Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not 'get' the weight lifting craze?

166 replies

bellaiceberg · 24/06/2022 14:50

It's only my own opinion, and I accept we are all different, blah blah.
But I don't get the contemporary obsession with building muscle. Keeping toned and fit? Yes. Strong and capable? Yes, sure!
But basically eliminating natural female curves and softness to a large extent makes no sense to me. For those who are into body sculpting, that's great, but for the general population?

It kind of reminds me of Germaine Greer when she asked why is 'equality' now about imitating men, rather than men meeting us in the middle?
We women do seem to be growing more and more towards the masculine whilst pushing the naturally feminine away somewhat. Strength is something that isn't always skin deep, and our natural bodies perform just perfectly without terrifying hip thrusts and being able to lift up a small car.

Im exaggerating, but I do feel that our culture is becoming more and more weird about women's bodies. Building muscle in theory is great, and we do tend to lay more fat down, but there's a point where it all starts getting weird. Just seen images of a woman with a fabulous figure who was slightly overweight. She had soft curves and looked pretty fit. Everyone advised her to get everything built up at the gym, that her curved thighs and soft (flat) stomach were not 'healthy'.

AIBU to think it is all bollox? That it's gone from a healthy fitness thing towards a fear of the feminine? I know many women dont have curves and are still obviously feminine. I also know that what we term 'masc/fem' is pretty fluid anyway. But I am strictly focusing on weight training here, and the idea that this is the optimal way for a woman to get fit and healthy.

If I look at some instagram accounts where people are into this, I would honestly say it's more of a fashion/vanity project that health related, for both men and women. Whilst some are concentrating on having exaggerated 'booty's', others are desperate to eliminate any softness or curve. As if it is wrong to have any soft flesh at all.

I agree that muscle is as much feminine as masculine, but we still live in a society where our culture teaches boys to look down on anything traditionally associated with girls (from colours ~ pink!, emotional expression, nurturing, softness, intuition, etc). IMHO we have had to imitate men to become acceptable as opposed to men gaining more respect for US.

And yes yes i know people will pile on and say weight training saved their life/the third world/their obesity, etc. But I do think it's bonkers when a perfectly healthy woman is told any softness is unhealthy.

OP posts:
Pedallleur · 27/06/2022 10:09

there was the 'you'll look like a man' brigade. You wont.

KatharinaRosalie · 27/06/2022 08:39

It's criminal really how we were sold the 'don't touch weights, you will bulk up' and that feminine means be weak and fragile like a butterfly.

WombleOfWimbledon2022 · 26/06/2022 08:13

I remember when I started doing Body Pump at my local gym in my late teens. I was a recovering anorexic and the gym owner took me to one side and told me not to do more than one class a week as otherwise I would bulk up like a male rugby player. That was 20 years ago…I’m so glad that attitudes are changing. Weight training is the best.

WeAreTheHeroes · 25/06/2022 22:17

@withiceplease - add a scoop of protein powder to your yoghurt in the morning and eat bigger portions of protein at lunch and dinner.

Oorwulliesbucket · 25/06/2022 21:28

Amazing, thank you xxx

Work2live · 25/06/2022 21:17

I’ve started a weightlifting support thread over in the weights room, if anyone wants to join!

Here

withiceplease · 25/06/2022 19:50

I'm meant to be eating 100-120g protein a day and it's so hard. I get 25g in at breakfast in yoghurt, 20 or so g lunchtime in tuna, another 20g meat or fish for dinner and a protein shake 22g. This is under 100mg - may get a bit from broccoli and I eat roasted endemame as a snack but it's not easy.
I can't get my head round eating in a surplus at all though

SwanAnn · 25/06/2022 19:44

I'd also be interested in a support thread.

I was going to ask where you get your protein from and that sort of thing.

Work2live · 25/06/2022 19:20

@Oorwulliesbucket definitely! It’d be nice to speak to other women who lift (I don’t know many tbh and I mostly train at home so don’t get to meet people at the gym much).

Would be happy to help out with protein intake/diet etc, but I would honestly recommend finding a reputable trainer to help with diet too.

Oorwulliesbucket · 25/06/2022 19:14

Work2live · 24/06/2022 23:13

For anyone on this thread who is struggling to really see muscle growth, it’s SO important to eat at your maintenance TDEE, or in a small calorie surplus if you want to see real progress.

