Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tesco's and fake labels - totally legit

108 replies

Moonshine5 · 22/06/2022 02:55

Genuinely shocked.
What is the point of a fake label? AIBU

Tesco's and fake labels - totally legit
OP posts:
LincolnshireYellowBelly · 22/06/2022 06:37

Completely acceptable - Tesco are attempting to inform us consumers in the best way they can. They need to keep food coming to us, and haven’t time to sort out new packaging. The products might have the correct ingredients but then again they might not.
This mass shortage of oil has been caused by the horrific war in Ukraine. I for one don’t care if they’ve not got packaging correct, when there are people the other side of Europe who have lost their livelihoods, homes and family members.

PrincessConsuelaBanana · 22/06/2022 06:27

Sorry OP but YABU. Considering the alternatives and the circumstances, and the fact that the supplier has alerted you to the substitution this really is not the issue you are trying to present it as.

Soontobe60 · 22/06/2022 06:24

SpookyButTrue · 22/06/2022 04:39

Seed oils are so bad for you they should be avoided. They are fine for running engines but in the human body they destroy cells.

Been on the pop tonight?

User46489 · 22/06/2022 06:11

It's similar to the eggs, YABU

girlmom21 · 22/06/2022 06:05

They'll have thousands of products whose labels needs updating, and they'll need to print tens of thousands of said labels. It takes time. Considering the oil is an ingredient in these items, the change shouldn't be enough to harm almost anyone. They're also clearly making consumers aware.

A few months ago there was a similar thing with them having to cage free range chickens for a while.

PAFMO · 22/06/2022 06:03

Moonshine5 · 22/06/2022 03:29

The post is 100% legitimate.
Labeled as one ingredient contains a different one.
Personally attacking me for "running off" just because you agree with this practice is low.

The article is legitimate.
Your interpretation of it is not.
As others have pointed out. Nobody is filling up bottles of olive oil with rapeseed and telling you it's olive oil. Your oven chips may have been coated with rapeseed instead of sunflower.
Nothing to see here, move on.

NumberTheory · 22/06/2022 05:59

BarbaraofSeville · 22/06/2022 05:19

I'm confused. Where does olive oil come into it?

The issue is:

Crisp manufacturer (for example) has a load of pre-printed crisp packets that list sunflower oil in the ingredients but they can't get sunflower oil or the price has increased so they're switching to rapeseed oil, but they're going to still use the crisp packets that say sunflower oil to avoid the cost and waste of ditching those crisp packets for new ones that list rapeseed oil on the ingredients.

Entirely sensible and a non issue IMHO.

^^ Not only a matter of avoiding ditching the packaging but also getting new labelling printed up in some cases would not be possible in a reasonable time frame (or swapping back and forward would be too costly), meaning that all the other food that goes into creating the product could be wasted because they can't use the type of oil listed on the packaging.

Given that Russia's blockade of Ukraine's ports is affecting a lot more than sunflower oil and there are big concerns about food shortages, this sort of waste, for the want of the correct wording printed on the packet, would be appaling.

The notices and communication about this should be prominent and in particular there should be targeting towards people most at risk of negative consequences (e.g. those with allergies). But that doesn't mean it isn't a sensible, short term approach to a difficult situation.

byvirtue · 22/06/2022 05:55

I doubt most people actually look at the labels op since the UK is one of the biggest consumers of ultra processed foods and our supermarkets are stacked high with them.

Seed oils are not good for you (seeds are fine), they are processed at high heats which changes the chemical constituents and the effect on the body. Cold pressed oils are preferable.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 22/06/2022 05:31

Oddly enough I've just eaten a packet of own-brand wotsits that I know have had an oil substitution, because suppliers are doing their best to let us know wherever possible when changes have had to be made. Tasted fine, by the way.

Sometimes we just have to struggle through these terrible hardships that war can bring…

Tesco's and fake labels - totally legit
BarbaraofSeville · 22/06/2022 05:19

I'm confused. Where does olive oil come into it?

The issue is:

Crisp manufacturer (for example) has a load of pre-printed crisp packets that list sunflower oil in the ingredients but they can't get sunflower oil or the price has increased so they're switching to rapeseed oil, but they're going to still use the crisp packets that say sunflower oil to avoid the cost and waste of ditching those crisp packets for new ones that list rapeseed oil on the ingredients.

