Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Govt declares war on teachers again. Fucksake.

308 replies

noblegiraffe · 22/06/2022 22:44

The Telegraph front page tomorrow is reporting that the DfE is preparing an 'army of supply teachers' to keep schools open in the event of a teacher strike.

Is that like the army of volunteers they failed to raise to keep schools open during the covid surge in January?

Changing the law to allow agency staff to cover for striking colleagues is a shitty move, an opportunity I can't imagine agency staff in general would be leaping at; but using it as some sort of trump card against teachers?

  1. supply teachers would most likely be in a teaching union (they'd be mad if not)

  2. WE CAN'T GET SUPPLY TEACHERS NOW BECAUSE THERE'S A CRITICAL SHORTAGE OF TEACHERS

If they've got an army of supply teachers, where are they fucking hiding them?

If the government think children have 'suffered enough' during the pandemic then:

  1. fund schools properly

  2. stop haemorrhaging teachers by e.g. not treating them like shit in the national press

  3. improve working conditions and reduce workload by e.g. funding children's services like CAMHS, SEN services, social services so that schools aren't picking up ALL the slack.

That would improve the situation far more for children than shitty headlines in the Telegraph deliberately antagonising the few teachers the country has left.

twitter.com/samfr/status/1539717032043859968?s=21&t=uLvLET4xftQW31sTEKBaLg

OP posts:
riesenrad · 23/06/2022 09:46

cakeorwine · 22/06/2022 22:47

I'd imagine a supply teachers would think carefully before coming into a school to cover a strike. If they returned to that school later, they might not have a good reception.

If the government is going to use agency staff then they will also have to outlaw picketing. Nobody in their right mind is going to walk past a picket line to break a strike.

Kokapetl · 23/06/2022 09:44

I would support teachers striking of course.

However, I do wonder if unions could be a bit more creative with action-short-of-strikes. Perhaps for industrial action days teachers could do things like:

Not do paperwork beyond what is needed for basic safeguarding.
Boycott after school punishments and meetings.
Take a full lunch break.
Not follow the curriculum and not plan lessons, just teach things they find fun and interesting. (If that included things like history of the unions, recent politics, critical thinking, media studies, debate, bias, real colonial history and other things the government doesn't want taught, then good. Although it might end up being lots of sport.)

All this would inconvenience and upset the government and management without upsetting most pupils or parents very much. It might get more people on their side. it could lead to some memorable days at school as well!

I know it won't happen though.

theworldhas · 23/06/2022 09:40

@Dotjones
its not quite as easy as “taking another job” when you’ve spent your whole life (and possibly significant money) training for the career you currently have.
Your arguments for Universal Income may be right. However the fact is that right now we do not have it. So it’s an argument sort of built on a false premise. Removing the right to strike would be madness. If we are to start stripping away our existing rights, we’d better get alternative protections in place FIRST, surely!

Whitehorsegirl · 23/06/2022 09:39

The government tried the same thing with the railways/tube and initially claimed temp staff would help keep things running during the strikes. That did not happen and the RMT is smashing it with their strike and spokesperson annihilating any mP or journalist who comes against him with the usual lies and bluster...

Good luck to teachers and HNS staff with their strikes. Time to make a stand against that vile government.

In fact I want to see a general strike.

Enough is enough.

nojudgementhere · 23/06/2022 09:37

artisanbread · 23/06/2022 07:50

I would consider striking for the first time in my career. However, I'm concerned that my school would use my TA to cover me as they do any other time I am not in class and I wouldn't want to put that on them.

I'm a TA and I won't be covering for anyone. If my teachers strike then I will be right there with them!

spirit20 · 23/06/2022 09:35

To the people claiming teachers aren't paid badly, you're missing the point.

There are, right now, massive teacher shortages. So many teachers are leaving the profession and teacher training programes cannot meet their recruitment targets

So it would seem that a large number have people have considered their options carefully and decided teaching isn't for them. If the conditions weren't that bad, they wouldn't be choosing to do this.

As I've said before though, it's not just the money, it's the workload and the expectations to work from 7.30 - 9 pm during the week and at least one full day on weekends to get everything done.

Also, I've just seen that Teach First has just recently reopened their applications for this coming September, which is a clear sign they don't have enough incoming trainees. Not sure what good easing the requirements and qualifications to enter the profession will be when they can't get people who wan to enter it in the first place.

theworldhas · 23/06/2022 09:32

pretty amazing stat:

In every quarter of 2021, U.S. corporations’ overall profit margin remained above 13%, a level reached during only one previous quarter in the past 70 years

fortune.com/2022/03/31/us-companies-record-profits-2021-price-hikes-inflation/

”all in it together!”