I weight trained for a couple of years before I got myself an online trainer to keep me accountable and it’s been invaluable! I now eat 110-160g protein a day and my muscle gains are insane. I also use creatine.

@pixie5121 your best bet is to ask a qualified PT to show you the basics - how to perform a squat/deadlift/row/press with proper form. There are some really good video tutorials on YouTube etc too. Or do you have any friends who weight train regularly? I’d love it if one of my friends asked me to help them get into it!

Work2live would you be interested in a support thread, iv been lifting for a couple of years, concentrating on compounds, i know im stronger but i dont look differentvery slow progress and im so confused sbout the diet ect!! I try to eat proein but mfpal just says really low protein intake!!

Iamthehickeymonster · 25/06/2022 16:51

Could we see the photo and comments? Where was this?

Ikeabag · 25/06/2022 16:28

One last thing, for PP talking about protein intake - MacroFactor is a brilliant app for tracking. Not weight loss focused at all unless you want it to be, designed not to encourage disordered eating. One of the guys who part created it is a lifter who has tried a lot of different apps to track, he wanted to lose weight but you can set it to whatever your purposes and level of activity are and it just does the maths for you. Mine is telling me to eat just over 100g protein daily which I really find tricky unless I pay attention, it's very interesting to see how good I feel if I do manage it too.

Ikeabag · 25/06/2022 16:22

Goldfinch - my knees would sublux (partially dislocate) in my sleep. It was extremely painful. I didn't know what was happening. I was in my early 30s. Now I get out of bed in the morning and although I look like standard shit I can swing my legs out and walk around without a 30 minute ease into it. I used to struggle with the stairs first thing, if an early parcel came and I woke and had to go straight down I feared for my life! I think some people think weights reduce mobility but the opposite is true, unless you're training way too hard and not taking steps to adequate recovery. It literally solves so many issues. I remember looking at the weights at school with curiosity and not getting to use them, not once. When teens hit the hornonal stage they should be taught to lift as standard and it should be considered normal to keep doing it. I really wish the govt/NHS would realise how important it is and create some kind of campaign. Unfortunately there's so much other stuff going on and they're so underfunded... ugh. It's what I'd change if I were in power, once all the other dots were joined.

goldfinchonthelawn · 25/06/2022 13:53

Kfjsjdbd · 25/06/2022 10:33

I was a competitive cross fitter pre kids, training 5 - 6 days a week, lots and lots of very heavy weights. I never looked ‘not feminine’. You need to stick to an extremely strict diet and be blessed genetically for that to happen.

I find your OP massively misinformed and disappointing. We should absolutely be focussing on weights. My 70 year old aunt can’t lift herself out of the bath because she lacks the muscle strength. This is what we should be lifting weights to prevent .

This is one reason I love weights. In my mid fifties I was in decline. Getting out of the bath (I was overweight) began to be a bit of a struggle. That's called premature decrepitude in medical terms and we get it because we don't exercise properly, especially upper body. Weights make us strong and energused and have a knock on effect of making us happier. I love feeling strong - it gives me a buzz.

Pedallleur · 25/06/2022 12:34

You wont look like some magazine for ripped women. that takes serious dedication, dieting and poss steroids. Actually lifting heavier weights and doing high impact exercise will reduce the chances of Osteoporosis in later life. Bone density thins a lot as you age. Also a strong core is going to make lifting/carrying so much easier and those abdominal muscles are helping keep you upright.

waterlego · 25/06/2022 12:09

To clarify my previous post: I meant to say that weight training has helped get rid of some of the fat around my middle as well as building muscle on hips, thighs and bum, thus giving me a curvier shape.

waterlego · 25/06/2022 12:07

@NeverDropYourMooncup, your post was fascinating; thank you for taking the time to write it. My history knowledge is poor, so a lot of that was stuff I didn’t know or hadn’t really thought about.

@AquaticSewingMachine
I sometimes think the future depicted in Wall-E, where humans have completely lost the ability and muscle tone to mobilise their own bodies, isn't that far-fetched.

Completely agree, and although I think Wall-E is a great film, it has always disturbed me because I totally see it as prophetic!

Like some of the PPs, I’m a woman who doesn’t have much in the way of natural curves. Small bust, small hips, wide waist, so I just look rectangular 😂 I think I now have a nicer shape thanks to lifting weights. I carry most of my fat round my middle and weight training actually gives me a waist because I’ve built muscle around my hips and bum.

