Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask DD to pay towards her lifts home from work at midnight?

269 replies

Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 24/06/2022 14:50

Firstly, I just want to say that I’m happy to give Dd 19 regular lifts to uni, friends etc, as she doesn’t drive, and in her previous job whilst she was still at College, I’d pick her up from work three times a week from the City centre about 11pm.

As you can imagine, it’s not nice to be in the town especially at weekends when there’s the possibility of trouble, as there’s loads of drinking going on obviously.
Dd had said before that she’d look for another job with more suitable hours as she knew I didn’t really want to go into the town late at night and I didn’t like the thought of her waiting outside her place of work for a taxi, and not keen on her getting Ubers.

long story short, she’s found another job she loves, but, again it’s in the town centre and this time she finishes even later, just after midnight.
Dd’s already asking if I can pick her up, but is happy to get an Uber if not.

Now, I don’t want to sit at home worrying again if she’s ok getting home, but also I don’t relish the thought of regular lifts from town so late at night. Im also a bit put out re the cost of petrol when, if she’d got a job where she could get a bus then it’d saving me the money. AIBU to think sod it , she can pay half of what a taxi would cost if she wants me to pick her up so late (after all it was her choice to go for this job) , or should I suck it up and fetch her for free as I’m concerned about her getting home any other way?

OP posts:
Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 11:19

wouldyaeverquitit · 26/06/2022 11:16

You just don’t like being told that you come across as mean. Anyone who has disagreed with you, you have got angry with. Don’t put it out there if you cannot take it.

Are you hard of understanding? genuine question.

I’ve explained why (about three thousand times it seems) I’ve considered asking for a contribution.
I won’t explain myself again.

OP posts:
bendmeoverbackwards · 26/06/2022 11:18

Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 11:09

Exactly! it’s not on for people to think they can just expect parents to ferry them home at unsociable hours, and if they’re earning, why should the parent pay the petrol money all the time?
Just in case someone jumps on me, I’ll reiterate that I DO NOT expect petrol money all the time. The ONLY time I’m considering asking for a contribution is picking Dd up from work at midnight.
Now, if this was the only job she’d been offered, then I’d probably just accept it and collect her without asking for a contribution, but she was also given the opportunity to work the earlier shift in this job (which would’ve enabled her to get home on the bus), but she wanted the late shift so therefore I’m also trying to teach her that she has to realise that her choices don’t mean that mum will always bail her out (for want of a better word)

@Chocolatetrufflesandcream I see your reasoning but TBH it does seem a bit petty. Charging her is not being done out of your financial hardship, but rather to ‘teach her a lesson’ for choosing the late shift.

Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 11:16

wouldyaeverquitit · 26/06/2022 11:11

Coz petrol is more expensive when you pick up after midnight….

Ok, let her pay £12 for an Uber then shall I?

OP posts:
wouldyaeverquitit · 26/06/2022 11:16

Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 11:13

To be fair I only get angry with people like yourself who come across as up their own arses and are nasty to me.
You find it ‘highly amusing’ as well do you? So obviously you’re trying to goad.

Go forth and multiply.

You just don’t like being told that you come across as mean. Anyone who has disagreed with you, you have got angry with. Don’t put it out there if you cannot take it.

Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 11:13

wouldyaeverquitit · 26/06/2022 11:06

Just mortified for you.
I also find it highly amusing how angry you get with all of those who disagree with your miserliness.
So double mortified for you!
Get a nice little chest like Fagan had in Oliver to put all your little fivers in that you charge your daughter for picking her up.

To be fair I only get angry with people like yourself who come across as up their own arses and are nasty to me.
You find it ‘highly amusing’ as well do you? So obviously you’re trying to goad.

Go forth and multiply.

OP posts:
wouldyaeverquitit · 26/06/2022 11:11

Coz petrol is more expensive when you pick up after midnight….

Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 11:09

LindaEllen · 26/06/2022 10:54

When my stepson was getting a job, the one thing we insisted on was that he could make his own way there and get back (I posted a thread a while back about him wanting independence so we started insisting that he do most things for himself).

Even so, we would get woken up at 5am or 1am saying there were no buses/taxis/trains to get him there/back.. because he didn't think about how he was going to travel until the moment arrived.

It depends on the relationship you have with your daughter but if, like our teen, she could benefit from learning a life lesson about taking care of herself then yes, either ask her to pay or get alternative transport.

Would it work to work out how many miles you do, and get her to put the appropriate amount of fuel in your car each time she gets paid?

