Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Women are now womb carriers

79 replies

Callingoccupants · 24/06/2022 09:47

Women are being attacked, again. A long standing publishing company, Verso Books, has decided women should be referred to as womb carriers. Can it get any worse? Will try and provide a link.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Callingoccupants · 24/06/2022 17:46

LegInLegOut · 24/06/2022 15:17

Do you know, years of women standing up for themselves and their rights as women for women, present and future, is still being held in the grip of the patriarchy as this issue clearly demonstrates.
The jealousy and bitterness of those who demand that words such as woman, women and mother be consigned to the dustbin knows no bounds, and those jealous, bitter people just happen to have been born a male.
Until us women stand together and say enough is enough, we're not putting up with this eradication any longer, then it will continue and not only will it continue, but it will get worse.
In a generation or two, the women of the future will be back to dancing to the tune of man.
Think it can't happen? Take a damned good look at what's happening today.
Women's spaces being taken to include men.
Women's sports being played by men.
Women being referred to in a derogatory manner by being called womb carriers and such like, and it is derogatory as far as I'm concerned.
Is this the world you want for your daughter's and granddaughters? If it is, then carry on participating in this ridiculous notion.
If it's not then make a stand today and challenge it every single time.
If you're pregnant and you're referred to as a pregnant person, challenge it and tell them you're not a pregnant person, you're a pregnant woman.
For the sake of women in the future, challenge it today.

100% this

OP posts:
LegInLegOut · 24/06/2022 15:17

Do you know, years of women standing up for themselves and their rights as women for women, present and future, is still being held in the grip of the patriarchy as this issue clearly demonstrates.
The jealousy and bitterness of those who demand that words such as woman, women and mother be consigned to the dustbin knows no bounds, and those jealous, bitter people just happen to have been born a male.
Until us women stand together and say enough is enough, we're not putting up with this eradication any longer, then it will continue and not only will it continue, but it will get worse.
In a generation or two, the women of the future will be back to dancing to the tune of man.
Think it can't happen? Take a damned good look at what's happening today.
Women's spaces being taken to include men.
Women's sports being played by men.
Women being referred to in a derogatory manner by being called womb carriers and such like, and it is derogatory as far as I'm concerned.
Is this the world you want for your daughter's and granddaughters? If it is, then carry on participating in this ridiculous notion.
If it's not then make a stand today and challenge it every single time.
If you're pregnant and you're referred to as a pregnant person, challenge it and tell them you're not a pregnant person, you're a pregnant woman.
For the sake of women in the future, challenge it today.

Callingoccupants · 24/06/2022 15:14

TheKeatingFive · 24/06/2022 11:10

I can get on board with it actually, so long as the term male becomes obsolete in favour of 'dick possessors'.

😂

OP posts:
Callingoccupants · 24/06/2022 15:09

Immaterialatthispoint · 24/06/2022 11:44

@Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g thanks

@Callingoccupants Bit much to call me ridiculous. I didn’t deny it had happened, I asked to see more info before commenting: you provided a daily Mail link and I simply said I wasn’t clicking that!

Just because it's in the Daily Mail, doesn't mean it hasn't happened. The DM extracted tweets commenting on how disgusted ppl are. I'd say the increasing denigration of women is too important an issue to argue over one of its reported sources.

OP posts:
Penners99 · 24/06/2022 14:40

Woman = adult human with XX chromosomes.

FFS it’s not rocket science.

Brefugee · 24/06/2022 14:25

I am sure that when those women were selected for sterilization they weren't selected on the basis of being a womb-haver but being a woman (and therefore expected to have a womb). Any transman with a womb would presumably have registered themselves as a man and not been sterilized? Who knows.

But the word "woman" can and should be used, especially when it is about something that was done to women based on their sex.

Merryclaire · 24/06/2022 14:12

It’s hard to understand why they felt the word ‘woman’ wasn’t appropriate - presumably to avoid offending non binary people and trans men? PC gone potty.

I’m all for being inclusive but surely the language used has to be appropriate to the vast majority concerned here - ie ‘women’.

While non binary people and trans men are no doubt marginalised members of society, it is madness to change the terminology used for the overwhelmingly huge majority so as not to offend a small minority.

Is it really going to offend them to read an article about ‘women’ that is also relevant to them? I mean, really?!

If I’m wrong and it does, then is it that fecking hard to include the words ‘this advice applies to women and other people with wombs’ as a disclaimer somewhere near the top of the article? Then just carry on as normal. Honestly.

334bu · 24/06/2022 13:54

mobile.twitter.com/UpSticks2/status/1540293322547290115?cxt=

According to the study referenced in the aboveTweet , there is no such thing as men and women, only male and non male.😡

HooverIsAlwaysBroken · 24/06/2022 13:43

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sterilization_of_Native_American_women

this is actually disgusting. It seems that the main way to sterilisation of Native American women was through hysterectomy - i.e removing the womb. Are these people trying to be funny or are they just misogynistic and racist?

UWhatNow · 24/06/2022 13:36

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

WhereYouLeftIt · 24/06/2022 13:35

Immaterialatthispoint · 24/06/2022 09:53

Daily Mail, I’m afraid I’m not clicking that. I’ll find something less based in bullshit to give my click revenue to.

