Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My brother refuses to move out

188 replies

tryingtohelpmyparents · 22/06/2022 19:46

Name change.

My brother is 37. He has always lived at home. Pre covid; he was travelling mostly the states on a specific visa (can't remember which one.... b1?) anyway, he was only home for like a month, then away back over again for 3-4 months at a time. Covid hit and he's found himself stuck at home.

Since this time, he has been incredibly troubled. I worry I may offend here but I'm saying as it is...

He says he's depressed. However he only treats my parents like absolute shite. He does nothing in the house and expects everything to be handed to him. He acts like everything is fine, and I'd honestly say he is his usual self to his friends.

He is very manipulative to get his way. My parents are late 60s and honestly I think they are verging on a stroke or heart attack. Believe me when I say this, they are at breaking point.

They have asked him to leave, says he won't as he has mental health issues and can't manage on his own.
They have offered to buy him a place, he refuses.
They have tried calling various groups, police (when he's in one of his aggressive outbursts), social services and no one helps. Just tell my parents to ask him to leave which he refuses to do.

Lately my dad booked them a holiday and my brother wanted to go. So he booked it. My brother paid. The night before the holiday, he had an outburst and refused to go. Ironically he survived in the house for 3 weeks absolutely fine despite claiming he can't live on his own.

My parents have been home less than a week and he's kicked off again. Claims my dad is aggressive and is a bully. He's anything but.

My brother is on medication but always taps the doctors all is fine. He smokes weed and vapes loads.

It's now at the stage my parents are fighting (verbally) with each other.

I'm worried about my parents. But I don't know what to do. He refuses to leave and says he will commit suicide if he's forced to leave. My parents fully believe he would do it.

He is a musician by trade so he does some work for his commissions, but half the time he blames my parents aggression as the reason he falls behind on work.

He hates my parents but he refuses to leave. He's got it good at home. I've seen how he manipulates the situation, makes my parents out to be the bad one when it's honestly him and his moods. I honestly think he might be bipolar.
He has counselling but he says it's a waste of time. He claims he had a life of bullying from my dad. He didn't and I know that for a fact.

What can we do? No one seems to want to help.

OP posts:
Ottersmith · 22/06/2022 21:45

Sounds like he needs DBT and has a personality disorder. If he doesn't get help then it shouldn't be up to other people to put up with his behaviour. You know that the only option is for them to force him out. Otherwise he will make their life miserable until they die. They'll have to tell him if he doesn't get therapy then he has to move out.

alwaysmovingforwards · 22/06/2022 21:42

Change the locks and leave his stuff in bin liners on the lawn an option?

Nothappyatwork · 22/06/2022 21:41

pixie5121 · 22/06/2022 21:31

Oh wow, I'm in exactly the same situation.

A sibling in his mid thirties who is living at home, claims he can't cope alone because he's autistic (like me), has ADHD (like me) and anxiety (like me). I've had a hard life so far but have tried my hardest to help myself, spent a fortune on therapy and have a decent job. He seems to expect my parents to sort his life out and still blames them for the way his life has turned out, despite being 35.

My parents are terrified to throw him out because every time he leaves, he ends up in some shit and they're afraid he'll die.

Funny how it's always men who act like this, isn't it?

Everything you’ve described there is my daughter to an absolute tee so I bought her house, she lives in it, pays rent from which which I pay all the bills and she’s as happy as Larry she literally could not wait to move out there was no way she was staying living with me for the rest of her life, her exact words.

she’s 21

Tangled123 · 22/06/2022 21:32

The brother staying at home is a symptom of the problem, not the problem itself. Treating it might be a better idea than just kicking him out by force. I don't know if 37 is too late for it, but OP's brother needs to start doing things for himself. Doing his own laundry, cooking for himself, paying own bills, wifi password changed etc. Brother needs to learn staying with parents isn't an easier life than making his own way. Parents need to start acting as if he isn't there and maybe he'll get the hint. Bonus points if they walk around the house naked or have stupidly loud sex within earshot of him.
Alternatively, maybe he needs to see a doctor?

pixie5121 · 22/06/2022 21:31

Nothappyatwork · 22/06/2022 21:10

Why the fuck would you inflict this on some poor woman my god that’s no solution.

Yes....fucking hell....why would anyone think some poor woman should have to deal with this?

pixie5121 · 22/06/2022 21:31

Oh wow, I'm in exactly the same situation.

A sibling in his mid thirties who is living at home, claims he can't cope alone because he's autistic (like me), has ADHD (like me) and anxiety (like me). I've had a hard life so far but have tried my hardest to help myself, spent a fortune on therapy and have a decent job. He seems to expect my parents to sort his life out and still blames them for the way his life has turned out, despite being 35.

My parents are terrified to throw him out because every time he leaves, he ends up in some shit and they're afraid he'll die.

Funny how it's always men who act like this, isn't it?

independentfriend · 22/06/2022 21:29

Another option: sell the house (assuming it's a bigger house that's too big for your parents in retirement). Your parents can then buy a retirement home and reconsider buying him a flat. Has the advantage that they might be able to conceal their new address from him.

A further option, if your parents have lots of money: they move out into their preferred retirement property and he's left in the house on his own.

whynotwhatknot · 22/06/2022 21:27

theyre not being forceful enough- what exactly do they tell the police they need to say they want him removed from their house theyre frightened of him not just say can you come round please

hes a manoulative twat he knows exactly what hes doing-how can he say he wont cope alone when hes been travelling abroad

Watapalava · 22/06/2022 21:22

To be honest OP it sounds like no one has a backbone here

understandably there are concerns but your parents have options - they’re not using them and that’s their issue

they are enabling your brother

so are you! Go no contact with him

do something to prove your point

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 22/06/2022 21:18

@tryingtohelpmyparents - that is too bad. Because if he goes they need to get a restraining/non molestation order and change the locks when he is gone. But if he does not go, I would suggest you support your mother to see her GP to discuss her stress. She sounds like the key here. Although both have been enabling him, sorting out visas and stuff. Nevertheless, however much your dad does to get him to the US, he still has to manage by himself when he is there. And managed when they were away. So sorry for you all, this is an awful situation.

sausagerole · 22/06/2022 21:16

OP the reason no-one can help your parents is because they won't follow any of the avenues that are actually open to them. I'm not saying it's not heartbreaking for all involved, but there are definite ways to enact firm boundaries here with your brother.

Your parents need to understand that they cannot control your brother's behaviour. They can only do what they feel is right and let him make his choices. I can't understand why they're saying he 'won't accept' a rented flat. Of course he won't - he's happy where he is! But if that's what they want to do to ensure he has the best possible chance of safety, then they need to orgnise it and then evict him/change the locks. The problem is they are trying to control all the outcomes so they know he is happy and safe, which is totally understandable, but your brother is using that to manipulate them, so they need to accept that they can't control the outcomes and can only do the best they can and let your brother make his choices from there.

ComfyChairPose · 22/06/2022 21:12

Is there internet at home? cut that off.
Would your parents sell the house?
If I were in this situation I think I'd do that. Cut off internet and sell the house from under him. i know they shouldn't have to and don't want to...

Nothappyatwork · 22/06/2022 21:10

Maurepas · 22/06/2022 21:09

People are MADE to leave properties all the time - as in divorces and unwelcome guests. How do you think women get divorced/separated and make their husbands/partners leave the home/a property as part of the break up arrangement and many women have to do this alone by themselves and protect young children too?
Regarding suicide - it is always a risk but a person at 37 has to take some responsibility for themselves. Why has he not got a GF he can live with etc?

Why the fuck would you inflict this on some poor woman my god that’s no solution.

Nothappyatwork · 22/06/2022 21:10

tryingtohelpmyparents · 22/06/2022 19:52

They've done this several times before. The police never get involved.

I find that very hard to believe actually because my daughter got really upset and I was very concerned about her and called for an ambulance and instead of an ambulance I had 3 bloody police officers turn up on my doorstep.

Seraphinesupport · 22/06/2022 21:09

his excuses are bull as at some point they will pass in, then what is he planning to do? he will be alone anyway. might as well learn to live by himself now rather than later. Tosser

Maurepas · 22/06/2022 21:09

People are MADE to leave properties all the time - as in divorces and unwelcome guests. How do you think women get divorced/separated and make their husbands/partners leave the home/a property as part of the break up arrangement and many women have to do this alone by themselves and protect young children too?
Regarding suicide - it is always a risk but a person at 37 has to take some responsibility for themselves. Why has he not got a GF he can live with etc?

WhatNowwwww · 22/06/2022 21:07

tryingtohelpmyparents · 22/06/2022 19:59

They were going to do this! They were going to even buy him a place, but he refused to leave.

They need to make it their decision not his. Persuade your Mum that she can visit every day if she wants to and you’ll check on him as well. She can write to his GP so they’re aware he’s not well and living alone.
If they sort a flat and move his stuff while he’s out. Change the locks, then he’s gone. It’s up to him whether he goes to the flat or a park bench. I’d make sure I was there if I were you when he returns to the house. Offer him the keys explain that’s where his stuff is. He’s had plenty of warning that he wants welcome, if he kicks off ring the police. They won’t leave him on the doorstep kicking off.
It’s the only way I can see working OP.

Kennykenkencat · 22/06/2022 21:06

tryingtohelpmyparents · 22/06/2022 20:04

No joke, my dad wanted to sell up and buy a 1 bedroom flat!

I was going to say if he won’t move out then they should.

If he thinks his parents are such terrible people why does he live with them?

I would call out anything he said against your parents. Tell him he doesn’t mean what he says. He must think they are brilliant parents as he lives with them.

tryingtohelpmyparents · 22/06/2022 21:06

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 22/06/2022 21:02

So your brother can arrange visas to work in the US and manage himself there but cant live in his home town or city? Is your mum able to see the ridiculousness of this? As for MH - as someone who worked in psychiatric hospitals I think this is a red herring. True mental health problems are not so convenient - people don't only have them when they are not getting their own way. He may have some mild problems, but I think the causes of his behaviour are more likely to be entitlement, selfishness and weed.

My dad has to arrange that for him - he wouldn't have a clue!

He's meant to being going back next week but we know he won't go! He's starting this episode now to get out of going!

OP posts:
oviraptor21 · 22/06/2022 21:03

Sort out the alternative flat.
Change the locks on parents house when he is out.
Give him keys and help him settle into new flat. Is it possible for you to help him with this part?
Get non-mol order on parents house if necessary.

Dixiechickonhols · 22/06/2022 21:03

Is he going to go back to USA? I’d be very tempted for them to downsize to a 1 bed flat/bungalow in a over 55 development whilst he is away.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 22/06/2022 21:02

So your brother can arrange visas to work in the US and manage himself there but cant live in his home town or city? Is your mum able to see the ridiculousness of this? As for MH - as someone who worked in psychiatric hospitals I think this is a red herring. True mental health problems are not so convenient - people don't only have them when they are not getting their own way. He may have some mild problems, but I think the causes of his behaviour are more likely to be entitlement, selfishness and weed.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 22/06/2022 21:01

Next time he threatens suicide, call 999 and get the police and ambulance service involved.

Amethystbluexo · 22/06/2022 21:01

OP you address everything but changing the locks. Tbh that sounds like the only thing that will work for your parents Sad

SeaToSki · 22/06/2022 20:59

If you have POA for your parents, that helps

Here is my suggestion, which is probably too far fetched, but maybe an element in it will help you craft your own plan

Find a rental for him and rent it, pay a month or so up front (then your mother doesnt need to worry about him being out of the streets). Put basic food in the fridge and sheets on the bed (again for your mothers benefit)

Apply for a non molestation order for them and make sure it specifies stating away from their house (if possible)

When its enforced, send your parents away for the weekend (with new cell phones so he cant call them), take your brother out for lunch and tell him he is not coming back to the house and give him the keys to the new rental. Tell him you will drop all his possessions off for him and that there is a court order for him to stay away. Tell him the locks will be changed and he will not have access (if you are v organized, have a lock smith at the house while you are at lunch).

If he causes problems, use the police and keep your parents away until he calms down a bit.

Cross your fingers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread