Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask DD to pay towards her lifts home from work at midnight?

269 replies

Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 24/06/2022 14:50

Firstly, I just want to say that I’m happy to give Dd 19 regular lifts to uni, friends etc, as she doesn’t drive, and in her previous job whilst she was still at College, I’d pick her up from work three times a week from the City centre about 11pm.

As you can imagine, it’s not nice to be in the town especially at weekends when there’s the possibility of trouble, as there’s loads of drinking going on obviously.
Dd had said before that she’d look for another job with more suitable hours as she knew I didn’t really want to go into the town late at night and I didn’t like the thought of her waiting outside her place of work for a taxi, and not keen on her getting Ubers.

long story short, she’s found another job she loves, but, again it’s in the town centre and this time she finishes even later, just after midnight.
Dd’s already asking if I can pick her up, but is happy to get an Uber if not.

Now, I don’t want to sit at home worrying again if she’s ok getting home, but also I don’t relish the thought of regular lifts from town so late at night. Im also a bit put out re the cost of petrol when, if she’d got a job where she could get a bus then it’d saving me the money. AIBU to think sod it , she can pay half of what a taxi would cost if she wants me to pick her up so late (after all it was her choice to go for this job) , or should I suck it up and fetch her for free as I’m concerned about her getting home any other way?

OP posts:
SurfBox · 26/06/2022 09:58

Do you think it’s fair that because of that, I have to find probably an extra £50 a month in petrol, which I wouldn’t have to do if she’d chosen a job she could get home from easily on the bus

50 a month isn't what would irk me although yes agreed it's quite a sum and she should pay, but it's the fact I'd to sit up so late waiting to lift her home. It's the commitment.

Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 09:57

SurfBox · 26/06/2022 09:50

I’ve no idea of your age, but there’s probably five times more crime in my area than there was when I was 19. In other words, it’s a more dangerous place nowadays

I also recall my parents and auntie saying this to my older sister and 1st cousin who were 19 when they went out at that age. This was 1994.

And that’s probably because it’s true! … crime has got worse and worse over the years, that’s pretty obvious.

OP posts:
Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 09:53

EarringsandLipstick · 26/06/2022 09:31

So do you honestly think it’s out of order of me to consider asking her to help towards petrol, considering if I don’t pick her up she’ll pay around £12 for an Uber?

Yes, because you are conflating issues.

If you are happy to give lifts for free at 'sociable' hours, it doesn't make sense that you feel the need to charge for the fuel at 'unsociable' times. You either need the money for fuel or you don't. Timing shouldn't be relevant.

It reads like she has to pay you for the favour of picking her up at midnight. Not a contribution to fuel.

I would also not like to do midnight pick ups! So your decision to go with an Uber, until she can drive herself, sounds like the right one.

I get what your saying, but whilst I’m happy to help her out with lifts, there’s got to be some kind of line drawn, especially since petrol prices are going through the roof.

As I’ve said before, she’s been offered a number of jobs but chose this one. Do you think it’s fair that because of that, I have to find probably an extra £50 a month in petrol, which I wouldn’t have to do if she’d chosen a job she could get home from easily on the bus?
Bear in mind that if she’d accepted earlier hours, even with this particular job she’s started, she could have got the nearby bus from the City centre home. But my Dd was happy to agree to work the later shift.

OP posts:
SurfBox · 26/06/2022 09:50

I’ve no idea of your age, but there’s probably five times more crime in my area than there was when I was 19. In other words, it’s a more dangerous place nowadays

I also recall my parents and auntie saying this to my older sister and 1st cousin who were 19 when they went out at that age. This was 1994.

SurfBox · 26/06/2022 09:46

It’s actually a City, but we tend to say town centre. I’ve no idea of your age, but there’s probably five times more crime in my area than there was when I was 19. In other words, it’s a more dangerous place nowadays

I'm 36, this was 2005 so not that long ago and yes back then people said the exact same thing ''there's far more crime now than ever before, the world is now a different place...,''

In 30 years time your daughter's generation will be saying it.

SurfBox · 26/06/2022 09:44

My Dd goes out all the time too, but the difference is I know (well I believe) she’s always with her friends and not waiting outside a place of work alone in a busy city centre late at night

my parents often believed I was doing x also but truthfully when they weren't around I did the opposite.

What’s more, your parents probably weren’t as worried as they didn’t know where you were, so didn’t visualise you standing alone waiting for a taxi at night if you see what I mean

ok i hear you but I just think you are making a deal with the devil going to collect anybody on a regular basis. To be truthful I had to leave at 19 because my parents were fiercely overbearing; that's how it can be. But it's for this reason I think after 18/19 most people should move out and be gone for some time or it just becomes too much clashing with parents. They need these years to find their independence and with parents around this can be a challenge.

