Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not driven for 5 years should I drive in Canada?

32 replies

IIama · 23/06/2022 14:21

Hi,

I passed my drivers test 5 years ago at the age of 19. Never bothered getting a car as I went from uni to working in London.

I am taking my mother on holiday to Canada in October as a belated 60th birthday treat for her (delayed 2 years by Covid). She has now decided she is too anxious to drive an automatic on the other side of the road.

Would I be mad to be the one to do the driving? It would be an automatic car, which I have driven twice before and found very easy.

I would be driving from Montreal to Ottawa to Quebec and then back to Montreal with a few stops along the way. So a lot of driving.

I have heard driving in Canada is fairly easy so I think I’ll be fine or am I being naive?

Thanks!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
milkyaqua · 24/06/2022 01:08

I'd catch the train.

RaspberryParfait · 24/06/2022 00:26

I think the fact that you aren’t a regular driver and used to driving on the left will make it easier for you to drive on the right. Your brain won’t be telling you you’re on the wrong side!

Driving an automatic is so easy although you’ll need to get some practice in manoeuvring, on a motorway etc before you go. Can your mum put you on her insurance for a month so you can drive around a bit before you go?

Hopefully your mum will go over her fear when you’re there - the thought of something is often worse than actually doing it - and you can take turns.

I loved Canada for driving. So scenic, especially in the fall, lovely long wide roads, lots of free parking. We drove from Toronto to Edmonton once. Used to regularly drive into Winnipeg when we lived just outside there, found driving there much easier than most UK cities.

Never went over to the French part so couldn’t say what it’s like there.

Changechangychange · 24/06/2022 00:15

Also automatics set off as soon as you put them in “drive”! With no acceleration! That is off-putting. It is like the car is haunted Grin

I’m sure OP will be fine by the end of the trip, but the first journey might be a bit hair raising for her.

heyitsthistle · 24/06/2022 00:12

You'll be fine 👍 you may need to pay a young person's driving surcharge but it shouldn't be too much

crazycanuck · 24/06/2022 00:10

Changechangychange · 24/06/2022 00:03

@crazycanuck Automatics aren’t harder than manuals per se, it is just that it is yet another thing to think about when you already have information overload from driving in a new country - different road signs, wrong side of the road etc.

You really need driving the car to be unconscious, in order to reduce your mental load - if you are trying to change the non-existent gears, or you put your foot on the brake thinking it’s the clutch, you have less brainpower to concentrate on situational awareness. And as OP is an inexperienced driver, her situational awareness is likely to be pretty bad anyway. So not a great combination.

I can see how it would be extra to take in along with driving in a new country. My friend though, she was still in the UK, and she wasn’t the first I knew there who was afraid of automatics.

When I moved back to Canada, we got an automatic. Since we sit on the other side of the car here, it was a couple weeks before I stopped hitting the door with my hand when I was going for the non-existent stick shift.

Changechangychange · 24/06/2022 00:03

@crazycanuck Automatics aren’t harder than manuals per se, it is just that it is yet another thing to think about when you already have information overload from driving in a new country - different road signs, wrong side of the road etc.

You really need driving the car to be unconscious, in order to reduce your mental load - if you are trying to change the non-existent gears, or you put your foot on the brake thinking it’s the clutch, you have less brainpower to concentrate on situational awareness. And as OP is an inexperienced driver, her situational awareness is likely to be pretty bad anyway. So not a great combination.

crazycanuck · 23/06/2022 20:42

motogirl · 23/06/2022 15:14

I wouldn't, I drive a lot but still it was hard driving in Canada in an automatic

Being Canadian, and having driven both automatic and manual, this always fascinated me. What is difficult about driving an automatic? You hardly have to do anything. I had a friend when I lived in Jersey (Channel Islands) who was terrified of driving an automatic, she almost didn’t buy a car she loved otherwise because of this.

OP, if I were you I’d think twice about driving in Montreal. It’s notorious for awful drivers/traffic.

Canadian drivers are also nowhere near as likely to let you out at junctions compared to UK drivers. Over here, it’s much more down to who has the right of way. You could be waiting ages to get out of a side road here that UK drivers would happily slow down and give you time for. Following that, there’s definitely more aggro from a significant portion of drivers here too.

Mumofnowgrownkids · 23/06/2022 16:45

Absolutely not. You would be a danger both to yourself and other round users.

EmmaC78 · 23/06/2022 16:42

I would be wary of doing this. I have been driving nearly 25 years and I was still a bit nervous when I drove in the US a few years ago. No way would I have done it if I was inexperienced.

Jules0702 · 23/06/2022 16:38

I’m originally from Canada but I’ve lived in the UK for the past 9 years. I find driving here hair-raising and haven’t done much recently for insurance reasons but I always drive when I return to Canada. They have wide streets, large parking spots and very few roundabouts. Drivers are not as courteous and seem more aggressive lately but I think you would be ok driving if you had some practice before you go. I don’t think driving in the other side would be such an issue as you don’t drive that much here anyways.

zingally · 23/06/2022 16:34

I would strongly NOT recommend this. You are a new, very inexperienced, rusty driver. You aren't even fresh off the test, where all the skills are fresh in your mind! You'll have forgotten a lot and be very out of practice.

New car, on the other side, so none of the operations are where you expect them to be, driving on the other side of the road, in an unfamiliar place. It's a big fat recipe for disaster.

fallfallfall · 23/06/2022 16:28

The TransCanada is called the A-30 through Montreal.

fallfallfall · 23/06/2022 16:26

The stretch I’m familiar with is highlighted with repairs and detours. BUT it is short. Lachine to Repentigny is nerve wracking.
Other than that section you would probably be fine, and if you take the TransCanada even better.

Not driven for 5 years should I drive in Canada?
IIama · 23/06/2022 15:30

@JolieJ Thanks for the recommendations. It looks like there is a train to Ottawa, which I’d be happy to get, although we had planned a trip to Parc Omega. If that stretch is really is that bad I think we can drop it.

Would you say the drive to and from Montreal and Quebec City is okay? It seems a straight road based on Google maps. Our hotel/apartments all have free parking so we wouldn’t be using the car to drive around the cities. Just for day drips to national parks.

Thanks!

OP posts:
Iamfour · 23/06/2022 15:27

The roads are good between the cities but Montreal is a mess with lots of one-way streets downtown and inconsiderate drivers. However, there is a very good transit system so I would suggest leaving the car at the hotel and getting around by bus and metro. I don't know about driving in Ottawa, but Quebec is pretty small so you can leave the car at the hotel and probably get around on foot to see the touristy parts.

JolieJ · 23/06/2022 15:22

In from ottawa and I always fly into Montreal airport and drive home. That stretch from Montreal to ottawa is filled with crazy drivers and busy. But the rest of it is easy, I would say if you can get to ottawa by bus or train and then drive from there?

Glittertwins · 23/06/2022 15:14

We went to the US when I was under 25 and it was a massive premium on the car rental so I was quite happy for now DH to drive

motogirl · 23/06/2022 15:14

I wouldn't, I drive a lot but still it was hard driving in Canada in an automatic

IIama · 23/06/2022 15:12

Thanks for the honest opinions!

I am a member of the local car club so will get practicing. My mother has said she is fine with me driving if I feel comfortable. She personally is too anxious to drive on the other side of the road. She is also too afraid to drive an automatic even though I keep telling her they are much easier. My father would always do the driving when we went on holiday.

I do have a car booked but it is fully refundable. It was only £168 a week, even with me being under 25. It’s a 4x4.

I am considering cancelling the car. Getting the train to a from the cities and then renting a car on the days we want to visit national parks etc. Although it would involve a big change in plans.

OP posts:
SirenSays · 23/06/2022 15:12

I did something very similar and was fine. I honestly just drove around a car park for a while to get back into the swing of things.

chipsandpeas · 23/06/2022 15:03

I think you would be crazy

SpringSparrow · 23/06/2022 14:57

How does your mum feel about you driving in Canada? If she’s anxious, would she not feel even more anxious with an inexperienced driver at the wheel? I think if you want to do this, then you would be better to start driving regularly again now in this country over the next four months and then you will be more prepared for your trip.

fallfallfall · 23/06/2022 14:57

Driving in Canada is “easy” because on some stretches of road you’re the only driver for miles and miles! But the corridor you’ve mentioned Ottawa to Quebec City will be packed. As mentioned above the stretch through Montreal is a nightmare, at least on the 2-20. maybe the TC is better? What route were you planning.

emmathedilemma · 23/06/2022 14:51

Also, if you’re under 25 you might find it hard to get insured on a rental car, or expect to pay a premium.

negomi90 · 23/06/2022 14:50

You need to do some driving in London first. Get confident in driving, control of the car, hazard perception, concentration etc. Then drive in Canada.
You have time before you're holiday, if its something you want to do. Rent a car for a few weeks, do little drives around where you live, then do a long drive somewhere pretty in the UK to practice long drives - speed control and concentration and stamina.
If that goes ok, then drive in Canada.