Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"gently move away from..." can fuck off

181 replies

MolliciousIntent · 23/06/2022 01:38

If you'll pardon my french. But I've been trying to "gently move away from" feeding my baby to sleep (as advised by so many on here) and I just don't get how it's supposed to be possible without screaming! I remove the nipple, she thrashes, demands it back, and then sobs if she doesn't get it. As soon as she does get it, fast asleep.

And before I get a huge influx of people telling me to just go with it cs it's normal, I was completely happy to do that until a fortnight ago, when it became impossible to unlatch her without her waking up and screaming. She will literally only sleep with my nipple in her mouth. No amount of gentle this or that will do, it is boob or bust. Ive tried feeding lying down/safe cosleeping but I've got a bad back and literally cannot sustain the position needed for safe cosleeping/boobsleeping without waking up immobilised by pain.

She's 4.5m and I'm genuinely counting down the days to 6m when I can try Ferber.

OP posts:
Topgub · 23/06/2022 10:09

@Somethingsnappy

Youve the cheek to say I'm talking nonsense when you're spouting crap like cortisol is released in tears?!

Meraas · 23/06/2022 10:08

Merryoldgoat · 23/06/2022 09:07

This.

These posts make me so sad. I’m no Earth Mother but we’ve really lost sight of what is normal with a baby.

4.5 months is still TINY - they still think they’re a part of you.

I’m not saying it’s easy but they’re just doing what they do.

I think you are misunderstanding the point of OP's posts.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 23/06/2022 10:07

OP all I can say is I sympathise, I remember vividly these days/nights both my DC were the same. Nothing worked (also wouldn't take a dummy) and they woke practically every hour, I couldn't do cc and they both just wanted me as exclusively breastfed. I remember going back to work and I was so tired I was thinking I'd rather be dead.

All I can say is it does pass, as you know with your first DC. Get your DH to do some of it and keep in mind that it's not forever!
Sending sympathy and lots of coffee!

peridito · 23/06/2022 10:06

Some Posters
Something I wish more parents would accept much, much sooner is that at some point your baby has to learn that screaming isn’t going to get them what they want anymore

sometimes your baby is going to cry because they aren’t getting their own way… trying to placate them at all costs will turn them into entitled arseholes and you into a jibbering wreck

Personally I don't believe that when a baby is a few months old they are capable of the thought processes necessary to be deliberately manipulative .I might be wrong but this is what I think your post suggests .

me being there and smelling of milk was the distraction keeping her awake at that point it really isn't always that simple .

We're all different - I tried CC with my son .Gave up when it had to be repeated after any blip ( new tooth ,visit to grandmother ) .Son is not an entitled arsehole he is thoughtful ,kind ,endlessly patient with the autistic children he works with .

ImNotBossyImtheBoss · 23/06/2022 10:06

Is she hungry? If she isn't getting into a full floppy deep sleep? I.e. is she snacking all night rather than getting a couple of big feeds. The equivalent of us having a cracker every 30 mins rather than 3 big meals a day. Even if she's getting enough milk overall it'll leave her pretty irritable and unwilling to leave the milk bar.

Could you try a couple of days of really boosting your supply: eating loads of oats, lots of skin to skin, litres of water, etc. I appreciate it's easier said than done but my baby has done this when my supply has dropped a bit (me being unwell, period, back to work etc.) But as soon as I can get back to big satiating feeds he's happy to unlatch and sleep in his cot and the all night snacking stops.

I also have a bottle and dummy refuser so I feel your pain!

Scirocco · 23/06/2022 10:03

That sounds really tough, @MolliciousIntent. Sleep deprivation and back pain suck by themselves, let alone in combination.

My DC is 4 months old and primarily breastfed, and they can sometimes struggle with the removal of a breast after falling asleep (not to the same level as you're describing, though!).

Some things that have helped us when DC is struggling with it (I don't know if they'll help or if you've already tried them)...

  • Wearing a fresh nursing bra and top at bedtime (to reduce the smell of milk posing a distraction).
  • Distraction with other comforting things (favourite music, comforter).
  • If DC is getting upset about the boob or lack thereof, having DH come in to comfort (DC can get skin-to-skin but not with a functioning boob causing distraction and distress).
  • Taking the night in shifts - if your DC will take a bottle and accept comfort from their dad, this combination might be tolerable for some of the night, and you can get some rest.

Splitting the nights into shifts was a real sanity-saver for us. Unless DC is unwell or extremely upset, it means each of us gets at least 4 hours continuous rest. It might help you, I don't know?

