Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that doctors in the UK/EU are stigny with benzos/opioids?

210 replies

janef001 · 24/06/2022 11:04

I understand how addictive these drugs can be but I think the pendulum is swung too far on the other side. I know a woman who had to have a painful root canal and wisdom tooth extraction. She wasn't given any strong post-operative painkillers but instead told to take panadol . OTC Codeine and tramadol never worked for her as she was deficient in the liver enzyme that metabolises them. She ended up having to get a friend from America bring her Vicodin.

I've heard the same things with benzos. Many GP's and psychiatrists just refuse to hand them out and instead put patients on SSRI after SSRI even when they say that they don't work.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheSummerPalace · 29/06/2022 21:31

PS - I was eleven, when I vomited at the dentists. It hadn’t occurred to me to be frightened of them, until that experience!

TheSummerPalace · 29/06/2022 17:57

You don't need vicodin for a wisdom tooth extraction, I think sometimes dental pain is more psychosomatic (I don't mean toothaches I'm talking about tooth extraction, root canal etc). I had a root canal and tooth extraction during pregnancy and only had paracetamol and was absolutely fine, I think some people let their fear of the dentist get ahead of them.

You can only talk about your own experience of pain. You may have a high tolerance of pain, when others have a different brain structure and a low tolerance of pain. I have red hair; it’s widely recognised they need 20% more anaesthetic to sedate them and more local anaesthetic. Our experience of pain is different from other people’s, due to our genes!

I have vomited at the dentist’s when the pain from the drill hit me, and that was after the injection. After that I assumed the point of injections was just to take the edge off the pain, so patients didn’t vomit during a filling. I was absolutely astonished to hear a colleague talk about how he hadn’t felt a thing after the injection for a filling! I have not had that pain free experience.

Likewise, I had to tell a consultant anaesthetist that I could feel everything during the general anaesthetic for a procedure done regularly, and it was excruciating! I wanted more next time!

SnowWhitesSM · 29/06/2022 08:35

@motogirl I had dry socket too! Absolute killer! The numbing package they filled it with helped immensely as did that numbing liquid you can buy in a chemist. Painkillers didn't touch it and I was on a shit load of pain killers from my sciatica at the time.

motogirl · 29/06/2022 08:12

I had dry socket following a wisdom tooth extraction, worst pain of my life but no way would I touch opioids. My dd has Valium, it is prescribed in the U.K. where clinically appropriate, this doesn't include taking aeroplanes which are optional leisure activities for 99% of people and there's always an alternative

SnowWhitesSM · 29/06/2022 07:52

Americans get diagnosed more because their insurance only pays when they're diagnosed with something. In england we still try not to put diagnoses on children and YP - BPD is a perfect example of this. If you get diagnosed with BPD you're more likely to act like you've got it, if you don't get diagnosed you are more likely to grow out of it (most people do in their 30s, it's normally a trauma response and we keep medicalising trauma responses and giving them names like BPD partly because of the way the US is).

ADHD medication isn't great. It takes a toll on your heart. It's basically speed! Also, I don't mean this horribly at all, in my job (SW) we see lots of YP diagnosed with ADHD and autism and they don't have it, they have trauma responses. Sometimes trauma can manifest into ADHD symptoms and C-PTSD overlaps a lot with autism traits. From what I can gather in up to date training and in my work we're moving away from diagnosing as it leads to the self fulling prophecy.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 29/06/2022 00:46

janef001 · 28/06/2022 22:52

Interesting responses but I'm still wondering about the difference in attitudes between doctors in the States and here in Europe. Why does it seem so much easier to get drugs of any kind there than it is here?

Take ADHD meds for example. Many doctors here don't believe it even exists in kids and getting a diagnosis and meds as an adult is nearly impossible. There are plenty of stories of Americans going to a physician without any childhood diagnosis and getting prescribed.

Is it simply money making or perhaps taking pills is less stigmatized?

Well, it is and it isn’t.

In recent years, a numbers of states have introduced new laws restricting the prescription of opiates by doctors.

As a result, you may be referred to a pain specialist to deal with long term pain. The doctor who previously prescribed them for is no longer legally able to do so. If a doctor (non-pain specialist) is able to prescribe them, you may be limited to a three day supply unless you have, for example, terminal cancer.

As I said, these are recent changes brought in as a result of the opioid crisis. It was practically wall to wall coverage on the news about 4 years ago in the US.

