Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is my neighbour?

263 replies

Barbiepink · 22/06/2022 19:16

While I was at work today I asked my dad if he would be able to come round and trim the ivy/weeds that are growing in our back garden.
He said he would.

I went to work, my dad messages me and tells me he’s done it.

I got home and went into the garden to check out the work.
My next door neighbour came out and told me in no uncertain terms that my dad had cut ivy from their side of the fence as well and he’d pulled it out by the roots.
She said she’d spent 20 years growing it in the way she wanted it to be.
Her husband said she’s been crying all afternoon.

I said I was so sorry and it wasn’t my intention, it was my fault for not communicating what I wanted correctly to my dad. I just wanted the weeds pulled out and the ivy trimmed back as it was starting to grow up through the paving slabs.

Anyway, they were very upset and on the war path.

I went out and bought her some flowers to say sorry and she nearly didn’t accept them, then did, even though she said she was still so upset she couldn’t talk about it.

I hate confrontation and I feel really uneasy tonight now. I’m not sure what to do for the best.

OP posts:
WellTidy · 23/06/2022 11:31

If they want ivy in their garden, and many people do (our neighbour is one), then they should contain it and keep it under control.

If they didn’t, then you are able to pull it from your side or cut it back. It all gets intertwined as a PP said, there is no way you’d be able to do this without also pulling some of the growth from their side. But if they’d kept it under control, you wouldn’t have to.

Our neighbour’s ivy got so out of control (a few years’ uncontrolled growth), that it had a massive trunk and needed a saw and an axe to chop through it. They’re really keen gardeners, pride and joy, but that doesn’t dictate how we can use our garden (the fence our side was covered). It took hours, I would doubt your dad did this.

It absolutely will grow back. It grows rampantly and everywhere. And there has been no damage/loss to them by the sound of it, so unlikely to be any sort of claim there.

viques · 23/06/2022 11:30

Where does your dad live and how much an hour does he charge to kill ivy? Asking for a friend………………

007DoubleOSeven · 23/06/2022 11:24

Take you to court, for ivy??

I think they're being a bit batshit tbh
Who cries all day over ivy and then refuses a genuine apology?

Leave them to it.

It doesn't sound like your dad did anything wrong.

SmartCarDriver · 23/06/2022 11:20

ImAvingOops · 22/06/2022 19:35

Ivy is a fucking menace. She has no business growing something that is damaging your property, then whinging when you remove it!
Besides, it will grow back in about 5 minutes!

This 100% it's fucking horrible invasive stuff!

P205 · 23/06/2022 11:18

They won’t take it to court.

unfortunately, you can’t unring a bell. You e apologized, so just draw a line under it and move on. There’s nothing else you can do really.

milkyaqua · 23/06/2022 11:16

Barbiepink · 23/06/2022 07:55

This morning they’re throwing all the ivy cuttings from their side into our garden.

Well, that would seem to indicate your father did do a lot more than he said he did. I'm not surprised they are upset.

Squills · 23/06/2022 11:14

I would buy them a really nice large ivy plant and a garden voucher.

Tiani4 · 23/06/2022 11:14

I meant

  • No one will believe he pulled it out by the roots their side as he never leaned over but rather there was an overgrown tangle of Ivy that your Dad trimmed on your property from your side.

How Ivy grows is that the vines wind in and out the fence slats so by his lawful cutting the parts on your side it may have been in the middle of some of the vines that had invaded into your property garden - that can't be helped as neighbours will know full well this-

They could have unwound the vines each year and retrained it (hard to do tho) away from growing between the fence slats.

Tiani4 · 23/06/2022 11:07

@Barbiepink
I think it is unlikely they can sue as they freely admitted to you they have cut the Ivy their side now as well so how can it be legally determined that it was your Dad not they who damaged their side of the Ivy plant. No one will believe he pulled it out by the roots but rather there was an overgrown tangle of Ivy that your Dad trimmed from your side.

And if it turns out to be your fence you'd have a counter claim that they were damaging your fence by letting the Ivy become invasive (although I wouldn't go there unless they attempted to sue you! It'll likely cost them more to sue than they'll get back so I doubt they'll actually do it!)

Your legal line is your Dad cut back the Ivy that grew on your side which you have a legal right to do as it was over the boundary interfering with your property and garden.

I wouldn't volunteer any of the rest other than to say you listened and responded to neighbour with kindness to keep good neighbourly relations if they bring up why you brought flowers round then. My neighbour killed my Ivy in back garden boundary (my fence!) as it was growing through into his greenhouse which was up near boundary. He put weed killer on it and the fence (my fence!) then fell apart as the Ivy had been keeping it up! I had to replace the fence panel Grin I didn't say anything to him though as i appreciated his perspective that it was an invasive nuisance and grows fast! I planted a small tree there instead Smile

Campervangirl · 23/06/2022 11:06

It was nice if you to buy her some flowers and you’ve apologised, whether you needed to is depatable as your dad said he he didn't pull it from their side, he may have got hold of some roots from your side and inadvertently pulled some from their side.
As for it taking 20 years to grow "how they wanted it" is complete bollocks, ivy grows how it wants and it grows fast.
I have a fence covered in ivy and I pulled it down where it was growing up the wall of the house a month ago and it's already starting to creep back up the wall, it's a menace 😁
I'd ignore the issue, if it's mentioned again just say I've apologised if you were upset but your ivy was invading my property, the next time it needs trimming I will be sure to liaise with you.
End of ❤️

fatfrenchprick · 23/06/2022 11:05

Your neighbour need to get a grip, she also needs to make sure her plants stay in her garden.

My neighbour grows ivy and it's almost collapsing my fence.

SurpriseSurprise · 23/06/2022 11:01

Why didn’t they speak to your dad when he was doing it if he was upsetting them that much

BlanketsBanned · 23/06/2022 11:01

Look at your Deeds or speak to your solicitor to determine whose fence it is, ivy doesnt die overnight.

AdobeWanKenobi · 23/06/2022 10:58

I’ve been trying to grow ivy into a fence with Virginia creeper for 4 years. It’s still tiny. I’m quite jealous of all your rampant plants here.

Tiani4 · 23/06/2022 10:57

Barbiepink · 23/06/2022 10:29

@ColadhSamh I don’t really know whose fence it is. We moved in about 4 years ago and they have lived there for around 30 years.
it’s an unusual set up as they’re yards, not gardens and they have low fences.

The key part is whose fence is it. If it is your fence then their growing Ivy in it may be damaging the fence and you can say they need to remove it sue to the damage. However I wouldn't argue over a fence!

Your Dad had every right to cut back what was growing in your side but he should not have been pulling it through the fence as that was a plant on their side ! Your NdN is unreasonable to throw their side Ivy debris over the fence - you can bag that up and deposit it back at front of their house to return it. But I probably wouldn't do that as it'll aggravate them.

Look- I've learnt not to let my Dad loose in my garden, as some Dads tend to get carried away in hacking back things and not think about taking care over plants and impact on the plants.

(I try to supervise my Dad and say stop now (!) when he gets hacking too much as he's the "Dad killer of mature shrubs"!! Although he helped me sort my Ivy out very effectively!!)

I don't think you need to apologise anymore than you have. As others said it'll grow back fairly swiftly!

You can look up your deeds (it's about £7 to get an official copy) from this website (don't go to other websites as they charge extortionately for same thing) to try to find out who owns the boundary fence that side

www.gov.uk/get-information-about-property-and-land/copies-of-deeds

Barbiepink · 23/06/2022 10:55

I just spoke to a friend and they said that the neighbours might try and get compensation or take us to court.

Does that sound likely?

OP posts:
Lightningrain · 23/06/2022 10:51

It sounds like a massive overreaction on the neighbours’ part.

What do they expect you to do when it’s growing through into your garden and damaging your flags?

I hate the stuff and our garden was overrun with it when we bought the house. It still tries to grow back every year even though we’ve pulled as many roots out as we can.

MangoBiscuit · 23/06/2022 10:48

20 year old ivy growth got pulled through the fence by your Dad? Unless he's the hulk, I call bullshit.

tulips27 · 23/06/2022 10:45

@Barbiepink Oh I see, well that's different then , I suppose. Difficult situation. You probably shouldn't buy anything if that's the case.

stayathomegardener · 23/06/2022 10:33

If it's a low fence it can't be a 20 year old common ivy.

A domestic variegated variety would pull out pretty easily and could be sentimental.

Many in gardens I see we're indoor floral gifts that have been planted outside.

Throckmorton · 23/06/2022 10:31

To be fair, ivy can take decades to reach the stage of flowering, which is when it's really useful for pollinators etc, so theoretically the 20-year stuff isn't as mad as it sounds. However, there is no way your dad managed to pull out 20-year-old ivy roots without noticing, so it sounds like she's exaggerating there!

Agapornis · 23/06/2022 10:30

"he had damaged theirs and they’d all started dying, or something like that."

Total bullshit, ivy does not start wilting within a day. I wouldn't buy them anything you've done your best, but definitely don't buy an ivy plant, you'll just end up with the same problem. Maybe a clematis.
I've just tackled a quarter of 20 year old ivy with a chainsaw and loppers because it was destroying the fence and I couldn't access the shed. I've drilled in glyphosate ecoplugs to the stumps in my garden and it's still nowhere near dead. Neighbour whinged a bit, but I will replace it with a climber that's easier to maintain...eventually.

Barbiepink · 23/06/2022 10:29

@ColadhSamh I don’t really know whose fence it is. We moved in about 4 years ago and they have lived there for around 30 years.
it’s an unusual set up as they’re yards, not gardens and they have low fences.

OP posts:
ColadhSamh · 23/06/2022 10:24

Whose fence is it? You said they have trained it to around both sides of the fence, if so did you agree to that for your side?

stayathomegardener · 23/06/2022 10:17

Gardener here, something isn't adding up.

Is it common wild ivy or a special domestic variety? Variegated leaves or similar.

DH severed a 50+ year ivy round the base of an ash tree this winter, it took 8 weeks to see the leaves start to wilt because they are so waxy.

I recently cut a cultivated ivy back from round a property, put some stems in a pot to take cuttings, forgot and they still looked fresh several weeks later.

Their ivy definitely shouldn't be on your side, can you post a non identifying picture?