BogRollBOGOF · 23/06/2022 10:01

I have no advice, I had two babies that would only take milk directly from source, many rough phases of disturbed sleep that finally settled off at around 18m.

In DS1's case he was one of those inconvenient babies that didn't come with handy label to indicate that he had CMPA, soya intolerance and ASD. I did try at 5m in a broken state to give him formula and within days it was easier to cover him entirely in steroid cream than idenify the few tiny patches not crusty with eczema. He never accepted a bottle again.

DS2 was easier in that he was better at co-sleeping, could feed less intrusively and didn't have a biting phase.

Some methods work for some babies. I'm glad I didn't try too hard with DS1 or I'd have potentially made him rather ill and have resulted in him being on neocate if I'd lost my supply. The plod on and regularly vent method worked for me despite regularly feeling crap about being told that babies of his age not "needing" night feeds, when actually he probably did it to soothe indigestion from food allergies.

It's hard and while it's gruelling, it's not forever.

Calphurnia88 · 23/06/2022 10:01

Somethingsnappy · 23/06/2022 09:51

I agree with this. My (4th) baby did (and still does sometimes) this, but the screaming doesn't usually last long. And while you are holding them, you are comforting them, and so stress levels don't get too high. Remember too, that crying in itself releases stress. Cortisol gets released in their tears. Some babies even cry as a way of self soothing.

And please pay no attention to the ignorant PP who said you have created a sleep crutch by breastfeeding. It's nonsense. Babies are designed to fall asleep by breastfeeding. You are doing perfectly. Sending hugs and empathy, and remember, this will just be a phase and 'this too shall pass'. 4 months is classic for a sleep regression.

Remember too, that crying in itself releases stress. Cortisol gets released in their tears. Some babies even cry as a way of self soothing.

Hate to be that guy, but what scientific evidence do you have to back this up? I have literally never read any of these and I've been obsessed with baby sleep ever since LO was born 3 months ago lol.

Marvellousmadness · 23/06/2022 10:00

And....This is why you should not get your kid in the habit of being nursed to sleep. Now you are fckd.

EsmeGythaMagrat · 23/06/2022 09:58

I have no advice OP, but sending you Flowers and Cake (no wine as you’re bf-ing). The nights when they don’t sleep seem endless.
I hope you’re at the other side of this soon.

Chulainn · 23/06/2022 09:57

Does your baby ever suck on either yours or DH's finger? My first baby was like yours. I tried soothers and she refused them, screaming for my nipple. One day DH put his finger in her mouth in desperation and she sucked it. It turned out she didn't like the size of the soother as it was too small in her mouth. We went around the shops holding soothers up against DH's finger until we found a similar sized one. She took it straight away. Maybe try a different sized soother to see if that works.

Calphurnia88 · 23/06/2022 09:56

MolliciousIntent · 23/06/2022 08:35

@Topgub I posted at 2am because I was losing my mind and wanted to vent! As far as I'm aware that's allowed.

I'm not looking for zero crying, but I'm not comfortable with an hour plus of hysterical crying in a 4m baby, I think that's too much. Up until a week ago she'd feed to sleep and then go down for a bit and that was fine, this is new, so I was ranting.

And I don't agree that nothing will work til I spot BF, it's perfectly possible to night wean and sleep train and still breastfeed, I've done it before. Just not with a tiny baby, because again, I don't think that's appropriate.

Did you really let your 4m babies scream for hours?!

Are you based in the UK? I ask because my 3mo has been a lot more sucky in the last week (will unlatch for bedtime but not daytime naps) and I am convinced its linked to the heat somehow.

Could be talking complete rubbish, but it has coincided with when the hot weather kicked in and we're struggling to keep our house cool (fan directly onto bed worked last night).

BungleandGeorge · 23/06/2022 09:54

Have you tried a natural latex dummy? They’re much softer and more like skin
NUK used to make them

Somethingsnappy · 23/06/2022 09:51

3WildOnes · 23/06/2022 08:40

I think you just talked the nipple out, let her scream but comfort her whilst doing so. She will soon learn to fall asleep without the nipple in her mouth but in your arms, then you transition to her asking asleep in the cot whilst you shushand pat and then soonafter you should be able to slowly transition to her falling asleep without you in the room. You probably won't even need to do ferber.

I agree with this. My (4th) baby did (and still does sometimes) this, but the screaming doesn't usually last long. And while you are holding them, you are comforting them, and so stress levels don't get too high. Remember too, that crying in itself releases stress. Cortisol gets released in their tears. Some babies even cry as a way of self soothing.

