Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give up on Grade 7 applications (civil service)

56 replies

savebuckbeak · 22/06/2022 15:31

I've been an SEO in a policy role in the CS for about 2 years and have been applying for Grade 7 roles for a few months now both internally through EOIs and externally. Had 2 unsuccessful interviews and just feeling very dejected. I've got mentors I work through stuff with, get involved in a lot of corporate/strategy stuff, have refined my behaviours examples hundreds of times, gotten advice on them, prepared strengths answers and generally done A LOT of career building stuff. In interviews I talk about leadership, strategy, work programmes I've led and delivered through others, how I've challenged and negotiated and convinced stakeholders to do x y z. Literally don't know what to do going forward and any nuggets of advice about any of this very welcome.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
mackthejackknife · 15/07/2022 11:49

savebuckbeak · 14/07/2022 16:28

I should have said - I'm very much in the Westminster bubble, working in a policy role in a major ministerial department. So I suppose what I've observed is others in similar positions and spaces where it's very much the norm to progress to Grade 7 after 2 or fewer years as an SEO>

Same here although I’m based outside of London, and while I’m a good performer I certainly don’t think I’m top-1%-exceptional. You don’t and shouldn’t need to be to get a grade 7 role in policy after two years at SEO, especially in a department like this. (We actually don’t even have such a thing as SEO, so obviously it’s not universally considered essential to have long term experience there).

mackthejackknife · 15/07/2022 11:45

I’m not sure any of this conjecture is particularly helpful to OP who feels ready for promotion and is seeking advice on how to get there. But I do agree that this isn’t the point to give up on promotion or to leave the civil service. OP, what’s your manager like? Would they be helpful with interview technique, or is there someone else senior in your network who would? I’ve had lots of mock interviews when I’ve been preparing for promotion - that might help you get some feedback on whether interview technique is the issue.

jevoudrais · 14/07/2022 17:27

Civil service sounds pretty old fashioned. Are you desperate to stay, OP? Sounds like they want your right arm to get a G7. Doesn't your department or line manager help support you and find you something more challenging too, given the size of the CS?

If you're getting interviews and it's not ending up in an offer over a period of time something isn't working. I'd consider looking at other employers probably, sounds as though you might be a better fit somewhere with a more modern and less hierarchical structure.

Seemslikeaniceday · 14/07/2022 17:03

savebuckbeak · 14/07/2022 16:28

I should have said - I'm very much in the Westminster bubble, working in a policy role in a major ministerial department. So I suppose what I've observed is others in similar positions and spaces where it's very much the norm to progress to Grade 7 after 2 or fewer years as an SEO>

Exactly my point.

This is why I and others with wider experience are clearly stating to the OP and others


  • stop focusing on tick box activities

  • ask manager/other manager to provide coaching on interview technique

  • focus on doing your job and getting the most out of it

  • consider a level transfer to broaden your skills and knowledge

  • 2 years experience and 2 interviews is not the point to give up on G7.

savebuckbeak · 14/07/2022 16:28

I should have said - I'm very much in the Westminster bubble, working in a policy role in a major ministerial department. So I suppose what I've observed is others in similar positions and spaces where it's very much the norm to progress to Grade 7 after 2 or fewer years as an SEO>

OP posts:
Seemslikeaniceday · 14/07/2022 16:12

savebuckbeak · 14/07/2022 14:07

@Seemslikeaniceday Sorry, but did you just make that 1% figure up?! I was an HEO for 2 years, and been an SEO for 2.5 years. Aiming for Grade 7 promotion, in my experience from seeing my peers and those around me, is actually incredibly normal and expected at this stage. It's akin to the fast stream, where you progress to Grade 7 after four years of being on a fast stream grade (which is basically HEO/SEO). I really don't understand why there's such a bleak view in segments of the civil service re promotion prospects, or that Grade 7 is this holy grail type thing. It's just mid-management, for God's sake, and as SEOs many of us are essentially doing Grade 7 roles anyway, or at least part of them.

The 1% was just a rough figure based on 30+ years observation may be higher. What you have to remember is the difference between London and the regions and department structure. I’ve worked in departments with Regional offices of c250-350 staff with 1 G6 post in charge of the whole office, and possibly 1 or 2 G7 posts. With that ratio unless you are very exceptional or able to move to London it’s essentially deadman’s shoes and people can be in the same grade for years,

London is different, there will be differences between the two types of offices. Offices that deliver to the public e.g job centres, DVLA test centres which may have similar structures to regional offices but CS have the ability to move to other London locations and so have a far bigger pool of promotion opportunities.

The second are the Head Offices, which depending on the department can be combined with public delivery functions,. These typically have a lot flatter structure with many more G7, G6 and SCS posts. These also benefit from being in close proximity and so there are far more vacancies and opportunities. You also have a higher flow between public, voluntary and private sectors and opportunities like loans, secondments and TP.

