Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that doctors in the UK/EU are stigny with benzos/opioids?

210 replies

janef001 · 24/06/2022 11:04

I understand how addictive these drugs can be but I think the pendulum is swung too far on the other side. I know a woman who had to have a painful root canal and wisdom tooth extraction. She wasn't given any strong post-operative painkillers but instead told to take panadol . OTC Codeine and tramadol never worked for her as she was deficient in the liver enzyme that metabolises them. She ended up having to get a friend from America bring her Vicodin.

I've heard the same things with benzos. Many GP's and psychiatrists just refuse to hand them out and instead put patients on SSRI after SSRI even when they say that they don't work.

OP posts:
Dobbysgotthesocks · 25/06/2022 15:45

I've been on morphine on and off for over five years. Never had withdrawals never had any cravings for it. I take it when I absolutely have to at the point I can't cope without it due to the pain I'm in.
I usually take half the prescribed dose and always try to manage my pain in other ways. Exercise, hot packs, paracetamol, naproxen and then finally morphine.

I cannot take codeine anymore gives me a terrible terrible headache about 50 minutes after taking it and lasts several days. Tramadol gives me restless leg.

MsOllie · 25/06/2022 15:20

3weeksuntilwine · 25/06/2022 15:18

@Fitterbyfifty it’s ok to disagree with me.

The issue is even when take as prescribed, benzos are addictive and can be dangerous.

I never said ‘deal with it’. I said ‘deal with their anxiety by other approaches.. ie anxiety management’.

Not sure how me advising management plans based on NICE guidance for patients with anxiety is me being unsympathetic.

I don’t need to justify myself but in my practice of 4 GPs, many patients choose to consult with me if they have anxiety/depression.
I give my patients informed, guidance driven advice and support. Benzos just don’t feature in 2022.

Is there a reason why someone wouldn't find them addictive? I'm a redhead Grin but my tolerance to painkillers/codeine/diazepam is ridiculous. Same with antihistamines, I can take 4 a day (prescribed) and not even sleepy

3weeksuntilwine · 25/06/2022 15:18

@Fitterbyfifty it’s ok to disagree with me.

The issue is even when take as prescribed, benzos are addictive and can be dangerous.

I never said ‘deal with it’. I said ‘deal with their anxiety by other approaches.. ie anxiety management’.

Not sure how me advising management plans based on NICE guidance for patients with anxiety is me being unsympathetic.

I don’t need to justify myself but in my practice of 4 GPs, many patients choose to consult with me if they have anxiety/depression.
I give my patients informed, guidance driven advice and support. Benzos just don’t feature in 2022.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 25/06/2022 13:30

Fitterbyfifty · 25/06/2022 10:17

@3weeksuntilwine I disagree. I have tried various expensive courses and they haven't worked. My GP gave me some diazepam for flying, I took it as directed and was able to keep my job as a result. Surely any medicine can be used to overdose or use incorrectly? Do you never prescribe anything?

The issue with drugs like diazepam is that even taking it as directed can result in severe addiction.

It's not as easy as telling people to just follow the instructions.

ZealAndArdour · 25/06/2022 13:11

Hoardasurass · 25/06/2022 10:20

@3weeksuntilwine sorry if this is a bit cheeky but as a dr what would you suggest that someone who has a severe phobia about a particular medical procedure (as in panic attacks just at the mention of said procedure) that they really need do ie is there something that they can take to get them into the hospital that wouldn't interact with the general anaesthetic? Am asking for a relative who cant/won't discuss with a dr and won't ingage with a treatment plan and I'm wondering if I'm maybe being harsh by saying talk to your dr

This is for the operating surgeon and anaesthetist to manage and plan for, not the patients own GP.

FishcakesWithTooMuchCoriander · 25/06/2022 13:09

MrsTerryPratchett · 25/06/2022 02:53

People do not get addicted if they are using them as directed and make sure to taper down.

Bless you. When you talk to addicts about what they felt when they first tried their drug of choice, the answers are things like 'coming home', 'a warm bath', 'safe and blissful'. One pill.

And I think I can safely say if they handed out valium like they did in the States, I would be addicted. I had it for flying. I bloody LOVED it. Like really really loved it. Wanted more. My doctor would ask how many flights, want to see tickets and only give me one for each flight. Thank fuck. Stingy bastard.

The ‘people don’t get addicted if they take them as directed’ is the (truly awful) argument that Purdue Pharma used repeatedly to pretend that their drug (OxyContin) wasn’t the problem, addicts were. But the (very clear) evidence was that people taking them exactly as directed did become addicted. That’s what happens with opioids.

MsOllie · 25/06/2022 12:20

It's weird because I'm addicted to nicotine (have been for years) and am quite well, that personality that tends to get fixated/addicted

Yet I had diazepam for 3 months and came off it cold turkey, no issues. Currently on zopiclone, have some in the drawer and again, don't feel any urge/need and come off it with no issues
Take dihydrocodeine daily but can stop if needed. It's weird! The codeine doesn't really affect me though, I was on 60mg x 4 daily and still working and my friend can't even take one without falling asleep

ticktock19 · 25/06/2022 11:45

MrsTerryPratchett · 25/06/2022 02:48

The problem is this. If you are going to properly manage pain and painkillers you need a LOT of staffing. People need proper check-ins, management, counselling, alternatives and monitoring. We don't have that and so the alternatives are stingy painkillers or mass addictions.

Choose. And if you choose the latter, get trained and carry naloxone.

I completely agree with this, I was finally seen in the chronic pain service clinic this week and the support that was suddenly offered was brilliant. I've been on various forms and amounts of (prescribed) opioid pain relief for 25 years now. I broached the question with my gp about coming off Tramadol / pregabalin / nortriptyline / duloxetine just before the pandemic but was told it was 'working' so why alter what the consultant had prescribed me 10 yrs ago. I read and watched numerous documentaries and DopeSick and came to the conclusion that everything I was currently prescribed I was tolerant to which was my pain levels were increasing again. Sadly, my gp's were not particularly helpful when I requested help in lowering my dose (liquid forms of medicines were too expensive and when I requested alternate pain relief options - muscle relaxants/ Nefopam - I got told no) so I self referred to physio who saw me 6 months later and said they couldn't help either BUT would refer me to the chronic pain team.
I saw the lead nurse this week (15 months after my original referral to physio) and she was fantastic, agreed that everything I was on (aside from duloxetine) wasn't going to be helping much now and we have created a plan to go forward reducing my dependence on the opioids and gabapentinoids too. It will take months, I'm sure I will have a battle to get the liquid Tramadol prescribed due to its cost but I finally feel I have a plan in place.
The nurse said to me that NICE have now ruled out opioids and gabapentinoids being prescribed now for chronic pain as they don't work and the addiction plus side effect problems they cause are huge.
I'm so relieved that I'm now in the system to start coming off them but it's explained to me that it won't be a quick or pleasant process and they'll up my duloxetine to try and manage my anxiety which will most likely raise.
If I'd known this when I was 20 then I would never have started taking them but at that stage all I wanted to do was get back to my life so didn't think twice and if taking tablets enabled me to do that then what was the problem..

torquewench · 25/06/2022 10:34

Does no one else remember the benzo scandal in the late 80s? My first job in a law firm back then and there were literally filing cabinets full of people making claims because they'd become addicted to benzodiazepam. This could partly explain the reluctance to prescribe.

Hoardasurass · 25/06/2022 10:20

@3weeksuntilwine sorry if this is a bit cheeky but as a dr what would you suggest that someone who has a severe phobia about a particular medical procedure (as in panic attacks just at the mention of said procedure) that they really need do ie is there something that they can take to get them into the hospital that wouldn't interact with the general anaesthetic? Am asking for a relative who cant/won't discuss with a dr and won't ingage with a treatment plan and I'm wondering if I'm maybe being harsh by saying talk to your dr

Fitterbyfifty · 25/06/2022 10:19

Also it sounds like you are one of those doctors who really don't understand or want to understand anxiety tbh! Don't you think that if it were so easy to just "deal with it" most sufferers wouldn't do that anyway?

Fitterbyfifty · 25/06/2022 10:17

@3weeksuntilwine I disagree. I have tried various expensive courses and they haven't worked. My GP gave me some diazepam for flying, I took it as directed and was able to keep my job as a result. Surely any medicine can be used to overdose or use incorrectly? Do you never prescribe anything?

ChagSameachDoreen · 25/06/2022 09:02

I had to beg for oromorph after my c section. Aspirin just wasn't cutting it. Funny that, since it's abdominal surgery cutting through seven layers of tissue!

3weeksuntilwine · 25/06/2022 08:15

The whole ‘diazepam for a flight’ request really annoys me as a GP on so many levels.

  1. Getting a flight is a lifestyle decision. If you’re anxious, perhaps deal with this anxiety before booking. There are lots of private anxiety surrounding flying courses you can book
  2. it is my name on that prescription. If you take too many, become unwell and cause the flight to have to divert, the airline could come after me
Ive been on a flight when a passenger took several valium and a couple of vodka chasers. He stopped breathing. It was scary (he was ok in the end) but the pilot was informed and plans were made to divert.

It’s not really an NHS problem imo. In current climes, we really need to be focussing our time and resources on where it is needed, and I don’t think prescribing Valium for flights is one of these things.
I very occasionally give a very short course of diazepam for acute severe back pain or for patients who have had a significant trauma (bereavement etc) with the caveat that they’re addictive, short term use only, won’t be able to give more. Occasionally, you do get repeat requests for more within days of initial prescription, it really is a very addictive drug and coming off them after long term use is an absolute nightmare.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 25/06/2022 07:58

Candleabra · 25/06/2022 07:46

I agree with others about alcohol. And I think it weakens the “won’t prescribe Valium for fear of flying as it might make you drowsy” argument. If so, ban all alcohol on flights.

