Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How much board/rent

86 replies

loopshot · 23/06/2022 08:57

So ds18 just left college and started a full time job. He's on an apprentice wage so gets £192 a week. He pays £15 travel pass and £50 driving lesson a week.

Just discussing with DP (not ds dad) about charging him board. I said I haven't charged him yet, I don't know how much to charge him, should I wait till he's on full money?
Basically DP has had a go saying If I don't charge him board then he isn't paying anything towards bills. Why should ds live here rent free, why should he pay for him!

I never said he can live here rent free I just said I don't know how much to charge him. He's really pissed me off with his comment!

So who is being unreasonable and how much do you think I should charge ds?

OP posts:
RedorangeyellowBLACK · 23/06/2022 12:37

16 years old Ds has just left school and will be earning £250 per week as an apprentice. Dh has asked for £50 per week but we will save half of that for ds as he isn’t a great saver. I do also pay for his phone, clothes etc.

ItWillBeOkHonestly · 23/06/2022 12:35

I think it's good that he learns he's got to contribute. I'd say £100 per month and also suggest to him that he puts £50 also into savings. I think that's fair!

Proudboomer · 23/06/2022 12:31

When my youngest did his apprenticeship I didn’t charge him anything. He did take over paying for his phone, gym membership, netflicks and broadband connection. A few years now since he has qualified and he still pays the above plus buys his own food , car and pays £100 which is roughly the amount he costs in extra bills but it is only so low as he is saving a deposit to buy and puts away £1000 a month. He is now 24 and should be in a position to buy by he is 25. We are in the south east so needs a decent deposit even for a flat.

rwalker · 23/06/2022 12:25

I'd take something make sure it doesn't leave him skint . Mine got 2nd job in hospitality when they were 18 to pay to run there car .
At 18 need to start paying for something

AlwaysLatte · 23/06/2022 12:19

We never charged my adult stepchildren and won't be charging the younger ones when they're older, I don't personally feel good about charging! They used to sometimes buy ingredients and cook a nice meal though :-)

Noisyprat · 23/06/2022 12:16

I think it's good that they start to contribute especially given rising prices. I would show them, if you havent already, what your base costs are - mortgage/rent, council tax, water, gas, elec, insurance etc so they see the true cost.

I would say however that I think it is more important that they contribute to the running of the home. Of course they should clear up after themselves but they should be on the cleaning 'rota' e.g. bathroom, hoovering and do their own laundry. I know I will get flamed for this but I think this is especially important for young men so that they learn that these jobs are just a normal part of living not that they just magically get done.

HouseofHolbein · 23/06/2022 12:13

My son is an apprentice. He pays £25 a week plus £8 a week towards his phone bill. He also pays for his driving lessons and travel to work.

I am saving so I can give him money towards a car when he passes his test. So not specifically saving his keep but currently it's going towards that.

He's getting a chunky payrise towards the end of the year so I will put his rent up then a bit.

nokidshere · 23/06/2022 12:04

DS1 is earning similar at the moment. He pays me £60 per month for his share of electric/gas, WiFi, and water and, from September, he will be paying his own car insurance and phone bill.

There's no reason teens shouldn't be contributing to the household when they are earning even if it's just a nominal amount.

Comefromaway · 23/06/2022 12:03

Miajk · 23/06/2022 11:59

This baffles me about the UK coming from somewhere else in Europe. People have kids just to start charging them money when they turn 18 and are barely making any money?

I would never charge my child who should be prioritizing education/work experience and already has expenses like driving lessons.

This child has chosen to leave education and start work. An apprentiship is at the bottom of the work ladder but it is full time work and £192 per week is not barely making any money. In the UK when someone leaves education to start an apprentiship their parents lose things like Child Benefit. For families on low incomes things like housing benefit/universal credit may also be affected.

Miajk · 23/06/2022 11:59

This baffles me about the UK coming from somewhere else in Europe. People have kids just to start charging them money when they turn 18 and are barely making any money?

I would never charge my child who should be prioritizing education/work experience and already has expenses like driving lessons.

Jarstastic · 23/06/2022 11:53

Discovereads · 23/06/2022 09:15

I’d charge nothing. Apprentice wages are purposely low because it’s assumed the young person will be living rent/board free with their parents.

Your DP should shut the fuck up. Not his child, so he has no say.

Because it is a joint household with 2 adults? Usually 2 adults pay their way. And the OP said originally "Why should ds live here rent free, why should he pay for him!" Although OP has since said the DP doesn't pay for anything so who knows. The conversations sound like a bad Eastenders episode.

I should probably say my opinion is slightly coloured by the fact I currently have 19-year old DSS in the house who is currently treating our house like a hotel, as well as undermining our parenting with younger children. We do pay for him as he is at university and he has thousands in the bank left over from the year as well as his summer job, but was resentful when his father asked him to treat us to coffee on the way when we drove an hour and a half to pick up his girlfriend.

I would be flabbergasted if someone said I shouldn't have a say in my own house and 'should shut the fuck up.'

