Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My brother refuses to move out

188 replies

tryingtohelpmyparents · 22/06/2022 19:46

Name change.

My brother is 37. He has always lived at home. Pre covid; he was travelling mostly the states on a specific visa (can't remember which one.... b1?) anyway, he was only home for like a month, then away back over again for 3-4 months at a time. Covid hit and he's found himself stuck at home.

Since this time, he has been incredibly troubled. I worry I may offend here but I'm saying as it is...

He says he's depressed. However he only treats my parents like absolute shite. He does nothing in the house and expects everything to be handed to him. He acts like everything is fine, and I'd honestly say he is his usual self to his friends.

He is very manipulative to get his way. My parents are late 60s and honestly I think they are verging on a stroke or heart attack. Believe me when I say this, they are at breaking point.

They have asked him to leave, says he won't as he has mental health issues and can't manage on his own.
They have offered to buy him a place, he refuses.
They have tried calling various groups, police (when he's in one of his aggressive outbursts), social services and no one helps. Just tell my parents to ask him to leave which he refuses to do.

Lately my dad booked them a holiday and my brother wanted to go. So he booked it. My brother paid. The night before the holiday, he had an outburst and refused to go. Ironically he survived in the house for 3 weeks absolutely fine despite claiming he can't live on his own.

My parents have been home less than a week and he's kicked off again. Claims my dad is aggressive and is a bully. He's anything but.

My brother is on medication but always taps the doctors all is fine. He smokes weed and vapes loads.

It's now at the stage my parents are fighting (verbally) with each other.

I'm worried about my parents. But I don't know what to do. He refuses to leave and says he will commit suicide if he's forced to leave. My parents fully believe he would do it.

He is a musician by trade so he does some work for his commissions, but half the time he blames my parents aggression as the reason he falls behind on work.

He hates my parents but he refuses to leave. He's got it good at home. I've seen how he manipulates the situation, makes my parents out to be the bad one when it's honestly him and his moods. I honestly think he might be bipolar.
He has counselling but he says it's a waste of time. He claims he had a life of bullying from my dad. He didn't and I know that for a fact.

What can we do? No one seems to want to help.

OP posts:
getupstandupsitdown · 22/06/2022 22:58

Could they sell up and move into a retirement flat?

averythinline · 22/06/2022 22:51

If your parents won't do anything how can any outside agency do anything ..?
For your own sanity id be nipping the moaning from your parents in the bud as there's nothing you can do either....
Look up circles of influence....yoj cannot change your db behavior and equally not your parents ..so you need to try and disengage..

Your parents are choosing this all you can do is reflect that back to them..personally I wouldn't even discuss it anymore...and think about why u would cook for him if he did move to a flat....thats really strange...
Sounds you all think hes a child

Porcupineintherough · 22/06/2022 22:45

@Laurajane1987 just because you have a poa for somebody doesn't mean you can act on their behalf unless they have lost capacity. Nothing that the op has said has suggested that this is the case here.

My mum and I had poa for my dad who had dementia and we still have a hell of a battle to get my brother out of his house, despite the fact that he (brother) was robbing my dad blind because my dad said he was happy for him to be there.

tryingtohelpmyparents · 22/06/2022 22:44

RedorangeyellowBLACK · 22/06/2022 22:35

What a horrible situation for your poor parents especially at an age when they should be able to relax and enjoy retirement.
Your db is being an arse but is also obviously struggling with mental health issues (happy, content grown men don’t treat their parents like crap or want to live at home with them). It’s all been made worse by the weed (I have this in my family, severe mental health issues exacerbated by cannabis smoking).
Is their garden large enough to take a cabin? As a temporary option could they have one built in the garden for your brother to live?
At least that way he won’t be in the actual house with them and they would have that little bit of space (and can lock the doors to show him this is their space and the cabin is his) and in the meantime get some family counselling to help them all sort through this.
Looks like it’s not a situation which will get resolved easily without some help with his mental health issues (and he really needs to get himself off the weed, he is obviously one of those people the drug is not suitable for).

They had their own wee cabin which he took over and is now stinking of weed, despite my parents asking him not to do it in there.

