Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not 'get' the weight lifting craze?

166 replies

bellaiceberg · 24/06/2022 14:50

It's only my own opinion, and I accept we are all different, blah blah.
But I don't get the contemporary obsession with building muscle. Keeping toned and fit? Yes. Strong and capable? Yes, sure!
But basically eliminating natural female curves and softness to a large extent makes no sense to me. For those who are into body sculpting, that's great, but for the general population?

It kind of reminds me of Germaine Greer when she asked why is 'equality' now about imitating men, rather than men meeting us in the middle?
We women do seem to be growing more and more towards the masculine whilst pushing the naturally feminine away somewhat. Strength is something that isn't always skin deep, and our natural bodies perform just perfectly without terrifying hip thrusts and being able to lift up a small car.

Im exaggerating, but I do feel that our culture is becoming more and more weird about women's bodies. Building muscle in theory is great, and we do tend to lay more fat down, but there's a point where it all starts getting weird. Just seen images of a woman with a fabulous figure who was slightly overweight. She had soft curves and looked pretty fit. Everyone advised her to get everything built up at the gym, that her curved thighs and soft (flat) stomach were not 'healthy'.

AIBU to think it is all bollox? That it's gone from a healthy fitness thing towards a fear of the feminine? I know many women dont have curves and are still obviously feminine. I also know that what we term 'masc/fem' is pretty fluid anyway. But I am strictly focusing on weight training here, and the idea that this is the optimal way for a woman to get fit and healthy.

If I look at some instagram accounts where people are into this, I would honestly say it's more of a fashion/vanity project that health related, for both men and women. Whilst some are concentrating on having exaggerated 'booty's', others are desperate to eliminate any softness or curve. As if it is wrong to have any soft flesh at all.

I agree that muscle is as much feminine as masculine, but we still live in a society where our culture teaches boys to look down on anything traditionally associated with girls (from colours ~ pink!, emotional expression, nurturing, softness, intuition, etc). IMHO we have had to imitate men to become acceptable as opposed to men gaining more respect for US.

And yes yes i know people will pile on and say weight training saved their life/the third world/their obesity, etc. But I do think it's bonkers when a perfectly healthy woman is told any softness is unhealthy.

OP posts:
TheLadyGrayson · 24/06/2022 15:12

Extremely unreasonable. Strength training is good for everyone and is of particular benefit to women as they get older. Also, nothing about doing weights makes me feel any less feminine!! 😂

wwyd2021medicine · 24/06/2022 15:12

I think it's great that DD19 lifts, as do I.
I like having my muscles defined esp on arms and abs.
I have zero natural roundness to start off with anyway. Small boobs, small hips and no waist to speak of but I'm still a woman without that
I have found that weight training is amazing for self confidence and has improved my posture no end.
It's so important to keep muscle with aging to protect the joints and for bone density.

Paq · 24/06/2022 15:12

bellaiceberg · 24/06/2022 15:02

i have not said women are weak. Far from it.

Some important points here to mull over, thanks.

Women are weaker than men! It's a biological fact.

As others have said, it's incredibly difficult to have a very muscular physique as a woman. "Body building" is different to weightlifting. One is about looks, the other is about strength.

Very muscular women and men are usually on unhealthy regimes and potentially steroids. A normal weightlifting program won't give you that physique.

EmmaH2022 · 24/06/2022 15:11

Are you basing these observations on social media?

Carpy88999 · 24/06/2022 15:07

It doesn't eliminate curves. Most women don't lift to look like Hulk Hogan ffs.

forinborin · 24/06/2022 15:07

I started doing some resistance training including weights recently... and, to be honest, most of female trainers at the place I am going to don't have instagram bodies, despite being incredibly fit and active. A good amount of curves on many, and even some quite visible fat here and there. It was a relief in a sense as I was wondering if I will be harshly judged for being sausage shaped, and doing it for health rather than any visuals.

bellaiceberg · 24/06/2022 15:04

MsOllie · 24/06/2022 15:02

Isn't it great that women have the choice to be able to though now? Rather than years ago when it wasn't a thing
I'm 5ft 10 and built for lifting weights, I feel like a lumbering awkward man next to my friends who are feminine and petite. Except in the gym where I can be strong and nobody cares if I have muscles

of course., i agree with this.