If you only work in London you can get a false sense of what most Civil Servants experience. c75% of CS roles are outside London.

One reality you may not be aware of is the special treatment for those on grad/fast track schemes, the extra assistance and the behind scenes horse trading. I’ve known really capable people not get an interview/job because the SCS in charge of a scheme insists a job is ring-fenced for a grad so their success rate looks better. This makes it harder for those following a more traditional route to get promotion. Unfair, you bet, but why risk your own career as you climb the grades the pool gets smaller and peoples memories are long.

I’ve certainly seen grads with a plan to go back to their home town stymied because they rushed to G7 then G6 in London then find they can’t get a level G6 role in their home region as they are no competition for local long standing G7s.

i’m on my 6th department in over 30 years, I’ve worked in the regions and in London, I’ve worked on cross department roles working with peers in other departments to deliver cross government so,unions. I’ve also been involved in recruitment and promotion panels in a range of departments.

TheDepthsOfDespair · 14/07/2022 14:59

I think a lot of it is also about the departments involved and the geography etc.

in some departments it’s rare for roles to open up as people rarely move on, whereas in some others there is a high turnover.

if it’s out in the regions then G7 level work can be viewed differently to in the cities. It can be rare to get an opportunity. This seems to be changing more now with remote working being more acceptable.

im generalising of course but going on what I’ve seen over the years.

savebuckbeak · 14/07/2022 14:07

@Seemslikeaniceday Sorry, but did you just make that 1% figure up?! I was an HEO for 2 years, and been an SEO for 2.5 years. Aiming for Grade 7 promotion, in my experience from seeing my peers and those around me, is actually incredibly normal and expected at this stage. It's akin to the fast stream, where you progress to Grade 7 after four years of being on a fast stream grade (which is basically HEO/SEO). I really don't understand why there's such a bleak view in segments of the civil service re promotion prospects, or that Grade 7 is this holy grail type thing. It's just mid-management, for God's sake, and as SEOs many of us are essentially doing Grade 7 roles anyway, or at least part of them.

OP posts:
quietnightmare · 14/07/2022 13:52

Sometimes it's a case of your face just doesn't fit. Just keep going

SuperheroBirds · 14/07/2022 13:35

I’m a G7 and before getting a substantive promotion, I was on temporary promotion. I found that really gave me the opportunity to demonstrate that I could work at G7 level, and gave me some properly deep examples for applications.

Obviously the application has a limited word count, so it may be that on paper your examples look ok, but at interview there isn’t enough extra oomph to build them into a full G7 level example. As an interviewer, I always want more at the interview as you have time to expand and get into details.

in my experience, it is practical stretching work/projects that make the difference, not training courses. So I’d encourage you to keep an eye out for EOIs, temporary opportunities, or extra bits of work that you can put yourself forward for.

Seemslikeaniceday · 14/07/2022 13:05

mackthejackknife · 14/07/2022 11:53

I really disagree with a lot of the recent posts on this thread. I was an SEO for 8 months before my promotion. I don’t need (nor would I get) my ‘hands held’ now, and I have precisely the opposite of an inability to deliver (and am very high on the talent grid as a newish grade 7, work closely with and get great feedback from DGs etc). I agree with you OP that it’s probably about interview technique as I mentioned before.

You are an exception to the rule. There are always have been and always will be high flyers who progress quickly. However, they are the top 1%.

The posters on this thread with decades of experience know that there are a wide range of people seeking promotion. Some have breadth and depth of experience and have made life choices not to apply until now, some have followed the route of applying when they personally are ready (2 -10+Years), some are not quite ready but have potential and are chancing their luck, some need further development but have the potential in a year or three, and some are delusional about their abilities.

i have know people in the later category to get the job because they go for a department where they are unknown and have the gift of the gab and it’s shocking when they start work and everyone slowly starts to realise they hoodwinked the interview panel.

Yes, there is interview technique which your line manager and colleagues can coach you on, but technique alone should not result in a successful outcome. Transferrable skills, depth and breadth of experience also matter. Plus some jobs are more popular than others and so the standard of candidates can be much higher and impact on your chances.

123becauseicouldntthinkofone · 14/07/2022 12:19

You could actually be my friend writing this, i have reviewed with her all the standards and it just seems impossible. I also have another friend whose husband had a very similar situation who would be put in the role temporarily after a leaver for quite a few months then fail to get the position and then be put back in the role after they left. After 3 years of doing this he has finally got the position. Don't give up.....and if it is you, I will see you later ;)

mackthejackknife · 14/07/2022 11:53

I really disagree with a lot of the recent posts on this thread. I was an SEO for 8 months before my promotion. I don’t need (nor would I get) my ‘hands held’ now, and I have precisely the opposite of an inability to deliver (and am very high on the talent grid as a newish grade 7, work closely with and get great feedback from DGs etc). I agree with you OP that it’s probably about interview technique as I mentioned before.

