Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take them to court?

131 replies

AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 20:41

I had a car accident 3 months ago. I believe it was not my fault although the other party’s insurance company is not willing to negotiate with my insurance company and appointed solicitors to take me (and the insurance company) to court if I don’t pay the settlement figure.

so i either agree to take them to court, which will be handled by my insurance company and their lawyers but i will have to attend (have no control over how this people will handle the case) or i just agree for my insurance company to pay them but then my car insurance etc might go rocket high and will need to face any other consequences i guess.

i was at the roundabout, three lines when u get to the roundabout, at the roundabout and when u exit the roundabout. You can go straight from all three lines. I was on the third line going straight (second exit). It was very very busy and the other car just jumped in front of me and i hit him. He claims he was next to me and wanted to go to the third exit, but was literally in front of me when i hit him, i hit his rear passenger door, he completely turned around, his wheel came off, back door and bumper was smashed etc. to me he was speeding and entered the roundabout and wanted to make it in front of everyone but it happened so quick i cannot be sure. It is my word against his. No cameras or witnesses.

first picture is from Google map and shows the road when u get to the roundabout
second picture shows the actual roundabout, i was exactly where that white car is when i hit him

To take them to court?
To take them to court?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
Jessbow · 23/06/2022 07:08

I think you are totallyat fault, trying to exit a rundabout from lane 3

Where you have quite clearly assumed that you can in effect drive across two lane of traffic ( also on the roundabout) to get to your exit, regardless of where they are going.

Icedlatteplease · 23/06/2022 07:03

What does he say happened

NumberTheory · 23/06/2022 06:48

I think you stand a good chance in court if his statement says he was in lane 2 and intending taking the third exit and that the accident happened in lane three. Unless otherwise signposted, it is incorrect to take the second lane of a three lane roundabout for the third exit.

I also think, from your description of where the damage occured on his car, if it happened in lane three there is no way for that to have happened without it being his fault. To hit his rear driver door in your lane, he must have moved into you when there wasn't space, cutting you off. It's not as though you rear ended him. Unless he's claiming he was moving over, stalled (or otherwise was stopped dead before fully moving into the lane - which you shouldn't be doing on a roundabout, you go into the innermost lane you need and make your way to the outside as you approach your exit - and you came along with plenty of time to break but rammed his stationary car instead!)

If your insurance company is prepared to take this to court, personally I think you should. You don't really have much to lose and it looks, to me, like you're right.

It's possible the reason the other insurance company hasn't settled is because the other driver is a dick and cannot fathom he is a shit driver, so has refused to accept his insurance company's initial suggestion they pay out. It doesn't necessarily mean that insurance company thinks it's your fault.

Zigzagzoozoo · 23/06/2022 06:47

I would say that that is your fault. Sorry. You shouldn’t be exiting the roundabout from the third lane because it involves cutting straight across two other lanes of traffic.

startfresh · 23/06/2022 06:37

TokenGinger · 22/06/2022 21:47

I don't think you're in the wrong here, OP. I'd take it to court. He can't be in the middle Lane and take the third exit, when that requires going in front of somebody else's path.

The roundabout very clearly says all three lanes go straight on, so there's a high chance the person in the right lane (you in this instance) will go straight on, which then means he had to cut you up and cross your path to take the third exit.

I wouldn't accept fault for this.

100%. You were in the straight ahead lane, you were going into a three lane exit road. He undertook and cut across your exit.

I can't see how he isn't in the wrong tbh. You may not have checked blind spot bur he cut you up, you didn't change lane so why do people think you're more at fault?! Odd.

ittakes2 · 23/06/2022 06:19

I see what you mean now - we have a similar lane at our local roundabout and it drives me crazy as people assume its OK to go one way due to the markings and other people assume its OK to go one way due to the markings but they will crash if they don't look out for each other.
I would settle if I was you - he was being a dick but you hit him and sounds like he was also following his road markings.

BadNomad · 23/06/2022 06:14

NothingIsWrong · 23/06/2022 05:34

Not helped by the road markings not matching that though...

The road markings are old markings for when the 1st lane was left-turn only. This is the road sign in 2009.

To take them to court?
ittakes2 · 23/06/2022 06:02

I think we need a mini video please with toy cars to show what happened!

ittakes2 · 23/06/2022 06:01

I am very confused if neither of you were changing lanes then how did you hit him?

NothingIsWrong · 23/06/2022 05:34

BadNomad · 23/06/2022 02:41

See my beautiful diagram.

These are the lanes with appropriate exits, then what you and the other car tried to do. You were both in the wrong lanes for where you wanted to go.

The three lane exit is confusing you because the left lane is MK only (it bypasses the next roundabout), and the other two lanes lead to another three-lane roundabout.

Clear as mud, right?

Not helped by the road markings not matching that though...

BadNomad · 23/06/2022 02:41

See my beautiful diagram.

These are the lanes with appropriate exits, then what you and the other car tried to do. You were both in the wrong lanes for where you wanted to go.

The three lane exit is confusing you because the left lane is MK only (it bypasses the next roundabout), and the other two lanes lead to another three-lane roundabout.

Clear as mud, right?

To take them to court?
BadNomad · 23/06/2022 01:27

Unfortunately, this is your fault. You were in the wrong lane for going straight on, so when you tried to go straight you crossed into another lane and hit the other car. He was in the wrong lane for turning right, but it was your lack of observations before crossing into his lane that caused the crash.