However, marketing continues. On TV and in magazines, there are advertisements for drugs. Not generics. Actual name brand drugs. And advertising is a little different in that they can name their competitors and do direct comparisons. For example, ‘buy Advil instead of Nurofen because our trials show it relieves pain 5 minutes faster with fewer side effects!’

Marketing is effective. That is why people go to their doctor and say ‘I want a prescription for SuperDrugOfTheDay’. The doctor has a choice. Prescribe it or risk losing the patient (and their money) to a doctor who will. Not all doctors have the skill to gently explain that a) don’t believe all the marketing hype, b) a different and more reliable set of trials not sponsored by the pharmaceutical company show it is less effective or has more side effects, c) they get benefits from the pharmaceutical companies ranging from stress balls and pens to fancy dinners out or even trips to ‘conferences’ in luxury resorts to fulfil their CPD hours and learn about the latest Drug Du Jour.

Reallyreallyborednow · 28/06/2022 23:27

Is it simply money making or perhaps taking pills is less stigmatized?

money. Have you seen ads in the us for medicines? Direct to consumer advertising “ask you doctor about x”.

plus dr’s are private. Don’t prescribe what customer wants, customer goes elsewhere.

it’s one big downside about private medicine, the more they do, whether thats investigations, prescribing, treating, the more they get paid.

Mamai90 · 28/06/2022 23:01

You don't need vicodin for a wisdom tooth extraction, I think sometimes dental pain is more psychosomatic (I don't mean toothaches I'm talking about tooth extraction, root canal etc). I had a root canal and tooth extraction during pregnancy and only had paracetamol and was absolutely fine, I think some people let their fear of the dentist get ahead of them.

But I do actually agree about certainly benzos anyway. It would be nigh on impossible to get them in my surgery. It's so easy to get them on the street now aswell.

IJoinedJustForThisThread · 28/06/2022 23:01

SaggyBlinders · 24/06/2022 11:36

Watch dopesick.

OTC Codeine and tramadol never worked for her as she was deficient in the liver enzyme that metabolises them. She ended up having to get a friend from America bring her Vicodin.

That's interesting because vicodin is hydrocodone and paracetamol, and hydrocodone is metabolised by the same enzyme as codeine (CYP2D6).

Sorry to derail the thread, and admittedly I haven’t RTFT, but would you be able to tell me more about this enzyme please? Tramadol and liquid morphine have absolutely no effect on me, so I don’t take any painkillers. ( it’s not because I am “hard as nails” and I do NOT have a high pain tolerance, it’s just that nothing works). I’d be really interested to know more about why they have no effect on me.

janef001 · 28/06/2022 22:52

Interesting responses but I'm still wondering about the difference in attitudes between doctors in the States and here in Europe. Why does it seem so much easier to get drugs of any kind there than it is here?

Take ADHD meds for example. Many doctors here don't believe it even exists in kids and getting a diagnosis and meds as an adult is nearly impossible. There are plenty of stories of Americans going to a physician without any childhood diagnosis and getting prescribed.

Is it simply money making or perhaps taking pills is less stigmatized?

OP posts:
JumpingPiglets · 28/06/2022 11:34

@janef001 it was all of it. Stories about my father "passing out" at eg parties were numerous. He appeared functional to many people, but it massively slowed his cognitive functioning, and he'd spend a long time at home just not engaging and sitting in silence, as if we were in a foreign film and he didn't have the subtitles.

When he tried to quit it took him years, the better part of half a decade, to get from 30mg to 5mg.

Unfortunately, over the long term, valium made his anxiety worse not better. He smoked heavily to reduce the physical sensation of anxiety ("in his bones") which valium gave. He eventually gave up smoking completely. Unfortunately, though, he died of lung cancer many, many years later. His body was very weakened and one doctor said to me that the years of prescription drugs had done it no favours.

My father became addicted to valium before I was born. You wouldn't have been able to predict in advance that he would become so horribly addicted: future addicts don't walk around with red flags on their foreheads. And if you had met him during his addiction likely you'd never have guessed. Because the true pain of addiction is mostly behind closed doors.

I'm flabbergasted that medical professionals let it go on as long as it did and very, very angry. If they have learnt as a profession not to do prescribe this stuff on request that is only a good thing. Because there really is no way of predicting the outcome in advance and sadly, once sometime becomes addicted/dependent to anything they are often the last person to have any real insight into it.

Reallyreallyborednow · 28/06/2022 08:44

Clobazam is a wonder drug for DD; the most effective and no consultant neurologist has ever appeared to be bothered by the idea of addiction at all. They have been visibly worried about her dying

well yes. The bigger risk is seizures, and benzos are the standard of care.

addiction is not a concern when withholding them means brain damage or death from a seizure. You will not find a dr who won’t prescribe benzo’s in your case.

it’s all back to the old risk:benefit. Pain is awful but won’t kill you while you try other pain control methods to find one that suits. Addiction is the bigger problem, so guidlines are other medications.

TheSummerPalace · 28/06/2022 08:27

There was a massive scandal because millions were prescribed it in the 70s and 80s.

They should never have been prescribed for more than 2 weeks; but was that known at the start? I knew women on valium for years - because they were in bad marriages. Would it have been any better, if those people became alcoholics instead? People have used drugs to numb the pain in their lives for centuries; and I suspect people are self medicating with food now - is getting Type 2 diabetes, cardio-vascular disease, cancer, etc instead any better?

Anyway OP, I find it strange that most doctors are obsessed with addiction; when no consultant neurologist has ever raised it with us, in discussions about benzodiazepines for epilepsy! They are life saving drugs; used by families, paramedics and A & Es as first and second line emergency drugs. If your child were in front of you, having virtually non-stop seizures and possibly about to:

  1. stop breathing
  2. their heart might stop
  3. suffer brain damage and death within a couple of hours
would you be worried about addiction? You are told to give them benzodiazepines hopefully to stop this! If they don’t work, you have to call 999, who might give rectal diazepam on the spot; or the ambulance will take them to A & E for lorazepam as the second line emergency drug! You will be told not to take them to A & E yourself, as if your child stops breathing in the car, there won’t be anything you can do about it!

Clobazam, a benzodiazepine is also prescribed as a regular medication, to improve the quality of life for patients with epilepsy, because they are regarded as having a good safety profile, and are one of the most effective drugs in preventing drop attacks (the most dangerous type of seizure for the injuries they cause); and in preventing all seizure types in the most severe syndromes. People like this will be on three to four drugs, and the side effects of some of the other drugs are more serious. Tolerance is not a significant problem; they work effectively for years for many people. DD has been given clobazam both as a regular medication for years, and as an emergency medication. I’ve weaned her off it, at least three times while they try different combinations of three or four drugs; and with a good weaning schedule, it’s quicker and easier, than weaning off many of the other anti-epileptic drugs - which all take months and cause rebound effects!

It’s in the Nice guideline for Epidiolex (the cannabis drug), that patients must take it with clobazam.

Clobazam is a wonder drug for DD; the most effective and no consultant neurologist has ever appeared to be bothered by the idea of addiction at all. They have been visibly worried about her dying.

janef001 · 28/06/2022 07:54

JumpingPiglets · 27/06/2022 21:36

Valium is horribly, horribly addictive. My father was prescribed it "for two weeks" in 1980. He ended up on 30 mg a day. It took him years to come down to 5mg a day. He was a "functional" - high functioning - addict. He held down a big job. But it had a terrible effect on his life, my mother's life and my life. I can't describe what it is like to live with someone who isn't fully present, but isn't drunk or high. The constant, constant background music of "what is wrong here".

My father wasn't the only one. There was a massive scandal because millions were prescribed it in the 70s and 80s. This is why doctors are so careful with it now. You might be fine after a few weeks and trot back to normal life. Good for you! Unfortunately millions weren't and it is very difficult to predict in advance.

@JumpingPiglets Wow, I've heard those sentiments echoed about benzos in general.

When you say the effect on his life, what is the physical symptoms/withdrawal (seizures, sleeplessness) or the psychological ones (slowed mental state, amnesia)?

OP posts:
sweetkitty · 27/06/2022 23:18

I take dihydrocodeine for chronic pain, I have to take two in the morning to unravel myself, to be able to get up and function properly. I will have two at dinnertime most nights but that’s it no more than four a day max. I can’t take naproxen as it hurts my stomach. They have been life-savers for me.

skybluee · 27/06/2022 23:00

But how is the doctor or anyone to know whether you are the person who will not have a problem, taper down off it and walk away from it or you're the person who will end up with a problem that can end up destroying your life? The effects of addiction can be horrifying. If you read a lot of the US stories, a lot of addiction over there starts with being prescribed opiates for a surgery or injury. A few days can be enough and everyone reacts differently - you don't know until it's too late. That is why doctors are so cautious - the pain of a lifelong addiction outweighs the pain of a lot of other things. Obviously it's different if someone is in a hospice, etc.

