Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not forgive this (chicken pox related)

587 replies

JustLyra · 24/06/2022 09:21

My youngest DD is CEV. She has numerous health problems and we’ve had to be very careful her whole life.

That has meant, especially since covid, finding a balance between protecting her, but making sure her siblings don’t live too limited a life. It’s not an easy balance and not one we always get 100% right.

Our policy with other people has always been - please give us a heads up if we’re due to spend time with you and we’ll risk assess it. We never expect other people to cancel their attendance at parties etc, if we don’t feel it’s safe enough for her then we miss out. All we ask is that we’re given the info.

People around us are generally really good. It’s been a bit problematic since the mindset of covid being over has come in, but generally we’ve muddled through ok.

Earlier in the summer one of my other kids, who is 8, was invited to a sleepover for a birthday - just her and the birthday kid. The parent of the birthday kid knows us very well and said there was no coughs, colds or anything in their home the afternoon I dropped DD3 off. Everything seemed fine and dandy.

A few days after the party I got a message saying that the birthday child had chicken pox. Sure as fate DD3 had caught them. DD4 then caught them and it was a horrid time as she ended up spending 6 days in hospital seriously ill.

To me it was one of those things and couldn’t be helped.

Except now it turns out that the birthday child was known to have CP before the party. The birthday mum told another mum because she felt guilty and that mum told her to tell us or she would.

Birthday child felt well with the CP and apparently “really really really wanted DD4 as their sleepover guest” so the parents decided to just not say anything because it “could” have happened that they didn’t know so we had decided to take that risk.

They’ve been apologetic, as in the Dad apologised very briefly, but they seem fixed on “but, if we hadn’t known them you wouldn’t have known” and that, to them, seems to make it ok. Whereas to me it really doesn’t make it ok.

I don’t want anything to do with them again. I don’t trust them and I’m furious that they’d take that risk with someone else’s child, especially in our situation.

and they don’t seem to grasp that even before I had my youngest I’d have been pissed off if someone deliberately hid that because who exposes another child to CP deliberately without their parents ok? What if the Mum was pregnant?

My AIBU is this - the kids met at an activity. During the holidays when it’s off we usually try and organise a few play dates so they don’t lose touch. It’s always them/their DD that asks. Mine is happy to meet up, but has never asked. This summer I’m thinking just not agreeing to any of the meet ups.

If my DD asks id need to re-assess, but I don’t think she will. Id rather just let the friendship fizzle to a weekly thing at their activity as that way it limits contact with the parents.

OP posts:
pastaandpesto · 26/06/2022 08:41

OP, I get it. For all of the posters (and the dad) saying, that a few days earlier they wouldn't have known and the girl still would have been contagious -

Are you saying that if I knocked over and killed your child in a tragic accident, you'd feel the same as if I had pointed my car straight for them and deliberately mown them down? The outcome would be the same, so hey, why make all the fuss?

ZandathePanda · 26/06/2022 08:40

Oh dear god MamanDeChoix what are you on? Chicken pox is most infectious just as the spots are coming out. Like this child had. Even if the daughter attending the party had already unknowingly been exposed (which the parents and medics know they hadn’t), the parents knew their child was infectious. Your point is irrelevant.

Ohthatsexciting · 26/06/2022 08:40

really really really wanted DD4 as their sleepover guest” so the parents decided to just not say anything because it “could” have happened that they didn’t know so we had decided to take that risk.

Absolutely no where do they subscribe to the logic you are outlining here as a possible motivation @MamanDeChoix

user1496146479 · 26/06/2022 08:40

@MamanDeChoix stop bloody excusing their despicable behaviour!

Biscuit
Bovrilly · 26/06/2022 08:40

Fucking hell Maman, why don't you read the OP's posts, you might not make such a tit of yourself.

your other child was most likely already to be catching cp anyway from the prior contact

The OP has repeatedly said they had not seen each other for over a week and that medical professionals who have all the information (unlike you) say that she was infected at this sleepover

likelihood is that they were ignorant, many people are about cp

They were friends, they have looked after DD3 before when DD4 was in hospital, they know how vulnerable DD4 is to infection. The mum has said she is feeling guilty. She is now avoiding the OP. They knew exactly what they were doing but prioritised their DD's party

You want to cut the relationship, what about what your healthy child wants? What about their needs?

Again the OP has addressed this more than once. Her DD likes the activity they do together but is not fussed about seeing the other girl apart from that. So the OP is letting the activity continue and cutting out the extra meet ups.

If you really want to put a healthy child's needs ahead of a vulnerable child's, I guess you could complain on behalf of the girl who hosted the sleepover. She is the one who asks for the extra meet ups that will no longer be happening. For me though, this is way down the priority list when the OP cannot trust that family not to knowingly put her DD's life at risk.

Ohthatsexciting · 26/06/2022 08:38

@MamanDeChoix

but the parents have EXPLICITLY confirmed that they were not using that logic?

MamanDeChoix · 26/06/2022 08:36

JustLyra · 26/06/2022 08:31

Should they be guilt tripped - likelihood is that they were ignorant, many people are about cp and may have assumed the ill rules were regarding cold and covid type issues.

This I will reply to, and only this - they weren’t ignorant.

They openly admitted they knew I would cancel my DDs attendance over chicken pox.

They decided that if they hadn’t been aware their DD had chicken pox my DD would have been at risk so, for them, that made it ok to pretend they hadn’t been aware.

They knew. That’s the whole point of my post.

Maybe they were putting their child's emotional needs first and using the balance of logic regarding the fact that your child has already been in contact within the previous 21 days?

JustLyra · 26/06/2022 08:31

Should they be guilt tripped - likelihood is that they were ignorant, many people are about cp and may have assumed the ill rules were regarding cold and covid type issues.

This I will reply to, and only this - they weren’t ignorant.

They openly admitted they knew I would cancel my DDs attendance over chicken pox.

They decided that if they hadn’t been aware their DD had chicken pox my DD would have been at risk so, for them, that made it ok to pretend they hadn’t been aware.

They knew. That’s the whole point of my post.

OP posts:
HeelsAtDawn · 26/06/2022 08:29

The OP has already explained how she tries to balance the needs of her other children.

As a parent with one CV child and one healthy child I can tell you that the daily (and usually several times a day) of risk assessment, balancing, trying to deal with competing needs is really quite second nature now- yet deeply deeply exhausting.

@MamanDeChoix you are just lecturing a person who knows her situation better than you do and telling her she's clearly not doing it properly. It's uneccessary at best.

JustLyra · 26/06/2022 08:28

@MamanDeChoix I’m not even going to give that nastiness merit by replying to any of it.

Hope you feel better for trying to make someone feel bad.

You’re spouting bollocks so you’ve had no effect on me.

OP posts:
MamanDeChoix · 26/06/2022 08:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

JustLyra · 26/06/2022 08:25

It’s always the same @HeelsAtDawn - someone always thinks they know better when they don’t

Me - who knows all the circumstances - that’s where it was picked up

Medics - who knows all the circumstances - that’s where it was picked up

Party Parents - who know all the circumstances- that’s where it was picked up

MN Poster - who doesn’t because my only point of the thread was the deliberate non disclosure - It’s probably not as I know better

It’s laughable really

OP posts:
HeelsAtDawn · 26/06/2022 08:21

@MamanDeChoix is there any need for that?

JustLyra · 26/06/2022 08:20

the child had had contact in the 7 days before the sleepover.

ive said repeatedly they had no contact for over a week (they’re not at school together and hadn’t seen each other at the weekly activity)

OP posts:
JustLyra · 26/06/2022 08:18

MamanDeChoix · 26/06/2022 08:09

You've decided this, it makes no difference you don't know this as fact.

And the fact that you're so reluctant to state how many days after the child on the sleepover exhibited cp symptoms suggests to me you realise this, but have now dug a hole....

No. I am trying not to be over identifying as I’ve already been identified once.

we know because we know exactly how many people we were all in contact with for the duration.

I’m also not answering stupid questions from people determined to not pick because they think they know better than the people actually involved

OP posts:
MamanDeChoix · 26/06/2022 08:13

EvergreenForest · 25/06/2022 21:11

@MamanDeChoix just to correct you it's an incubation period of up to 21 days. Spots can form 1-3 weeks after exposure.

Honestly why are some posters grasping at straws to vindicate a couple who by their own admission knowingly exposed OPs family to CP knowing full well what the repercussions could be.

Because, as you said, the incubation period was up to 21 days and the child had had contact in the 7 days before the sleepover.

The average incubation period for varicella is 14 to 16 days after exposure to a varicella or a herpes zoster rash, with a range of 10 to 21 days. Now obviously there will be those with earlier points, but this is the norm and fits entirely with the earlier contact.

MamanDeChoix · 26/06/2022 08:09

JustLyra · 25/06/2022 21:09

No offence, but me, the parents involved and my DDs medical team are all confident it came from the sleepover.

No idea how it “sounds to you” that it was already incubating when you know nothing about my DD other than she hadn’t been in contact with the child for over a week.

Ive no need to be educated on chicken pox. Funnily enough having gone through what we did, and previous scares, I know how it works

You've decided this, it makes no difference you don't know this as fact.

And the fact that you're so reluctant to state how many days after the child on the sleepover exhibited cp symptoms suggests to me you realise this, but have now dug a hole....

Sands123 · 26/06/2022 07:40

The number of people making comments about how your child could have gotten this in the community are missing the point. It's absolutely disgusting that these parents intentionally chose to withhold this information from you. I'd be absolutely fuming in your situation and you are totally warranted in cutting them off.

unname · 26/06/2022 06:05

Cancel the check? Sorry!

Deliberately withhold vital information which caused your child to spend time in the hospital seems criminal to me.

WimpoleHat · 26/06/2022 05:25

Don't mean to diminish your anguish but there are still shed loads of us CEV who are disregarded by just about everybody re covid.

As I’ve said upthread, this isn’t the equivalent of these parents not wearing a mask, or having the OP’s child round the day after they’ve been to a pop concert. This is the equivalent of these people testing their own child for Covid, getting a positive result and then deliberately not telling the OP because they knew she had another child who was CEV and so knew that she wouldn’t want her child to go to their child’s party. There is a world of difference….

MindYourHeadDoggy · 26/06/2022 05:06

Weepah · 25/06/2022 18:51

I guess this is is a sign I've been living the States for too long but all I could think was why aren't all these kids vaxxed for CP?

I’d take it as a sign that your literacy and comprehension skills aren’t very good.

Sorry to hear your daughter was so unwell, OP. I would be reeling and not want anything to do with those people again. Their actions were downright stupid.

BeenToldComputerSaysNo · 26/06/2022 04:41

OP, sorry they betrayed your trust and deliberately gambled with your DD's health like this. You are 100% right.

ZFace · 26/06/2022 04:38

Outlookmainlyfair · 24/06/2022 10:04

I’m shocked (at time of writing) that 13% think YABU,

Down to 7% thankfully

JustLyra · 26/06/2022 02:17

stayingpositiveifpossible · 26/06/2022 00:07

I am not sure about this.

Don't mean to diminish your anguish but there are still shed loads of us CEV who are disregarded by just about everybody re covid.

how is this different?

How many times have people tested positive for covid and then deliberately withheld that information from you?

And even if that happens frequently why the fuck would that make it ok?

OP posts:
ElderflowerAccordian · 26/06/2022 02:04

I'd create a massive stinker. Full blown dressing down, in public. If anything it would make a point and hammer home to everyone exactly what you expect from them. If you had known then you could have risk assessed and probably not taken her. Honestly these people sound like idiots who are looking to ease their own guilt.

Swipe left for the next trending thread