Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How much board/rent

86 replies

loopshot · 23/06/2022 08:57

So ds18 just left college and started a full time job. He's on an apprentice wage so gets £192 a week. He pays £15 travel pass and £50 driving lesson a week.

Just discussing with DP (not ds dad) about charging him board. I said I haven't charged him yet, I don't know how much to charge him, should I wait till he's on full money?
Basically DP has had a go saying If I don't charge him board then he isn't paying anything towards bills. Why should ds live here rent free, why should he pay for him!

I never said he can live here rent free I just said I don't know how much to charge him. He's really pissed me off with his comment!

So who is being unreasonable and how much do you think I should charge ds?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
KosherDill · 24/06/2022 04:23

Discovereads · 23/06/2022 09:15

I’d charge nothing. Apprentice wages are purposely low because it’s assumed the young person will be living rent/board free with their parents.

Your DP should shut the fuck up. Not his child, so he has no say.

This.

He's a teenager for god's sake.

SKATEB0red · 24/06/2022 03:57

Charge some
Save it & give it to them on 21 or when they move out
Add to the savings if you can too

Toughtimesagain · 24/06/2022 00:01

I’m a single parent but my DS is on a similar wage and gives me £100 a month. I save it when I can, slip him the odd £20 when he’s skint at the end of the month, but it’s the principle. Gives him a sense of pride too.

AhNowTed · 23/06/2022 23:32

I could have guessed straight away that he's not his dad.

Your so called DP resents your son, and the tables would be turned if it were his own son.

See it time and again on here and it's depressingly common.

Darbs76 · 23/06/2022 20:07

I wouldn’t charge either, especially as he’s paying for his own driving lessons. We are paying for our son’s and will for all our children. I will only start charging if they are still living at home post Uni. My mum charged me £5 a week when I was earning around £60 a week, which I thought was fair enough. She was of the opinion you should charge your child something, even if a low amount. I don’t agree, but am working and don’t need the money. As you don’t need it either I’d either not charge or charge and save to return for help with his own place one day

loopshot · 23/06/2022 19:52

I totally agree DP is being an absolute arse with all of this and it really really is putting me off him and seriously making me think twice about this relationship.
It's not like I'm letting some random person live in the house rent free or for £20 a week. He's my bloody son and just got himself a good job that will eventually pay good. So whilst he's not earning very much let him enjoy having a bit of money for himself now!

I think I will charge £20 a week when we get back off holiday and he isn't saving for that, and put it in to a saving account for him.

OP posts:
Darkstar4855 · 23/06/2022 19:35

I would charge a small amount to help him get used to budgeting but secretly put it in a savings account for him to have when he moves out. Hopefully that will help encourage him into good saving habits.

IncessantNameChanger · 23/06/2022 19:27

I have said around 10% too but told ds he can have the summer off before getting a job. He’s having a year off to decide what he wants to do. I said we will sit down and review every six months.

if he decides to go to uni it will stay low. If he decides not to go to uni then I have told him that charging him £100 a month isn’t going to help him in the longer term. He is fine with that. We’re all on the same page

Miajk · 23/06/2022 19:17

loopshot · 23/06/2022 17:18

Dp does contribute yes. He gives me around half a month towards bills and food.

He is really starting to piss me off again and making me think twice about our relationship.
I've told him if I do ask ds for money it will be around £20 a week till he gets full wage.

Dp at it again saying what's £20 going to cover, he's not paying for someone in work to live here. If that's the case then he will lower the money he puts in every month as well.

I do sort of get where he's coming from but it's not just anyone living here it's my son!!
Told him see what his attitude is like when his own children are old enough to pay rent/board. Sure it will be a different story then!

I'm sorry but your DP sounds like an idiot if he really doesn't see the difference between him and your DS. Surely it's not rocket science to understand it's not the same.

He chose to be in a relationship with someone who has a child, and in most parts of the world unlike the UK parents don't charge their kids for living in the family home.

Because actually, it's really hard to save, pay for driving lessons, get on the property ladder, etc. as a young person, and much harder for younger generations. Your DP is behaving like a child and it doesn't seem like he views you as a family unit.

HappyDays40 · 23/06/2022 19:14

Get rid of the partner he sounds like an arse.

WhatTheWhoTheWhatThe · 23/06/2022 19:11

DS is 17 and on a similar apprenticeship wage. I don’t charge him anything but he pays for the following himself each month
bus fare £42
gym £35
mobile phone £10
driving lessons £140
spotify for himself and his younger brother £14
He also buys his own clothes, going out money etc but doesn’t buy a lot. He puts a large chunk away each month into savings which I would much rather see him do for his future than take anything off him. He’s saving us a fortune by choosing not to go to university so I don’t need to skim £50 a week off his wages to prove some point about not living rent free.

