Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask which painting you like best

84 replies

dingit · 22/06/2022 12:21

1 or 2

To ask which painting you like best
To ask which painting you like best
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SiobhanSharpe · 22/06/2022 16:05

@GarrettAMorgan 's response would perhaps be fine if the OP had entered the paintings in a competition or exhibition of some kind. As this was not the case, it comes across as both pretentious and overblown, unnecessary and unkind. As is their second response.
It's the kind of written criticism which gives enormous pleasure to the writer but rather less to anyone else.

dingit · 22/06/2022 15:04

I don't actually visit her house often and she's just moved. So she could have shoved it under the bed and I would have been none the wiser. It was the fact she made a point of telling me about the professional one.
Oh well lesson learned 🙄

OP posts:
MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 22/06/2022 15:03

I chose 2 as it looks more finished. 1 looks like it's floating as needs some shading and something not quite right with the eye. Saying that if my friend gave it to me I'd be really pleased!

Mallysmomma · 22/06/2022 14:58

I just saw that you painted it. I chose 2 because it was (ever so slightly) a better pose in my opinion however if someone had painted me a picture of one of my cats to the high standard of Number 1 I would be ecstatic so not sure why your “friend” opted to get a “ professional” portrait as they both look professional to me. You’re a great artist; try not to let it dampen your enthusiasm at all. Art is after all very subjective. Xx

Mallysmomma · 22/06/2022 14:54

It’s 2 for me 🥰

LadyEloise1 · 22/06/2022 14:46

Sorry I hadn't read the full thread when I replied. Yours is so much nicer @dingit

chesirecat99 · 22/06/2022 14:44

I prefer the composition of 1 apart from the fact that he is just floating in space. I think 2 is slightly better technically. I don't think I would have been very happy to pay £70 for 2 as the composition is awful. I would have been very grateful and impressed with your gift of a lovely painting though.

There isn't much in it though.

LadyEloise1 · 22/06/2022 14:43

No. 1

Wammawink · 22/06/2022 14:40

2
Theres something a bit off about the face in the first one

Nothingfree · 22/06/2022 14:39

2

madasawethen · 22/06/2022 14:38

I like 1 for the textures and puurrrsonality.
It needs to be finished.

2 is ok as it's finished. It just looks too flat to me.
It happens when people don't have the basics down.
Working with graphite, charcoal, one colour
composition

IcakethereforeIam · 22/06/2022 14:36

Prefer 2, 1 is very good, but would prefer if it had background or shading. Love no.3, behind the cat in the photo.

ScattyHattie · 22/06/2022 14:33

I prefer pose and style of 2 over 1 but I think an owner may prefer 1 and see more of their cats character in it. It looks lovely in photo alongside the model and other cat head picture would be nice gallery display of ginger cat artwork.

diddl · 22/06/2022 14:27

I much prefer the way you have done the fur Op!

To me it just doesn't look quite finished though.

Angelou79 · 22/06/2022 14:25

2

Blowthemandown · 22/06/2022 14:25

100Stickers · 22/06/2022 12:43

No. 2 definitely, the cat look's really cosy and happy 😊

No. 1 i think the eyes and paws need a little work

Agree, 2

GarrettAMorgan · 22/06/2022 14:23

numberthirtytwowindsorgardens · 22/06/2022 14:17

This is not a very kind reply, considering that the OP said some time ago that she painted it.

Well, I wrote my reply having not read the whole thread, so sorry if that was too harsh, OP.

However, another way of looking at this could be that if the OP, who I see is not a beginner, had had people who were kind enough to give her honest and informed critiques of her work when she was a beginner, she would almost certainly be a better artist now.

Notgoodatchoosingnames · 22/06/2022 14:22

1

dingit · 22/06/2022 14:20

It's fine. At first I was upset by some replies, but am now taking on board the criticism! No one ever stops learning.

OP posts:
numberthirtytwowindsorgardens · 22/06/2022 14:17

GarrettAMorgan · 22/06/2022 14:07

If you believe, as I do, that the true subject of any painting is light, you won’t find much merit in 1, which is very flat in terms of value and colour. If you skinned a cat and laid that skin flat under a uniform light source, then the color and value of one stripe on the cat would be roughly the same all the way across the cat, as it is in number 1. However light falling from one direction onto a three-dimensional cat should mean not only the value but the perceived colour of the stripe should vary depending on how much light is reaching each individual point on the stripe. There is no sense that the person who coloured in number 1 has ever noticed this, which is quite poor.

I assume this work was done from a photo and not followed up on with observations from life, which makes it impossible to get an accurate sense of colour, as the human eye perceives colour in a much more nuanced way than photos can capture.

The composition of number 1 is equally poor and uninteresting. As some have said, fine for a bit of hobbyist copying and colouring in, but in my opinion entirely without artistic merit.

This is not a very kind reply, considering that the OP said some time ago that she painted it.

ThreeRingCircus · 22/06/2022 14:17

Well I prefer 1 by miles and also thought number 2 looked like a dead cat (sorry!)

You are very talented OP.

Aria999 · 22/06/2022 14:12

Even if you are working from a photo if you kind of half close your eyes and squint you can get a sense of the blocks of light and dark. Then, exaggerate them like crazy if you naturally tend to under realize them.

smellybuntelly · 22/06/2022 14:12

I prefer 1 as it is more detailed and I think cats have beautiful eyes. But both are lovely and I would have both in my house.

Wilkolampshade · 22/06/2022 14:11

#1 is hugely better.

Dagnabit · 22/06/2022 14:09

2

Swipe left for the next trending thread