Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"gently move away from..." can fuck off

181 replies

MolliciousIntent · 23/06/2022 01:38

If you'll pardon my french. But I've been trying to "gently move away from" feeding my baby to sleep (as advised by so many on here) and I just don't get how it's supposed to be possible without screaming! I remove the nipple, she thrashes, demands it back, and then sobs if she doesn't get it. As soon as she does get it, fast asleep.

And before I get a huge influx of people telling me to just go with it cs it's normal, I was completely happy to do that until a fortnight ago, when it became impossible to unlatch her without her waking up and screaming. She will literally only sleep with my nipple in her mouth. No amount of gentle this or that will do, it is boob or bust. Ive tried feeding lying down/safe cosleeping but I've got a bad back and literally cannot sustain the position needed for safe cosleeping/boobsleeping without waking up immobilised by pain.

She's 4.5m and I'm genuinely counting down the days to 6m when I can try Ferber.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Calphurnia88 · 27/06/2022 08:08

@Tadpoll I think the 'attack' comes as you've come across a bit superior with your criticism of responsive parenting. It's quite natural to respond to your babies cries, it's how they communicate distress, and to put it down to bad advice from health visitors and baby books is a bit insulting.

Everyone has a different approach, but what you've described as letting a newborn baby 'have a little cry' before falling asleep is essentially the same as crying it out, which even advocates of the CIO method don't recommend until after 6mo.

MolliciousIntent · 26/06/2022 22:28

@Tadpoll I would say an hour is a very long time for a newborn! That's certainly not "a little crying before they fall asleep".

I don't believe that crying is inherently damaging but I do believe when our babies are tiny it is our duty to respond to their needs as much as we can. It may be inconvenient but that's babies for you. The type of training you described upthread is generally held to not be developmentally appropriate for babies under 6m.

OP posts:
Tadpoll · 26/06/2022 22:20

MolliciousIntent · 24/06/2022 11:42

From their initial post, it's not a no-cry approach, they're just happy to let the baby cry from the getgo and think we're being overly sensitive to not want our babies to be distressed around sleep.

Not really ’happy to let my baby cry’, no.

It’s more about accepting that babies do cry. And when they do, it doesn’t mean they’re being psychologically damaged. It’s normal for babies to have a little cry before they fall asleep. The problem is that mums have been told it’s damaging, so the guilt means they’re terrified to let their babies cry at all. As a result the baby never learns to settle happily by itself.

I never let my babies cry for long periods. But I didn’t rush to them, and they (generally) soon settled themselves. Some had dummies, some didn’t, depending on whether they wanted one.

I’m not falling into the trap of sharing my ‘routine’ because you’ll say ‘Tried that and it didn’t work’.
But I would advise an approach where the baby is awake for a good while straight after feeding.

You can think I’m heartless or less of a mother for not co-sleeping or feeding to sleep but they were all happier - and I was happier - because they were getting a good night’s sleep on their own in their cot.

I believe that lack of sleep is far more damaging (for everyone) than a little bit of crying as they settle. Not expecting you to agree with me but all I know is that it worked for me with three very different babies.

So no need to attack!

Zombiemum1946 · 26/06/2022 21:37

Not of any help in the wee small hours but, this is most likely down to being 4-5 months old. Both of mine did this and I had to ride it out for a few weeks. It does settle. If lo will settle with dad in a separate room then turn about might be a way forward for a while. I usually did night with handover at 6-7am to dh. 2nd had to be bottle fed (still woke if the bottle was moved), neither took a dummy. It will end and become a distant nightmare. I tried cc with 1st and hated it, didn't bother 2nd time. I co slept which made a huge difference when they went through the night terror phases. You will find what works for you but you'll feel like crap for a while.

MolliciousIntent · 24/06/2022 11:42

Calphurnia88 · 24/06/2022 11:37

@Tadpoll you still haven't shared your alternative approach? Seriously, if you think you have nailed getting babies to sleep independently without crying, effectively putting hundreds of sleep consultants out of business, you should share it. Or monetise it.

From their initial post, it's not a no-cry approach, they're just happy to let the baby cry from the getgo and think we're being overly sensitive to not want our babies to be distressed around sleep.

OP posts:
Calphurnia88 · 24/06/2022 11:37

@Tadpoll you still haven't shared your alternative approach? Seriously, if you think you have nailed getting babies to sleep independently without crying, effectively putting hundreds of sleep consultants out of business, you should share it. Or monetise it.

MolliciousIntent · 24/06/2022 11:21

@Tadpoll you're attributing to your parenting skills/philosophy what is much more likely down to luck.

I attempted exactly what you set out with both children and ended up with hungry, overtired, miserable babies after a handful of days and quickly sacked it in. You either had easy babies or you were much more comfortable with inflicting distress on newborns than I am.

The first six months are vital for infant development and there is so much research that suggests that highly responsive parenting of babies creates securely attached, independent children. I'm very comfortable with that approach, just a little frustrated by the need to chew on my nipples.

OP posts:
Tadpoll · 24/06/2022 11:17

There is not a chance my baby would just fall asleep simply after putting him in his crib (trust me, I've tried) and most mums I know have to support their babies to sleep. It's probably why the sleep industry is so lucrative.

This is my point. The sleep industry is so lucrative because mothers are being given bad advice by HVs and books. They need to be told that although it’s fine to choose attachment parenting styles - feeding to sleep, co-sleeping etc - there are potentially problems that come later down the line when you want your life back/some sleep. Some mums would still choose that, but I think many aren’t being properly informed.

I’m aware it’s an unpopular opinion but I think it needs to be said. Maybe not here, granted, but there are many, many of these threads and I feel for the OPs so much. Yet the narrative is still that this is just what motherhood is like.

Tadpoll · 24/06/2022 11:12

(I also never said that I didn’t follow my babies’ cues.)

Tadpoll · 24/06/2022 11:11

JenniferBarkley · 24/06/2022 09:58

@Tadpoll I don't think it's particularly supportive to post on a thread where the mother of a young baby is losing her mind due to sleep deprivation to boast that your baby slept well.

I also fed broadly to a routine because it suited me and my babies. However I also followed their cues and was more than happy to feed or rock to sleep early if they seemed to need it that day.

My eldest was a terrible sleeper and nearly killed me. My youngest was a fantastic sleeper who never had me up more than twice a night, and so I was never too tired on maternity leave, and I certainly enjoyed her baby months more than her sister's. That wasn't my skill, I didn't do anything different, they're just different people and we got lucky sleep wise the second time around.

What your post should have said is "Gosh OP, that sounds so hard. I won't offer advice as I was lucky with my baby's sleep, but I hope things improve for you soon."

I don’t know what the point of your post is?

I never said it was ‘skill’. But neither is it luck. I think mums are being given terrible advice by healthcare professionals and so many of them are ending up horribly sleep deprived. Once it gets to that stage, there isn’t really a ‘gentle’ option unfortunately - there will be some crying involved.

I think less helpful are the posters who are telling OP that letting her baby cry will damage it. That’s become the narrative now and I think it’s really damaging for maternal health.

Calphurnia88 · 24/06/2022 11:08

So glad you had a better night OP! It's still very hot in my neck of the woods, hoping it'll cool down soon. Never thought I'd say that!

@Tadpoll either you have singlehandedly the solved the problem of independent infant sleep (in which case you should really consider going into sleep consultancy, given it appears to be a very lucrative, global industry) or - more likely - you have had unicorn babies.

There is not a chance my baby would just fall asleep simply after putting him in his crib (trust me, I've tried) and most mums I know have to support their babies to sleep. It's probably why the sleep industry is so lucrative.

I would be genuinely interested in hearing your routine, if you're happy to share.

MolliciousIntent · 24/06/2022 10:48

curlydiamond · 24/06/2022 10:15

Glad you've seen an improvement OP. DH cosleeping would have been my suggestion, with bringing baby to you for her night feeds and taking her back afterwards. Exhausting for both parents but would break the cycle of her needing your nipple for comfort to sleep and likely wouldn't be needed for too long.
Good luck going forward.

We were all in our room together last night and she went in her cot, which was lovely, but I can see separate rooms being necessary on and off in the future!

OP posts:
curlydiamond · 24/06/2022 10:15

Glad you've seen an improvement OP. DH cosleeping would have been my suggestion, with bringing baby to you for her night feeds and taking her back afterwards. Exhausting for both parents but would break the cycle of her needing your nipple for comfort to sleep and likely wouldn't be needed for too long.
Good luck going forward.

JenniferBarkley · 24/06/2022 10:01

Delighted things have picked up for you OP. Flowers

MolliciousIntent · 24/06/2022 10:01

Last night was MUCH better, I think PPs must have been on to something when they mentioned the weather because it was loads cooler and she was so much easier to detatch. I also handed her over to DH in the evening and got an extra hour of sleep while he settled her, she woke twice (standard) and the first time was back down in half an hour, second time was much harder so after an hour I passed her to DH again, and she settled for him in 5min.

Thank you all for your advice and insight, it's been largely very helpful.

OP posts:
JenniferBarkley · 24/06/2022 09:58

@Tadpoll I don't think it's particularly supportive to post on a thread where the mother of a young baby is losing her mind due to sleep deprivation to boast that your baby slept well.

I also fed broadly to a routine because it suited me and my babies. However I also followed their cues and was more than happy to feed or rock to sleep early if they seemed to need it that day.

My eldest was a terrible sleeper and nearly killed me. My youngest was a fantastic sleeper who never had me up more than twice a night, and so I was never too tired on maternity leave, and I certainly enjoyed her baby months more than her sister's. That wasn't my skill, I didn't do anything different, they're just different people and we got lucky sleep wise the second time around.

