Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS and End of Term Grades

36 replies

ButterfliesnWaterfalls · 23/06/2022 21:16

Hi all,

DS (10) is Autistic in Year 5. His concentration level is around 10 minutes. Needs lots of breaks. Doesn’t get 1:1.

Academically, he has improved and progresses every year (thankfully). His teacher emailed today to say he was a few marks off 5EX for Maths.

I feel deflated. I know I shouldn’t. I work hard with him and I know he tried his hardest with his tests but I just feel Maths is the one thing he would get an Expected for and he didn’t.

English - he’s working way below age related as he has no interest and hates writing and reading.

I know if he’s not working at age related now - chances are he won’t do well in Year 6 SATs. What does this mean for GCSEs and future academic career? Will he be able to go to University?

Do children with SEN get to experience uni life? What about work? Will he get employed?

AIBU to be worried. I don’t know how else to help him.

We have always been taught the traditional - get C or above in GCSEs and do A-Levels and go to Uni. But I don’t know what else is out there as an alternative which pays well.

Any ideas as to how I can help him?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
jevoudrais · 25/06/2022 13:32

FWIW, my brother used to tutor GCSE and A Level students for Maths and Physics. He could turn E's into B's. If your son can get some 1 to 1 things like Cs in Maths and English might not be out of reach if he does need them for what he wants to do.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 25/06/2022 13:05

You really do need to be more focused on his EHCP and Y7 now than SATs or GCSEs. Getting the right provision in place will change everything. My dd is autistic and in Y10 and academically very able. She's in a good mainstream and keeping her there and on track was our goal. An autistic friend of hers who was pretty much written off academically is in a fantastic specialist school and he's really picked up academically and should get some qualifications. He might not go to university but he's going to have a decent future.

ThePenOfMyAunt · 25/06/2022 12:54

I would concentrate on on getting his EHCP into good shape for his transition to secondary. If you can afford an independent OT assessment I would get one done. You should have a transition review, usually the first term of Yr6, so it would be good to have the report for then. Even if the LA starts being dramatic about it being included in the EHCP, it will be useful for you to share directly with your secondary preferences, and appeal the EHCP to get the provision sorted.

IME secondary schools are much more accommodating of laptops. My eldest point blank refused to use one though!

DS1 started school with a Statement of SEN, which transferred to an EHCP. He's just finished his GCSEs. He won't have passed many, but it's not the disaster it would have felt when he was Yr5. We've got a really good post-16 package for him, which will be based our his interest. He will gain qualifications without sitting exams. I can see him maybe doing an open university course down the line, or carving out a niche career around his interest.

stayingpositiveifpossible · 25/06/2022 12:39

With any kind of SEN from what I know from friends the parent/carer has to push to get things done. Unfortunately. It will be a bit of a postcode lottery but educational psychologists and SEN specialists sometimes have long waiting lists for assessments - due to funding cuts. I've heard some have saved up and got it done by a private ed psych.

Not sure how things are where you are - postcode wise but here - the SEN/disabilty support is better in further education colleges than it was in schools. Also Universities (look on UCAS) have things that young people can apply for to help them study - and extra grants and I believe have to take a certain quota of SEN young people by law in the interests of equality.

Degree apprenticeships as someone said - may be relevant - too. If you are wanting to - you could ask already at local FE college just for info.

There are also foundation years for uni which I guess will be increasingly popular as many have missed out on so much during covid. Course it does mean there is an extra year of student loan. Usually once they reach further education there are progression pathways that help a lot i.e in the last term of the year they focus very much on aspirations and where they can go next.

DontLookBackInAnger1 · 25/06/2022 12:23

If he has an EHCP then the primary school will be getting funding for him. So they should be providing extra support for him.

If I were you I'd be asking where that support is. They may seem supportive but they're not doing the best by your son if they're taking the money and not investing it into your son (which they legally should be)

ButterfliesnWaterfalls · 25/06/2022 12:20

His review was in Feb. And next one will be in October I think? But I will email the Senco and find out if these changes can be made earlier and in place for September.

OP posts:
ButterfliesnWaterfalls · 25/06/2022 12:19

@MargaretThursday This is good to hear, I might push for him having a laptop for his work. I know he enjoys typing. I don’t mind buying the laptop for him, if it helps him.

