Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DS sports day was odd and not really in the spirit of inclusion?

283 replies

Notbeinfunnehbut · 22/06/2022 13:59

Me and DH and DM attended DS sports day yesterday
it was very hot and it wasn’t set out like a traditional sports day I.e activities each team goes round
mall kids were seated , activities did happen but certain kids from each team were read out and all other kids remained seated , there were children who took part in multiple races , and some none my son did 1! Being stood in a sun trap for over 2 hours to see him do one race at the end 😡

like I said some kids did nothing,

I asked him and he said teachers asked kids which ones they wanted to do instead

AIBU to think the whole point of SD is that everyone takes part??

OP posts:
StressedOutMumBex · 23/06/2022 21:08

emmathedilemma · 22/06/2022 14:05

Having been forced to participate in sports I was no good at and didn't enjoy, particularly in front of an audience while probably coming last, this sounds perfect!!

This - my son is no good at sport at all and he has horrendous anxiety about sports day every year, its awful, i see no reason to have him go through the humiliation of coming last when he is never going to be an athlete, he has flat feet and dyspraxia, why put them through it ?

wentworthinmate · 23/06/2022 21:06

Surely your son could have told you he was only doing one event? I was forced to do sports day and I became very anxious and ill because of it. Pro choice here!

Kteeb1 · 23/06/2022 20:54

One of my residing memories of secondary school was being made to do the high jump just because I was taller than everyone else in front of everyone and just crashing into it like a test dummy while everyone stood around laughing. I was already teased for being a bean pole. So yeah. I definatley think more sporty kids should be forced to do this they are shit at. Character building.

celticprincess · 23/06/2022 19:59

If sounds more like the school should have communicated better how the sports day was being done, and let parents know how many races their child was taking part in.

Whilst giving choices is supporting inclusion by not forcing children to take part who don’t want to, it sounds like they could have made it a bit more equal. Allowing children who can’t cope with sport day to avoid it can be helpful but making them sit in a sun trap for 2 hours isn’t fair either. Those not taking part in many races should have been given other roles, perhaps giving out stickers at the finishing line, keeping score lists. I’d have been more than happy to watch my child take a responsible role in the event but would have been disappointed to assume they take part in all and only see them do one.

I also think inclusion would have been to find a sport that those who hasn’t volunteered would have been comfortable on taking part in. Maybe a child and adult together race (parent or staff member to do it with them).

I’m a teacher and worked in various schools. One school had all students taking part in the races but non competitively. Scores were never collected etc. they all just had fun doing each of the activity and the parents went round the field with their class as they did all the activities. Another school all the children sit and watch each class do each race and every child competes. But 1st 2nd and 3rd place stickers given out each time. But not 1/2/3 out of whole class but each group (random) of 5 that take their turn. No overall winner decided! Then other schools where they collect points for each race they do and points rallied at the end for overall winners.

Léighméleabhair · 23/06/2022 19:54

@ToCaden

Thank you so much for posting about your own experiences. Yes, to falling up the stairs too. I knew he struggled with hand writing and balance related activities but didn’t realise just how poor his motor skills were. His school wouldn’t refer him for testing because he is excelling academically and they prioritise students who are struggling with the basics of reading and maths, which I can understand. We had to pay privately to get him tested and the detailed report was eye opening to read.

How interesting that you love swimming as well!

We're taking DS to London soon to meet up with family and I’m already feeling anxious about how he will cope with walking along the crowded streets. I’m probably going to continue holding his hand even though he’s a teenager, as I think this is probably the safest option. 🙁

We live very rurally here in Ireland and we call it ‘rush hour’ when there’s two tractors on the road causing a traffic jam, so he’s really not used to walking around in built up suburban areas at all. We don’t take him to supermarkets because he’s liable to knock over the displays. I know he finds it very frustrating as it’s definitely not a lack of trying on his part.

Fizzydog · 23/06/2022 19:47

We had similar with similar reaction our end. DD ( 4) did one race. She had no idea what was going on and was clearly bewildered and intimidated being anywhere near much bigger children. There was positive atmosphere at all and at the end of the hour this thing swallowed up, the children just went back inside. It was grim to watch and even sadder that only winners got a mention.
I'm fine with this sort of formal competitive ethos at secondary level but at primary, it needs to be fun, positive and more relaxed.

Gr33ngr33ngr4ss · 23/06/2022 19:26

Notbeinfunnehbut · 22/06/2022 14:11

Primary, he probably should have said I’m only doing one but yeah it did seem to be the same kids again and again, surely the already sporty kids aren’t the ones who need the encouragement?

I find this a really sad attitude. Considering you're bleating about inclusion.

Newbie20 · 23/06/2022 19:26

My 5yo had sports day the other week and I was a little shocked to see him not take part in the whole thing. I asked him about it and he said that they got to choose what they wanted to do. But I'm 100% sure I saw him join the queue for 2 of the events but didn't get to take part in them. They're were 6 events and he came home with 3 stickers but I told him that I was proud of him for doing his best. My daughter who is in year 7 didn't even get an invite to do sports day, they only invite people they want. It's so wrong

Raizin · 23/06/2022 19:01

I thought the way my son's school set up sports day was quite good. Each class was split into 3 groups, reflecting physical ability/stamina and they competed within their groups. Finally, the long distance running was totally optional.

Loudhousefun · 23/06/2022 18:56

There are major problems with inclusion in PE and sports. Eg Traditional sports arent actually the best thing for fitness, especially for children with SN or coordination difficulties and sports days are emblematic of this

I have been saying this to my daughters school for so long, it literally is like talking to a wall.

Mojoj · 23/06/2022 18:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

niugboo · 23/06/2022 18:54

PeachyPeachTrees · 23/06/2022 18:26

I think all children should take part. It's annoying how people think Maths and English are important and exercise isn't. By all means have different events, so the ones who excel do the running and sprinting and the others do the throwing bean bags into a pot etc. I agree with the posters who talked about resilience and not growing up thinking they can cherry pick what they like and don't like.

Does you school host parent observed maths competitions?

niugboo · 23/06/2022 18:53

Mojoj · 22/06/2022 18:40

Yes kids should be made to participate in sports day and there should be winners and losers. It's never too early to learn that you can't be good at everything and sometimes you lose. This "everybody's a winner" mentality is not any kind of preparation for real life. Non academic kids don't get to opt out of tests etc where they're unlikely to shine so why should it be any different for non sporty kids?

Do you live on the moon @Mojoj

firstly lessons and assessments are adapted for children based on ability and disabilities. You won’t have a child who’s lower performing at maths doing a higher grade paper. And accessibility arrangements are required. But more importantly no children are forced to publicly humiliate themselves or perform maths papers in front of their peers parents.

niugboo · 23/06/2022 18:47

You don’t have disabled kids do you?

I will spin it. If a child was dyslexic would you make them stand up in front of the other parents and do a spelling bee?

Its not inclusive to force all children to take part. It’s inclusive to adapt activities so children can take part when it’s appropriate. For some sports day quite simply isn’t accessible because there are parents there. Please don’t judge a situation you know nothing about. As a parent of two disabled children one of our biggest issues is this everyone must be included nonsense.

PurpleDaisies · 23/06/2022 18:45

I think all children should take part. It's annoying how people think Maths and English are important and exercise isn't.

Literally nobody is saying that. Exercise is important. Sports days are not the same as enjoying regular exercise. It’s usually a competition in front of peers and strange adults in primary.

Benjispruce4 · 23/06/2022 18:31

Yes @Sirzy that could happen. I can think of one child that may apply to this year. These things are dealt with when they become apparent. The problem with making something openly optional is that some chn who are just a bit nervous will opt out. Over and over I see chn that we’re anxious about doing something, overcoming their fear and being elated and proud that they managed to take part with their best effort.

PeachyPeachTrees · 23/06/2022 18:26

I think all children should take part. It's annoying how people think Maths and English are important and exercise isn't. By all means have different events, so the ones who excel do the running and sprinting and the others do the throwing bean bags into a pot etc. I agree with the posters who talked about resilience and not growing up thinking they can cherry pick what they like and don't like.

Hmm1234 · 23/06/2022 18:17

some children who aren’t very good at sports normally choose to sit out. It’s quiet considerate of the teachers to allow them rather than ridicule and shame them for not being the most athletic. In my day you had to ‘bunk off’ to avoid sports day if you were one of the more self conscious kids.

Sirzy · 23/06/2022 18:02

But for some children that adjustment will be to let them not take part at all.

Ds school (secondary) have sports day next week. DS has already said he won’t be taking part and so school have made reasonable adjustment for him and others. He has additional needs (a whole host of!) and gives 110% is all subjects including PE but can’t cope with the “chaos” of sports day which is fine.

Benjispruce4 · 23/06/2022 17:51

@Léighméleabhair in my very first post I said chn take part unless there is good reason why that might be difficult. Our sports days are inclusive and fun. We have had a children with a physical disability or SEN and their need ma are met in lucid that means their race is adapted or that they want to have a different role such as score keeper etc.

Mumkins42 · 23/06/2022 17:51

I love that kids are given a choice here. Sports day must be so traumatic for some kids in certain school environments.

ToCaden · 23/06/2022 14:38

Léighméleabhair · 23/06/2022 12:14

So your DS is quite sporty. Good for him.

Do you understand what ‘serious balance issues’ might mean?
My DS spent two hours completing various tests last year led by a specialist occupational therapist here in Ireland, where he scored 0.5 on the scale for balance and co-ordination with 50 being classed as average.

Any sort of obstacle course would be the worst kind of hell for my son.

He regularly falls into me when we’re out shopping as he tries to walk alongside or just behind me but struggles to work out the space around him.

He is however, a great swimmer as he has had a course of 1:1 swimming lessons with an excellent teacher. He occasionally hits the ropes dividing the lanes but his swimming and breathing technique is great. He has learnt to climb trees during lockdown which was a major achievement.

Academically, he is extremely capable and classed as ‘gifted’.

The only ideas I’ll be putting into his head is that he can choose not to take part in something if he doesn’t want to risk public humiliation.

Interesting. Rather severe dyspraxia here too. I was never without bruises as a child. I've also always loved swimming, especially underwater.

Walking alongside someone is still a bit of a challenge, but less falling and walking into walls nowadays which is lovely. Have to employ a few tactics in order to manage stairs and not veering off the pavement. And sometimes I can even pass people in the hallway without bumping into them or the wall!!!

I hope your DS also sees improvement when he reaches adulthood.

PurpleDaisies · 23/06/2022 13:37

Pressed post too soon. It also doesn’t follow that you don’t enjoy sport because you don’t want to perform in sports day. Some kids don’t like the pressure or being on display. They can still enjoy pe etc.

PurpleDaisies · 23/06/2022 13:36

HairyDad · 23/06/2022 13:29

I wasn't sporty at School, nor was I a bully. In fact I was the one bullied by the sporty kids. I'm not saying they should have to do it, but just if they don't want to do it then why sit there opting out and watching other people do things that you don't want to do? Surely those who don't like sports (or sports day) could all do a different activity inside? ANyway, I'm sure those kicking up a fuss are over-reacting. It's, what, 1 or 2 hours out of the year? It's not as if they're being forced to do it every day

Just because you don’t like doing sport doesn’t mean you don’t enjoy watching it or supporting your friends.

HairyDad · 23/06/2022 13:29

I wasn't sporty at School, nor was I a bully. In fact I was the one bullied by the sporty kids. I'm not saying they should have to do it, but just if they don't want to do it then why sit there opting out and watching other people do things that you don't want to do? Surely those who don't like sports (or sports day) could all do a different activity inside? ANyway, I'm sure those kicking up a fuss are over-reacting. It's, what, 1 or 2 hours out of the year? It's not as if they're being forced to do it every day