Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is my neighbour?

263 replies

Barbiepink · 22/06/2022 19:16

While I was at work today I asked my dad if he would be able to come round and trim the ivy/weeds that are growing in our back garden.
He said he would.

I went to work, my dad messages me and tells me he’s done it.

I got home and went into the garden to check out the work.
My next door neighbour came out and told me in no uncertain terms that my dad had cut ivy from their side of the fence as well and he’d pulled it out by the roots.
She said she’d spent 20 years growing it in the way she wanted it to be.
Her husband said she’s been crying all afternoon.

I said I was so sorry and it wasn’t my intention, it was my fault for not communicating what I wanted correctly to my dad. I just wanted the weeds pulled out and the ivy trimmed back as it was starting to grow up through the paving slabs.

Anyway, they were very upset and on the war path.

I went out and bought her some flowers to say sorry and she nearly didn’t accept them, then did, even though she said she was still so upset she couldn’t talk about it.

I hate confrontation and I feel really uneasy tonight now. I’m not sure what to do for the best.

OP posts:
SmartCarDriver · 23/06/2022 12:31

FictionalCharacter · 23/06/2022 12:03

Neighbour is overreacting but nobody should interfere with plants on someone else’s side of the fence, whether or not they are wild plants or if you don’t like them.
We value the ivy in our garden. Birds nest in it, and in the winter it’s an important food source for birds.

That's great, but if you're my neighbour I don't want your plants on my side of the fence, growing in my garden.

Ivy is horribly ugly and destructive.

SilverBirchWithout · 23/06/2022 12:31

From your description it sounds like an ornamental ivy growing back and forwards through a low wire fence creating an attractive screen.
On this thread others are imagining a huge invasive dark green monster.
Which is it OP?

RosieRoww · 23/06/2022 12:29

Ivy is growing like a crazy, it hardly took 20 years imo.

SmartCarDriver · 23/06/2022 12:27

Meraas · 23/06/2022 12:25

Or is my neighbour?

Why would you think your neighbour is being unreasonable, OP?

YABU for not supervising happening in your home, saying you weren’t there is no excuse.

This morning they’re throwing all the ivy cuttings from their side into our garden.

Good for them.

Are you the batshit neighbour? WinkWink

Knittedfairies · 23/06/2022 12:25

Unless your dad is Superman I doubt he pulled the ivy out by the roots. It gets into a tangled mess; it took us weeks to get rid of the thug growing up the outside of our house. It looked pretty, but it had grown under the slates on the roof and bent a gas pipe while my back was turned.

Meraas · 23/06/2022 12:25

Or is my neighbour?

Why would you think your neighbour is being unreasonable, OP?

YABU for not supervising happening in your home, saying you weren’t there is no excuse.

This morning they’re throwing all the ivy cuttings from their side into our garden.

Good for them.

MinnieGirl · 23/06/2022 12:25

This is ridiculous!
Ivy is a nightmare, and does not take 20 years to grow….
You have apologised for causing upset and given them flowers. Which you didn’t need to do.
Do not accept any liability. Your dad was clearing the Ivy your side as you are entitled to do as it’s such a destructive plant. End of….
But look at your deeds and find out who owns the fence….. if it’s you, tell them you don’t want any ivy in your fence as it will destroy it.

WilsonMilson · 23/06/2022 12:23

Your neighbours sound unhinged, and I wouldn’t be pandering to their nonsense.

It’s ivy ffs, it is an invasive weed will grow back quickly - as for them cultivating it the way they wanted it for 20 years, what melodramatic bullshit.

The weeping and wailing about it too - load of old cobblers. I wouldn’t entertain any more of their shite and I certainly wouldn’t be giving flowers or grovelling.

Ofcourseandyouknowit · 23/06/2022 12:20

@Barbiepink sounds very frustrating, but if I had to guess from what you’ve described - there is something else going on in your neighbour’s personal life that for whatever reason she doesn’t feel able to react to appropriately. It’s easy to psychoanalyse from a distance but when someone is that upset about something that possibly didn’t even happen- there’s usually more too it.

Who knows what it could be but top candidates for what’s really going on: fight between neighbour couple that hasn’t been resolved so they are teaming up against a common external “enemy”; bad diagnosis of one of them or a loved one which they feel they have no control over; a recent death in the family they haven’t been able to come to grips with. Grief psychosis is a thing.

I wouldn’t worry too much more about it for now, just avoid them for a bit and let the calm down you’ve done all you can do.

Choccyp1g · 23/06/2022 12:20

Barbiepink · Today 09:32
They told me yesterday that they cut the bits off their side because where my dad had pulled some by the roots he had damaged theirs and they’d all started dying, or something like that.
It winds around the fence on both our sides , but my neighbour has trained it like that, so that t grows in that way.

So they've been storing half their ivy in your garden?

FictionalCharacter · Today 12:03
Neighbour is overreacting but nobody should interfere with plants on someone else’s side of the fence, whether or not they are wild plants or if you don’t like them.

by the same token nobody should poke their plants through the fence into their neighbour's garden.

LakieLady · 23/06/2022 12:17

Barbiepink · 23/06/2022 07:55

This morning they’re throwing all the ivy cuttings from their side into our garden.

Oh dear. I'm afraid I'd be pretty pissed off if a neighbour left a load of cuttings in my garden, after cutting back a plant I didn't want cut.

I certainly wouldn't want to have to take it all to the tip myself!

TollgateDebs · 23/06/2022 12:04

You can pull Ivy by the roots until the cows come home, it will be back. It strangles other plants, pulls moisture and the weight breaks fences, destroys tree and can make branches break before their time. Give it a month or so and it will be back!

FictionalCharacter · 23/06/2022 12:03

Neighbour is overreacting but nobody should interfere with plants on someone else’s side of the fence, whether or not they are wild plants or if you don’t like them.
We value the ivy in our garden. Birds nest in it, and in the winter it’s an important food source for birds.

Notagain76 · 23/06/2022 11:58

I spray my fences at the bottom with weed killer at the back of our house, all my fence but neighbours like to grow ivy so I’m always killing it. Same neighbour also thought it was ok to use my tree to support their tree house, soon put a stop to that. They also put tarpaulin on my fence as a sort of gazebo, I took that straight off throwing their staples back in their garden which didn’t go down well. Use to get on with them then heard them bitching about us.

EvilPea · 23/06/2022 11:54

im quite pro ivy it is great for pollinators and wildlife, helps cool buildings and stops damp.
however it is a thug and needs to be managed.

they are being unreasonable by the way and what they are saying doesn’t ring true. If he didn’t get into their side, theirs will recover within a few weeks.

managing it going forward. Cut all the stems off at the bottom, it will die back naturally on your side. Theirs will try to climb up and over your fence and then back to the floor (if that makes sense) so every so often trim the ones coming over the top, they won’t reach your ground and root.

Cookiecrumble22 · 23/06/2022 11:52

SmartCarDriver · 23/06/2022 11:20

This 100% it's fucking horrible invasive stuff!

Totally agree its awful. Should not ge allowed.

She should be more understand about her wonderful ivy is intervering with your garden /fencing.

Rosehugger · 23/06/2022 11:48

It'll grow back in about two weeks. It's hardly a precious delicate flower that has been destroyed. They are being unreasonable.

astoundedgoat · 23/06/2022 11:48

FallopianTubeTrain · 22/06/2022 19:28

He could have aimed a nuclear missle at it and it'll all be back by the end of the week. Your neighbour will get over it, you apologised, nothing more you can do.

On the flipside my neighbour and I have a coordinated battle plan to destroy the masses of ivy that grows down the boundary line, it takes both of us tackling from either side to even remotely make a dent in the evil shit.

Speaking as someone fighting a WAR against ivy right now, I concur.

Also, if she'd been cultivating it for TWENTY YEARS your Dad would need a feckin' bulldozer to get it out by the roots. It would be the thickness of his leg at this point.

It'll be back the way it was by September. Small consolation to you though! Is it originating on your side or theirs?

Libre2 · 23/06/2022 11:47

Choccyp1g · 22/06/2022 19:52

Where do you live ? If it's anywhere near me, I'll pay your Dad good money if he can get the ivy out of my garden.

This. But I bet my bottom it’ll be back - it always is.

Your neighbour sounds either (being generous) like a. she has a lot of other stuff going on in her life and this has tipped her over the edge or b. She doesn’t have anywhere near enough going on in her life and needs some outside interests.

You have been more than reasonable.

jessycake · 23/06/2022 11:41

I have living in my house for over 30 years and never been able to pull next doors ivy from the roots , and it's not for want of trying. Don't pander to this nonsense , he has pulled a few strands that were growing through your fence and possibly thinned it a little on her side . Tell her if she doesn't want it to happen again she need to make sure she keeps it regularly trimmed including the bits that creep through and under the fence.

SmartCarDriver · 23/06/2022 11:40

Well, that would seem to indicate your father did do a lot more than he said he did. I'm not surprised they are upset.

The the neighbour should stop their shitty ivy growing on OPs side!

Crying over ivy is ridiculous.

KatharinaRosalie · 23/06/2022 11:39

as others have said, there's no way one can accidentally pull up a 20 year old ivy by roots. No way.

Julen7 · 23/06/2022 11:38

Ivy is a complete menace and neighbours should be thanking your dad not berating him.

SmartCarDriver · 23/06/2022 11:34

viques · 23/06/2022 11:30

Where does your dad live and how much an hour does he charge to kill ivy? Asking for a friend………………

😂

So am I......

catsmother · 23/06/2022 11:33

What a load of nonsense. It's clear your neighbours have very little understanding of ivy and its growth pattern

I had a fence replaced a few years ago which had been covered in ivy and three burly builders dug down at least two foot to try and eradicate the roots. What they eventually extricated was as thick as my thigh and even though they pulled up loads I was still finding offshoots from the main stems for quite some time afterwards when I was digging the new bed.

In other words there is no way, no way at all, that your dad would have been able to wreak the havoc they allege simply by casually pulling a few strands through the fence. If he managed to disturb and remove any root matter at all then they must have been fairly new tendrils which hadn't deeply imbedded themselves yet.

I've pulled ivy before now and have been sent flying hard and painfully onto my backside due to the effort required to get it out of the ground - and that's newish stuff, not a twenty year old monster.

Like previous posters I've also sawn larger bits of ivy off at the root, and though that works on the existing leaves, they do take quite a few weeks to brown and wither. It doesn't happen overnight. Ditto when I've resorted to weedkiller. What's more, it's a bastard for regrowing from any tiny bit of root left behind.

Your neighbours sound utterly hysterical and ridiculous. Of course, it's upsetting when the appearance of your garden is changed / ruined at someone else's thoughtless hands, I understand that, but in this case I just can't see, logically, that your dad would have literally been able to do the damage he's being accused of.