Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Good fences make good neighbours.

38 replies

Windypants21 · 23/06/2022 20:31

I would like to raise a small portion of the fence between my neighbour and I, but my neighbour is telling me what i can and cannot do. I want to get a dog and she is telling me what height I can build it up to and that I have to have her approval as such. She rents the house out to a man but she is a friend of his and calls up to see him regularly.

To picture it .....down the left side of my property, from the front low level wall I have a 6 foot high hedge which is about 10 metres long but stops just before it gets in line with the front of the house. It then drops to a short 'fence' that is about 1/2 metre high which is made up of 2 wood posts and a couple of pieces of wood across. This then adjoins a 6 foot high wooden plank fence that continues to the end of the house on my side and the beginning of their garage at the end of their drive on their side. The fence does continue on further back but it is a fence between their garage and my garden. The fence carries on round the circumference of my garden.
My understanding is that the builder erected the fence between the houses around 1997 when they were built. So I'm not sure who 'owns ' them. The nice bit of the fence is facing my side.
My attempt at securing my garden for when I get a dog and getting more privacy by building this up in line with the rest of the fence has had my neighbour over at my door 3 times in the last 5 days. I thought we had come to an agreement the other day ( i agreed a lower fence ) but she was back today at my door practically wanting architectural 'plans' for the fence. Omg

What are the rules for fences, ownership etc. Can someone tell me please. Not so I can bulldoze her just so that I know what I'm talking about when she comes back....this weekend apparently. She has told me her lodger isn't well and when he passes away she will likely move into this house. If she is like this a 10 foot fence won't be high enough to keep her out never mind keep the dog in ! Help please.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheHumanExperience · 24/06/2022 22:51

@Windypants21 I had that problem. The fence to my right is my neighbours chain link fence, that she didn't want to change. She liked the view across our gardens as it made hers feel bigger. All my neighbours have 6f fences as per our councils guidelines. No permission is required, no informing the neighbour is required.

The important note: I put a fence right up against the existing fence, on my land. She came out shouting abuse, that I was trying to take away her light and make her garden a prison. Funny thing is the sun rises at the bottom of her garden, and goes up and over her house in the afternoon. The fence does nothing to block her light. Wouldn't matter if it did.

By the sound of it, this boundary fence may belong to the neighbour. So you can do what I did and ignore your neighbour as I do. I too have a dog, who escaped into their garden twice. I couldn't risk that again, their garden is wild.

Stop answering the door, when you're not expecting visitors. You do not have to engage. I act as if they don't exist as they are just very unpleasant people. Never had a problem with neighbours in y whole life before this.

Littlebirdyouaresosweet · 24/06/2022 20:12

Surely Fenton not Jackson?.

Sarah13xx · 24/06/2022 19:44

Hire an absolute psychopath of a dog for half an hour so she thinks you’ve went and got one (I can lend you mine if need be), go out shouting his name, we’ll call him Jackson.

Jackson leaps over this tiny fence into your neighbours garden. She will very quickly want the fence raised 🙃

Windypants21 · 24/06/2022 19:35

The original fence has been restored. If h&s man comes Sunday, as promised, there will be zip all to see ...or photograph. Solicitor says neither of us own it outright. So I'll just do my own thing in my garden. Thanks for all the suggestions , links, feedback and tellings off, helped enormously.

OP posts:
TheNoodlesIncident · 24/06/2022 16:17

It doesn't matter who owns the fence. Get your own up on your side to the height you require and ignore NDN, she's had way too much input on this already. I would recommend you get netting or mesh or similar on your side of the hedge to ensure neither your nor her dog can get through (or make) any gaps.

She sounds a total pain in the arse who hasn't got enough to do. I'd tell her I needed to make the garden secure as required by law and that I wouldn't engage with her any further on it. Channel Joyce Grenfell in "That will DO, Dorothy*!" ringing tones if need be.

The cheek of some people!

*Or whatever her name is

RandomMess · 24/06/2022 16:09

Such cute dogs!!!

Install a new fence in your boundary. She ought be reversing onto her drive anyway, has she not read the Highway Code 😉

Delectable · 24/06/2022 15:58

Get on the Land Registry site and request your title plan. Look out for the Ts on the fence. The inward facing Ts show which fence is yours and where there's none it's likely joint.

OhmygodDont · 24/06/2022 14:43

Just build your fence inside the boundary. Fuck her.

if you was suddenly putting up a 6ft fence where she would be trying to manoeuvre to join the highway I would see her point as that is something taken into consideration when granting permission for dropped kerbs.

Windypants21 · 24/06/2022 14:20

SwedishEdith · 24/06/2022 12:38

I can't really understand wade through the description but is your neighbour wanting a lower fence? Why? Who are these people who like less privacy in their back gardens?

She wants it low because she claims she can see the oncoming traffic ....apparently .. while ignoring the fact that after the gap in the hedge there is a 10 foot high, 10 metre length hedge, before she reaches her gate.

The gap looks directly across my front door and garden toward the far bend in the road. About 50 yards away. She has to reverse out of her drive and claims she won't see the traffic coming. So unless she is a rally driver, she is still going to have to drive slowly out her gate to get onto the road.

I have amended my wants to accommodate this claim but she has now come back twice since still unhappy. The h&s man is her friend. My brother is fixing it so it goes back to its original state and so that in theory should end the debate but I can just imagine what the next knock on my door will present.

I have been flexible, listened to her, amended my initial plans but her, 3 visits to my door, behaviour and multiple questions, (most of which I haven't answered, or simply returned the query as absurd and unreasonable), means I just don't want to engage any longer.