ErickBroch · 23/06/2022 11:42

As an apprentice who is paying for own travel there/back and also driving lessons (extortionate right now) I would not charge him yet. I would wait. Just my thoughts though.

ifonly4 · 23/06/2022 11:34

When DD was at home from uni during lockdown, she was earning about the same amount. She bought about £30 of food a week, mainly things that she'd prefer to cook for herself (as virtually vegan) but she'd sometimes cook for us and bring home nice treats for us. She's funded herself at uni this year, so that's a large chunk out of her earnings.

KneeQuestion · 23/06/2022 11:31

I used to pay my mum a weeks wages per month. I was 16 and in my first full time job.

best deal ever!

so 25% of his weekly pay if he’s paid weekly.

grxxxx · 23/06/2022 11:27

Your DP expressed himself very badly but he does have a point , everyone who is capable of earning should be able to keep or contribute towards there keep

Your son is earning almost £200 per week , he has a current financial outlay of £65 per week leaving him £128 over , I really think he should contribute something in the region of £20-25 for the household budget and put into savings a further £40-50 this will leave him around £ 53-68
it may sound harsh but £53-£68 is loads of pocket money , more than many have left to spend as they like
It's a perfect opportunity now he has a regular income to build a responsibility with money where he saves regularly for his future , it would be good if he saves with your guidance to develop a good habit of saving (towards a house deposit or similar ) rather than you save it for him as too many young people do not have guidance in saving money and then cannot budget later within their means

SexyBastardSmile · 23/06/2022 11:03

PurpleButterflyWings · 23/06/2022 10:55

FGS, it's hardly 'showing him a hard life' to charge fifteen to twenty quid a week for board money! Good grief! Hmm It's simply showing him that now he's working and bringing in almost TWO HUNDRED POUNDS A WEEK in, that he needs to contribute a little bit!

No need to make it harder if you don’t need to. He’s on a low wage and his travel and driving lessons take a big chunk. My opinion is as valid as yours, remember that.

Seraphinesupport · 23/06/2022 10:59

$40 a week for the next year is like 2kish so he would have a nice start up fund to do something with

Seraphinesupport · 23/06/2022 10:58

I would take £40 a week and then save it all for him until he really needs it for example for a car or to rent a place etc, furniture and stuff.

PurpleButterflyWings · 23/06/2022 10:55

SexyBastardSmile · 23/06/2022 10:31

I agree. But for many mumsnetters, everything has to be a lesson in how hard life must be for your children.

FGS, it's hardly 'showing him a hard life' to charge fifteen to twenty quid a week for board money! Good grief! Hmm It's simply showing him that now he's working and bringing in almost TWO HUNDRED POUNDS A WEEK in, that he needs to contribute a little bit!

Comefromaway · 23/06/2022 10:37

I looked at dd's budget

Wages £240
Universal Credit housing £52

Rent £125
Food £35
Travel £30
Bills £10
Council Tax £10
Phone £5
Insurances £2.50

Left over for clothes, socialising etc £74.50

SexyBastardSmile · 23/06/2022 10:31

Discovereads · 23/06/2022 10:27

Why should anyone get a free ride at the expense of others?
Because your DC isn’t just “anyone” and as their parent it’s your responsibility to give them the best start in life. That doesn’t mean withdrawing support at age 18 when they’re in the middle of FT education as an apprentice simply because they’re getting a bit of money to cover costs instead of going into masses of debt as a Uni student.

I agree. But for many mumsnetters, everything has to be a lesson in how hard life must be for your children.

Ragwort · 23/06/2022 10:29

I think he should pay something, young people need to learn that wages (even apprentice wages) aren't just for clothes, social life etc. Does he save anything out of what he earns?

Your DP's attitude is not very pleasant though .. I would be tempted to get rid of him .. what does he bring to you life?

Discovereads · 23/06/2022 10:27

Why should anyone get a free ride at the expense of others?
Because your DC isn’t just “anyone” and as their parent it’s your responsibility to give them the best start in life. That doesn’t mean withdrawing support at age 18 when they’re in the middle of FT education as an apprentice simply because they’re getting a bit of money to cover costs instead of going into masses of debt as a Uni student.

PurpleButterflyWings · 23/06/2022 10:27

Agree with @Discovereads

Discovereads · 23/06/2022 10:25

LindaEllen · 23/06/2022 10:19

That's a bit harsh. If we needed the money, and there was an adult bringing in money to just blow on shit, I would absolutely expect them to contribute their share. Why should anyone get a free ride at the expense of others?

I think you’re being harsh to say “there was an adult bringing money in to just blow on shit”. There is zero evidence the apprentice wages are going to be blown on shit FFS. There are all kinds of expenses involved such as transportation, uniform/clothing, college course materials/computer/printing, saving for tools of the trade/equipment, and so on. Plus he is paying for driving lessons…not cheap. Then there is saving to move out after the apprenticeship. Deposit on a rental, furniture, white goods, home stuff like dishes, pots, pans, kettle and so on.
The focus should be on that income being saved towards the DCs independence, which most responsible apprentices will use the money for. Yes, a few feckless youths might blow their money on shit, but that’s not the norm.

Swipe left for the next trending thread