Fifthtimelucky · 23/06/2022 01:17

I'd say the other driver was definitely in the wrong lane and ideally you'd have been in a different lane too. Presumably like you, the other driver found it was too busy and couldn't change lane either.

It is not uncommon for people to end up in the wrong lane on roundabouts, in my experience, but when they do they should be aware of it and drive carefully, making their intentions very clear.

It sounds like both of you were to blame to some extent. Him, because he was speeding, and you because it sounds like you weren't paying enough attention to other traffic if you didn't see him until you hit him. Also, you haven't said whether you were indicating or not. The other car would have had good reason to assume you were carrying on round the roundabout if you weren't indicating that you were coming off it.

I also don't understand how, if he zoomed ahead of you on your inside, you hit his rear passenger door rather than the rear door on the driver's side.

HappilyHadesBound · 23/06/2022 00:50

@ChagSameachDoreen thank you!

It was advice for the future, not a suggestion for time travel... 

The point is you might think it's too late now, but as I said, it's happened to us twice in a few months so really important.

NothingIsWrong · 23/06/2022 00:42

It does look like the road signs do not match the road markings though, so clearly I don't remember as well as I thought!

all three lanes marked on the road for straight on. But the sign says middle and LH only. However he should have been RH to turn.

I would think 50:50 is the best you'd get as the sign says you were both in the wrong lane, although the lane markings say otherwise.

To take them to court?
Youcansaythatagainandagain · 23/06/2022 00:30

TokenGinger · 22/06/2022 21:47

I don't think you're in the wrong here, OP. I'd take it to court. He can't be in the middle Lane and take the third exit, when that requires going in front of somebody else's path.

The roundabout very clearly says all three lanes go straight on, so there's a high chance the person in the right lane (you in this instance) will go straight on, which then means he had to cut you up and cross your path to take the third exit.

I wouldn't accept fault for this.

I don't understand how three lanes can all go straight when there is a high probability that some cars will want to go right which means they have to cut across the cars on their right unless they are in the 3rd lane only themselves.

NothingIsWrong · 23/06/2022 00:05

However, you still hit him rather than the other way round, so you may still have done liability even if you were at the first roundabout and in the correct lane to go straight on.

NothingIsWrong · 23/06/2022 00:04

The other option is that you were back a roundabout and had just left the M1?

In which case I think you are right in the all three lanes are A421, with the RH lane only signed to turn right up the A507. This pic is a bit more blurry.

At the first roundabout after you exit the M1, to either turn hard right up the A507 or turn partially right to immediately rejoin the M1, you have to be in the RH Lane

I know that jn reasonably well and would say if you were approaching the FIRST roundabout off the M1 you are correct to be able to go straight on in the RH Lane and he was in the wrong lane.

if it's the SECOND roundabout after leaving the M1 you cannot go straight on for MK in the RH lane.

To take them to court?
Rollercoaster1920 · 22/06/2022 23:55

The OP has driven into the side of a vehicle whilst leaving the lane of a roundabout. No way you'll get no fault.

The other driver may have been in the wrong lane, but they were ahead of you and you drove into them instead of stopping or staying in the lane on the roundabout and continuing round.

I see this too much with cyclists on roundabouts, going all the way round on the outer lane because they are slow. It's legal, but not very safe.
OP: you're going to have to accept some of the blame here. I wouldn't go to court. Also 50:50 vs 70:30 probably makes no difference apart from pride.

NothingIsWrong · 22/06/2022 23:54

I think that is the junction where all three lanes are signed for the A421, but you are joining the A421 and it goes both ways from the roundabout.

so LH lane is straight on for the A421 to MK. RH Lane is turn right to the A421 to Bedford. Middle lane you can either go to MK or turn for Bedford, as RH Lane is Bedford only.

So you saw A421 on all lanes, thought you could use the RH lane for MK, and he was in the middle lane for Bedford so turned?

To take them to court?
Basilbrushgotfat · 22/06/2022 23:42

Oh and I would expect the highway code to take precedence over a poorly designed roundabout - at least until there's a significant test case at court.

HangOnToYourself · 22/06/2022 23:40

Which junction is it? An aerial pic from google maps might help?

Basilbrushgotfat · 22/06/2022 23:40

He was absolutely in the wrong lane.

Arguably, you were too.

Based on the principle that you keep left for exiting up to 180°, right if you go beyond 180° and stay in the middle lane if you're going straight on.

Given that the exit you took, op, had 3 lanes then you could argue you were positioned correctly.

He was more at fault though, because if he'd been in the correct lane you wouldn't have collided and because on a roundabout cars on the right take priority.

Yes to poorly designed roundabout.

I'm not legally trained at all, btw, it's just my interpretation based on the highway code as I was taught by my instructor.

I can see why it's disputed. I think its either a case of dual-fault or you're in the clear. Given that its going to court though, I'm not sure I'd be expecting you to be completely exonerated.

AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 23:37

@B0ssAssB1tch the insurance company is waiting for me to decide if i want to go to court ot not. They will handle it of course but i would have to show up at court too. At least it is what they said

@Lou98 thank you. Fyi - no witnesses

OP posts:
AnxietyLevelMax · 22/06/2022 23:32

More pics from google trip. Well i guess we were both wrong. I really dont understand how can you have three lanes go straight, you take an exit and you still have three lanes…nothing merges there.

i needed to get to A421. I am assuming i could change the lane after i exit the roundabout but it all seems to be just too complicated

To take them to court?
To take them to court?
To take them to court?
OP posts: