Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Govt declares war on teachers again. Fucksake.

308 replies

noblegiraffe · 22/06/2022 22:44

The Telegraph front page tomorrow is reporting that the DfE is preparing an 'army of supply teachers' to keep schools open in the event of a teacher strike.

Is that like the army of volunteers they failed to raise to keep schools open during the covid surge in January?

Changing the law to allow agency staff to cover for striking colleagues is a shitty move, an opportunity I can't imagine agency staff in general would be leaping at; but using it as some sort of trump card against teachers?

  1. supply teachers would most likely be in a teaching union (they'd be mad if not)

  2. WE CAN'T GET SUPPLY TEACHERS NOW BECAUSE THERE'S A CRITICAL SHORTAGE OF TEACHERS

If they've got an army of supply teachers, where are they fucking hiding them?

If the government think children have 'suffered enough' during the pandemic then:

  1. fund schools properly

  2. stop haemorrhaging teachers by e.g. not treating them like shit in the national press

  3. improve working conditions and reduce workload by e.g. funding children's services like CAMHS, SEN services, social services so that schools aren't picking up ALL the slack.

That would improve the situation far more for children than shitty headlines in the Telegraph deliberately antagonising the few teachers the country has left.

twitter.com/samfr/status/1539717032043859968?s=21&t=uLvLET4xftQW31sTEKBaLg

OP posts:
EvilPea · 23/06/2022 11:40

My view is just that inconveniencing the public is not the right way to go about it.

i do agree, however I sort of look at it that the train drivers are taking one for the team. Doctors and nurses can’t realistically strike without deaths - I know there’s rumblings and I know they have before, as have ambulance staff. They are a service that has enough of an impact to make a difference, without risking lives or having wide long term implications E.g GCSEs

dolorsit · 23/06/2022 11:35

Well, my daughter has not had a full week of scheduled A-level lessons this academic year.

The idea that a school could recruit enough supply teachers to teach 1600 pupils is bloody stupid. I doubt that there's that many supply teachers in the county.

Piggywaspushed · 23/06/2022 11:32

Dotjones · 23/06/2022 09:30

The media and the government are anti the rail strikes not because they are wrong but because they are right.

Correct, the media and govt are 100% correct to be against the strikes. Allowing small sections of the workforce to hold the rest of us to ransom is plain wrong, and shouldn't be allowed. There should be no right to strike, a person who is not happy with their current pay or conditions can either continue to work whilst negotiating an improvement, or hand in their notice and find a job that suits them better.

Don't get me wrong, I believe that our system is morally wrong and nobody should be forced to work just to have a roof over their head and food on the table. Those things should be basic rights - there should be a universal basic income of £30K per year so that nobody has to work to survive. Obviously those people who claim to love working would be allowed to.

My view is just that inconveniencing the public is not the right way to go about it.

What is the right way?

GuyFawkesDay · 23/06/2022 11:32

Let's get realistic here:

I start on £21k nearly 20 years ago. It's now £25k. Will rise soon but no matter how experienced you are £41k is all you will ever earn if you stay in the classroom and no matter how good you are. And TLRs are a joke for the extra work required for a measly increase. I saw one recently in-house for helping pupil premium kids. £1500 a year. So £1200 after tax. £100 a month, £25 a week or a fiver a day for all that work!!!

The starting salary is being improved at last but with no development or scope then people will still stay away.

DdraigGoch · 23/06/2022 11:27

balalake · 23/06/2022 07:15

The government is talking about preparing an army of supply teachers. This does not mean they are actually preparing one, or that there will be one.

Most of the government I would not trust to be able to prepare my lunch.

Yep, when Shapps started talking about agency staff for rail, one of the MDs just said "it's not going to happen". Sure, railway companies employ agency staff for roles such as cleaning, catering, security etc. but the drivers/guards/signallers etc. who actually keep the railway moving are skilled staff who take up to a year to qualify, and longer to become fully productive (route/traction knowledge). Getting agency workers in at two weeks notice to cover these roles just isn't possible.

It's all talk, just like the automation wibble.

123ROLO · 23/06/2022 11:22

I don't think the pay is bad. But I live in the northeast where 25k is considered a lot.

I don't have children so won't have any childcare issues so might be easy enough for me to say, but I agree with the strikes, I'm just not sure what they can achieve though? As more pay won't help much.

The issue to me is workload not pay. My sister in law is a teacher, she's young (26) been doing it 3 years now.

Every time I go round to hers, whether it's evening or weekend, she's got her laptop out and is surrounded by books/paper and she's working.

She gets to work for 7:30am, leaves 5:30/6ish. She teaches in a 'rough' area, last week she had to stay late one day as a child showed up very unkempt, and there were issues with safe guarding. Another day a parent forgot to pick their child up as they were drunk, so she had to stay till that was dealt with, this ended up being 7pm, then shes come home, write reports, lesson plans, marks work etc.

She once received a complaint from a parent for being "too young", she received another complaint from a parent for not being able to appreciate a child's drawing which upset him, because she was too busy dealing with an autistic child's meltdown.

She has 7 ld children in her class. She gets told off if she separates them too much to the other kids, then gets told off if she doesn't adapt their workload and environment enough, she can never get it right.

To me, it is not a case of salary.

I think schools need more staff that aren't teachers such as safe guarding leads, well-being/well fare officers, on site relief support workers to deal with challenges / disruptions, staff trained more in special educational needs...basically, just people around so teachers can just teach !

Still all comes down to money, though I expect all these additional services would save money in the long run.

donquixotedelamancha · 23/06/2022 11:19

We’ve worked to rule before, did anyone notice? I’m not sure the union work to rule instruction was ever lifted, tbh.

The NASUWT has had it in place for at least 10+ years. It doesn't make any difference, not because it couldn't but because teachers are generally very, very reluctant to do anything which impacts the kids- so it's completely ineffective.

Strikes have clear timescales and goals, so are generally much more effecive. The problem is that I think it will be hard to gather support until the pay cuts really bite in a year or two.

The other problem is that the government really want strikes so they can be seen to be doing battle with the left, so I'm not sure how successful it could be.

Eelicks · 23/06/2022 11:16

ThrallsWife · 23/06/2022 06:50

The right to strike is obviously on the chopping block. But to be honest, I joined the picket lines and national marches on pay and conditions many years back and all that happened as a result was being down a day's pay for every day I joined the strikes.

The goverment ignored us as best as they could, the public loathed us because it inconvenienced them and got them in the shit with their own employers unable to understand that they needed childcare.

So I stopped joining strikes.

What I do now is much more effective for my own mental wellbeing. I effectively work to rule, with some minor exceptions like the odd bit of lesson prep or marking a set of exam papers while watching TV, but I start at 8, finish at 4.30 latest and while I work through most breaks and many lunches I rarely take work home.

The hard bit is saying no and showing work I mean it. I refused to cover for a colleague driven out by the profession in my gained time. I refused to take on extra marking for the mocks for a colleague who was off with stress when I got asked to. I make a note of all the times my "gained time" has been taken off me for intervention, exam cramming, sports days, PSHE days etc. so that when I get asked why the huge amount of work I'm meant to be doing during my gained time wasn't completed I can ask "so when did you want me to do these, exactly"? I also refuse to comply with ridiculous demands that have zero impact, like parking in an assigned spot or having all of my book boxes colour coordinated. I have had open arguments with SLT over workload and some of the more ludicrous demands and I challenge them when it's needed.

The other side of the coin is this: I can do all of these things because I am very experienced, so can plan and fully resource a lesson in 10min, and I am very good at my job in a shortage subject. I get away with a lot, because it would be much more of a ballache for my school to replace me than to accept that I am one of the more "militant" teachers in my school and mostly leave me be. Parents don't complain to the school about me (unless their darlings are one of those), but they do complain about endless cover, marking not being done and generally lack of staff - as they should.

I wish fewer of my colleagues were wet lettuces and did the same, because then things may change for the poor, young, fresh-faced graduates joining our profession who do not know how to stand up for themselves.

TL;DR: striking is mostly pointless these days; more teachers need to work to rule and stop being scared - we are in a strong position now to do this with no one to replace us.

I agree with this. Rather than a full strike i think teachers need to agree with each other to have firmer boundaries and say no to all the pointless ridiculous admin. If there's a shortage than surely the school isn't going to fire them all

donquixotedelamancha · 23/06/2022 11:15

YABU the teachers at my children's school school are crap

Well, we should let the government keep cutting their pay and budgets then, that will fix the problem.

It's definitely the case that it must just be the teachers who are personally crap people rather than problems with the system.

stopringingme · 23/06/2022 10:43

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

nickthefox · 23/06/2022 10:38

YABU
the teachers at my children's school school are crap

oops I meant underpaid and overworked

stopringingme · 23/06/2022 10:37

Well said @Whitehorsegirl if every profession came together and were not comparing who gets what and showed a united front then the government would have to take note.

