Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not forgive this (chicken pox related)

587 replies

JustLyra · 24/06/2022 09:21

My youngest DD is CEV. She has numerous health problems and we’ve had to be very careful her whole life.

That has meant, especially since covid, finding a balance between protecting her, but making sure her siblings don’t live too limited a life. It’s not an easy balance and not one we always get 100% right.

Our policy with other people has always been - please give us a heads up if we’re due to spend time with you and we’ll risk assess it. We never expect other people to cancel their attendance at parties etc, if we don’t feel it’s safe enough for her then we miss out. All we ask is that we’re given the info.

People around us are generally really good. It’s been a bit problematic since the mindset of covid being over has come in, but generally we’ve muddled through ok.

Earlier in the summer one of my other kids, who is 8, was invited to a sleepover for a birthday - just her and the birthday kid. The parent of the birthday kid knows us very well and said there was no coughs, colds or anything in their home the afternoon I dropped DD3 off. Everything seemed fine and dandy.

A few days after the party I got a message saying that the birthday child had chicken pox. Sure as fate DD3 had caught them. DD4 then caught them and it was a horrid time as she ended up spending 6 days in hospital seriously ill.

To me it was one of those things and couldn’t be helped.

Except now it turns out that the birthday child was known to have CP before the party. The birthday mum told another mum because she felt guilty and that mum told her to tell us or she would.

Birthday child felt well with the CP and apparently “really really really wanted DD4 as their sleepover guest” so the parents decided to just not say anything because it “could” have happened that they didn’t know so we had decided to take that risk.

They’ve been apologetic, as in the Dad apologised very briefly, but they seem fixed on “but, if we hadn’t known them you wouldn’t have known” and that, to them, seems to make it ok. Whereas to me it really doesn’t make it ok.

I don’t want anything to do with them again. I don’t trust them and I’m furious that they’d take that risk with someone else’s child, especially in our situation.

and they don’t seem to grasp that even before I had my youngest I’d have been pissed off if someone deliberately hid that because who exposes another child to CP deliberately without their parents ok? What if the Mum was pregnant?

My AIBU is this - the kids met at an activity. During the holidays when it’s off we usually try and organise a few play dates so they don’t lose touch. It’s always them/their DD that asks. Mine is happy to meet up, but has never asked. This summer I’m thinking just not agreeing to any of the meet ups.

If my DD asks id need to re-assess, but I don’t think she will. Id rather just let the friendship fizzle to a weekly thing at their activity as that way it limits contact with the parents.

OP posts:
Alaric72 · 25/06/2022 21:34

Chickenpox. Tell people if anyone has it. End of story. Just ignore them and avoid them until FOREVER.

Redladybirdbaglady · 25/06/2022 21:34

More a sign of your not bothering to read any of the OPs posts...

ZandathePanda · 25/06/2022 21:31

OP like you I have a medically vulnerable child. She is doing exams and I had to come off a year group thread because some posters just don’t understand what a virus could do (fair enough) but when I explained how it could affect her, said they sympathised and then argued we should all just get on with life. How I wish we could.

My Dd wrote to her MP about the fact the official guidance was for exam candidates to not test for covid unless you had a temperature and after a doctor had authorised it. If a doctor told a pupil to test and they tested positive they could go back to exams after 3 days (even if still testing positive). So the risk for Dd was very high in school which is an added stress when doing exams. There were several students (chemo etc) in her position. Too many I expect for everyone to have separate rooms and separate invigilators. She asked why courts had found the government unlawful to send untested old people back to care homes without isolation, yet it was ok for knowingly covid-positive pupils to sit exams next to medically vulnerable pupils, following the official guidance. Her MP sent it to the Department of Health. They never replied.

I know you are talking about the chickenpox virus (which I know kills more children than mumps or measles in this country as we nearly lost Dd who was hospitalised and then needed treatment for CP complications for 6 weeks). But the government (lack of ethical) response to the covid virus and medically vulnerable pupils seems to be very much like these parents.

It is so wearing trying to risk assess and second-guess constantly. So I completely understand your relief at not having to speak to the father again. It’s not worth wasting your energy.

And if the parent who is helping you is still reading, thank you for emphasising with the OPs situation. It makes a big difference.

Diva66 · 25/06/2022 21:31

BMW6 · 24/06/2022 09:26

Frankly I'd be telling them to Fuck Off out of your lives forever.

Completely unforgivable.

This.

