Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask which painting you like best

84 replies

dingit · 22/06/2022 12:21

1 or 2

To ask which painting you like best
To ask which painting you like best
OP posts:
GarrettAMorgan · 22/06/2022 14:07

If you believe, as I do, that the true subject of any painting is light, you won’t find much merit in 1, which is very flat in terms of value and colour. If you skinned a cat and laid that skin flat under a uniform light source, then the color and value of one stripe on the cat would be roughly the same all the way across the cat, as it is in number 1. However light falling from one direction onto a three-dimensional cat should mean not only the value but the perceived colour of the stripe should vary depending on how much light is reaching each individual point on the stripe. There is no sense that the person who coloured in number 1 has ever noticed this, which is quite poor.

I assume this work was done from a photo and not followed up on with observations from life, which makes it impossible to get an accurate sense of colour, as the human eye perceives colour in a much more nuanced way than photos can capture.

The composition of number 1 is equally poor and uninteresting. As some have said, fine for a bit of hobbyist copying and colouring in, but in my opinion entirely without artistic merit.

dingit · 22/06/2022 14:06

Here he is. Scampi in his gorgeous lion pose

To ask which painting you like best
OP posts:
UnshakenNeedsStirring · 22/06/2022 14:05

1 as you can see the eyes

dingit · 22/06/2022 14:04

Aria999 · 22/06/2022 14:01

I think yours is good too! I think the reason I said the other one is partly that 1 is kind of floating in blank space. It doesn't have any shadow around it, or very much shadow on the form, which makes it seem a bit flat, you have done the fur beautifully though.

Yes I'm really bad at that. I wish I could get it back and alter it!

OP posts:
Aria999 · 22/06/2022 14:01

I think yours is good too! I think the reason I said the other one is partly that 1 is kind of floating in blank space. It doesn't have any shadow around it, or very much shadow on the form, which makes it seem a bit flat, you have done the fur beautifully though.

dingit · 22/06/2022 14:01

Howyoualldoworkme · 22/06/2022 13:55

I draw animals myself and I prefer 2 🙂

I love it too.

OP posts:
Howyoualldoworkme · 22/06/2022 13:57

Update: Your painting is really well executed and just as good as 2 but obviously a different style

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 22/06/2022 13:56

I prefer 2, but I’m generally not a huge fan of the more realistic style of the first.

I couldn’t pinpoint any issues with your painting @dingit it’s just not my taste

dingit · 22/06/2022 13:55

The last few posters have made me feel a little better. I've just completed a commission ( a dog) and was ready to rip it up 😂😂

OP posts:
Howyoualldoworkme · 22/06/2022 13:55

I draw animals myself and I prefer 2 🙂

FreestyleInTrance · 22/06/2022 13:53

I prefer 1 (although both are great!), 2 is a cute pose but it looks more stylised / generic, whereas 1 looks more realistic to me (although without a photo of the actual cat I suppose this could be wrong!). As a cat owner I'd prefer one in the style of 1 that was identifiably my cat, not just a cat that looks a bit like mine!

Sebastianthecoo · 22/06/2022 13:53

Before I saw your update I was going to say 1, it looks like someone’s pet so I wouldn’t have it unless it was my pet. However if I was the type of person to hang pictures of random cats then 2 would be the natural choice.

your very talented!

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 22/06/2022 13:49

KarmaStar · 22/06/2022 13:22

Number one.🐈
Number two looks like he's passed away (sorry)

I agree! Much prefer no.1 for the same reason. There's no character in a dead sleeping cat. It's not even curled up, it's just led there

steppemum · 22/06/2022 13:46

well I think 1 is a great picture, but there is something that captures the essence of the cat more in 2 for me.

Having said that, every cat is different, so it would be probably about which one looked more like MY cat.

dingit · 22/06/2022 13:45

Verbena87 · 22/06/2022 13:37

two is technically better but 1 is a really decent go if you’re fairly new to painting. Get your sketch/under painting bang on accurate before you start adding colour, and attend carefully to tone as well as colour so you get a bit more depth/dimensionality. It wants to feel like a sculpted form rather than a coloured-in drawing, if that makes sense?

Not particularly new to painting, I guess it's literally back to the drawing board for me.

OP posts:
paisley256 · 22/06/2022 13:38

1

Verbena87 · 22/06/2022 13:37

two is technically better but 1 is a really decent go if you’re fairly new to painting. Get your sketch/under painting bang on accurate before you start adding colour, and attend carefully to tone as well as colour so you get a bit more depth/dimensionality. It wants to feel like a sculpted form rather than a coloured-in drawing, if that makes sense?

Xanadu58 · 22/06/2022 13:31

2

dingit · 22/06/2022 13:31

Time to confess that I did no1, glad to see some like it but a lot think it’s pants!
I only asked as I gave it to my friend, she then told me she paid for a professional one which upset me a bit sad 😂
I can see what people mean about the eye, annoyingly I don’t have the original photo so can’t check. I did have tutor overseeing so they might have pointed it out! The paws, I think sometimes rush to get a piece finished!

OP posts:
KarmaStar · 22/06/2022 13:22

Number one.🐈
Number two looks like he's passed away (sorry)

SurferRona · 22/06/2022 13:17

Figures. 2 is good, well observed. Worth paying for. 1 isn't. Not v good. Eyes are wonky. The painter there painted what they knew was there as opposed to what they really see. I'd have said artist has not so good observational skills, but no2 is ace!

FlappyCats · 22/06/2022 13:17

2 for me

dingit · 22/06/2022 13:15

Sorry no 1 was free

OP posts:
dingit · 22/06/2022 13:14

The paintings belong to a friend. I suppose she got what she paid for then. No 2 was £70, the second was free!

OP posts:
ThisSceptredIsle · 22/06/2022 13:12

YABU

Swipe left for the next trending thread