I will again say - Train Drivers are not on strike ! there is an interesting thread in chat titled Rail strikes, where a member of staff (not a driver !) sets everything out with a detailed explanation which is worth a read.

EvilPea · 23/06/2022 10:27

its just Boris living up to his clown name. He’s trying out new material.
there are no supply teachers
there are no bin men
there are no kitchen staff
there are no vets
there are no lorry drivers
there are no nurses

i could go on.

DogsAndGin · 23/06/2022 10:23

Apparently there’s a post-covid baby boom coming too! This will affect teaching staff disproportionately due to the number of young women who go into teaching - particularly in primary.

I know a primary school with 14 teacher vacancies for September, most of them mat covers. They haven’t found a single temporary cover or supply yet… it’s not looking good!

Teaching is a hard to come-by skill. You can’t just put any old body in front of the class and expect a skilled workforce to pop out the other end of the system in 10-15 years.

It is short sighted to not prioritise teachers.

itrytomakemyway · 23/06/2022 10:14

I taught for 30 years and walked away two years ago. I now do agency temping work in admin posts for less than half of my old salary.

Hell would freeze over before I went back into school. The stress, hours, pointless bureaucracy, shoking behaviour for a minority of students (and sometimes their parents), constant ctiticism from the press and some sections of the public, constant need to 'prove' your worth through endless lesson observations, book reviews, the constant threat that the school may be inspected at any minute, overpromoted managers with little to no teaching experience....... I could go on but my stress levels are rising just remembering it.

I quit teaching before my marriage broke up and my health collapsed. It has taken me two years to get back my sense of self worth. I will never be free of the anxiety it caused me.

There is no army of supply teachers ready and willing to cross a picket line. There are not enough to go in today. As a pp rightly said, those of us who got out of teaching did so with good reason and will never return.

This country needs to take a long, hard look at the state of it's schools. I am seriously concerned about the sort of experience my own grandchildren will have. Don't blame the teachers. The majority give and give and give agan, until they have become broken. I loved teaching - very little beats the pure joy of teaching someone something new and watching them as they understand and grow as learners and as people. But it's not enough. You can't keep exploiting people becuase it is a vocation and then wring your hands and pretend to be shocked when those people cannot take any more.

noblegiraffe · 23/06/2022 10:03

Teacher have the right to strike and can’t be disciplined for this.

They do not have the right to decide not to follow school policy on marking or not attend meetings or whatever.

Working to rule when the ‘rule’ is whatever tasks deemed necessary by your head to discharge your professional duties means you still have to do the vast majority of the massive workload.

We’ve worked to rule before, did anyone notice? I’m not sure the union work to rule instruction was ever lifted, tbh. We still had to mark and plan and assess and attend meetings. What we were told we could refuse to do was organise school trips and clubs. But teachers who wanted to, still could. And because trips and clubs are nice things that teachers want to put on, they still happened.

OP posts:
Walkden · 23/06/2022 10:02

"There should be no right to strike, a person who is not happy with their current pay or conditions can either continue to work whilst negotiating an improvement, or hand in their notice and find a job that suits them better."

This would do nothing to solve recruitment problems in core sectors that we all need.

You approach would only work in a scenario where absolutely all services are run on a free market basis so pay could match demand for those services. Not everyone can afford private healthcare and education etc

Only authoritarian government ban strikes and what you propose is not compatible with British values as they currently stand, even if those values are being flushed down the toilet as we speak.

echt · 23/06/2022 10:00

A massive✊✊✊for noblegiraffe in her tireless support for teachers. Good on yer.

Here in Victoria, similarly afflicted by a lack of supply teachers (though to be fair It's not about utter contempt for teachers, though better pay would be good) they're offering big bucks to teach in the regions and have waived the vaxx requirement to teach, er, anywhere.

I'm recently retired after 43 years and have no desire to dive in the Covid soup when I won't get paid if I go sick. FFS.

StaunchMomma · 23/06/2022 10:00

No way will they pull that off!

Supply teachers are actual teachers so they're well aware how feckin shit it is!

wonderstuff · 23/06/2022 09:57

Kokapetl · 23/06/2022 09:44

I would support teachers striking of course.

However, I do wonder if unions could be a bit more creative with action-short-of-strikes. Perhaps for industrial action days teachers could do things like:

Not do paperwork beyond what is needed for basic safeguarding.
Boycott after school punishments and meetings.
Take a full lunch break.
Not follow the curriculum and not plan lessons, just teach things they find fun and interesting. (If that included things like history of the unions, recent politics, critical thinking, media studies, debate, bias, real colonial history and other things the government doesn't want taught, then good. Although it might end up being lots of sport.)

All this would inconvenience and upset the government and management without upsetting most pupils or parents very much. It might get more people on their side. it could lead to some memorable days at school as well!

I know it won't happen though.

We had action short of strike for a really long time in the 2000s, what happened was that loads of teachers ignored it, because it’s really difficult to be in work with people who are constantly going the extra mile and say ‘I’m not going to do x, y or z’. Unless everyone does it, which they often don’t individuals are seen as difficult or militant. I’m very much of the opinion I should do what I’m paid to do and nothing else unless I want to, but I’m not interested in career progression beyond my current job and have an exit plan, hopefully will be doing something else in a couple of years.

Last time there was a strike quite a few colleagues refused to participate as they weren’t prepared to lose a days wages. I’m often surprised how many teachers have no interest in politics at all, even when it affects their job.

Many teachers are only in a union for the legal protection it gives if a complaint is made against you. Will be interesting to see how ballots go.

user1477391263 · 23/06/2022 09:56

I am intrigued by a PP's suggestion of "working to rule." Refuse to do the piles of paperwork and "extras," stop doing marking and do whole-class feedback instead. What would make this interesting is that we would have an opportunity to see whether all this pointless "make-work" bollocks makes any difference to the kids. My guess is that it does not.

orwellwasright · 23/06/2022 09:54

Dotjones · 23/06/2022 09:30

The media and the government are anti the rail strikes not because they are wrong but because they are right.

Correct, the media and govt are 100% correct to be against the strikes. Allowing small sections of the workforce to hold the rest of us to ransom is plain wrong, and shouldn't be allowed. There should be no right to strike, a person who is not happy with their current pay or conditions can either continue to work whilst negotiating an improvement, or hand in their notice and find a job that suits them better.

Don't get me wrong, I believe that our system is morally wrong and nobody should be forced to work just to have a roof over their head and food on the table. Those things should be basic rights - there should be a universal basic income of £30K per year so that nobody has to work to survive. Obviously those people who claim to love working would be allowed to.

My view is just that inconveniencing the public is not the right way to go about it.

Lol. Reminds me of the dinny poster who said teachers should only strike in the school holidays.

Strikes must cause inconvenience. That's the whole point.

Basically you don't support a worker's right to withdraw their labour. Up to you I guess.

riesenrad · 23/06/2022 09:53

Had the idiotic government not recently taken us out of the world’s biggest trading block, there’d be far more leeway for reasonable wages in the public sector

Had the idiot Cameron not called a bloody referendum which was only ever going to go one way. Twit.

I accept that there were different ways of "getting Brexit done" and we could have at least stayed in the customs union if not the single market, but it was obvious what line Boris was going to take, and still people voted for him.

riesenrad · 23/06/2022 09:51

The government tried the same thing with the railways/tube and initially claimed temp staff would help keep things running during the strikes

Well I think it depends where you live and what rail company it is, but we have a half hourly service on our line today, which is actually better than the Sunday service they ran yesterday! SWR have plenty of practice dealing with strikes though because of the strike by guards before covid. Nothing to do with the government.

In some ways it would be good to see a strike against this vile government, but all of this has been caused by covid (not their fault) and Brexit (partly their fault for pursuing such a hard line Brexit but partly the people who voted for it, and then voted for Boris in the first place "to get Brexit done". No good moaning about the government and Boris if you voted for it! The strike would be for all the wrong reasons.

And also - even if you accept that rail staff are underpaid, who's going to pay the increased wages? People don't want to pay tax. We've just come out of the worst bits of the covid pandemic, and STILL people moaned about the NI increase for the NHS and social care!

If you want decent public services with well paid staff you have to pay the tax. It's that simple.

theworldhas · 23/06/2022 09:48

Brexit will hit workers’ real wages by nearly £500-a-year
www.standard.co.uk/news/politics/brexit-britain-workers-wages-damage-competitiveness-b1007614.html

Had the idiotic government not recently taken us out of the world’s biggest trading block, there’d be far more leeway for reasonable wages in the public sector.