you've actually given birth and understand what it can do to someone, you'll know how important it is that it isn't forced on anyone.

If you don't want an abortion, don't fucking have one. If you care about babies, don't force them to be born to people who don't want them.

CoastalWave · 26/06/2022 18:47

Gilead · 26/06/2022 16:38

Imagine being so angry over NOT being able to murder babies
Imagine being so concerned about another woman’s body that you cannot see the reality of the situation. You don’t actually give a shit about that baby, you’re not donating to orphans or to adoption centres. You’re not helping these women when the baby (they couldn’t cope with/didn’t want/were forced to have) or the product of the pregnancy. Imagine being so mired in appalling religious propaganda that you cannot help and support women to have autonomy, physically and politically.

With the greatest of respect, how the fuck do you know that?! You have absolutely no idea what I do with regards to these type of situations.

I stand by my viewpoint. Abortion should not be available freely with no questions asked. It absolutely should be on a case by case review. The rights of the mother do not trump the rights of the unborn child who is carrying their own DNA.

My 17 week loss showed me that's it not a bunch of cells. You are growing a human being. It should not be on a par with taking medicine for a sore throat or ringing the doctor for migraine tablets.

I do give a shit about the babies.

Andouillette · 26/06/2022 18:33

WooFighters · 26/06/2022 18:02

This very rarely happens.

That was my point...

I know. I was just clarifying that there's more time than people might think to get all test results in and make the decision.

WooFighters · 26/06/2022 18:02

This very rarely happens.

That was my point...

Andouillette · 26/06/2022 17:29

WooFighters · 26/06/2022 10:52

The cut off for abortions is 23 weeks in the uk, 24-27 in the USA.

That's a surprisingly early cut off point considering many women don't have their anomaly scan till later than 20 weeks due to demand on the system. That's three weeks to make a heartwrenching decision regardless of what you choose and how poor the outcomes might be if you choose to give birth. It's certainly not treated in the blase way some posters suggest, like a whim.
So infanticide being argued as the same as abortion is an absolute strawman.

24 weeks in the UK (not including NI) and it is not an absolute cut off. A pregnancy which grossly endangers the mother, or where the foetus is incompatible with life can be terminated at any time up to birth. This very rarely happens.

Leontine · 26/06/2022 17:18

I’m in total disbelief it’s even happened. It’s one of the few political things that have happened during my lifetime that I’ve been truly stunned by.

AclowncalledAlice · 26/06/2022 17:12

Sums it up I think

Gilead · 26/06/2022 16:38

Imagine being so angry over NOT being able to murder babies
Imagine being so concerned about another woman’s body that you cannot see the reality of the situation. You don’t actually give a shit about that baby, you’re not donating to orphans or to adoption centres. You’re not helping these women when the baby (they couldn’t cope with/didn’t want/were forced to have) or the product of the pregnancy. Imagine being so mired in appalling religious propaganda that you cannot help and support women to have autonomy, physically and politically.

BaconAndAvocado · 26/06/2022 16:04

HavfrueDenizKisi · 24/06/2022 15:22

It's unbelievable in this day and age really. How can a country go backwards? It feels like Gilead.

This.
And it will probably get worse re access to contraception.
The gun laws are crazy enough, now this!

ReneBumsWombats · 26/06/2022 15:51

For you, @CoastalWave, and your wonderful social conscience.

To be totally gutted for American women?
SpinningTheSeedsOfLove · 26/06/2022 15:14

Yes, those judges lied under oath on the Bible. To quote the Pet Shop Boys, It's A Sin.

Cartoonmom · 26/06/2022 15:08

@DontBlameMe79 - I think I can blame those conservative judges. They straight up lied at their Senate confirmation hearings about abortion. Isn't that grounds for impeachment?

Further, only Clarence Thomas was appointed by a popularly elected president (Bush Sr.). The rest come from W and Trump. 2 losers that a majority of Americans didn't want to be president. Does that sound like democracy?

I think we have a right to be angry and disappointed with these judges.

riesenrad · 26/06/2022 14:51

Imagine being so angry over NOT being able to murder babies

As you well know, the bans in many countries go way beyond "lifestyle abortions" and is nothing to do with the "baby"'s life. In many cases they are to save the life of the mother. In many cases the baby will die anyway. And why should someone have to bring up their rapist's child? And who wants to grow up knowing they were a product of rape? (The last time I posted this on here a few years ago the post got deleted but I think it's a reasonable comment to make - it would be devastating to know your father was a rapist).

You don't have to have an abortion. I never have (I've been lucky enough not have a miscarriage either). But don't tell other women what they can and cannot do under some pretext of protecting babies' lives. We all know it has zero to do with that.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 26/06/2022 14:04

If anyone's interested, the official view of the Pontifical Academy of Life is contained in this (scroll about a third of the way down):
www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/251629/pontifical-academy-of-life-statement-overturning-roe

There's some good stuff in it too, referring to the wider social context and support of women, but as so often not even the briefest suggestion around practical measures
Then again, considering the Supreme Court Justice's remarks about leaving babies in doorways, I wonder if he at least feels another Tuam would be a good idea?