IfIhearmumagaintoday · 26/06/2022 09:43

balalake · 26/06/2022 09:38

I think it would be better you picking her up instead of supporting Uber, who after all have a track record of adherence to rules almost as bad as those in number 10.

I think that your DD should contribute towards fuel costs, perhaps by paying for your car to be fuelled on a regular basis. Say once a month.

Don't you have work in the mornings? 11pm onwards is very late to leave the house to go picking her DD up

Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 09:41

SurfBox · 26/06/2022 09:33

forgive me for not relishing the thought of her travelling on her own late at night from a busy town centre

I did at that age, also is it a town or a city? There is a difference.

It’s actually a City, but we tend to say town centre. I’ve no idea of your age, but there’s probably five times more crime in my area than there was when I was 19. In other words, it’s a more dangerous place nowadays.

OP posts:
Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 09:39

SurfBox · 26/06/2022 09:31

She needs to be an adult. And I know it’s hard as fuck but most kids who go to uni at that age would be 100s of miles away from their parents doing whatever (and whoever) they like. Sometimes putting themselves in danger and it’s anxiety inducing but it’s how we learn. I feel like it built me

this I was living alone 100s of miles from parents at 19 and would often be out and about until all hours gallivanting across the city at night. So were many people of that age, Take a step back op, you can't wrap them in cotton wool;if she was 16 I'd understand but she's a woman.

My Dd goes out all the time too, but the difference is I know (well I believe) she’s always with her friends and not waiting outside a place of work alone in a busy city centre late at night.
What’s more, your parents probably weren’t as worried as they didn’t know where you were, so didn’t visualise you standing alone waiting for a taxi at night if you see what I mean .

OP posts:
balalake · 26/06/2022 09:38

I think it would be better you picking her up instead of supporting Uber, who after all have a track record of adherence to rules almost as bad as those in number 10.

I think that your DD should contribute towards fuel costs, perhaps by paying for your car to be fuelled on a regular basis. Say once a month.

SurfBox · 26/06/2022 09:33

forgive me for not relishing the thought of her travelling on her own late at night from a busy town centre

I did at that age, also is it a town or a city? There is a difference.

Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 09:31

SurfBox · 26/06/2022 09:26

and not keen on her getting Ubers

why exactly? She is an adult, let her make her own way home.

It’s already been established way back that she’ll get an Uber. Of course she’s an adult and capable of getting her own way home, and whilst I’m not going to try and stop her from getting an Uber if that’s what she wants, forgive me for not relishing the thought of her travelling on her own late at night from a busy town centre.

OP posts:
SurfBox · 26/06/2022 09:31

She needs to be an adult. And I know it’s hard as fuck but most kids who go to uni at that age would be 100s of miles away from their parents doing whatever (and whoever) they like. Sometimes putting themselves in danger and it’s anxiety inducing but it’s how we learn. I feel like it built me

this I was living alone 100s of miles from parents at 19 and would often be out and about until all hours gallivanting across the city at night. So were many people of that age, Take a step back op, you can't wrap them in cotton wool;if she was 16 I'd understand but she's a woman.

EarringsandLipstick · 26/06/2022 09:31

So do you honestly think it’s out of order of me to consider asking her to help towards petrol, considering if I don’t pick her up she’ll pay around £12 for an Uber?

Yes, because you are conflating issues.

If you are happy to give lifts for free at 'sociable' hours, it doesn't make sense that you feel the need to charge for the fuel at 'unsociable' times. You either need the money for fuel or you don't. Timing shouldn't be relevant.

It reads like she has to pay you for the favour of picking her up at midnight. Not a contribution to fuel.

I would also not like to do midnight pick ups! So your decision to go with an Uber, until she can drive herself, sounds like the right one.

SurfBox · 26/06/2022 09:26

and not keen on her getting Ubers

why exactly? She is an adult, let her make her own way home.

Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 09:22

LBK2022 · 26/06/2022 02:44

Sounds a LOT like my parents. They didn’t want me getting my license/driving or getting rides, but wanted me out/working…but didn’t like doing the driving, especially at night or “too far” etc.
Almost charged me rent etc. (and then admitted they took $ I didn’t have access to anyway, they were just asking for rent on top of it).
Got my license in college and they had the same control issues until I moved a few flights away a decade later. We still have issues when we’re in contact, but that is very minimal at this point. (If you heard their version, it would be very different.)

Ffs can’t some people actually READ all the posts?

If you read everything you will see that my Dd is taking driving lessons, have I implied that I don’t want her to drive? NO I haven’t.