I would still prefer men to join us and not minimise our place in society/interests, etc. I do not believe we have true equality.

"you throw like a girl" still going strong amongst boys. Anything effeminate is gay, gay is still an insult, it's not great. Even if we have more choices, we are not accepted.

OP posts:
Madmaxxy · 24/06/2022 15:04

People exercise for reasons other than to change the shape of their body. I strength train because I enjoy it, I like the challenge of improving and working on Olympic lifting skills, it's helped me out massively in terms of everyday life with improved mobility, lifting things properly etc. It's not in the least bit about what I look like and that's such a liberating thing.

Also it's surprisingly difficult to gain muscle and 'look muscley' unless you're on a really strict regime and/or it's your job. You don't just get bulky by picking up some weights.

To use you're own language, I'm 'soft' as fuck to look at but strong as fuck too.

YABU

DialsMavis · 24/06/2022 15:02

When I am weightlifting (let it slip a bit recently, life, bla bla bla) I look much more feminine, nice nipped in waist, round bottom, shapely arms. It feels great too. I am never going to be ripped as I love wine and crisps too much, but when I lift I can get away with drinking more wine and eating more crisps and still look good(ish) in my jeans.

bellaiceberg · 24/06/2022 15:02

i have not said women are weak. Far from it.

Some important points here to mull over, thanks.

OP posts:
MsOllie · 24/06/2022 15:02

Isn't it great that women have the choice to be able to though now? Rather than years ago when it wasn't a thing
I'm 5ft 10 and built for lifting weights, I feel like a lumbering awkward man next to my friends who are feminine and petite. Except in the gym where I can be strong and nobody cares if I have muscles

rubyslippers · 24/06/2022 14:59

EmmaStone · 24/06/2022 14:55

It's really difficult for women to fat reduce to the extent that their muscles are as defined as you're suggesting, it takes a lot of hard work and dedication to diet and exercise, not just me going to the gym a few times a week.

However, weight bearing exercises for women are hugely important for protecting bone density health, and should absolutely be incorporated into all women's exercise regime (note weight bearing exercise isn't necessarily weight-lifting, it can also include yoga, running, bodyweight exercises like push ups).

So sorry, but I think YABU.

So important! Weight training and bearing is very important for women

Purpleavocado · 24/06/2022 14:57

I think it depends on the accounts you're looking at. If it's a female body builder, that will be different from a more moderate account that's looking to produce lean healthy muscle. I do see some women who in my opinion have lost a bit too much body fat, but that's certainly not all. I'm a big Sydney Cummings fan, she lifts reasonably heavy weights for home works and in my opinion doesn't look 'masculine'

To not 'get' the weight lifting craze?
NeverDropYourMooncup · 24/06/2022 14:57

Do you really think that women have always been 'soft' and weak?

Or is it more likely that the majority did hard, physical labour and the lack of muscle was fetishised because, like being pale skinned and then tanned, it was associated with wealth?

UtterlyUnimaginativeUsername · 24/06/2022 14:57

YABU. It's nothing to do with rejecting femininity, it's about health. It's good for your body to have muscle to support it as it ages. And finally it's acceptable for women to lift, rather than it being the sole domain of men. We should have been doing it all along.

Plus, to be honest, it just feels bloody brilliant. I love it.

EmmaStone · 24/06/2022 14:55

It's really difficult for women to fat reduce to the extent that their muscles are as defined as you're suggesting, it takes a lot of hard work and dedication to diet and exercise, not just me going to the gym a few times a week.

However, weight bearing exercises for women are hugely important for protecting bone density health, and should absolutely be incorporated into all women's exercise regime (note weight bearing exercise isn't necessarily weight-lifting, it can also include yoga, running, bodyweight exercises like push ups).

So sorry, but I think YABU.