DontBlameMe79 · 26/06/2022 13:42

All the virtue signalling politicians should have put it into law (you Obama…), not just rely on precedent. But they didn’t want to spend the political capital.

The Conservative judges are just doing what they do. It’s like blaming a crocodile for being a crocodile.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 26/06/2022 13:40

And don’t forget the social costs of these unwanted children - neglected/unwanted/abused tend to have poorer adult lives and can be linked to poor mental health, increased crime, low educational outcomes, increased disassociation to societal norms and expectations. Plus these negatives tend to be repeated for the generation they produce. The future costs (in all aspects) is enormous.

BettyCake · 26/06/2022 13:35

CoastalWave · 26/06/2022 11:27

At 5 weeks an embryo has a heart beat. A Fetus feels pain at 20 weeks.

Imagine being so angry over NOT being able to murder babies.

Seriously.

So how would you decide which cases are exceptions and should be allowed to have abortions, and which cases are just silly women not making good choices and taking responsibility for their actions? Seriously how would this work? Would women need to sit in front of a panel and have someone say yes Mrs Smith you can have an abortion as you were raped, but Mrs Jones your contraception failed and you need to take responsibility for your actions and you can't have an abortion? Do you seriously think this would work?
And then Mrs Jones gives birth to her 6th child that she cannot afford or feed, the baby gets abused and neglected and has a lifetime of trauma and the cycle of pain and suffering continues.
But you don't give a shit about the babies once they're born, do you? It's so much easier to protest about unborn foetuses than to actually make a difference and work with the troubled teenager that has had two failed adoptions and no prospects and no one wants anything to do with. Right?

AclowncalledAlice · 26/06/2022 12:54

Puzzledandpissedoff · 26/06/2022 12:40

Save your breath, AclowncalledAlice - I'll be amazed if you get any proper answers to that, beyond perhaps "parents should be obliged to provide" with no detail as to what should be done if they won't

Here's a thought though: where their diktats have brought something about, perhaps we could ask organised religions to pay the costs? After all they have the money - or rather would have, if they weren't having to spend so much defending the pitifully few child abuse cases they're held accountable for

Quite. It's very telling how they are all wanting to force women into giving birth but are strangely quiet about what happens to the baby once it's born. It's almost as if they haven't worked out that unwanted babies will have a shitty life but who cares about that as long as they get to control what a woman is able to do with her own body. That's all that matters as far as they are concerned.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 26/06/2022 12:40

Save your breath, AclowncalledAlice - I'll be amazed if you get any proper answers to that, beyond perhaps "parents should be obliged to provide" with no detail as to what should be done if they won't

Here's a thought though: where their diktats have brought something about, perhaps we could ask organised religions to pay the costs? After all they have the money - or rather would have, if they weren't having to spend so much defending the pitifully few child abuse cases they're held accountable for

CapMarvel · 26/06/2022 12:33

CoastalWave · 26/06/2022 11:27

At 5 weeks an embryo has a heart beat. A Fetus feels pain at 20 weeks.

Imagine being so angry over NOT being able to murder babies.

Seriously.

At 0 weeks pregnant the woman has a brain and the ability to make the best choice for herself and the potential baby.

Imagine thinking that you have the right to dictate to another person who you have never met, will never meet and have no understanding about their circumstances what they can do with their own body.

Pro-lifers do not give a flying fuck about life and unborn babies. They don't give a fuck that removing access to safe abortions kills women. It's all about control and punishing women for having the audacity to have sex without wanting a child.

Binkybix · 26/06/2022 12:28

Because it completely ignores the utterly unique situation of a woman and a child in utero. It ignores the fact that in this specific situation autonomy over the woman's body directly affects another living organism/ body/ potential body/ potential human. It completely fails to answer or address that point

I agree there are differences obviously.

it is an artificial construct designed to tease out why we feel how we do - like many thought experiments are. The whole point is WHY do people feel differently because the cells are in utero if the result to use your body to support the cells/person in the thought experiment would have the same result. Something continues to ‘live’ or not.

The idea of being compelled to do either gives me a really similar sense of panic. But yes, it was the first thing that came to mind when I was turning this thread over in my mind, so in that sense, not well thought out at all!

AclowncalledAlice · 26/06/2022 12:26

Those against abortion, what are YOU prepared to do once a woman has a child she did not want? Are you prepared to pay for it until adulthood? Give it a home? Pay for the mother to access MH services to address issues that may arise from her forced (by you) to give birth? Will you be happy that there are no school places due to all those unwanted children now needing an education? Will you not complain about how children's services are overwhelmed by those who have been traumatised through/born with FAS or addicted to drugs? If you're not prepared to do any of that then why not? Is it only the unborn child that you care about and to hell with them once they are here?

Swipe left for the next trending thread