“Corporate greed is motivating large companies to use the pandemic and supply-chain issues as an excuse to raise prices simply because they can,” House Energy and Commerce Committee Chairman Rep. Frank Pallone (D-N.J.) said during a February inflation hearing”.

fortune.com/2022/03/31/us-companies-record-profits-2021-price-hikes-inflation/

Of course exactly the same is happening in Europe, with Russia/Brexit/Pandemic (take your pick) used as cover.

Dotjones · 23/06/2022 09:30

The media and the government are anti the rail strikes not because they are wrong but because they are right.

Correct, the media and govt are 100% correct to be against the strikes. Allowing small sections of the workforce to hold the rest of us to ransom is plain wrong, and shouldn't be allowed. There should be no right to strike, a person who is not happy with their current pay or conditions can either continue to work whilst negotiating an improvement, or hand in their notice and find a job that suits them better.

Don't get me wrong, I believe that our system is morally wrong and nobody should be forced to work just to have a roof over their head and food on the table. Those things should be basic rights - there should be a universal basic income of £30K per year so that nobody has to work to survive. Obviously those people who claim to love working would be allowed to.

My view is just that inconveniencing the public is not the right way to go about it.

theworldhas · 23/06/2022 09:22

The media and the government are anti the rail strikes not because they are wrong but because they are right. The constant downward pressure on living standards and wages for the majority, while profits for a tiny elite have continued to soar the last few years and still continue to soar is unsustainable. This economic model is broken. But rather than try to fix it or at least address it, the government and media instead try to demonise those who point out that it’s broken and stand up for their rights. The government is terrified that the penny will soon drop for millions and millions more. That’s what they’re most scared of.

Chesneyhawkes1 · 23/06/2022 09:20

@Itisasecret what has it got to do with train drivers? How is it even a comparison?

Train drivers aren't on strike or asking for anything?

1moreyear · 23/06/2022 09:20

Yeah also as others have said....good luck finding enough supply teachers! Thin on the ground round here, I could work everyday if I wished. I don't because kids are arseholes tbh. (Obv not all kids etc etc before anyone has a go at me!)

1moreyear · 23/06/2022 09:18

I teach supply. I would never cover for striking teachers. I am completely on board with striking due to pay and conditions. One of the reasons I work supply is so I can actually go home at the end of the day!

JennyForeigner · 23/06/2022 09:16

There was an excellent interview with the head of the agency industry body yesterday. He said they are telling government they have no interest in a law change and won't supply workers, it isn't reputationally worth it and they couldn't find them if they tried.

It was general rather than teaching specific but on the nail.

theworldhas · 23/06/2022 09:14

The only way we can ever be free of this Government and Media’s Populist us against them bullshit is by implementing a system of PR.

wonderstuff · 23/06/2022 09:13

DownNative · 23/06/2022 09:03

Those on checkouts, shopfloor, online shopping pickers and online customer delivery drivers at Tesco do NOT earn close to this figure you quoted for a teacher:

"£25,714 a year for 39 weeks @ 70 hours a week for an ECT..."

Managers at Tesco get about that figure.

Is It a bad wage? No, not really. I'd be earning that upon qualifying as an audiologist after two years study. I'd certainly be happy with a wage of £25k a year which I don't get at Tesco as a driver.

It doesn’t matter whether you think it’s a good salary compared to x job, what matters is that we can’t recruit and retain teachers. We need a salary that is attractive enough to attract people into the profession. It’s a great career, but people with the skills to teach have choices and they aren’t choosing to teach.

theworldhas · 23/06/2022 09:10

Don’t believe anything you read in the gutter press, by which I refer to the Mail, the Express, the Sun, the Telegraph, the Times, and the Guardian.

wonderstuff · 23/06/2022 09:09

Army of supply teachers 😂😂😂

Im genuinely worried about the future of education if something doesn’t change soon. We just can’t recruit good people, not to teaching vacancies, not to TA positions, not to middle management. I work in a lovely school which gets great results and has mostly supportive parents. If we’re struggling I dread to think what it’s like elsewhere. Behaviour has dipped because of a combination of pandemic recovery and having fewer experienced teachers in certain subjects.

I won’t be happy with anything below 8%, if it’s below 5% we absolutely need to strike, pay has fallen by 20% in real terms already since 2007, it can’t keep dropping.