Entirely sensible and a non issue IMHO.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 22/06/2022 05:14

SpookyButTrue · 22/06/2022 04:39

Seed oils are so bad for you they should be avoided. They are fine for running engines but in the human body they destroy cells.

You'll have already been avoiding every single product that this information relates to, then. What's the relevance of your comment when we're discussing the replacement of a seed oil with (for the most part) another seed oil? Unless you just wanted to evangelise. Or you thought sunflower oil was made from petals…

lightand · 22/06/2022 05:00

Moonshine5 · 22/06/2022 03:09

That reason doesn't make it acceptable to lie. To brand something as olive oil when in fact it is rapeseed oil

I sort of see where you are coming from, but they are actually being upfront. Saying they havent got time to change the whole packaging. And telling us that they have substituted a part of what you are about to eat, assuming you still want to buy it.

They are providing the information, for us to make an informed choice.

InChocolateWeTrust · 22/06/2022 04:52

Seed oils are so bad for you they should be avoided

Eh? Humans have been eating seeds for thousands of years they are a great source of fats for vegetarians

RoseGoldEagle · 22/06/2022 04:50

Sounds like the most sensible option given the circumstances. You’re not misinformed- you’ve literally been informed, so you can avoid these products if you want to.

SpookyButTrue · 22/06/2022 04:39

Seed oils are so bad for you they should be avoided. They are fine for running engines but in the human body they destroy cells.

NumberTheory · 22/06/2022 04:32

Moonshine5 · 22/06/2022 03:19

@NumberTheory
Do you work for a supermarket?

No. I work for a food bank.

CherryReid · 22/06/2022 04:12

Surely you have heard about food shortages on the news? It's going to get much worse before we're finished in a year or twos time.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 22/06/2022 04:04

Both the supermarkets I use have had big signs up at the entrance explaining this ever since they had to start doing it. I'm very keen on accurate labelling because I'm a coeliac, but what they're doing makes sense to me.

MintJulia · 22/06/2022 03:55

It isn't lying, they have made it plain oils may be substituted. Take oven chips as an example.Some oven chips now have rapeseed oil rather than sunflower oil on them.
The manufacturers don't know from one week to the next whether they will have sunflower oil, and use rapeseed oil as a backup. However, the plastic bags with the ingredients on are ordered and manufactured in their millions in advance. Waiting for new bags to be proofed and manufactured would hold up production and add cost.
So if you want food supply to be uninterrupted and as cheap as possible, accept generic labelling.

WiddlinDiddlin · 22/06/2022 03:54

But thats what this announcement from FSA/FSS and the supermarkets etc is about, informing you. You are not misinformed if you read it.

If you sit on mumsnet pulling bullshit out of thin air, then yeah, you're misinformed, thats on you.

Moonshine5 · 22/06/2022 03:53

Aligning it with price rises is unethical.

OP posts:
Moonshine5 · 22/06/2022 03:51

Would prefer a label to not misinform. Most people are under the misapprehension that labels are used to inform which ingredients are used not which ones should be.

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddlin · 22/06/2022 03:44

Well why didn't you read about it properly first, before posting on mumsnet?

www.food.gov.uk/news-alerts/news/fsa-and-fss-advise-consumers-on-substitution-of-ingredients-in-certain-food-products-to-avoid-food-supply-disruption

You've stated they're substituting rapeseed oil for olive oil - that is not happening. Kicking up a big dramatic fuss about something that isn't actually happening .. makes you look a bit of a tit!

Just avoid processed foods that are labelled as sunflower oil if you have an issue with rapeseed (most likely to be used as we produce it here in the UK) or the other substitutes.

Or would you prefer empty shelves/price increases?

Moonshine5 · 22/06/2022 03:29

The post is 100% legitimate.
Labeled as one ingredient contains a different one.
Personally attacking me for "running off" just because you agree with this practice is low.

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddlin · 22/06/2022 03:21

The FSA have also done a risk assessment so you can read that and understand whats going on and how to avoid these products if you need to.

You know, instead of running off to Mumsnet with 1% of the story and looking like a bit of a tit.

www.food.gov.uk/research/food-allergy-and-intolerance-research/rapid-risk-assessment-on-the-risk-of-allergic-reactions-in-uk-consumers-if-sunflower-oil-is-substituted-with-certain-vegetable-0

Swipe left for the next trending thread