Exactly! it’s not on for people to think they can just expect parents to ferry them home at unsociable hours, and if they’re earning, why should the parent pay the petrol money all the time?
Just in case someone jumps on me, I’ll reiterate that I DO NOT expect petrol money all the time. The ONLY time I’m considering asking for a contribution is picking Dd up from work at midnight.
Now, if this was the only job she’d been offered, then I’d probably just accept it and collect her without asking for a contribution, but she was also given the opportunity to work the earlier shift in this job (which would’ve enabled her to get home on the bus), but she wanted the late shift so therefore I’m also trying to teach her that she has to realise that her choices don’t mean that mum will always bail her out (for want of a better word)

OP posts:
wouldyaeverquitit · 26/06/2022 11:06

Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 10:51

Mortified for me are you? … is this a joke? 🙄

thanks anyway, , but when I read a moronic post like yours (which says to me you’ve obviously not either read and digested my posts or UNDERSTOOD my reasoning) then your opinion is absolutely meaningless to me.
P.S If I was ‘stingy’, don’t you think I’d either never give my Dd lifts or charge her every time? Ffs …

Just mortified for you.
I also find it highly amusing how angry you get with all of those who disagree with your miserliness.
So double mortified for you!
Get a nice little chest like Fagan had in Oliver to put all your little fivers in that you charge your daughter for picking her up.

XmasElf10 · 26/06/2022 11:05

She’s 19 not 9.. she can get an Uber.

SurfBox · 26/06/2022 11:04

Isn't it the stuff you do as parents to help the kids get set up and move towards independence

yea but 19 yo isn't a kid;it's very much an adult. I think if the offspring on this post was a male the responses be quite different and it be like 'he's an adult/man' .

Vikinga · 26/06/2022 11:04

Hi op. Yanbu because it is you that is paying for her stubbornness in taking a job that costs you time, effort and money.

So if she pays you or an uber, it may encourage her to take a job that she can get to by bus.

I would charge her. She's an adult and she needs to learn that she has to weigh up the pros and cons of things.

bendmeoverbackwards · 26/06/2022 11:03

So this is a non issue then, she’s getting an Uber so no need for lifts from you.

SurfBox · 26/06/2022 11:02

It depends on the relationship you have with your daughter but if, like our teen, she could benefit from learning a life lesson about taking care of herself then yes, either ask her to pay or get alternative transport

there is a difference between a 'teen' though as this could be 15/16 to a 19 yo adult. What age was your stepson?

Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 10:59

bendmeoverbackwards · 26/06/2022 10:52

@Chocolatetrufflesandcream you are contradicting yourself. On the one hand you say your dd is an adult and perfectly capable of choosing this particular job; yet you are ‘not allowing’ her to use an Uber.

She should crack on and use Ubers. My DDs use them all the time with no problems.

We have to be careful raising daughters not to teach them to be afraid of everything. I know women’s safely is an issue and no one should be taking risks. But I also want to bring up my daughters to live their lives and be confident. I often read about women or girls being scared of going out after dark. I’d hate that for my daughters, who wants to be stuck st home from 4pm in the winter?

Is there a ‘bang head here sign’ anywhere? 🙄

I’ve already said (probably on page 2 ) that YES she maybe ought to get an Uber.

OP posts:
Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 10:57

buttonstep · 26/06/2022 10:36

I would and do do these kind of lifts nightly. Isn't it the stuff you do as parents to help the kids get set up and move towards independence? Goodness knows it's hard enough once they fledge, why not help where possible now. It's not forever.

If you also read my posts p.r.o.p.e.r.l.y., you might understand where I’m come from.

You will ALSO see that I ferry my daughter around on many occasions, and I’m happy to do so.

OP posts:
LindaEllen · 26/06/2022 10:54

When my stepson was getting a job, the one thing we insisted on was that he could make his own way there and get back (I posted a thread a while back about him wanting independence so we started insisting that he do most things for himself).

Even so, we would get woken up at 5am or 1am saying there were no buses/taxis/trains to get him there/back.. because he didn't think about how he was going to travel until the moment arrived.

It depends on the relationship you have with your daughter but if, like our teen, she could benefit from learning a life lesson about taking care of herself then yes, either ask her to pay or get alternative transport.

Would it work to work out how many miles you do, and get her to put the appropriate amount of fuel in your car each time she gets paid?

bendmeoverbackwards · 26/06/2022 10:52

@Chocolatetrufflesandcream you are contradicting yourself. On the one hand you say your dd is an adult and perfectly capable of choosing this particular job; yet you are ‘not allowing’ her to use an Uber.

She should crack on and use Ubers. My DDs use them all the time with no problems.

We have to be careful raising daughters not to teach them to be afraid of everything. I know women’s safely is an issue and no one should be taking risks. But I also want to bring up my daughters to live their lives and be confident. I often read about women or girls being scared of going out after dark. I’d hate that for my daughters, who wants to be stuck st home from 4pm in the winter?

Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 10:51

wouldyaeverquitit · 26/06/2022 10:36

You’re so worried about her getting home safely that you want to charge her for collecting her. Honestly one of the stingiest posts I have ever read on here. Free pickups at certain hours but charging after midnight coz you are “so worried” about her getting home. I can’t get my head around charging your daughter a fiver a pickup. Mortified for you.

Mortified for me are you? … is this a joke? 🙄

thanks anyway, , but when I read a moronic post like yours (which says to me you’ve obviously not either read and digested my posts or UNDERSTOOD my reasoning) then your opinion is absolutely meaningless to me.
P.S If I was ‘stingy’, don’t you think I’d either never give my Dd lifts or charge her every time? Ffs …

OP posts:
buttonstep · 26/06/2022 10:36

I would and do do these kind of lifts nightly. Isn't it the stuff you do as parents to help the kids get set up and move towards independence? Goodness knows it's hard enough once they fledge, why not help where possible now. It's not forever.

wouldyaeverquitit · 26/06/2022 10:36

You’re so worried about her getting home safely that you want to charge her for collecting her. Honestly one of the stingiest posts I have ever read on here. Free pickups at certain hours but charging after midnight coz you are “so worried” about her getting home. I can’t get my head around charging your daughter a fiver a pickup. Mortified for you.

Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 10:29

balalake · 26/06/2022 09:38

I think it would be better you picking her up instead of supporting Uber, who after all have a track record of adherence to rules almost as bad as those in number 10.

I think that your DD should contribute towards fuel costs, perhaps by paying for your car to be fuelled on a regular basis. Say once a month.

Thank you, I’m baffled why some people think it’s a big deal asking for a small contribution.

OP posts:
Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 10:26

SurfBox · 26/06/2022 09:44

My Dd goes out all the time too, but the difference is I know (well I believe) she’s always with her friends and not waiting outside a place of work alone in a busy city centre late at night

my parents often believed I was doing x also but truthfully when they weren't around I did the opposite.

What’s more, your parents probably weren’t as worried as they didn’t know where you were, so didn’t visualise you standing alone waiting for a taxi at night if you see what I mean

ok i hear you but I just think you are making a deal with the devil going to collect anybody on a regular basis. To be truthful I had to leave at 19 because my parents were fiercely overbearing; that's how it can be. But it's for this reason I think after 18/19 most people should move out and be gone for some time or it just becomes too much clashing with parents. They need these years to find their independence and with parents around this can be a challenge.

You’re 36 so I’m guessing you don’t have dc’s out in the town centre alone at night …… oh dear, one day you may just be eating your words when you’re worrying about them!

OP posts:
Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 10:22

You didn’t lesson to what I’ve already written. Your parents weren’t worried because they didn’t KNOW where you were! Don’t you think my Dd goes out nightclubbing etc? Of course she does, but I don’t KNOW which nightclub she’s at so I don’t worry so much.
There’s a difference between KNOWING your dc is probably waiting alone and not knowing where they are.
Oh, and you don’t need to be so patronising.

OP posts:
SurfBox · 26/06/2022 10:01

And that’s probably because it’s true! … crime has got worse and worse over the years, that’s pretty obvious

It was always dangerous though, there will always be crime. It never was and never will be safe so even in 05 I wasn't safe but I still went out at night with no adult looking out for me. So did millions other my age across the world away from parents-it's called being an adult and growing up.

Chocolatetrufflesandcream · 26/06/2022 10:00

SurfBox · 26/06/2022 09:58

Do you think it’s fair that because of that, I have to find probably an extra £50 a month in petrol, which I wouldn’t have to do if she’d chosen a job she could get home from easily on the bus

50 a month isn't what would irk me although yes agreed it's quite a sum and she should pay, but it's the fact I'd to sit up so late waiting to lift her home. It's the commitment.

I agree that that does irk me too.

OP posts: