Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give up on Grade 7 applications (civil service)

56 replies

savebuckbeak · 22/06/2022 15:31

I've been an SEO in a policy role in the CS for about 2 years and have been applying for Grade 7 roles for a few months now both internally through EOIs and externally. Had 2 unsuccessful interviews and just feeling very dejected. I've got mentors I work through stuff with, get involved in a lot of corporate/strategy stuff, have refined my behaviours examples hundreds of times, gotten advice on them, prepared strengths answers and generally done A LOT of career building stuff. In interviews I talk about leadership, strategy, work programmes I've led and delivered through others, how I've challenged and negotiated and convinced stakeholders to do x y z. Literally don't know what to do going forward and any nuggets of advice about any of this very welcome.

OP posts:
horsesforcoursess · 12/07/2022 10:10

So I think you can link your answers back to the strategic objectives of your current dep. Also maybe think of some questions that you can ask at the end of the interview eg 'what do you think are the biggest challenges for this dep in the next 2 years?' or 'how is the cost of living crisis affecting the work this dep does'.

I would also ask someone you trust/respect to comment on what they think your skills gaps are. I found that really useful.

But keep positive and remember that CS applications are a numbers game. Also check if there is a lead behaviour and if so really focus in on it - when choosing between similar candidates it often comes down to that.

Ooh and also do as much sifting and interviewing as poss - this makes it so much easier to visualise what a good/bad answer looks like.

CthulhuInDisguise · 12/07/2022 10:01

I got my G7 in 2018 after a year of undertaking a temporary promotion on a specific project, and many applications during that period. I'm now trying for my G6 and it's tricky. The inconsistency on how Success Profiles is used doesn't help - some are looking for experience answers and some for competencies, and I find it hard to know how to draft the application.

I have had some excellent advice from my mentor, about how to think strategy when drafting. Tying in strategic aims to projects and showing how I've led a team and negotiated, but at a step removed from the nitty gritty. So not about what you have done in a process but what the outcome was and the issues that you encounter. I have also taken part in a reverse mentoring scheme which has helped me to reflect on my leadership practice and given me more examples. It's a hard slog though and SEO to G7 is a massive change from doing the job to leading the team and handling ministers and external stakeholders at that level.

savebuckbeak · 12/07/2022 09:55

@horsesforcoursess This is helpful, thanks! But in behaviours-based interviews, how would you recommend I demonstrate my interest in the department?

I do already work quite closely with ministers in my current role, and line manage 2 people, but will definitely try to develop more in these areas.

OP posts:
horsesforcoursess · 12/07/2022 09:54

I work in policy and recently moved to a G7 role after 2.5 months yrs as SEO. I would second making a sideways move - I took a sponsorship role for 12 mths which gave me massive responsibility for my grade, I worked with ministers and N10. This made the transition to G7 much easier.

I think you need to work out your gaps e.g leadership, working with ministers etc, and work out ways to get this experience. I would also advise in an interview to make sure you really understand the departments wider strategic objectives and how they fit in with this gov'e policies eg levelling up. There is def a risk that if you focus too much on the star examples, and not on the job/department, you can come across as just interested in promotion and not the actual job.

Hope that helps!

savebuckbeak · 12/07/2022 09:52

Ah, classic civil service "you need to be in XXX grade for 75 years before moving."

Sorry, I don't mean to be unkind, but it's just so common in the civil service and I'm not sure why. Many of my friends and colleagues have made the jump from HEO to Grade 7 within 3-4 years.

OP posts:
StellaGibson2022 · 11/07/2022 23:30

appreciate this isn’t my thread but really appreciate all the responses here. Really good advice and it’s making me feel more positive

TheDepthsOfDespair · 11/07/2022 21:56

DH started as an AO and is now a grade 6, working his way up over 20+ years. Ones of the hardest jumps was SEO to G7, it took him ages and eventually it was through being on temporary promotion and then applying for that role when it was advertised as a substantive post. The next step up to G6 was really quick.

always ask for feedback after interviews, preferably a proper discussion rather than a general email. And go for the job not the grade. Keep going and remember it takes ages sometimes.

SalterScales · 11/07/2022 21:25

Really interesting thread. I'm a grade 7 and I was an SEO for 12 years. My roles during that time were largely policy but I also did an ops and delivery post too. During those 11 years I built up experience of policy development and delivery and the span of activity that covers, running a consultation, being part of a bill team, financial management of projects worth several million, intergovernmental negotiations and line management of big and small teams, some of which threw up some very challenging to navigate issues. This breadth and depth of experience stood me in good stead when I eventually decided to make the leap to G7 because I had so much to draw on.

My first thought on reading your post OP was that I can't see how 2 years at SEO would give you the breadth and depth of experience required to hit the ground running at G7. Are you clear on what the core skills are which are required to operate as a G7 in the areas in which you're applying? If you are clear, can you demonstrate them all with some really robust examples which stand up to scrutiny when interviewers start to scratch beneath the surface? I find that when I interview these days, a lot of candidates come along with high level, impressive sounding statements, but when you ask follow up questions, there's no real substance there - usually due to a lack of experience. Not saying that this is you - but may be worth thinking about if you haven't already.

MintUmbrella · 11/07/2022 20:42

Talk to your LM and ask them to help you set up some mock interviews so you can practise.

seemsikeaniceday · 11/07/2022 20:38

@savebuckbeak you are not hearing what I am trying to tell you. Focus on your job, not the tick boxes you think will get you a promotion.

Do you have tasks you’d rather not do? do you have tasks you don’t know how to do? If you get through your tasks do you offer to take some of your managers work? Do you think ahead for your manager and make their life easier?

If you answer yes to the first two and no to the second two then you have scope in your current role to gain more knowledge and experience.

savebuckbeak · 11/07/2022 19:22

Hi all! I know this thread is from a while back but also wanted to ask - is there any specific training, certifications, learning or anything you could recommend? Obviously I am doing everything possible in my role to get more experience etc but any ideas for any formal or even informal learning would be really helpful.

OP posts:
seemsikeaniceday · 30/06/2022 01:40

StellaGibson2022 · 30/06/2022 00:58

@seemsikeaniceday I hope you are right but this is not my first sideways move and have been an SEO for nearly 12 years. The past 4 years I feel I have completely wasted as I’ve worked in a badly managed part of CS and despite feeding back, asking for feed back, trying to work strategically and looking for opportunities to build behaviours I feel I have de-skilled. I’m feeling pretty low tbh!

Do you have a mentor? They can really help you focus on what you need to be doing and help pull out good examples for applications.

Are you London based? If so, the fact they aren’t running the Grad scheme should mean more G7 opportunities over the next few years.

The last 4 years won’t have been wasted, but what you may have learned is what not to do.

Look at the new job as a new start, almost act as a G7 by thinking of things before your G7 does and, if appropriate, doing them. Don’t undermine but upwards manage your G7, it’s hard to explain but make your G7s life easier and you will be given the opportunities that make good examples for applications.

Keep looking for G7 roles, but be very selective and only go for the ones you really want.

StellaGibson2022 · 30/06/2022 00:58

@seemsikeaniceday I hope you are right but this is not my first sideways move and have been an SEO for nearly 12 years. The past 4 years I feel I have completely wasted as I’ve worked in a badly managed part of CS and despite feeding back, asking for feed back, trying to work strategically and looking for opportunities to build behaviours I feel I have de-skilled. I’m feeling pretty low tbh!

SatinHeart · 29/06/2022 12:05

Are you a line manager OP? I'm CS but not currently going for promotion myself but SEO colleagues of mine have found it hard to get any higher without some management experience.

2 years in an SEO role doesn't seem that long before going for Grade 7, most people I know have stayed at SEO for a fair bit longer than that before getting a promotion. Have you considered a sideways move to get more breadth of experience?

seemsikeaniceday · 29/06/2022 12:05

savebuckbeak · 29/06/2022 11:49

@seemsikeaniceday I mention it when specifically asked about my motivations for applying etc. - not just randomly!

OK, but you said you talk about it a lot, my advice would be to keep it brief. If they want more detail they will ask.

In my experience a panel starts with a soft opening question, such as what interests you about the job, to let people settle in. Interviewees who give lengthy replies take up their interview time allowing less time for “scorable” questions. Just keep it brief.

smashmakesmash · 29/06/2022 11:57

I work in a similar kind of public sector role .
I would say you need to keep your spirits up and get the volume of applications out. So much of this is luck and who the other candidates are, it doesn't necessarily reflect on your or your abilities.
I recently was on an interview panel for equivalent of a G6 post and one of the applicants, who on paper had the weakest profile of the four interviewed candidates, did well in the interview when, bizarrely, the other three bombed when they should have done much better . So he got the job because the others didn't pass the interview and it was a massive jump for him (he basically skipped a grade).
A lot of good advice above too. Have you asked to do the Crossing Thresholds course? You could find it useful. A lot about managing profiles and positioning yourself for your next job.

savebuckbeak · 29/06/2022 11:49

@seemsikeaniceday I mention it when specifically asked about my motivations for applying etc. - not just randomly!

OP posts:
seemsikeaniceday · 29/06/2022 11:06

@StellaGibson2022 a sideways move is really sensible, a lot of people see it as not progressing rather than a step up. When you move as an experienced SEO you can hit the ground running and can really maximise the new role. It also gives you a lot more examples for interviews.

@savebuckbeak I do talk about the role a lot in the interviews, my motivations for applying, etc. etc. That is possibly one reason why you are not successful at interview, is this.in response to a warm up question? Or are you weaving it into responses so not actually answering the question?

StellaGibson2022 · 28/06/2022 23:50

Can I join this thread? I’m in the same position and have just taken a sideways move as I thought I was coming across as more about the Grade than the role.

savebuckbeak · 28/06/2022 22:52

@GuidingSpirit Thanks for your comment. What are some of the ways candidates come across as they're focussed more on the grade rather than the role?

OP posts:
savebuckbeak · 28/06/2022 22:50

@WWYD3 Thanks for the feedback. That's a good point that maybe I'm coming across too focused on the grade and not the role. Do you have any suggestions to rectify this? I do talk about the role a lot in the interviews, my motivations for applying, etc. etc.

OP posts:
mackthejackknife · 24/06/2022 19:37

I’m a grade 7. If you’re getting interviews but not offers it sounds like it’s interview technique rather than your behaviours that might be the hurdle. One thing I’ve always been told has set me apart as a candidate is the evaluation I add to my behaviours at interview - so after explaining the result as per STAR, I always add “reflecting on that, I think I did x strongly and could develop y…” or “if I were to do this again I would…”

GuidingSpirit · 24/06/2022 18:29

The jump between SEO and Grade 7 is one of the biggest. Are the roles you are going for related to your current work or are you looking for something different?

I'm a grade 6 and have done lots of recruitment. It's generally pretty obvious if someone is applying for the grade rather than the role (not saying that is you, but could it be coming across that way?) Also with people concerned that the cuts could lead to a potential recruitment freeze, I'm seeing a lot bigger number of applicants for roles - presumably people want to move in case it's a lot harder to move for the next few years. It could just be a numbers game?

Are you in a big or small department?

Darbs76 · 24/06/2022 18:12

I have just secured my G7 and I’ve been an SEO for 15yrs! 2 children and a serious health issue slowed me down but you’ve not been applying for too long so don’t feel too dejected. I know that it’s difficult as it’s so disappointing to get that rejection. I had one rejection but I have waited a long time before applying and think I was overly ready with a lot of experience. Use the feedback, but don’t worry too much about negative as my feedback for my 1st one said I needed more SEO postings before I’d get a G7 and I got it on the next interview, who thought I was a solid candidate. Every recruiter is different. Are you applying for the right role?

WWYD3 · 22/06/2022 18:57

Is it possible you're coming across as focused on the grade rather than the role?

I'm a Grade 6 and I'm seeing a lot of this at the moment, I think due to the cost of living. The concern is that if candidates aren't truly interested in the job, they'll disappear pretty quickly.

I'd ask for feedback, do some interviewing as a panel member for HEOs or other SEOs if possible and focus on finding a job you really want and are aligned to as opposed to a grade you really want.

Good luck!