And please pay no attention to the ignorant PP who said you have created a sleep crutch by breastfeeding. It's nonsense. Babies are designed to fall asleep by breastfeeding. You are doing perfectly. Sending hugs and empathy, and remember, this will just be a phase and 'this too shall pass'. 4 months is classic for a sleep regression.

JuneJubilee · 23/06/2022 09:49

@MolliciousIntent

Up until a week ago she'd feed to sleep and then go down for a bit and that was fine, this is new, so I was ranting

you said earlier that you just wanted to vent, yes of course that's 'allowed' but YOU ousted in AIBU, not the place for venting, try chat or an appropriate topic.

so, in a WEEK you have tried everything. I think that's extremely unlikely and even if you had, you wouldn't have given any method long enough to work.

Sleep deprivation is dreadful & affects your ability to think straight.

Just feed her when she needs it & then get DH to settle her. If he complains, tell him to try to settle her without a feed & see how he feels after a few hours (except I'd only threaten not follow through for DD's sake).

Calphurnia88 · 23/06/2022 09:48

AussieAussieAussie · 23/06/2022 06:16

Ferber suggests fixing sleep associations before 6 months (see quote).
He has a special method to reduce nighttime feedings gradually which is different to the ‘progressive waiting’ approach.

Assume you're Australian (not sure where OP is) but in the UK we are currently experiencing a heatwave.

My 3mo has needed more night feeds this week, but I have assumed that this is normal given the heat. Much in the same way that I've needed a glass of water in the middle of the night to help me go back to sleep.

Samanabanana · 23/06/2022 09:47

I have one of these! He also wouldn't sleep anywhere but in my arms until very recently. He's now 9 months old and it is starting to get a bit easier. A good tip I've found is a gentle unlatch using your finger, then placing your finger under their bottom lip and holding it gently there for a few seconds. Don't know why it works but it does, they don't seem to realise they've been unlatched!

Smartiepants79 · 23/06/2022 09:43

Merryoldgoat · 23/06/2022 09:07

This.

These posts make me so sad. I’m no Earth Mother but we’ve really lost sight of what is normal with a baby.

4.5 months is still TINY - they still think they’re a part of you.

I’m not saying it’s easy but they’re just doing what they do.

She not saying she expects her to sleep though the night!!
She jus doesn’t want to have to spend night after night with her nipples in someone else’s mouth while her back is screaming in pain!!

Wnikat · 23/06/2022 09:36

At that age I left them for up to 6 minutes to settle themselves (I mean, whilst crying). I wouldn't do longer than that but often that was enough.

I would have white noise on VERY LOUD while you do it.

Snuffy28 · 23/06/2022 09:35

Do you have Ewan the sheep? It's not a solution for the breastfeeding issues but might keep her from waking up so often so that you can get a longer rest.

numberthirtytwowindsorgardens · 23/06/2022 09:32

I don't have any advice, OP, because I'm in the same human dummy position, but I just wanted to send solidarity and hope it gets better for you soon. It's rubbish. I know.

Topgub · 23/06/2022 09:31

I had entirely realistic expectations of newborn/baby sleep

Those expectations included sleep training

SomePosters · 23/06/2022 09:28

Merryoldgoat · 23/06/2022 09:07

This.

These posts make me so sad. I’m no Earth Mother but we’ve really lost sight of what is normal with a baby.

4.5 months is still TINY - they still think they’re a part of you.

I’m not saying it’s easy but they’re just doing what they do.

So OP should just let her back get totally fucked out of some parental Martydom?

SomePosters · 23/06/2022 09:26

Something I wish more parents would accept much, much sooner is that at some point your baby has to learn that screaming isn’t going to get them what they want anymore

when I went from breastfeeding to sleep to settling with a story and a snuggle dd was 7mo and like so many others before me I felt trapped by the idea that I wasn’t supposed to let my baby cry even for a second.
eventually the day came where I had to go to the toilet while I was trying to settle her.

she screamed blue murder while I was peeing and washing my hands and by the time my hand was on the door handle she had started to wind down, so I waited outside the door frozen and realised she was settling. I never fed to sleep again.

me being there and smelling of milk was the distraction keeping her awake at that point!

sometimes your baby is going to cry because they aren’t getting their own way… trying to placate them at all costs will turn them into entitled arseholes and you into a jibbering wreck.

EatYourVegetables · 23/06/2022 09:17

And btw, we kept breastfeeding till s he was 3yo, sleep training didn’t break that in any way.