Plus, as so many others have said, it’s essential for our health. My paternal grandma, and 90% of my aunties (of which there were seven) all had osteoporosis so badly, they had quite extreme curvature of the spine by the age of 70 or so and needed walking aids. I hope to mitigate against the worst of any genetic tendency I might have to that same fate.

BordoisAgain · 25/06/2022 11:22

I think a lot of women are seeing what being "soft and feminine" actually does to the female body as you get into old age and don't want to end up with osteoporosis, kyphosis, etc.

AquaticSewingMachine · 25/06/2022 11:12

Absolutely @Wanderingowl . I sometimes think the future depicted in Wall-E, where humans have completely lost the ability and muscle tone to mobilise their own bodies, isn't that far-fetched. Such a bizarre priding of "softness" and perception that the second a woman picks up a 3kg dumbbell, she'll become "bulky" and "mannish".

SwanAnn · 25/06/2022 11:08

Excellent points @Wanderingowl

Fadeout83 · 25/06/2022 11:04

LongLiveThyKing · 25/06/2022 09:51

I started lifting and gaining muscle when it was first popular at the start of the “strong not skinny” movement four/three years ago whilst recovering from anorexia. I loved how I looked: abs, muscular thighs, arms, toner booty etc and I was dating fitness model men and strong men as they appreciated the effort my body took. I then met my current DP who disliked muscular woman and asked me to stop training. I am glad he did as I look back at those pictures of me now and think I looked too manly and just generally not as attractive as now. However, I do miss feeling powerful and being able to run miles and miles without feeling it.

You miss being healthy and strong. This doesn’t surprise me. I hope you realise that this man is toxic to your life and find the strength to leave and be your best self for yourself.

AquaticSewingMachine · 25/06/2022 11:01

I am also really disturbed by @LongLiveThyKing 's "D"P, and giving him some serious fucking side-eye.

You don't ask someone to change their body for you. You just don't. And you really really don't ask someone to stop doing something they enjoy and is beneficial for their health to make them look more to your taste.

Wanderingowl · 25/06/2022 11:00

Over 50% of women of European and Asian descent will develop osteopenia post menopause. Over 50%! Ie, most of us. Of those 40% (more than 1 in 5 of all ethnic European and Asian women) will go on to develop full osteoporosis. Do you really think that the majority of us are meant to spend the latter half of our lives with our bones not fully able to support out bodies? I don't. We are meant to be stronger than we (collectively) currently are. We are meant to have our bodies' natural muscularity. We actually need to have it in order to make the latter half of our lives healthy.

But misogyny and classism lead to 'femininity' being defined by our softness. Only peasant women had muscles, proper ladies were soft and delicate. We aren't male, we're not meant to look like men but strong healthy muscles aren't exclusively male. The idea that they are male is false. Women are meant to have strong healthy muscles too. They don't take away our natural curves, in fact the body type that builds muscle most easily is mesomorphic, which in women is a natural hourglass.

Some online fitness influencers have clearly cut their body fat lower than is healthy for a woman. I suspect that many of those women cut heavily in the days before filming, film a months worth of content and then go back to better eating patterns and look much less defined in their normal lives. I don't think this is a particularly healthy way to live as I suspect the cutting is too extreme. But I do know that allowing ourselves to feel hunger while keeping out bodies as strong as we can, by exercising for both functional strength and hypertrophy. And having a strong focus on our cardiovascular systems, especially for endurance, is the absolute number one way to reduce our mitochondrial age. Allowing us the most potential for long, healthy lives.

SwanAnn · 25/06/2022 10:48

And lots of male and female ballet dancers lift weights. There are variety of weights and weight machines in the gyms at ballet schools.

SwanAnn · 25/06/2022 10:47

I agree it is tragic @CloseYourEyesAndSee

I do lots of sport and exercise, running, yoga, ballet, etc, but weights have made the biggest difference for me and helped in those areas. Even my stamina.

After 40, I believe, it's supposed to be especially beneficial to lift weights of some description. Someone with more knowledge will be able to explain why, but something partly to do with muscle loss.

I'm slim but have defined arm and shoulder muscles, which I'm rather pleased about. I think proper weightlifters might scoff that my dumbbells are only 2kg each and my kettlebell doesn't weigh much more combined, but I plan to improve, expand and increase as I'm still relatively new to weights.