ChickenBurgers · 25/06/2022 21:16

I’d be absolutely furious. My eldest brought it home from school, he’s 6 and when our middle and youngest got it he felt awful for passing it on to them as middle was really poorly with it (not as bad as your DD) despite me telling him it wasn’t his fault. My 6yo had more humility over spreading it than these grown adults. Absolutely not unreasonable to have nothing to do with them.

cass5 · 25/06/2022 21:14

I entirely undertand, would be also extremelly upset. The only reason I would be persuaded to keep any contact is if the friendship was very important for DD3 Hope your DD4 is now ok.

WhiskerPatrol · 25/06/2022 21:13

YANBU. This thread also makes me think of this book, which I read recently. Very similar plot!

The Herd

EvergreenForest · 25/06/2022 21:11

@MamanDeChoix just to correct you it's an incubation period of up to 21 days. Spots can form 1-3 weeks after exposure.

Honestly why are some posters grasping at straws to vindicate a couple who by their own admission knowingly exposed OPs family to CP knowing full well what the repercussions could be.

Av0bo55 · 25/06/2022 21:09

That’s awful and so selfish of them!
I can’t believe there’s people like this, when it would surely be so easy to rearrange or ask someone else and be honest about it.
I think yanbu and I don’t blame you for wanting to cut off and avoid them
they have no respect or care for your situation and dd and not worth the friendship for that reason.

JustLyra · 25/06/2022 21:09

MamanDeChoix · 25/06/2022 21:03

How soon after the sleepover did your child show symptoms?

Given there's an incubation period of 21 days, it sounds to me as though she may well have already been incubating and the sleepover is actually neither here nor there in terms of passing on the cp.

Though accept that cp has put your youngest at risk. But this may not be due to the sleepover.

No offence, but me, the parents involved and my DDs medical team are all confident it came from the sleepover.

No idea how it “sounds to you” that it was already incubating when you know nothing about my DD other than she hadn’t been in contact with the child for over a week.

Ive no need to be educated on chicken pox. Funnily enough having gone through what we did, and previous scares, I know how it works

OP posts:
UniversalAunt · 25/06/2022 21:07

@Eek3under3 I am sorry to hear of your loss. Flowers

Scirocco · 25/06/2022 21:06

Wow, @JustLyra those parents were horrendously selfish and I admire your restraint in how you're managing the situation. You're definitely NOT unreasonable at all - what they did would have been a crappy thing for them to do if all your children were entirely healthy; it's unforgivable for them to have done it knowing that they were jeopardising the health of a clinically vulnerable child.

MamanDeChoix · 25/06/2022 21:03

JustLyra · 24/06/2022 09:57

So you are saying the birthday child actually had chicken pox on the day of her birthday party and the party went ahead as a sleepover no less without giving anyone the choice to expose their kids/families? That is insane. Chicken pox can kill healthy kids without thinking about your sick kid.

Exactly this. They had 3 children (plus family) round in the afternoon for a little party, then DD stayed for a sleepover.

They knew the child had CP the day before.

And at that point hadn’t been in contact with my child for over a week so no “well they were sat next to each other in school all week so we thought it was ok” type thing (which still would have been wrong, but is a mindset lots have with covid).

How soon after the sleepover did your child show symptoms?

Given there's an incubation period of 21 days, it sounds to me as though she may well have already been incubating and the sleepover is actually neither here nor there in terms of passing on the cp.

Though accept that cp has put your youngest at risk. But this may not be due to the sleepover.

Redladybirdbaglady · 25/06/2022 20:58

bluesky45 · 24/06/2022 13:46

It does sound bad. The thing with chickenpox though is that it's contagious before you have spots so every child your kids come into contact with could be about to have chickenpox and they wouldn't know. My kids have both recently had it and in the 2 days beforehand went to a birthday party and saw a newborn which obviously we wouldn't have done either with chickenpox. So I'm not sure how you are supposed to keep your little one safe in the case of these illnesses that are contagious before showing symptoms, very difficult for you all, especially your older children.

And if that was the case, OP wouldn't be on here as she already said she felt like it was just one of those things until she found out it was deliberate.

Knowing that there is a risk of catching it anyway does not in ANY way negate this awful couple's behaviour.