OP posts:
Laurajane1987 · 22/06/2022 22:41

If you have POA over your parents there's obviously a reason for that. That also means that it's your responsibility to deal with the situation because it seems they are incapable. The police in Scotland definitely will get involved if you use the correct phrasing and do it calmly. Point out the record of your other calls, mention the coercive and abusive behavior. Point out who owns the house, they no longer want him there and he needs to be removed, your parents have reduced capabilities and you hold power of attorney. If you have a flat set up for him to be removed to that's one less hastle for them to deal with. Then follow up quickly with a non molestation order, all I see in your replies is multiple excuses. If he was going to kill himself he'd have done it already. He won't and if he tries it will be superficial but an excellent road into accessing hospital mental health care (which he obviously requires for whatever the hell it is he's got going on)
As the eldest sibling there have been so many times where I've had to bite the bullet and be 'the bad guy' this is one of those times. Your mum might be a bit miffed but will come round, dad will be thankful and brother? Well he can spit his dummy out for as long as he likes.
If you don't want to do any of that and your mother won't allow other intervention then you need to tell her not to bring it up with you again, ever. If they won't take the advice or action required to deal with it they can't then moan and whine at you all the time that isn't fair.

ventreàterre · 22/06/2022 22:36

Your mother is going to have to accept that he's an adult and he's being abusive. Eventually, he'll have to stand on his own feet, to some degree. What does your mother thing will happen when she passes away? He has to learn to manage at least the basics on his own sooner or later. (And he clearly can. He just doesn't want to!)

It will be a hard pill for her to swallow, but as long as she gives in to his adult tantrums, nothing can change. He's getting what he wants and is too shameless to stop taking advantage. He's a grown man with a support network of family able to offer financial assistance. That's more than many people have!

pixie5121 · 22/06/2022 22:35

wellhelloitsme · 22/06/2022 22:20

Would it help your mum be less soft if you reframed her behaviour?

By enabling him, she's not allowing him to hit rock bottom.

With that safety net in place, unable to hit rock bottom, there's zero reason in his eyes to change.

Remove the safety net and maybe he will / maybe he won't. But at least he's had a chance to.

His behaviour is tantamount to abuse, in their own home. It's horrific.

Where does he get money for weed?

But sometimes reaching rock bottom means dying. Especially where mental illness or neurodiversity are concerned. Would you really be happy to kick your child out if you thought they might die?

RedorangeyellowBLACK · 22/06/2022 22:35

What a horrible situation for your poor parents especially at an age when they should be able to relax and enjoy retirement.
Your db is being an arse but is also obviously struggling with mental health issues (happy, content grown men don’t treat their parents like crap or want to live at home with them). It’s all been made worse by the weed (I have this in my family, severe mental health issues exacerbated by cannabis smoking).
Is their garden large enough to take a cabin? As a temporary option could they have one built in the garden for your brother to live?
At least that way he won’t be in the actual house with them and they would have that little bit of space (and can lock the doors to show him this is their space and the cabin is his) and in the meantime get some family counselling to help them all sort through this.
Looks like it’s not a situation which will get resolved easily without some help with his mental health issues (and he really needs to get himself off the weed, he is obviously one of those people the drug is not suitable for).

MontanaMountains · 22/06/2022 22:32

If your parents are not on board with trying to evict him (and it sounds as if your mother is not) then you're wasting your breath.

It's always sons isn't it? I've never heard of a daughter behaving the same.

MakeItRain · 22/06/2022 22:29

It sounds like your mum feels very guilty and anxious about what would happen if they force him to leave. So I would be telling your mum that in the long run that this situation is making things incredibly difficult fir your brother. Say that she and your dad won't be able to care for him forever and that if this carries on they are making it impossible for him to live independently. And that the day he needs to do that WILL eventually come no matter what she feels about it. I would tell her that the best time for this to happen is NOW, while you're all healthy and able to support him.

Look for a small place for your parents and a small place for your brother and get them to push ahead with a move. Look up agencies that can support your brother if he begins to have mental health problems and show them to your mum.

I think it sounds like you need to push her (kindly but firmly) into making a move and your best way to do that is to emphasise the huge negatives and risk for your brother of things remaining as they are.

BitBehind · 22/06/2022 22:28

Saying he will kill himself is abusive btw. It all is. But that especially. Its more than being a shit, its coercive and controlling and your poor mum and dad can get help. But it will be incredibly hard of course as I'm sure the last thing they want to do is get him in trouble

Siepie · 22/06/2022 22:28

Your parents have options, especially if they have the money to buy or rent somewhere else for him to live. It will be emotionally hard to kick their son out but, ultimately, if they're not willing to do that, then there's nothing that anyone else can do.

GoldenSongbird · 22/06/2022 22:27

My friend's parents had this situation with her brother. They made an appointment with his GP and told the GP that he was suicidal. They called the police when he threatened suicide and when he had aggressive outbursts. The police did eventually remove him from the house and took him for an emergency psych evaluation. He was then admitted to hospital.

My other friend had a similar situation. Again, the police removed her brother from the house. Kept him in the cells overnight - he had been aggressive and it spilled into the street meaning he could be held on breach of the peace. Then sent him for an emergency psych evaluation. He wasn't admitted to hospital - because he wasn't suicidal just manipulative - but he went to stay elsewhere rather than going home to his parent's house because he realised his manipulation didn't work any more and he didn't want to risk another night in a police station or a hospital.

When your brother goes out, your parents could change the locks and bag up his stuff. He doesn't have a 'right' to stay in their house. They're entitled to put him out and if they can't do it physically then they're entitled to make it difficult for him to re-enter when he leaves.

BitBehind · 22/06/2022 22:26

This is abuse. Children to parent abuse is one of the fastest growing domestic abuse dynamics due to a) increasing number of adults children living with parents b) parents unwillingness to call it abuse in case they get their own child arrested. Look up CPV. A blog called holes in the wall. There is a charity called safelives who operate in Scotland who do stuff on this and might be as to help or know who would.

The police will only get involved properly if they're willing to call it abuse. But if your mum is scared of him she can legitimately call a domestic abuse service for support.

If they're not willing to go down that avenue as feels too extreme then I don't have any other suggestions that haven't been suggested but adults being abused and fearful of their own adult sons is more common than you think and domestic abuse services should provide support.

Domestic abuse is as simple as being scared and controlled by a loved one, partner, ex or family member.

RustyShackleford3 · 22/06/2022 22:24

I empathise with you OP. I also have a brother who leeches off my parents and treats them like shit. Funnily enough, he also got mixed up in drugs. Seems to be the common theme...

Anyway, the truth is, you can't solve this problem. Your parents have to want to deal with this themselves. You can help them, you can work with them, but you can't make them do it.

Sounds like you dad wants him out but your mum isn't really on board. It's up to your Dad how far he's willing to go.

I would honestly leave it to them. I know it's hard, but there is nothing you can do.

Inkyblue123 · 22/06/2022 22:23

Next time he threatens subside call 999 and have him sectioned. I had a family member suffer psychosis from smoking weed. It’s the only way to get him in the system and out of the house. It may sound extreme but it does sound like you have run out of options,

wellhelloitsme · 22/06/2022 22:20

Would it help your mum be less soft if you reframed her behaviour?

By enabling him, she's not allowing him to hit rock bottom.

With that safety net in place, unable to hit rock bottom, there's zero reason in his eyes to change.

Remove the safety net and maybe he will / maybe he won't. But at least he's had a chance to.

His behaviour is tantamount to abuse, in their own home. It's horrific.

Where does he get money for weed?

CuppaTeaAndSammich · 22/06/2022 22:16

I agree with PPs, change the locks on the house and refuse to let him back in. If they don't want him homeless, they could still buy him a flat, give him the keys to it and change locks to their own house and refuse entry to him. He will have no choice but to live in the flat.