Where do you come up with the assumption that it’s me who wanted my Dd out working? Do you not think she’s capable enough to decide for herself what job she does and where it’s located?
If you actually READ my posts you will see that she’s been offered numerous jobs with more sociable hours, and it was her choice to go for one working late at night.

So do you honestly think it’s out of order of me to consider asking her to help towards petrol, considering if I don’t pick her up she’ll pay around £12 for an Uber?
Remember also that I’ve stated a few times that I’m happy to ferry her around without expecting any petrol contribution, but I don’t want to add to my petrol expense because she’s chosen a job she didn’t need to take (as there were others she could’ve accepted)
And if you think that it’s about ‘control issues’, then you sound like you’ve grown up a spoiled brat.

OP posts:
LBK2022 · 26/06/2022 02:44

Sounds a LOT like my parents. They didn’t want me getting my license/driving or getting rides, but wanted me out/working…but didn’t like doing the driving, especially at night or “too far” etc.
Almost charged me rent etc. (and then admitted they took $ I didn’t have access to anyway, they were just asking for rent on top of it).
Got my license in college and they had the same control issues until I moved a few flights away a decade later. We still have issues when we’re in contact, but that is very minimal at this point. (If you heard their version, it would be very different.)

Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 25/06/2022 11:32

Bednobsbroomsticks · 25/06/2022 11:19

Fellow worrier here. Also don't like my daughters getting ubers but she uses them. I'd prob be awake tracking the uber lol so I'd prob pick up too. Not unreasonable for her to chip in petrol costs fortune

Some of us can’t help worrying can we!

OP posts:
Bednobsbroomsticks · 25/06/2022 11:19

Fellow worrier here. Also don't like my daughters getting ubers but she uses them. I'd prob be awake tracking the uber lol so I'd prob pick up too. Not unreasonable for her to chip in petrol costs fortune

Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 25/06/2022 11:15

DailySheetWasher · 25/06/2022 02:33

How unfortunate for your PIL. Ours get their licenses and start driving themselves as soon as they can. Then figure out how much fuel costs and opt for jobs closer to home.

Ah, so you agree that fuel costs money then?

But you wouldn’t expect your dc’s to contribute a small amount towards petrol if you’re giving them a lift from work at midnight on a regular basis? (remember, I’ve already pointed out I’m happy to and I do give my Dd ‘free’ lifts all the time at more sociable hours)

You also say that if it’s not convenient for you to give a lift, they would either not go or sort themselves out.
So basically, you’re trying to put me down for CONSIDERING asking my Dd for a contribution for petrol (only at that inconvenient time of midnight), but I’m the parent whose prepared to go out and pick her up, which would also save her having to pay twice as much for an Uber.

Where as you, on the other hand, are happy to let your dc’s either forfeit somewhere they need or want to go to, or will happily let them pay for an expensive Uber or drive themselves (which will cost them fuel, as you’ve already admitted) rather than do them a favour.
So you’re not really in a position to judge me are you?

OP posts:
Snoopsnoggysnog · 25/06/2022 09:37

BMW6 · 24/06/2022 15:07

She's 19. An adult. She should be getting herself home.

Does her employer not pay for staff taxis home? When I was working as a waitress in a cocktail bar (that much is true 😏) till 2am we were taxid home on employer account

Grin
Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 25/06/2022 09:26

familyissues12345 · 25/06/2022 07:30

...

Blimey, I only posted on here for a quick response and didn’t expect it to be posted anywhere else!

OP posts:
Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 25/06/2022 09:23

Oblomov22 · 25/06/2022 07:18

I wouldn't do give lifts regularly at midnight. One off fine, not regularly. You've admitted you are a complete over-worrier. Glad you've finally agreed to Uber until she passes test.

I find anxious over-worriers really irritating. I've got it with all of ds2's friends mothers atm, not letting them do things. I actually think it's becoming more of a serious problem. It's poor parenting, damaging.

I’m not ‘not letting her do things’, my Dd has her own mind and it was she who asked me for a lift originally. She knows I’m not keen on her travelling on her own in an Uber or a taxi late at night (I’d say many parents would feel the same) and so I didn’t want her to feel as if I’m a free taxi home at such an inconvenient hour.

As I’ve previously said, I give her lifts all the time whenever she wants them usually, (and I never expect petrol money) , but to come out at night as well made me feel like I needed to draw the line somewhere.
A bit cheeky of you to claim it’s ‘poor parenting’ too.

OP posts:
saraclara · 25/06/2022 08:09

MoniJitchell · 25/06/2022 07:20

Why not just let her get an uber?

Why not read the thread before posting?

Oblomov22 · 25/06/2022 08:08

The mirror now, rather than the sun? I hate it when papers print mn threads.

Swipe left for the next trending thread