OP posts:
Cherrysoup · 24/06/2022 13:12

I echo the stop talking to her, it's none of her business. Just put a fence on the inside so it doesn't affect her. 6 feet all the way. My small springer easily jumped the 5 ft fence between us and the neighbour.

SwedishEdith · 24/06/2022 12:38

I can't really understand wade through the description but is your neighbour wanting a lower fence? Why? Who are these people who like less privacy in their back gardens?

WombatChocolate · 24/06/2022 12:31

You can get the deeds but it’s extremely common for them not to show fence ownership. So, to all those saying you need to check the deed…this might not help that much.

Ask on the other side too if they know which fence they own. Sometimes you can work it out like that.

Otherwise, you are entitled to build a fence on BOTH sides if it’s on your own land. So the question about this fence you’re talking about, is does it go into the ground on your or neightbour’s land? If it’s on theirs, then to get what you want you might need to build another fence immediately next to it, on your own land.

If this turns out to be the only say, I’d try telling neighbour that if they won’t agree to the fence being extended (at your expense) then you will build another fence right behind it which is taller. The impact on them if a taller fence will be the same as if you extend. Ask them if you really need to do that, or if they will reconsider the fence being extended up. Ask them if you can discuss different options - trellis etc, so it’s not so impactful.

If the fence is built on your own land, I would tell neighbour that the deeds don’t identify fence ownership, so whoever’s land it’s built on assumes ownership and because of this, you will be extending the fence. Again, I’d say I was happy to discuss different possibilities but will make the final decision.

Its best if you can come to an agreement as you need to live next door to each other. Try to be a bit flexible yourself over exact height, materials etc, but also don’t be deterred from doing anything if you really want it and just because neighbour is more assertive.

Littlebirdyouaresosweet · 24/06/2022 12:14

Well your chosen pooch does have rotty markings!!
😁

Squills · 24/06/2022 12:08

Sorry just realised H&S guy isn’t her friend.

Squills · 24/06/2022 12:05

I would look at your deeds - you can do so online. if your boundary is shared you’ll have a ‘T’ marked on both sides of the fence. If it has ‘T’ marked on one side only it belongs to the property showing the T mark. Fences can be 2mt high.

Your neighbour sounds unreasonable so, once ownership is established, it would be best to just get on with putting your fence up with no further interaction with her.

As for her H&S friend… well it’s just more evidence of her unreasonableness. If her friend does come taking photos I would take a video of him doing so in case of future ‘developments’.

Windypants21 · 24/06/2022 11:33

Spoke to my onveyancing solicitor informally. The boundary fence is shared ...so not hers or mine in entirety but there should be agreement if any changes are to be made. So I'll put it back as it was and then do my own thing my side. I am sure though that she will take issue with this...as that just seems like the kind of person she is.

OP posts:
PattyMelt · 24/06/2022 08:25

Stop discussing it with her. If you can't figure out who owns the fence have a new one put on your side of the fence up against the old fence and make nice and tall. You're being to nice about it all.

Windypants21 · 24/06/2022 07:41

Requested dog pic.

Good fences make good neighbours.
OP posts:
Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 24/06/2022 00:59

Your welcome! I think land registry is £3 for a download copy of your plot. If you’ve paid off the mortgage - you may have a physical copy of all the paperwork associated with your house. That may elicit more information regarding the boundary/fence.

Windypants21 · 24/06/2022 00:44

Thanks for the link Alphabetti.
As I wasnt sure who owned what, I approached my neighbour first. In conversation it appears she didnt know either. It was she who told me it was the builders of the houses who erected the boundary fences. I thought that if agreed between us then there wouldnt be an issue.
When she objected to what we started, we discussed it, mutually agreed a way forward, only for her to come back days later complaining again, discussed it , agreed a modified version of the previous agreement, but then she returns complaining telling me a h&s man is coming to take pictures. I'll just put it back the way it was and put a fence in front of it if it isnt 'my'fence. But now I'm def going to find out who owns it.

OP posts:
Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 23/06/2022 23:31

www.blbsolicitors.co.uk/blog/boundary-fence-rules-uk/

@Windypants21 Try this linky. Might answer everything. Or at least some of the questions.

picture of ddog required!!

easyday · 23/06/2022 23:24

If it's unclear in the deeds who owns the fence you can always build a second fence on your property.
Generally the ugly side faces the owner, but not always.
Tell her if she is not amenable to the changes you will erect a second fence. There's nothing she can do about it.

Colinthesnail · 23/06/2022 23:17

No, your biggest mistake is not just finding out who owns the fence (given it’s a modern house it’s probably marked on your plans from the legal work done when you bought the house - usually it’ll have a “T” marked on boundaries you own) and then just acting accordingly.

If it’s yours then as long as you obey planning rules around the highway and heights then you certainly don’t need her permission or photos or “health and safety” man. If she owns it then you obviously need to come to an agreement or just put your own up inside boundary line.

I don’t understand how you hoped to have a sensible “upfront and open” conversation with her about it when you don’t even know who it belongs to! I mean if it’s hers then I have every sympathy with why she’s wanting plans and to “dictate”.

NotMushroomInEre · 23/06/2022 23:17

As far as I'm aware, you can have a 6' fence without planning permission, as long as it isn't at the front of the house. I'm not sure if this depends on elevation. So, if your neighbours property is below yours, I don't know if it is a total of 6' from the ground level of their house? IYSWIM. I'd love to know the answer to that though.

Yodaisawally · 23/06/2022 23:00

Windypants21 · 23/06/2022 22:58

My biggest mistake is I'm friendly and try to be upfront and open but this mini person who is literally about half my height is over pushing her tiny little weight around.

But she saw the other side of me today. I wasn't vile but I was no pushover. Ridiculous behaviour.

I was with you until that one op.