He’s working bloody hard 9 to 5 five days a week, I’m really proud of him so as far as I’m concerned his wages are his reward and motivation to keep going whilst his mates are sleeping in til midday before doing one or two lessons at sixth form and then back on their Xboxes by 3.30!

ToxicCuntMum · 23/06/2022 19:10

When you say your DP pays towards bills and food does that include housing costs i.e. your rent or the interest part of your mortgage? Because otherwise he’s not paying fully for himself let alone towards DS

My DS is an apprentice earning a little bit more than yours. I take £150 a month off him to pay for his car insurance which is over £1000 a year

IcecreamForAlcohol · 23/06/2022 18:57

Subaru4336 · 23/06/2022 09:37

Could you charge him a token amount, so he gets used to paying/budgeting, but save it for him secretly so it could go towards future needs? (Assuming you can afford to do that)

Yes, this seems like the best solution.

Tell your DP he can move out and find somewhere else to live. See how he gets on refusing to pay bills 😂

5thHelena · 23/06/2022 18:53

firef1y · 23/06/2022 18:38

Seems I'm mostly going against the grain, but simply because if you don't it will come as a massive shock to him when he moves in to his own place, I'd charge him at least £50 bed and board. If you don't need it then put it in a savings account for him when he moves in to his own place. He'll still have over £100/week to himself (which he should be using to buy anything else he needs) which is a hell of a lot more than he's likely to have when he moves out.
It really is a case of being cruel to be kind and will help him prepare for the real world.

I could not disagree more. I think it's being cruel to be cruel. It's not going to be a major shock for them to have to pay for things, kids know this! They have enough crap to deal with as they emerge into the world of adulthood without their parents taking money off them when they have so little coming in in the first place.

firef1y · 23/06/2022 18:38

Seems I'm mostly going against the grain, but simply because if you don't it will come as a massive shock to him when he moves in to his own place, I'd charge him at least £50 bed and board. If you don't need it then put it in a savings account for him when he moves in to his own place. He'll still have over £100/week to himself (which he should be using to buy anything else he needs) which is a hell of a lot more than he's likely to have when he moves out.
It really is a case of being cruel to be kind and will help him prepare for the real world.

gabsdot45 · 23/06/2022 18:21

My son will be starting his apprenticeship in August and I plan to get him to give a third of his money for housekeeping.

5thHelena · 23/06/2022 18:19

Miajk · 23/06/2022 11:59

This baffles me about the UK coming from somewhere else in Europe. People have kids just to start charging them money when they turn 18 and are barely making any money?

I would never charge my child who should be prioritizing education/work experience and already has expenses like driving lessons.

@Miajk baffles me too.. and I'm in the UK!

loopshot · 23/06/2022 17:18

Dp does contribute yes. He gives me around half a month towards bills and food.

He is really starting to piss me off again and making me think twice about our relationship.
I've told him if I do ask ds for money it will be around £20 a week till he gets full wage.

Dp at it again saying what's £20 going to cover, he's not paying for someone in work to live here. If that's the case then he will lower the money he puts in every month as well.

I do sort of get where he's coming from but it's not just anyone living here it's my son!!
Told him see what his attitude is like when his own children are old enough to pay rent/board. Sure it will be a different story then!

OP posts:
User3568975431146 · 23/06/2022 13:36

Charge him absolutely nothing and if that means that the old grump ups and offs then so be it. Your child is your child, not your tenant!!!

Yodaisawally · 23/06/2022 13:36

At 18 and he's self funding driving lessons at £200/month I wouldn't charge him anything.

hassletassle · 23/06/2022 13:31

I agree with @Discovereads

Itloggedmeoutagain · 23/06/2022 13:27

What's the financial split of bills between you and your partner? If it's 50 50 then I seem to be in the minority here but your partner will be paying for your child so therefore I think he does get a say. But is your partner living there rent free while renting his house out? Then no he doesn't get a say.
How much child benefit or whatever have you lost now that your son is earning?

britneyisfree · 23/06/2022 13:12

I'm glad you said that to your dp. Sounds like a bit of a tosser!

Amyrosa · 23/06/2022 13:06

will your partner have the same attitude to his biological children? not suggesting he treats then differently but does he?

I ask because similar situation happened to me, when I was 17 and working my mum and step dad took pretty much everything I earnt. I was left with just about enough for my train ticket and that was only halfway. had to cycle the rest of the way. His and my mums biological children have not had it so harsh, nowhere near so I think you need to be careful in that respect.

having said that, I think a token amount is reasonable to ask. Your partners attitude and stance on it is odd though, him and your son are not remotely comparable as you're not his mother and bear zero responsibility for your partner. Screams sulky man child to me.

BronzeSilverGold13 · 23/06/2022 12:56

I haven't read the other posts ngl but when I was 18/19 and working I'd get £79.50-£100 a week and I paid £20 and then when I turned 20 and went to uni I paid £50 a week