You started from the point of "Yeah, gonna need a link for that before I comment further" then moved to 'Not that link!'. Well if your preferred media source don't/won't carry a story, sometimes you have to go to another to get the details, which you can then use to generate your own searches (hmm, 'Verso Books', let's have a look at their tweets and website then). And maybe ponder why your 'acceptable' newspapers don't/won't carry the story, and whether they really qualify as acceptable.

Anyway, assuming you find Milli Hill acceptable, here's a screenshot she took. (https://twitter.com/cismeucu/status/1540306204668428290)

Women are now womb carriers
Brefugee · 24/06/2022 13:23

Until people educate themselves and realise + accept trans women are women

but that just doesn't cut it. If Transwomen are women, and womb-carriers are women - it doesn't match.

And you can bugger off with "educate yourselves" I get a lot of shit online because i stand up for people with trans identities, and try to use inclusive language and so on. But FFS - the word woman is a word that describes 50% of us very well. If Transwomen want acceptance from women, that is fine by me but don't piss us off by telling us that we should get used to not being called women. That is utter bollocks. Jezus, for this kind of shit, i get crap for saying it's ok by me if there is a TW in the toilet stall next to me. I don't know why i bother. (but i do bother because inclusion is important to me. As is my identity as a woman)

Pyewhacket · 24/06/2022 13:16

onlywhenidream · 24/06/2022 13:02

Do you think transwomen are women ?

What does the word women mean if it includes transwomen?

Let's face it, you only want to do a pregnancy test on the subset of trans-including women that are uterus havers and if you can't use women for that ...

No, I don't. Their fundamental biology is male. Shouting in people's faces and calling them offensive names doesn't change that.

TidyDancer · 24/06/2022 13:14

I'm saw the original tweet and I'm still struggling to understand why anyone, no matter how they identify or believe, thought that was a good idea. The more this crap is stated, the more people it will reach and not in the way the TRAs are hoping. Even the most passive and neutral people are going to see stuff like that and think 'wtf?'

I will not be reduced to being labelled by my body parts. Not now, not ever. Woman is sufficient. I am not a subset of that.

Throckmorton · 24/06/2022 13:11

Carrieonmywaywardsun · 24/06/2022 12:55

Until people educate themselves and realise + accept trans women are women, we're all going to be given these silly names. Women are women, men are men, people are people. It's all very simple but snowflakes still don't understand it

Trans women are trans women. They are not female. Women are adult human females

IstayedForTheFeminism · 24/06/2022 13:09

Maybe when women have a hysterectomy they could be given their womb in a jar that they could carry around with them.

LegInLegOut · 24/06/2022 13:06

Because that's not prejudiced against women who have had an hysterectomy and therefore have no womb to carry!
I'm sick and tired of women being reduced to parts, like we're not even human beings!
Each and every woman who is referred to as such, or referred to as an even more ridiculous pregnant person needs to challenge it as loud as they can every single time without fear of being labelled. Never be afraid to challenge. Never be afraid of being labelled when you challenge. Stand up for WOMEN as a WOMAN.
We are WOMEN, not parts!

HooverIsAlwaysBroken · 24/06/2022 13:05

I am not a womb carrier, this is ridiculous 🤬.

onlywhenidream · 24/06/2022 13:02

Do you think transwomen are women ?

What does the word women mean if it includes transwomen?

Let's face it, you only want to do a pregnancy test on the subset of trans-including women that are uterus havers and if you can't use women for that ...

Boomboom22 · 24/06/2022 13:00

But tw are tw the medical technology does not exist to actually change sex.
Gender is personality.

Carrieonmywaywardsun · 24/06/2022 12:55

Until people educate themselves and realise + accept trans women are women, we're all going to be given these silly names. Women are women, men are men, people are people. It's all very simple but snowflakes still don't understand it

onlywhenidream · 24/06/2022 12:54

Or we could try

Cervix helps defines woman - the word
But it does not define women - the people

Or

The word woman tells you something about the person but not everything

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 24/06/2022 12:53

ginghamstarfish · 24/06/2022 12:34

so let me get this straight, I as an actual woman am now referred to as a 'womb carrier', so the word 'woman' is now reserved for trans identifying males? WTAF?

Yes, our biology doesn't define us obviously, however it is something that we all share, regardless of gender feelings.

Remove anything to do with female biology from the word "woman", and woman now becomes an identity word that belongs to anyone men

Woo woo believers would say it's nothing to do with that, it's to cover all identities that share the same biology, but that's complete BS to be honest, because hardly ever are males referred to as prostate havers, or penis owners, or people with testicles. They still get to be men. The twitter activists would lose their shit if people referred to TW as people with prostates. It would be all how dare we deny their gender identity of woman?!!

Transmen on the other hand, apparently have to be fine and dandy with things like "cervix owner", or "person with a vagina", yep not denying their gender identity at all, just being "inclusive" 🤔

Nope, they know who the women are really. It's the ones whose language is being removed so that men can take it for their own.

Scianel · 24/06/2022 12:39

Can't have it both ways, transphobes. Either your cervix is defining or it isn't

Let me explain this as carefully as I can. Not all women have a cervix, but only women have a cervix.

TheKeatingFive · 24/06/2022 12:36

Perhaps natal men should be known as ejaculators?