Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gushing tributes when someone has died

64 replies

GarethKeenan · 23/06/2022 18:43

The tributes to deceased adults on social media are grating.

They become a saint when they die and people care far more about them when they stop breathing. People who had plenty of bad words to say, definitely held a grudge, made many very questionable life choices while openly judging others for theirs are mistily described as the best of us, pure magic etc. Even by people who actively disliked the deceased and were happy to say so

But, oh- "I can't believe they're gone, life will never be the same." I get that when it's coming from their spouse or kids (those that are close to their parents.) But a great grandson who never met them making a tiktok about how he will be sorting out a balloon release in honour? An ex neighbour who hasn't bothered for years posting live about how the news has hit her like a ton of bricks, they were so close etc. Really? You'll miss them so much will you? I doubt you've thought about them in years.

Why do people have to claim someone was practically Jesus Christ himself and that they had a close and loving relationship, "hole left in my life blah blah," when they hadn't laid eyes on them or spoken in years? And they tag a social media account of the deceased, it all seems to be so more people see it and get more likes and I find it ghoulish. Like a public act of grieving for a round of applause. Some of the tributes are so gushing it's uncomfortable to read them. Aibu to see it as a sort of grubby scramble for the most likes on a death announcement?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NippyWoowoo · 23/06/2022 22:22

@LisaSimpson77 I said it. It wasn't posted by a family member or anything, it was by an old classmate.

Georgeskitchen · 23/06/2022 22:18

@NippyWoowoo I'm a member of a FB group of my old school pupils. A few years back the death of a retired teacher was announced. Everyone gushed about how wonderful this teacher was. I privately messaged my friend and we reminisced about what an absolute arsehole this teacher really was 🤣

MistressoftheDarkSide · 23/06/2022 21:49

@EmmaH2022

Sorry, my snippy comment was aimed at those saying this thread is snippy and mean - spirited ….. I am in agreement with the OP and that the people they are referring to aren’t grieving exactly….. and perhaps just want to insert themselves into drama via the most tenuous of connections…..

I hit peak WTF when a few people asked who the widow was at my DPs wake, because I wasn’t weeping and wailing to the same level as some others….. I was numb, in shock, and quietly trying to dissolve into a vat of vodka…..

LisaSimpson77 · 23/06/2022 21:41

NippyWoowoo · 23/06/2022 21:36

I actually commented on a FB post about an old teacher of mine that died. All 'she was a great' etc, I said my memories of her were that she was a bully and screamed and scared the other children 🙈

I knew a couple of the people commenting their commiserations as well, funny because we'd all spoken in the past of how horrible she was

@NippyWoowoo you actually said that? Or just thought it and said something bland or nothing.?

OppsUpsSide · 23/06/2022 21:38

On one hand I agree with you, but on the other when DB died after years of being a complete mess it was really nice to read some really positive comments from people who knew him before, I was grateful for their comments tbh.

NippyWoowoo · 23/06/2022 21:36

I actually commented on a FB post about an old teacher of mine that died. All 'she was a great' etc, I said my memories of her were that she was a bully and screamed and scared the other children 🙈

I knew a couple of the people commenting their commiserations as well, funny because we'd all spoken in the past of how horrible she was

Bednobsbroomsticks · 23/06/2022 21:34

I agree. I told my husband a fee days ago the only people I want at my funeral are the ones I know who will support him and the kids. Not the fake crying brigade who come for a sausgae roll and a post on Facebook lol.
We had a family member pass away. Hundreds at funeral. Only a handful checked in. Can't stand the fake bullshit

LetHimHaveIt · 23/06/2022 21:27

I remember a thing in 'Private Eye' years ago whereby a man walking down a London street, found a cellophane-wrapped bouquet of flowers. He propped it up against a nearby lamppost in the hope that the owner would retrace their footsteps and be able to recover it, and that it wouldn't be crushed.

The following morning he drives past and sees the pavement surrounding the lamppost awash with floral tributes. Later that day they've been joined by candles and teddies.

He wrote to the local paper pointing out the rise of what we'd now call 'grief vampires' I guess, and was promptly accused of being some kind performance artist/weirdo, by people clearly reluctant to acknowledge their own batshittery.

WingingItSince1973 · 23/06/2022 21:12

Sorry I misunderstood the post. So please ignore my ramblings. But now I understand I have an aunty thats a grief tourist. She puts on Facebook any long distant relative that has died and gets lots of comments from colleagues how sorry they are for her etc etc. We know she doesn't actually know the deceased well, if at all but loves the attention. Awful to take it away from actual close family and friends.

EmmaH2022 · 23/06/2022 21:00

orwellwasright · 23/06/2022 20:40

I think some people are missing the OP's point.

Of course tributes to a loved one are of great comfort - they certainly were to me when my husband died.

But there is a type of person who wallows in the death of anyone they vaguely know, whose response is disproportionate to the relationship they had, who revels in the situation without actually having to genuinely suffer any loss. It's completely indulgent.

The day my husband died a friend(?) came round and screamed hysterically in my sitting room until my dad insisted she left. She wanted me to comfort her. It was completely inappropriate and horrifying. She barely knew my husband, she just got off on the drama.

And I don't need to hear any nonsense about people grieving in their own way. It's not grief.

Exactly! Mum, sis and I were asked for comfort by people who hadn't seen or cared about dad in years. The classic being "I'm struggling to cope with your father's death".

that guy was lucky I didn't boot him out. Last seen about 20 years prior, telling dad "I thought you'd have a better house by now". Absolute wanker of the highest order. There are even more on social media than IRL, I'm guessing?