DownNative · 23/06/2022 09:03

DirtyteaCup · 22/06/2022 23:23

You think that for 4 years of graduate/post grad studies earning less per hour than working in Nando's/tesco is good?

Those on checkouts, shopfloor, online shopping pickers and online customer delivery drivers at Tesco do NOT earn close to this figure you quoted for a teacher:

"£25,714 a year for 39 weeks @ 70 hours a week for an ECT..."

Managers at Tesco get about that figure.

Is It a bad wage? No, not really. I'd be earning that upon qualifying as an audiologist after two years study. I'd certainly be happy with a wage of £25k a year which I don't get at Tesco as a driver.

GuyFawkesDay · 23/06/2022 08:54

I love my job. I adore being in a classroom, teaching kids. I am really good at it.

I am also exhausted. 2 years of working through COVID, including teaching my own kids which simultaneously teaching online (which I was doing by April 2020) and going in for key worker kids etc then "catch up" for last school year whilst doing all the things we do in a normal year too. It's utterly unsustainable.

If I felt appreciated it'd be better. But I feel like the government and general public have no idea about the sheer intensity of a schoolteachers day. I can go from 8:20-1:10 without time for a break if I am on duty on a full teaching day. And all the admin that builds up during the day to do before one even starts marking and prep. Yesterday I dealt with an SEN child having a meltdown in a corridor as a supply teacher had pushed all the wrong buttons. Another misbehaving had to come to my room to be "parked" out of their lesson. A kid made a MH disclosure I had to log. Add on putting all those on systems, admin for the trips I am running over the next few weeks. Oh and I have reports to write, exams to mark etc. It's never ending!!

The appreciation of a profession partly comes in the form of a salary commensurate with a degree, postgrad and masters. And partly from the respect for the job I do.

I am not sure we get either right now.

Waffleboggy · 23/06/2022 08:51

FlimFlam2 · 23/06/2022 08:31

Bring back free training!! The government can make it conditional of they have to (e.g. you have to work for the NHS for three years, or pay back the cost of your training). It's a sensible fix, I don't understand why they won't do this.

I am established in a different career, but would strongly consider retraining as a nurse if I didn't have to pay to do so. I've been looking for apprenticeships, but they're few and far between.

Especially as a student you essentially work full time for the NHS and pay for the privilege to do so. Although students should be supernumerary on many placements they are being utilised at HCA levels which is outrageous. There are more apprenticeships starting to emerge but due to how short staffed everywhere is it depends if there are enough mentors etc to go round. I agree though, for all public sector core jobs like teaching, nursing (especially where there are placements) paying fees but with a fixed return of service would be brilliant. Perhaps everyone would apply for a loan and it'd be wiped out after x years, otherwise I guess might get people trapped but unable to pay to leave.

Waffleboggy · 23/06/2022 08:47

thrashingbo · 23/06/2022 08:45

Well that doesn't really add up then, does it? Either you think their pay and pension is good for the job they do, or you don't. The two are inextricably linked.

I disagree, more money doesn't make the ridiculous workload more manageable. Sure a payrise (which is coming) is nice, but for those burnt out who have zero work life balance it's not enough to keep them.

thrashingbo · 23/06/2022 08:45

Porcupineintherough · 22/06/2022 23:17

I have to admit I think teacher's pay/pension is pretty good. I think their working conditions and workload stink though.

Well that doesn't really add up then, does it? Either you think their pay and pension is good for the job they do, or you don't. The two are inextricably linked.

FlimFlam2 · 23/06/2022 08:31

newbiename · 23/06/2022 08:10

Same as the magic nurse cupboard where all the qualified nurses are hiding and waiting to train now they have the privilege of paying for it.

Bring back free training!! The government can make it conditional of they have to (e.g. you have to work for the NHS for three years, or pay back the cost of your training). It's a sensible fix, I don't understand why they won't do this.

I am established in a different career, but would strongly consider retraining as a nurse if I didn't have to pay to do so. I've been looking for apprenticeships, but they're few and far between.

Groovybic · 23/06/2022 08:30

There's zero point in increasing funding for CAHMS and social services as there aren't enough qualified staff or people who want to train to expand services. They have been trying to throw money at them but its too late, they should have addressed issues with recruitment and retention long ago- the same is true across the public sector to be honest.

cakeorwine · 23/06/2022 08:25

There is going to be a battle over pay rises in the public sector. This is only the start

Swipe left for the next trending thread