I suppose it's because alcohol isn't a prescription drug, so if anything bad happens because someone drinks on board - it can't be traced back to a GP.

Whereas if someone takes prescription drugs on a flight and something goes wrong, the GP could end up taking the blame?

The main reason alcohol is sold on flights is that you're a captive audience and they make a lot of money out of it, I suspect 🤷🏻‍♀️

Candleabra · 25/06/2022 07:46

I agree with others about alcohol. And I think it weakens the “won’t prescribe Valium for fear of flying as it might make you drowsy” argument. If so, ban all alcohol on flights.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 25/06/2022 07:35

SlowHorses · 25/06/2022 07:33

@coffeecupsandfairylights

To be fair lots of drugs on the market - including aspirin - likely wouldn’t get past the FDA today.

I agree.

I just think the comparisons are interesting. People are posting saying these drugs are so dangerous and so addictive - yet I wonder how many of them drink alcohol most days?

I'm not saying benzos etc. should be more freely available by any means, I just think it's an interesting conversation to have.

SlowHorses · 25/06/2022 07:33

@coffeecupsandfairylights

To be fair lots of drugs on the market - including aspirin - likely wouldn’t get past the FDA today.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 25/06/2022 07:28

It's interesting to see so many comments comparing drug addiction to alcohol addiction.

A lot of my relatives are in the medical profession and they've pretty much all said that if alcohol was invented today, then it would never be approved for general sale the way it is at the moment.

It's one of hell of a dangerous drug but it's so normalised that banning it now would be impossible.

Funkyblues101 · 25/06/2022 05:57

frenchfarmhpuse · 24/06/2022 11:38

The culture is to withhold anything that people want and make them feel pathetically grateful for their woeful treatment. So sad. Nowhere else on earth are doctors revered as gods. They are often not even that good.

Doctors are respected all around the globe. Our health is ultimately all we have. Opioid addictions are incredibly easy to fall into and incredibly difficult to fall out of.

kateandme · 25/06/2022 05:18

MrsTerryPratchett · 25/06/2022 02:53

People do not get addicted if they are using them as directed and make sure to taper down.

Bless you. When you talk to addicts about what they felt when they first tried their drug of choice, the answers are things like 'coming home', 'a warm bath', 'safe and blissful'. One pill.

And I think I can safely say if they handed out valium like they did in the States, I would be addicted. I had it for flying. I bloody LOVED it. Like really really loved it. Wanted more. My doctor would ask how many flights, want to see tickets and only give me one for each flight. Thank fuck. Stingy bastard.

Haha and this is why doctors don't give them out.ignorant comments like that.annoying how far we have to go on learning about mental illness,addiction etc.
Haha yes that's exactly how not to get addicted.soooo simple.how Do people get it wrong.

kateandme · 25/06/2022 05:14

I think it's a really hard balancing act.alot of people struggling with addiction.so too mental health.talkinvbtherapy should be available.mote support.social care etc.so medication like this aren't either needed or on their own with agreeing the problem.
They have had to come right down on them.aome people really can't not get addicted.
There have been a few too many deaths too.based on malnourished which often comes with mentally ill and things like eating disorders they can be fatal very very quickly.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 25/06/2022 03:17

This thread has been an interesting read with some posters who really know what they are talking about.

So…slightly off topic, can anyone explain why paracetamol usually, but not always, makes me vomit but ibuprofen, supposedly much harsher on the stomach, doesn’t?

Thank you!

Back to opioids - my mother moved from the UK to California and was on high doses of opioids/opiates for cancer related pain relief. She was terrified of becoming addicted but, as she was terminal, the doctor brushed off her concerns to focus on her quality of life.

I could have made a fortune selling the drugs that were left in her house after she died. But I took them to the fire station instead (as advised by the pharmacist).

MrsTerryPratchett · 25/06/2022 02:53

People do not get addicted if they are using them as directed and make sure to taper down.

Bless you. When you talk to addicts about what they felt when they first tried their drug of choice, the answers are things like 'coming home', 'a warm bath', 'safe and blissful'. One pill.

And I think I can safely say if they handed out valium like they did in the States, I would be addicted. I had it for flying. I bloody LOVED it. Like really really loved it. Wanted more. My doctor would ask how many flights, want to see tickets and only give me one for each flight. Thank fuck. Stingy bastard.

MrsTerryPratchett · 25/06/2022 02:48

The problem is this. If you are going to properly manage pain and painkillers you need a LOT of staffing. People need proper check-ins, management, counselling, alternatives and monitoring. We don't have that and so the alternatives are stingy painkillers or mass addictions.

Choose. And if you choose the latter, get trained and carry naloxone.