EmmaH2022 · 23/06/2022 20:57

MistressoftheDarkSide · 23/06/2022 19:44

So grieving people aren’t allowed to talk about things that they have found difficult and distressing to deal with …… alrighty then …… message received and understood…..

We're not talking about grieving people though Flowers

FatPatsCat · 23/06/2022 20:40

SharpLily · 23/06/2022 20:02

You're not wrong, OP. The modern fetishisation of death is extremely distasteful to me.

Agreed. I always wonder if it wasn't 'free' nowadays, how many people would actually pay to publish their grief in the local paper's 'deaths' section.

I knew somebody in childhood who was a little shit. Never grew out of it either. His mother disowned him. He died in recent years in a drug gang related incident and now his mother's Facebook name is 'Jane BobsMum Smith'. Sad thing is she has 4 other children who apparently won't mean as much to their mother until they're dead?

orwellwasright · 23/06/2022 20:40

I think some people are missing the OP's point.

Of course tributes to a loved one are of great comfort - they certainly were to me when my husband died.

But there is a type of person who wallows in the death of anyone they vaguely know, whose response is disproportionate to the relationship they had, who revels in the situation without actually having to genuinely suffer any loss. It's completely indulgent.

The day my husband died a friend(?) came round and screamed hysterically in my sitting room until my dad insisted she left. She wanted me to comfort her. It was completely inappropriate and horrifying. She barely knew my husband, she just got off on the drama.

And I don't need to hear any nonsense about people grieving in their own way. It's not grief.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 23/06/2022 20:25

can i state my annoyance?
it is about how beautiful they were

what happens if they werent beautiful?

SheriSmith · 23/06/2022 20:20

Thanks, Garth. After someone browbeats you enough times, you begin to question yourself. My husband asked his golf buddies what they thought of our son's behavior and they all said, He needs to grow up! Lol.

We live in a retirement community, so we're all 60'ish to 80 and on up, so I guess our old school generation looks at things differently. You would never consider to inconveniencing or burdening people for your own sake. But then again, they were put out when we moved away too. The entitlement mentality is ridiculous.

DorritLittle · 23/06/2022 20:19

I am sorry for your loss @tunnocksreturns2019

I agree that once someone's death is 'in the past' very few people want you to talk about it. People (who haven't also lost someone) go weirdly quiet when I mention the person close to me who died.

DorritLittle · 23/06/2022 20:12

I agree OP, it can be a very over the top thing.

Having lost someone very close to me I understand why people do post. The comments are the equivalent of sympathy cards and they do help.

But I also don't completely understand why Sandra from the post office does.

tunnocksreturns2019 · 23/06/2022 20:08

SharpLily · 23/06/2022 20:02

You're not wrong, OP. The modern fetishisation of death is extremely distasteful to me.

Fetishisation of death?! Most people in the UK pretend it doesn’t happen to anyone under 80!

My DH died age 37. A dear friend had just died aged 43. I know the challenges his wife is now facing because as a country we’d rather brush it under the carpet whilst paying lip service to mental health.

Sapphirensteel · 23/06/2022 20:07

“It would be alright if it was positive stories, like "I'll never forget when...."

But it's "my world has fallen apart, I don't know how to face this world without you, great uncle Bob who I met once when I was fifteen and occasionally accepted Facebook game invites from and liked a few statuses of"

It's so distasteful. I very recently lost a family member and the tributes are pouring in out of the woodwork from people who never bothered from one decade to the next, phrased as if they practically lived with my relative and never spent a day apart.”

There’s always been people who made it more about themselves than the deceased person or their immediate family but SM means they can star in their own show about it, lots of people will “like” what they say, sing, dance or whatever about it and that makes them feel as if they’re part of the drama.
I was so glad that neither DH or I used sm so I avoided all the false sympathy. Those who cared about me looked after me.

GarethKeenan · 23/06/2022 20:06

OP means people who come out the woodwork to pay their respects when they had no time for them in real life before they died!

the 4 of our colleagues who carried the coffin, do annual Fb posts about missing him and were full on going etc were the 4 who were utterly shit to him while living. That was really hard to watch. Dh and I had to see them soak up the tragedy.

These sorts of things are exactly what I'm on about: not grieving families who loved and will genuinely miss their departed relative. Twats who need attention and see a connected death as a brilliant way to get people to flock around them

OP posts:
TarasHarp55 · 23/06/2022 20:04

Ive noticed on FB certain people who rush to inform us when someone has died totally disregarding the deceased loved ones. Then others falling over themselves to inform us how well they knew them. It's like a competition to let everyone know how important they were to the deceased.

Agapornis · 23/06/2022 20:03

People are using social media as a medium but historically it's nothing new - Victorians especially were amazing at grieve tourism! There are some amazingly awful headstones inscriptions and obituaries out there - likely just as untrue as Facebook statuses. If it makes you feel better, think about the historians laughing at them in 150 years or so (if they can be bothered trawling through all our nonsense).

SharpLily · 23/06/2022 20:02

You're not wrong, OP. The modern fetishisation of death is extremely distasteful to me.

GarethKeenan · 23/06/2022 19:59

But, @SheriSmith I think you're doing the right thing by not going. Your respects can easily be paid by a card, and that's only if you've any respects to pay in the first place. You don't need to be flying over to hold hands with them.

OP posts:
ClaudiusTheGod · 23/06/2022 19:59

He probably wasn’t a selfish lazy arsehole when they met, though. She’s grieving the loss of what she was hoping for, not just what she actually lost.