He absolutely hates writing. And even though his handwriting is not age related, he has been trying to write in cursive so he can get the pen licence. Most of the other students in his class have one and write with a pen but he writes with a pencil.

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 25/06/2022 12:17

When is his EHCP up for review? It sounds like it needs rewriting with extra provisions (and perhaps money for a 1-1 in English? Certainly a laptop).

ButterfliesnWaterfalls · 25/06/2022 12:15

Sirzy · 24/06/2022 17:35

If a laptop will help you think then get it written into his ehcp at next review. Does he have an OT?

No, he doesn’t have an OT. He doesn’t have any other support.

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 24/06/2022 20:01

ButterfliesnWaterfalls · 24/06/2022 17:11

Thanks for the messages. It’s really helped. I know he is doing amazing and has come so far and he is only 10!

Thanks for the personal stories, they’ve made me feel loads better.

He does have an EHCP - and I’m looking at secondary options and where to send him.

When/how does ADHD get diagnosed? I might email his teacher and find out. Also - I did mention a laptop for English but they don’t use that for him, or if they do, it’s not consistent.

You may find secondary better for looking at getting a laptop than primary.

What they did for ds, was I requested from the SEN department that he was assessed for it, after it was mentioned at his ADHD assessment that he might benefit from it.
They did an assessment which involved him doing some handwriting and some typing and they compared answers. He scored roughly bottom 25% for handwriting for his age and top 5% for typing for his age. They said it was unusual to have such a huge discrepancy, but that meant immediately he was put into the needing to use it for exams.

Then he did a second mock and went up a number of grades, but also did a history exam in lessons and scored badly enough he was put down for an extra support session.
So I again contacted the SEN department and explained this and requested he could use it during lessons because this "wasn't fair". I offered to get him a computer (the school should provide if they decide they need one, but I felt quite strongly that as we could get him a second hand one for a not too bad price that would do, then we should leave the school ones, which I know they're always short of, for those who really can't get one)
They agreed straight away, and all we had to do was get the laptop and then take it into school so they could set it up on the private WiFi.

It was actually quite easy in the end and has made a huge difference, not just to his ability but also mentally, and how he feels about school.
He apparently had a bit of hassle in one lesson (when he'd gone up a number of grades) and some of the form were complaining it wasn't fair. He offered to "hug them and they could see if they caught ASD from him" which apparently has totally shut them up. 🤣

Sirzy · 24/06/2022 17:35

If a laptop will help you think then get it written into his ehcp at next review. Does he have an OT?

Unbored · 24/06/2022 17:31

@ButterfliesnWaterfalls my DS (13) needs to use a laptop, he has so much to say and will happily write and write (he’s only been happy to write since starting a new school this year as they helped him regain the confidence he lost in himself) but it’s totally illegible to even him.

Keep pushing for the help you know he needs so he can achieve his potential.

ButterfliesnWaterfalls · 24/06/2022 17:11

Thanks for the messages. It’s really helped. I know he is doing amazing and has come so far and he is only 10!

Thanks for the personal stories, they’ve made me feel loads better.

He does have an EHCP - and I’m looking at secondary options and where to send him.

When/how does ADHD get diagnosed? I might email his teacher and find out. Also - I did mention a laptop for English but they don’t use that for him, or if they do, it’s not consistent.

OP posts:
MumofSpud · 24/06/2022 10:29

Why doesn't he have an EHCP?

He is still only little - by focusing on Uni now is not productive- and will lead to stress all round

Uni is not for everybody and can actually hinder your chances if you do the wrong course

As he enters secondary school he will develop different strengths but he should have an EHCP

10HailMarys · 24/06/2022 10:25

Do children with SEN get to experience uni life? What about work? Will he get employed?

Nobody can know this about your child - all children with SEN are different.

I have a friend whose son was probably about where yours is at the same age. He's now in his 20s and he's a pastry chef at a very posh hotel. He didn't go to university and he still struggles with reading and writing. He has a perfectly normal life in every respect.

Elleherd · 24/06/2022 09:35

SATs are not an indication of a child's abilities, they are an indication of how the child is managing to receive a one size fit all type of education from a school, in the circumstances he and they have, and are working in.