StellaGibson2022 · 13/07/2022 12:18

Not to derail OPs thread but do you have any advice around making the leap from SEO to G7 and what you would want to see at interview?

from my most recent interviews feedback has been good but there is a better candidate however what I have found a barrier is that with Success Profiles I have never been asked about my career
history or what I could bring to roles.

Unhomme · 13/07/2022 11:12

Not at all, but G7 is much more than being 'interested in the role'. It's a significant change in approach and outlook, with much more focus on what you can bring to the wider team and organisation. Looking up and across rather than across and down. Some people might have extensive experience or skills that fit a particular 7 role, but I'd look at their talent grid placement to understand if they teally are a star across all 7 roles or in a narrow area of responsibility. And do they have that breadth of experience to be an asset.

Someone with 2 year's experience in one SEO role is, quite frankly, going to find it difficult to convince me that you do really have the ability to deliver.

And, having made the mistake of recruiting ambition over ability in the past (and seeing quite a lot of overpromotion and the issues it can cause), I am a lot more discerning now about getting the right person into my teams.

mamaes · 13/07/2022 11:02

I've gone from EO to Grade 6 in 10 years. I've taken two (albeit short) mat leaves and also done a sideways move out as an SEO equivalent to get wider experience before moving back in as a G7.

My advice would be stop focusing on getting a promotion. Focus on being the strongest SEO. The G7 post will come. Definitely focus on the role and not the grade. What department are you in?

savebuckbeak · 13/07/2022 10:59

@Unhomme Can I ask what you mean by "genuine"? I am genuine. I'm interested in the roles I apply for, and I have the skills, experience and drive to do well in them. Your approach to recruitment sounds a little odd, as if you're looking to catch people out. Why would someone be not genuine? Or do you take any indication of interest in the grade, or rising through the ranks, as not being genuine?

OP posts:
Unhomme · 13/07/2022 10:56

It might be, but you're the SEO looking to convince recruiters you're not. I've interviewed hundreds of people over the last years and it's very clear when someone is genuine or not.

savebuckbeak · 13/07/2022 10:52

@Unhomme Lol @ "grade chasing". In other sectors this might be called "being ambitious" or "career development".

OP posts:
Unhomme · 13/07/2022 10:43

Maybe you should stop grade chasing tbh. You're getting the interviews because you can play the blind application game but it's obvs not working when f2f.

If I had a 2 year SEO in front of me at interview for a G7 role I'd expect a lack of depth in your experience.

savebuckbeak · 13/07/2022 10:27

Thanks all. Not meaning to be dismissive at all. I guess I am just inclined to think that, as I am getting Grade 7 interviews, it's perhaps interview technique etc that I should focus on, as opposed to moving sideways. I will consider that too of course.

OP posts:
seemsikeaniceday · 13/07/2022 10:18

I should mention that I have coached and developed staff for over 30 years, including those on the graduate schemes. I have happily seen some of those rise to higher grades than me (personal choice).

I have also been involved in recruitment and promotion panels for 25 years. I understand how lack of experience can be identified at interview.

I have also had to support and work for managers who have been over promoted and their lack of experience makes its hard work for everyone. Usually they are entitled and move on quickly until they get caught out and are sidelined.

seemsikeaniceday · 13/07/2022 10:09

OP you have had some good advice on this thread but have been dismissive of anyone suggesting you need longer in your role and possibly a second role as an SEO.

No one is suggesting you need a decade before getting a G7 but what we are saying is you need more experience. For example managing 2 staff, whoop de do, I have known G7s manage an office I.e. c300 staff and SEOs manage 50+ staff. Yes this is managing a hierarchical structure rather than direct reports but without experience of managing staff at EO, HEO and SEO level you just will not have the depth of experience.

Look for a level transfer to an operational role with a significant team to manage. DWP, HMRC often have these roles.

AnneElliott · 12/07/2022 22:41

I agree with others that you may be coming across as desperate for the grade rather than the actual role. I'd also have reservations with someone at SEO only doing 2 years. I assume you were an HEO before that? That's quite a big jump and in my G7s I don't want to hold their hands so I'd be reluctant to risk a fairly inexperienced SEO in my team.

Sorry - I know that's probably not what you want to hear. I had 7 years at SEO and although I think I could have done the job earlier, I'm glad I waited and was sure of myself.

SalterScales · 12/07/2022 15:54

@savebuckbeak No one is saying you need to do 75 years at whatever grade before being promoted. My own experience of doing 12 years at SEO was excessive - although I should point out that it was during the 2000s when we didn't have post specific G7 promotions, we had formal G7 promotion boards once every few years and if you didn't get through, tough, you had to wait eg 3 years until the next one.

I'm not suggesting that we return to that, there is a happy medium here, whereby a few different posts at eg SEO, spread over a few years, enables individuals to really immerse themselves in what they're doing, become skilled and develop robust examples for interview.

Swipe left for the next trending thread