What your post should have said is "Gosh OP, that sounds so hard. I won't offer advice as I was lucky with my baby's sleep, but I hope things improve for you soon."

Tadpoll · 24/06/2022 09:51

Threads like these make me so sad, because we seem to have forgotten that it doesn’t have to be this way.

I wish HVs and midwives would give better advice on feeding and sleeping. So many of the issues people face are because they’re not taught how to avoid these long-term issues.

I followed a set routine (there, I said it) and my babies never had to be ‘Feberized’ or anything ‘ized’ or left to cry because we never got to the stage where we had these problems. Sure, we had the odd blip, but generally I never had to get up more than twice a night. Ever. I was therefore better able to enjoy my baby because I had had some sleep.

I’ll get flamed for saying it, but following a feeding routine, making sure my baby was awake for some time after each feed and putting her into the cot awake meant we never ran into these problems (with three babies).

What mums are going through now is damaging to their mental and physical health, all because we’ve been told it’s bad to let a baby cry or be ‘abandoned’ to sleep.

Never mind the damage the cortisol will do to your baby - what about you?!

I don’t care what people say - letting your baby cry for a few nights to get out of this situation will NOT do her any harm. And you will get your life back.

(FWIW, I would persevere with the dummy as it sounds like she’s a sucky baby).

Marotte · 23/06/2022 21:30

The other gentler solutions look worth a try too, I'm not necessarily advocating for controlled (or uncontrolled!) crying but just saying that sometimes the gentler methods don't work with some babies, or just are not possible to take the time to work through because it's affecting one or both parents or the family as a whole just too much ie it has become an acute problem. One of mine had colic and screamed nightly, nothing was going to change that so we just had to go with it, we really did try all manner of kind methods (which didn't work) and medication (worked a bit, not much). We worked through it as best we could with good advice from various healthcare professionals and others and I don't feel any guilt about it at all. I know your problem isn't colic but any of these problems may have different solutions with different babies/families, there is no one right answer. Same with a few other things that weren't 'textbook' but we were doing our holistic best with. All the children are now happy healthy adults. It matters how you parent overall but the exact details of how you solve this particular problem don't matter quite as much as you feel they do right now OP, I hope you see what I mean.

Marotte · 23/06/2022 21:19

I haven't RTFT. But you don't have to wait 6 months until starting Ferber, some start at 4 months or later at a year, I read. I suspect many of us were doing a version of Ferber without realising it, or perhaps without having any formal plan to follow, many years ago. Do what's right for you/your family and your sanity in the kindest way for your baby that you can manage of course. Certain babies in our family (multigenerationally) have been known to be those that scream and scream no matter what gentle or non-gentle way the parents tried to improve sleep patterns or wean etc. so while I wouldn't start with this of course, it turns out that some parents likewise have to get used to some screaming at some point (or have a very drawn out problem over a number of years which isn't necessarily good for the wellbeing of the parents, or at least the mother, other children in the home, or necessarily I suspect, the child).

MolliciousIntent · 23/06/2022 19:26

Live updates - we're on the sofa, she's asleep, I've reclaimed my nipples, so far so good except I forgot to make myself a G&t before I got started and DH is out, so I have only a partial victory.

OP posts:
Blueink · 23/06/2022 17:32

*she not ask

Blueink · 23/06/2022 17:30

Did you call your local Laleche number or if you don’t have one locally the National helpline is open until 11pm www.laleche.org.uk/call/
it might be good to speak to someone that will support you rather than keep posting here. You do sound like you need a break.
The hot weather might increase feeding for hydration, but you say your baby is sleeping, not feeding.
In answer to your last question, yes falling asleep on the breast is natural, but if she has had a full feed and is using the nipple only as comfort (and age won’t let you settle her) it’s better to hand her over to your partner to put her in to her cot and you rest in another room for 2-3 hours. It’s also helpful to get her used to going into her cot sleepy but awake. She’s naturally waking up now so in a new phase. Obviously she’s learnt how to keep you attached to her for her own comfort, but you need proper breaks to rest in her interest as well as yours. Please do talk to someone, not just on here.

MolliciousIntent · 23/06/2022 15:37

@Calphurnia88 yes we're in the UK. Hopefully it is just the weather.

OP posts:
SmallPrawnEnergy · 23/06/2022 15:33

Oh, this has only been happening for a week? Environmental factors most likely then. As others have said heat etc. What was her sleep like before? A week isn’t that long tbh and the methods PPs have mentioned usually take a few days to sink in. I know you’re tired but I think some perspective is needed before you go off the deep end.

JenniferBarkley · 23/06/2022 15:32

MolliciousIntent · 23/06/2022 15:25

Well something's gotta give because I'm so fucking tired I just dropped the baby. A few inches, onto carpet, but still. She's now fast asleep with my nipple in her mouth.

You poor thing, you must be shattered Flowers

Swipe left for the next trending thread