He's not meeting NT children's 'milestones' in an NT system, because he's not a NT child. He's doing well to manage in a system that's he's not designed to particularly benefit from.

Fitting the education to the child, often works better than trying to fit the child to the education.

There are many routes in life and the idea that if he doesn't manage x by y time, his future will be irretrievably damaged, or he'll never get on in life, is a myth created by those who benefit from such games.

We ended up home educating. Best thing we ever did, (in terms of Ds academically and socially, and giving him back a childhood) and he went to university, (was never previously on anyone's menu) and on to decent employment.

I'm now a mature student and there's lots of students with SEN's. Some quite honestly are using it to have an extended 'pre adulthood' and allow some basics to 'deepen down,' but that could be said of many of the non SEN students too.

MrsCat1 · 24/06/2022 09:27

Hello. I thought you might like to hear the story of my cousin's son who has autism and is now 22 years old. I can't deny that it has been a huge struggle over the years but he has surpassed all the expectations of the early years. Yesterday he leaned that he had achieved a lli degree (just one mark off a first). That's one very proud young man and one even prouder mum. Smile

FlatWhiteLover · 24/06/2022 09:22

There is nothing wrong with doing a trade, I have a vocational degree but all three of my brothers got a trade and they all earn more than me, plus they never had a massive student loan.

maeveiscurious · 24/06/2022 08:52

As my DC have finished their education now, finding what they are good at is important. High school can develop interests that naturally expand reading and knowledge.

My friends ds struggled through school and is SEN but has found he is an amazing coder and is looking at a career in cyber security.

Tabletable · 24/06/2022 08:35

Have a conversation with the teacher. Many borderline pupils can pushed into Expected by the end of year six as they learn exam technique. Is he working at Expected level within lessons? Expected is not easy to attain as the year five curriculum is so hard.

Hankunamatata · 24/06/2022 08:30

Hi. Have you considering seeing if he has adhd too? I have child with asd who turnd put to have adhd - which we wouldn't have even considered except he has siblings with adhd. We also then looked at dyslexia which turns out he has too so means we took a different approach to reading and writing - word hornet / word wasp books are excellent to work through with him yourself. You can order them online

I would also focus on his successes. Has he improved his maths from last year?

MargaretThursday · 24/06/2022 08:28

Would using a laptop help in English and other wordy subjects?
Ds started using a laptop after school assessment and in one subject he went up 3 grades, simply because he could actually concentrate on what to write rather than just writing.

MumofSpud · 24/06/2022 08:15

At our local colleges - and the courses are national ones, you can enter at different levels - the lowest level being not getting a '4' (a pass) in Maths and English and you will have to retake them
A levels and then Uni is not the only option for a successful career anymore
Apprenticeships are the way to go - when I was at school (a million years ago) apprenticeships were looked down on but now students (and parents) see the advantages
Unfortunately that means there is a lot of competition for them!

TeenPlusCat · 24/06/2022 07:58

On average someone not achieving 100 in y6 SATs will not be on track to pass the English & Maths GCSEs. That doesn't mean an individual can't though.

The alternatives to A levels is vocational BTECs or straight into an apprenticeship. BTECs can be done at Level 3 (A level equivalent) or Level 2 (GCSE equivalent) or Level 1 (lower than GCSE). You can work up the levels whilst resitting English & Maths GCSEs, or taking them as functional skills.

University isn't for everyone, but you absolutely can go with a L3 BTEC.

I agree don't write him off. However I would make sure you give a balanced message over the next few years about the options. Don't make him feel he has failed if he doesn't/can't do the A level -> Uni route.

We have learned that the world doesn't end even if you get zero GCSE passes first time round.

Sirzy · 24/06/2022 07:51

Focus on now. With any child you can’t know what is going to happen in the future even less so with a child with additional needs.

but for a bit of reassurance -

year 1 Ds couldn’t access any of the curriculum

year 2 he clicked for some basic maths and finally mastered reading basics.

year 5 he is working towards in everything still struggled with reading.

he is now coming to the end of year 7, he is in set 2 across the board I got a call from his English teacher last week to say how well he is doing and how impressed she is with his reading.

childeen develop at their own rate not on a government approved timetable! For us getting the right support through his ehcp was the game changer