Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take them to court?

131 replies

AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 20:41

I had a car accident 3 months ago. I believe it was not my fault although the other party’s insurance company is not willing to negotiate with my insurance company and appointed solicitors to take me (and the insurance company) to court if I don’t pay the settlement figure.

so i either agree to take them to court, which will be handled by my insurance company and their lawyers but i will have to attend (have no control over how this people will handle the case) or i just agree for my insurance company to pay them but then my car insurance etc might go rocket high and will need to face any other consequences i guess.

i was at the roundabout, three lines when u get to the roundabout, at the roundabout and when u exit the roundabout. You can go straight from all three lines. I was on the third line going straight (second exit). It was very very busy and the other car just jumped in front of me and i hit him. He claims he was next to me and wanted to go to the third exit, but was literally in front of me when i hit him, i hit his rear passenger door, he completely turned around, his wheel came off, back door and bumper was smashed etc. to me he was speeding and entered the roundabout and wanted to make it in front of everyone but it happened so quick i cannot be sure. It is my word against his. No cameras or witnesses.

first picture is from Google map and shows the road when u get to the roundabout
second picture shows the actual roundabout, i was exactly where that white car is when i hit him

To take them to court?
To take them to court?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
Hippopotas · 22/06/2022 22:08

Looking at the signage in the picture you posted it looks like a 2 exit roundabout is that right? In which case I think you may have been in the wrong lane.

AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 22:07

Thank you @NothingIsWrong @AnnaNext
i will have a think and see if i want to take it further then

OP posts:
Ottersmith · 22/06/2022 22:05

Hmm I would say that you would need to be in the left two lanes when going straight on but if you are sure the signs said the right lane was ok for straight in then how can you be in the wrong. If he was going right he should have been in the right lane surely. What does it say in the highway Code book. A court would go by those rules. I say take him to court.

Ginandthings · 22/06/2022 22:05

I went to court over an accident very similar to this as the other person said I was completely at fault, it was settled at 80% their fault and 20% mine as apparently you should be psychic, so I still had to declare it at renewal.
If you have legal cover as part of your insurance then there would be no cost to you, speak to your insurance legal team, use google maps satellite pictures for a birds eye view and walk them through it as they will then recommend what action to take.

NothingIsWrong · 22/06/2022 22:03

There's a roundabout like that near me. Three lanes coming onto the roundabout and all three lanes continue straight on, and signed as such. If you want to turn right you have to be in the third lane as traffic in the third lane is likely to be going straight over. I don't think you were in the wrong.

AnnaNext · 22/06/2022 22:00

I have no experience of taking things like this to court, but from your images and explanations, it looks to me like the only lane you can turn right on the roundabout is the third lane that you were in. The middle lane should have been labelled as ahead only - otherwise this exact accident can happen! If the third lane (that you were in) has a straight-ahead arrow as you approach (as the pictures show it does), then you have to be able to assume all lanes to the left of you are ahead only to be able to use the roundabout safely. I have never seen a roundabout where someone in the middle lane can go right while someone in the third lane can go straight ahead.

Without seeing the road markings on the roundabout it is hard to know if he is at fault, or if it’s just a very badly labelled roundabout. But I can’t see how it’s your fault, as the lane you were in said you could go ahead (and you can clearly see there are three lanes on the exit you are taking, showing there are three lanes from which you can leave the roundabout.

I’ve drawn a very rudimentary diagram showing where I think cars in each lane can go - I’d be fascinated to learn if anyone has come across a roundabout where someone in the green lane can turn right (without switching to the red lane), given red can go straight on!

To take them to court?
Logoplanter · 22/06/2022 21:57

If there were three lanes going straight on leading into and coming off the roundabout you've done nothing wrong in going straight on, providing those lanes don't disappear as you go round the roundabout. Often, but not always you need to move across the lanes to get off the roundabout and the lane that you entered as a straight on lane turns into a right turn lane.

MajorCarolDanvers · 22/06/2022 21:54

Its a normal procedure with insurance companies. Just follow their advice.

underneaththeash · 22/06/2022 21:53

I think you were in the wrong lane, with a roundabout / you change lanes as you go around it. So if you’re turning right, you start off if the furthest lane, then go I to the middle lane before going into the left lane as you exit.
it’s not often well taught and my husband is terrible at it.
but I’d say you’re at fault.

Logoplanter · 22/06/2022 21:53

Also, if he entered the roundabout at the junction after you, and cut across you he'd also be in the wrong as the person on the roundabout has priority.

I wonder if he expected you to be going right, as you were in the inside lane 🤔

AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 21:53

@FemmeNatal Diagram attached. And all three lanes go straight

To take them to court?
OP posts:
Logoplanter · 22/06/2022 21:50

If he entered the roundabout at the same entry as you he wouldn't have been able to turn right from his lane (based on the fact you could go straight on in your lane) which means he would be in the wrong.

AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 21:48

@TokenGinger i am fully aware it is hard to understand me but thank you! Exactly what happened and what i think

OP posts:
FemmeNatal · 22/06/2022 21:48

AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 21:46

i can do a diagram but is it not clear from google map pics?

No, you’ve said that no-one changed lanes, but also that they did.

gogogadgetgo · 22/06/2022 21:48

AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 21:45

@gogogadgetgo can you please ask your instructor if it is the same if the markings on the road are different? Picture reattached.

Well no. I passed and I'm not going to see him again.

I can however refer you to the Highway Code

www.highwaycodeuk.co.uk/roundabouts.html

Were you indicating?

TokenGinger · 22/06/2022 21:47

I don't think you're in the wrong here, OP. I'd take it to court. He can't be in the middle Lane and take the third exit, when that requires going in front of somebody else's path.

The roundabout very clearly says all three lanes go straight on, so there's a high chance the person in the right lane (you in this instance) will go straight on, which then means he had to cut you up and cross your path to take the third exit.

I wouldn't accept fault for this.

AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 21:46

i can do a diagram but is it not clear from google map pics?

OP posts:
AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 21:45

@gogogadgetgo can you please ask your instructor if it is the same if the markings on the road are different? Picture reattached.

To take them to court?
To take them to court?
OP posts:
HangOnToYourself · 22/06/2022 21:43

I hate to be that person but could you do a diagram? I'm struggling to understand

AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 21:42

@Logoplanter i was distressed, 3 months after i cannot be sure where he was because it was busy and out of so many silver cars around i just dont know. I did check my mirrors and everything and it seemed to be safe… i was going also slow because as mentioned it was busy.

It seems like he did enter at the same entry, he was in the middle, i was in the third lane. If he was next to me we entered at the same time.

Please look at the pictures of the roundabout.

@MrsTerryPratchett thanks…

@FranklySonImTheGaffer thank you. I guess i wont go to court if it so hard to understand what i say, it doesnt seem to be straight forward who is guilty and who is not, anything can happen then, it is very upsetting though.

OP posts:
FemmeNatal · 22/06/2022 21:39

AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 20:55

@1dontunderstand but i wasnt changing lanes, neither was he. Is it still my fault then? I am sure he shouldnt be assuming i am going right and not straight as i was able to go straight

If neither of you were changing lanes then how did you hit him?

Did they enter the roundabout from the same road as you, or were one of you coming on from a different road than the other?

gogogadgetgo · 22/06/2022 21:36

My instructor said left and middle lanes for turning left and going over. Middle and right for turning right.

Highway Code diagram looks the same. For going straight over you should be in the left lane. And them turning right should be in the right lane.

That said neither of you saw each other? Were you indicating?

FranklySonImTheGaffer · 22/06/2022 21:30

It's been a while since I dealt with claim liability however, I think it's highly unlikely this is going to result in a non fault claim for you.
You cannot prove he was speeding or that he hit you. It doesn't help at all that you have no idea where he came from or where he was before the impact - based on that, it'll be very hard to dispute his version of events.

Also, if the accident happened as you were passing the exit you intended to take, it is more likely (when the judge considers the probability of both sets of circumstances) that you were moving to take your exit, didn't see him and caused the accident - and if you're leaving your lane to exit, it is your responsibility to make sure there was no traffic coming and you were safe to do so.

When it comes to future premiums, you'll likely find an impact on your premiums regardless of the liability outcome.
If it's fault (whether 2% or 100% liability), many insurers will consider you a bigger risk to cover than you were prior to the accident and will increase prices accordingly.
And if you're non fault, a lot of the pricing research shows you're more likely to have another accident in the next 2 years which again, increases the risk of covering you.

It's always worth going to court to try and fight but you should be aware that there's a good chance you will lose.

Logoplanter · 22/06/2022 21:29

I think it depends where he came from. Did he enter the roundabout at the same entry as you? If a different entry/exit who was on the roundabout first? I'm presuming you were. Could you turn right in the lane he was in if he entered the roundabout at the same place as you?

Can you answer those questions.

MrsTerryPratchett · 22/06/2022 21:28

I'll be honest. In Court you have to be sure and you have to explain yourself effectively. Neither of which are happening here.