HooverIsAlwaysBroken · 25/06/2022 20:51

Lyra, I am so sorry, those people were awful. I just cannot understand the people here defending them.

my DD had a bad cold last week. Not Covid, no temperature but a tired and with a chesty cough. I kept her home and didn’t let her go to a sleepover she was supposed to have with a couple of girls. Nobody was immunocompromised but I didn’t want to expose other families to our germs. I just don’t get where some people are coming from here.

vipersnest1 · 25/06/2022 20:47

@JustLyra, dear God, I can't believe how ignorant some of the posters here are.
I have direct experience of a DC who became very unwell with a disease despite being vaccinated against it - in their case it was measles. (They actually went on to have an autoimmune condition which they are in remission from, but have gone on to develop another.)
I have to say some people are remarkably ignorant - I encountered this when asking to work from home during lockdowns - I wasn't CEV, but both of my DC and my DM are. I just couldn't risk exposing them to the virus.
To get back to your post, I too would be beyond furious. What happened was totally unnecessary and incredibly thoughtless.

Rabidturnip · 25/06/2022 20:46

YANBU. Years ago a “friend” sent her child to my DD’s birthday party knowing he had had spots appear that morning. Neither parent mentioned anything to me prior to the party. The mum in particular knew my CEV Mum would be there. Six kids from the party ended up catching CP. I was furious and have had nothing to do with them since. It still pisses me off to this day when I think about it.

carchi · 25/06/2022 20:40

They are irresponsible, selfish and unable to grasp how dangerous their actions were. You don't need people like that in your family's life.

VaccineSticker · 25/06/2022 20:40

Lyra, hope your vulnerable child stays clear of illnesses . I feel for you and trust me not everyone is selfish and ignorant like these so called friends. X

JustLyra · 25/06/2022 20:36

Lol I'm quite tempted to ask why you haven't vaccinated your kids just to see if I can give you an aneurysm.

well tbh @byebyeyaya I’m just lazy and couldn’t be arsed…

(I’m actually wondering how many people will actually read that post of mine and miss all the other ones now)

OP posts:
Nocutenamesleft · 25/06/2022 20:35

I’m the same

any illness from a cold to a sickness bug could easily kill me

im the same in that I access the risk. However I’ve learnt to live with it. People are constantly selfish and send their kids to school sick for example. So badly that I had to take my kids out of school because people kept sending children in with sickness bugs and I have spent a huge majority of time in ICU

byebyeyaya · 25/06/2022 20:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

VaccineSticker · 25/06/2022 20:29

MiniPiccolo · 25/06/2022 20:01

Because if we start a childhood vaccination programme for it then we will end up with a wave of very seriously unwell newborns, damaged fetuses and unvaccinated adults in 20 years time, ffs.

Chickenpox is not harmful or dangerous to the majority of young children. And they then carry that immunity throughout life and in the community creating a free and effective herd immunity.

Give your head a wobble ffs and stop spouting rubbish you clearly don't understand. There is a US vaccination schedule because herd immunity in the US was naturally low/poor.

Simply Not true and stop stating info without any reliable medical source to back it up. Many countries do it and it works. The reason why the nhs doesn’t do it is because it’s not cost effective, I personally know two children with no underlying health conditions who ended up in hospital, one needed surgery on the nhs because of her horrendous facial scarring.
Yes generally it’s a mild disease but for some it isn’t especially the vulnerable. I grew up in a country where there were hardly any CP cases because CP vax is part of the vax program.
ps your swear words are insulting, you are an adult so behave like one and just because you are anonymous on a forum doesn’t mean you can insult people.

MumInBrussels · 25/06/2022 20:22

MiniPiccolo · 25/06/2022 19:46

One hand yes they should've told you.

Other hand, sorry but your daughter is better catching them younger no matter how CEV. Your children could easily have brought them home too. The incubation period is 2 weeks. If your children developed them before that time frame it likely wasnt from the sleepover anyway. Chicken Pox is absolutely rife and has washed across the country for the past 12 weeks like noones business.

Is there a reason she isn't vaccinated against them?

Ignoring the vaccination point, since you've probably got that by now, are you a medical professional of any kind?

Because I'm not, but even I can imagine circumstances and illnesses where it would absolutely not be better for the OP's daughter to catch chicken pox younger, because it might kill her at any age. And it's not like she gets it once and is immune from then on, because her immune system doesn't work, so she doesn't develop immunity. (Otherwise the vaccine would probably have worked better...)

So there is absolutely no conceivable upside to the OP's daughter catching chickenpox, except that the friend got a sleepover. Doesn't really feel worth it, to me...

WilsonMilson · 25/06/2022 20:19

Some people are just self-centred, stupid or both.

I think it’s awful. I’d cut them out.

Also can’t believe the parent in question would confide in a mutual mum friend, did she expect support for her decision? Idiotic and selfish people with no regards for the consequences of their decisions- I wouldn’t want them in my life.

Swipe left for the next trending thread