Sapphire387 · 27/06/2022 22:32

I agree. There are instances when these drugs are needed. Valium, used very occasionally and judiciously, is a wonder drug for my anxiety. Fwiw, I took it every day for a year when my late DP was terminally ill. I weaned myself off gradually, no problems. Not saying that is everyone's experience, just saying there are circumstances when its usage is appropriate.

JamesBlond · 27/06/2022 22:15

@mmmmmmghturep Ah well in your case, it’s obvious; you need to take diazepam every day in case of sudden domestic contact with escaped reptiles.

😜

maddy68 · 27/06/2022 21:41

My experience living in an EU country is the opposite. Drugs are much stronger and possibly at risk of overdose or addiction

JumpingPiglets · 27/06/2022 21:36

Valium is horribly, horribly addictive. My father was prescribed it "for two weeks" in 1980. He ended up on 30 mg a day. It took him years to come down to 5mg a day. He was a "functional" - high functioning - addict. He held down a big job. But it had a terrible effect on his life, my mother's life and my life. I can't describe what it is like to live with someone who isn't fully present, but isn't drunk or high. The constant, constant background music of "what is wrong here".

My father wasn't the only one. There was a massive scandal because millions were prescribed it in the 70s and 80s. This is why doctors are so careful with it now. You might be fine after a few weeks and trot back to normal life. Good for you! Unfortunately millions weren't and it is very difficult to predict in advance.

mmmmmmghturep · 27/06/2022 20:56

Co codamol gave me terrible pain all over my torso. stomach chest and back. Bananas do the same.

@JamesBlond I have a phobia of snakes so tend to stay away from them. Kind of hard to do that though when the neighbours pet one got into my kitchen..

MsOllie · 27/06/2022 20:30

@Reallyreallyborednow I know some people can't convert codeine and I'm sure there's something about dihydrocodeine can but codeine can't. Maybe.. it's a vague memory!

I have absolutely no issues with addiction but I'm a typical redhead that it takes a LOT to knock me out and I need extra local anaesthetic too

Found it

Genetic differences in the expression of the CYP2D6 enzyme results in differences in the extent to which codeine is metabolised. Patients deficient in or lacking this enzyme cannot convert codeine to morphine and therefore may not obtain adequate analgesic pain relief. Conversely, patients who metabolise codeine very rapidly (ultra-rapid metabolisers) are at increased risk of developing adverse effects of opioid toxicity, even at low doses

Reallyreallyborednow · 27/06/2022 20:26

I can’t tolerate opioids, for example (they make me vomit uncontrollably and have violent nightmares)

me too. I was prescribed co-codamol 30/50 after a severe back injury.

took me a while to realise it was the cc making me throw up and feel so bloody out of it. People thought I’d been drinking.

post section too I think they gave me some sort of opiate during surgery as I the same upchuck response for 24 hours after. That was not fun.

i had a benzo once and bloody hell I’d take that stuff every day if I got chance. Made me calm, i slept so well and the whole world was right.

i do find it interesting on here that there are many phrases popping up that are red flags for addition- it’s the only thing that works for me, the o/p where the milder form of the same drug doesn’t work due to “lacking an enzyme” yet the stronger one does…

being deficient in such an enzyme would mean you don’t break it down, so small amounts have a much bigger effect as it would stay in your system longer.

Natsku · 27/06/2022 20:05

JamesBlond · 27/06/2022 12:35

If I were a prescriber (I’m not), I would want to ask why I should do something risky for me and the patient (prescribe diazepam) for their totally non-essential foreign holiday.

If I had a morbid fear of flying, I just wouldn’t fly. It really isn’t a human right/essential need to flit overseas to relax in another time zone.

If flying was part of my job, surely I would have known that going in and not applied? E.g. I am afraid of spiders, therefore didn’t apply to work in the arachnid section of the local zoo - rather than go ahead with it and ask for benzodiazepines to get me through!

If, after starting a job that entails flying, I developed a phobia, then I would re-consider my job.

It would really not be fair of me to get all huffy and puffy at my GP for following up to date, evidence based current practice and demand they abandon their way of working because I’m stamping my feet. To me, that’s the childish behaviour.

What if they were flying to see family, perhaps a family member's funeral? Would you just say tough luck, won't help you? People don't just fly to go on holiday.

XenoBitch · 27/06/2022 19:59

If I were a prescriber (I’m not), I would want to ask why I should do something risky for me and the patient (prescribe diazepam) for their totally non-essential foreign holiday

Instead of needing a benzo for a flight, how about something like a medical procedure?

Swipe left for the next trending thread