Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take them to court?

131 replies

AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 20:41

I had a car accident 3 months ago. I believe it was not my fault although the other party’s insurance company is not willing to negotiate with my insurance company and appointed solicitors to take me (and the insurance company) to court if I don’t pay the settlement figure.

so i either agree to take them to court, which will be handled by my insurance company and their lawyers but i will have to attend (have no control over how this people will handle the case) or i just agree for my insurance company to pay them but then my car insurance etc might go rocket high and will need to face any other consequences i guess.

i was at the roundabout, three lines when u get to the roundabout, at the roundabout and when u exit the roundabout. You can go straight from all three lines. I was on the third line going straight (second exit). It was very very busy and the other car just jumped in front of me and i hit him. He claims he was next to me and wanted to go to the third exit, but was literally in front of me when i hit him, i hit his rear passenger door, he completely turned around, his wheel came off, back door and bumper was smashed etc. to me he was speeding and entered the roundabout and wanted to make it in front of everyone but it happened so quick i cannot be sure. It is my word against his. No cameras or witnesses.

first picture is from Google map and shows the road when u get to the roundabout
second picture shows the actual roundabout, i was exactly where that white car is when i hit him

To take them to court?
To take them to court?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
B0ssAssB1tch · 22/06/2022 23:28

It's not really up to you though. It's up to your insurance company whether they take it to court. If you don't really know how the accident happened and aren't sure of the road layout then it's probably going to settle on whatever basis your insurance company decides rather than go to court. The good news is though there's no reason why you personally will have to pay the costs. Just let your insurance company handle it. Your premiums will be affected the same regardless of how much they pay out. All they're interested in is whether a claim has been made on the policy.

Lou98 · 22/06/2022 23:27

It's been a few years since I left but I used to work in motor claims and I think it would be quite unlikely you would be found non-fault in this situation.

From what you've said, it sounds like you were in the right lane and he was in the wrong lane so while he is also partially liable, failing to check your mirrors and make sure it was safe to go also makes you partially liable. You said you didn't see him until you hit him so you must not have checked properly. While the percentage of fault may go more in your favour with him having a higher liability, it's unlikely you would have no liability.
It's also impossible to prove speed so it doesn't matter if you think he was speeding or not if you can't prove it.
Do you have any witnesses at all that would help in your favour?

If non fault there is no consequences in terms of high insurance going forward

This also isn't true unfortunately. A claim in your insurance, regardless of fault or non fault, can (and usually does) affect the next years premium as it still needs to be declared

SunflowerGardens · 22/06/2022 23:19

llamadramapolli · 22/06/2022 22:58

Oh god, I've went back and looked. And maybe it was him in the wrong lane!! Argh this is frustrating, I can't for the life of me work out who is in the wrong!

He was in the wrong lane, realised he was in the wrong lane, tried to nip into the right lane, it didn't succeed. Most sensible people wouldn't go straight in the third lane though but you should be able to if the signage says you can without someone ploughing into you.

Rookiemistake · 22/06/2022 23:17

He is in the wrong lane OP. I don't see how he could argue otherwise. If he wanted to turn right then he needed to be in the third lane.

AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 23:15

I dont have any better pics besides the ones from google map but i guess i should drive up there and check it just in case before i make a decision

OP posts:
NoWordForFluffy · 22/06/2022 23:11

I agree. I want to see the road signs, even though the markings appear to support the OP.

llamadramapolli · 22/06/2022 22:58

Oh god, I've went back and looked. And maybe it was him in the wrong lane!! Argh this is frustrating, I can't for the life of me work out who is in the wrong!

Bummocks123 · 22/06/2022 22:56

I feel like I need to see the full sinage for entering the roundabout. If it says you can go straight on in the third lane then surely it should also say you must be in the third lane to turn right. Otherwise you are just going to get this accident happening as the person in the third lane has to either go all the way around the round about or stop to avoid cars going right in the second lane, which is ridiculous.

I'd start further back, find out which entry he used and try to prove he was in the wrong lane using the signs and road markings.

llamadramapolli · 22/06/2022 22:53

AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 20:53

Just to make it clear.

green line is the other car and red line is me. I hit him where lines crosses

Just seen this. Yeah you were in the wrong lane.

llamadramapolli · 22/06/2022 22:52

AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 20:47

@HappilyHadesBound great advice. As soon as i can go back in time i will sure do it.

@custardbear yes, from what he is saying he was in the middle lane going to the third exit and i was in the third lane going to take the second
exit

So you were in the third lane nearest the roundabout coming off at second exit. And he was in the middle Lane wanting to come off at third exit.

Sorry maybe I'm being dim but that makes no sense to me. Surely you were in the wrong lane then? You should have been in the first or second lane if coming out on the second exit? And he was fine to be in the middle lane to come off of third exit.

Why would you go in the very inside lane when going straight through? Maybe I've misunderstood but if not then I would say it's your fault.

Beachsidesunset · 22/06/2022 22:52

If the roundabout was too busy for you to check your blind spot and exit safely, you should have continued round and tried again.

MadeForThis · 22/06/2022 22:49

It sounds like he should have been in the third lane.

LIZS · 22/06/2022 22:45

@ILoveAllRainbowsx possibly. That also depends on road markings, did he join at same point as op or was he about to filter over?

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 22/06/2022 22:42

@LIZS

But he was in the wrong lane if he was turning right.

Mulhollandmagoo · 22/06/2022 22:41

I'm not sure if I'm looking at it correctly, but it looks to me like you were in the wrong lane? I could be wrong but if you were, you'll be a little bit stuck unfortunately 😣

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 22/06/2022 22:40

NothingIsWrong · 22/06/2022 22:22

This is the one near me, it's jn9 of the M40.

As you can see, three lanes all signed to go straight on over the roundabout down the A34. If you want to turn right to go M40 north you MUST be in the RH lane as traffic in the third lane can be going straight over.

Once you are off the roundabout the third lane merges with the second to make two lanes going down the A34, but there are very definitely three lanes on the roundabout all going straight over.

For those who know it, this is coming from Bicester, going over the top of the M40 towards Oxford.

If this is correct then he was in the wrong lame if he was turning right.

LIZS · 22/06/2022 22:38

Are there any painted road markings showing the three lanes all filtering straight on . If not the rh lane would normally be for taking a later exit , even if there are three lanes at straight on exit, and you should have changed lane to exit.

ChagSameachDoreen · 22/06/2022 22:35

AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 20:47

@HappilyHadesBound great advice. As soon as i can go back in time i will sure do it.

@custardbear yes, from what he is saying he was in the middle lane going to the third exit and i was in the third lane going to take the second
exit

Don't be so rude to people who are trying to help.

SunflowerGardens · 22/06/2022 22:33

Not sure it's worth the hassle of going to court, you're probably going to have to accept some of the liability anyway.

PurpleChairs · 22/06/2022 22:28

OP I understand exactly what you're saying. The road markings clearly state you can go straight on in all 3 lanes. You were not wrong.

I have a similar set up near me and I triple check my mirrors on that roundabout as it's an unusual road layout and I want to avoid the exact this incident!

AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 22:27

@NothingIsWrong it happened at J13 so very close.

OP posts:
TruthHertz · 22/06/2022 22:24

underneaththeash · 22/06/2022 21:53

I think you were in the wrong lane, with a roundabout / you change lanes as you go around it. So if you’re turning right, you start off if the furthest lane, then go I to the middle lane before going into the left lane as you exit.
it’s not often well taught and my husband is terrible at it.
but I’d say you’re at fault.

No, you don't 'change' lanes in terms of literally cutting across. What was the middle lane becomes the left lane when the previous left lane feeds off into an exit. But you're still driving in the same lane without having crossed any lines.

This is demonstrated in the below pic where the middle lane becomes the left lane after the first exit

To take them to court?
NothingIsWrong · 22/06/2022 22:22

This is the one near me, it's jn9 of the M40.

As you can see, three lanes all signed to go straight on over the roundabout down the A34. If you want to turn right to go M40 north you MUST be in the RH lane as traffic in the third lane can be going straight over.

Once you are off the roundabout the third lane merges with the second to make two lanes going down the A34, but there are very definitely three lanes on the roundabout all going straight over.

For those who know it, this is coming from Bicester, going over the top of the M40 towards Oxford.

To take them to court?
indoorplantqueen · 22/06/2022 22:09

I think you were both in the wrong lanes, so equally at fault.

FemmeNatal · 22/06/2022 22:08

AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 21:53

@FemmeNatal Diagram attached. And all three lanes go straight

That suggests that you changed lanes, hitting him. If, as I think you said, you hit him on the side of his car then I think you’ll bear most of the blame.