My family and I had a similar situation recently, except it my brother broke up with his ex and she refused to leave his flat. It got so bad they couldn't live together and he stayed between my mum and dad's houses while she squatted in his flat and locked him out his own flat which HE owns, not her. Got the locks changed on the flat whilst she was in there, she kicked off and with the support of the police, we kicked her out and have reclaimed his flat.

icelolly12 · 22/06/2022 22:13

How does he have the money to fund all this travel? I'd be booking him a one way plane ticket then changing the locks

Quitelikeit · 22/06/2022 22:12

I wonder if he’s getting all food, laundry, cleaning done etc

also I wonder if he is getting money from your mother?

get him a three month rental - discuss with your mother first

consider telling his friends and see if they can talk to him

Adicar · 22/06/2022 22:07

Make living there uncomfortable. Cut off the WiFi and TV subscriptions. No dinners or clothes washed. Maybe tell the rents to explore their sexuality loudly and often.

pixie5121 · 22/06/2022 22:02

Kidsaretryingtodestroyme · 22/06/2022 21:57

I cannot believe there are so many people in my situation. I genuinely thought it was just me. My D’B’ is just like this but the situation has more mileage. He’s in his early 40s and refuses to leave. He’s also a weed smoker. He also threatens to kill himself and treats my parents like shit.

Twice my parents have managed to get him out. Once with the help of the police (he can become very aggressive), and in retaliation he called mum from the streets. He’d deliberately got a tent and slept outside to manipulate mum into having him back.

The second time she ended up paying all his rent and food shopping and it became too expensive so he came back. They’re 80 now and on the verge of divorce. Dads had enough but mum won’t agree to throwing my brother out.

They walk on eggshells in their own home. I have no doubt DB is trying to wait it out until they die so he can get the house. I used to get involved as mum would always complain but she won’t do anything about it so I no longer listen and have distanced myself. I have to protect my own mental health.

I have several friends with brothers like this. Always brothers, never sisters.

They seem to just blame the rest of the world for their failures instead of looking in the mirror. In every case, all the other siblings have moved out and are doing fine, but the loser is still at home, still blaming their parents for everything that ever went wrong. My brother acts as if my parents somehow invited him there, and they don't want him to leave, when the opposite is true.

I think it has something to do with the role of men in society. In previous generations, useless fuckers like this would have been palmed off on some poor woman to look after. Now that women are independent and able to choose, nobody wants them, and so they're just eternal children, sponging off Mum and Dad.

Kidsaretryingtodestroyme · 22/06/2022 21:57

I cannot believe there are so many people in my situation. I genuinely thought it was just me. My D’B’ is just like this but the situation has more mileage. He’s in his early 40s and refuses to leave. He’s also a weed smoker. He also threatens to kill himself and treats my parents like shit.

Twice my parents have managed to get him out. Once with the help of the police (he can become very aggressive), and in retaliation he called mum from the streets. He’d deliberately got a tent and slept outside to manipulate mum into having him back.

The second time she ended up paying all his rent and food shopping and it became too expensive so he came back. They’re 80 now and on the verge of divorce. Dads had enough but mum won’t agree to throwing my brother out.

They walk on eggshells in their own home. I have no doubt DB is trying to wait it out until they die so he can get the house. I used to get involved as mum would always complain but she won’t do anything about it so I no longer listen and have distanced myself. I have to protect my own mental health.

pixie5121 · 22/06/2022 21:57

Ottersmith · 22/06/2022 21:45

Sounds like he needs DBT and has a personality disorder. If he doesn't get help then it shouldn't be up to other people to put up with his behaviour. You know that the only option is for them to force him out. Otherwise he will make their life miserable until they die. They'll have to tell him if he doesn't get therapy then he has to move out.

But there's a decent chance he'll die, and will that be any easier to live with?

This is what my parents have to think about every single day, because my cunt of a brother feels entitled to live off two pensioners in their late sixties.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/06/2022 21:52

He doesn't know this but I have POA

Unless your parents have lost capacity - and it doesn't sound as if that's the case - your POA doesn't prevent them acting for themselves, so there's no knowing what they may allow themselves to be talked into

As PPs have said, if they're not both on the same page nothing will change, so really there's little point suggesting things if the answer's always "Ooooo I can't"

You wouldn't be unreasonable to ask them to stop moaning to you though ...

Swipe left for the next trending thread