Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School ties

83 replies

FarewellNoel · 21/06/2022 20:09

DD's school (primary) are insisting all pupils, including those with SEN wear ties at all times in school. DD tells me their classroom is 'boiling' and that the thermometer on the teacher's desk suggested it was above 30 last week. Am I unreasonable to send her in without a tie when temps are predicted to be in excess of 25? Currently around a quarter of parents persistently send their child in without one, with another 10% or so not sending them in with one on hot days. The school is actively cracking down though and kids have been told off today for not wearing them.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Brefugee · 24/06/2022 07:28

Also my question for fans of uniforms: how do you think countries that don't have school uniform (and, indeed, encourage individuality in their pupils in terms of dress and hairstyle/-colour) manage to have a workforce of Stiff Collared Judges and so on? Bollocks is it about "preparing them for the world of work" and is about control.

MassiveSalad22 · 23/06/2022 20:04

YANBU, my school had ties for that age but summer uniform was open-neck blouses with no tie. I’m sure there must have been an equivalent for boys too. There’s no need for ties at all let alone in summer in primary!

orwellwasright · 23/06/2022 19:42

Ties are ridiculous. The world of work is moving away from them so any school that insists on them is completely out of touch.

Is this a state primary or an academy? Most LA primaries wouldn't even have shirts let alone ties. I can't think of a single one round here that doesn't have polo shirts.

orwellwasright · 23/06/2022 19:39

MuppetsRus · 21/06/2022 22:08

I think your attitude is a sign of the complete snowflake society we've become. We all used to wear ties to primary and secondary school in the 80s and 90s (and no doubt before) and I never heard anyone moan amount it in the hot weather 🤷‍♀️.

That's weird. I distinctly recall primaries not even having uniform in the 80s.

cantkeepawayforever · 23/06/2022 19:36

@motogirl

Apologies. I realise that in hastening to point out that it is not necessarily possible for all children to wear the standard uniform, I may have managed to give the impression that all autistic children can't.

Many will be able to. For some, it will be the least worst of conflicting options (different uniform vs discomfort of standard uniform). For others, it will be impossible. To be honest, I would prefer all school uniforms to be designed sufficiently flexibly that there isn't a specific 'adapted uniform', but instead either a range from within which everyone can find an option to suit OR that all uniforms are comfortable. The classic 'polo shirt, sweatshirt and some kind of plain bottoms' primary uniform, for example, is one within which the vast majority of children can find something to meet their needs. A strict secondary uniform of blazer, stiff collared shirt, tie, tailored skirt / trousers with stiff waistband - less so.

HappyHappyHermit · 23/06/2022 18:16

It really does help @Simonjt , I speak from experience!

Simonjt · 23/06/2022 18:03

Its just a tie, not wearing a tie and having a top button undone won’t make someone feel cooler.

motogirl · 23/06/2022 18:01

@cantkeepawayforever

My dd is autistic and the worst possible thing would be for her to stand out by having a different uniform. She's worn normal school uniform throughout including tying a tie. Not all autistic children are the same but none want to stand out as special needs!

IstayedForTheFeminism · 23/06/2022 17:58

Do you expect mainstream, secondary pupils to wear polo shirts?

Why wouldn't they? Confused DS1s mainstream secondary had polo shirts.

MajorCarolDanvers · 23/06/2022 17:50

Absolute madness to make anyone where a tie in hot temps.

Our schools we have a choice of shirt & tie or polo shirt (all year round). Additionally in the summer some of the girls wear gingham school dresses.

We are in Scotland and almost never get temps above 22C

Bickles · 23/06/2022 17:48

I would adapt it. Sew the clip on tie to a piece of elastic - loose fitting.
DS has had a tie as part of his uniform since age 3. As long as the short sleeved shirt is overly big (so loose collar) and then the tie goes under the collar, it’s fine. He now has a proper tie- he cracked tying it himself quickly enough and can have it on loose. He doesn’t do the top button on his shirts.

IstayedForTheFeminism · 23/06/2022 17:47

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 23/06/2022 17:38

I don't know any men who wear them either.
And if you look I didn't mention ties in my "I think uniform should be" list. Because I don't think anyone should have to wear them.
Unless dresses are compulsory for girls then it's not a direct comparison to say should they be compulsory for boys. I think they should be an option for both.

Apologies, your comment sounded very much like it was saying that just as many females as males (or nobody at all) traditionally wear ties - and that it was nonsense to suggest that there is any difference.

I agree that far fewer men are wearing them now, but surely you've seen men in a formal setting (or newsreaders on TV) wearing them?

I agree that they should be got rid of - horrible unnecessary things - but I was referring to schools that have them as compulsory for both boys and girls, and was making a comparison as to what would happen if they made a traditionally female-only garment compulsory also for the boys.

Haha no. I just meant that because something was traditionally male it didn't mean women couldn't wear it.
But in the interests of fairness then if its compulsory for one it should be compulsory for all (sen excepted). So if girls have to wear skirts whether they like them or not, boys should also have to wear skirts.
Make it all optional (from a list, not no uniform at all) imo.

DS2 was checking the wording on his school uniform list recently because the girls can wear skirts but he can't wear shorts and it's hot. Sadly skirts were listed as "girls" uniform so he can't wear one. I told him to identify as a girl on hot days

Puffalicious · 23/06/2022 17:45

cantkeepawayforever · 21/06/2022 20:22

Many autistic children have sensory differences that make close-fitting, formal and ‘scratchy’ clothes intolerable to them. Any school that doesn’t adapt uniform to meet their needs (eg no ties, soft collars, a variation in waistband) would be acting in a discriminatory fashion.

They don't need to make such adjustments. In my school children with ASN can loosen the tie/ remove blazer in class. Their shirts can be as soft as they can find. Do you expect mainstream, secondary pupils to wear polo shirts?

I say this as mother to a child with ASD and ADHD.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 23/06/2022 17:38

I don't know any men who wear them either.
And if you look I didn't mention ties in my "I think uniform should be" list. Because I don't think anyone should have to wear them.
Unless dresses are compulsory for girls then it's not a direct comparison to say should they be compulsory for boys. I think they should be an option for both.

Apologies, your comment sounded very much like it was saying that just as many females as males (or nobody at all) traditionally wear ties - and that it was nonsense to suggest that there is any difference.

I agree that far fewer men are wearing them now, but surely you've seen men in a formal setting (or newsreaders on TV) wearing them?

I agree that they should be got rid of - horrible unnecessary things - but I was referring to schools that have them as compulsory for both boys and girls, and was making a comparison as to what would happen if they made a traditionally female-only garment compulsory also for the boys.

IstayedForTheFeminism · 23/06/2022 17:11

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 23/06/2022 14:55

What nonsense. Why are ties "male" other than historically that's who wore them. Either ties for all, or ties for none/optional.
Personally I think uniform should be
Trousers/skirt/shorts and polo top/shirt.
Summer dress.
Jumper

Not just historically. How many women do you see nowadays wearing ties when dressed formally/in workwear? Of course, anybody is free to wear them, but they are not culturally female clothing in the UK. They look even more silly when a woman/girl has a big chest.

Why not tell the boys they have to wear the summer dresses too, explaining to them that it doesn't matter which sex historically/currently wears them? Good luck with that!

I don't know any men who wear them either.
And if you look I didn't mention ties in my "I think uniform should be" list. Because I don't think anyone should have to wear them.
Unless dresses are compulsory for girls then it's not a direct comparison to say should they be compulsory for boys. I think they should be an option for both.

Brefugee · 23/06/2022 15:06

have not RTFT but: i think the UK obsession with ridiculous school uniforms is completely batshit.
Not allowed to take off blazers? Have to wear a tie? and all the rest.
Even our partners wander around in short sleeved open necked shirts in summer. And we are a horribly traditional company in so many ways.

HappyHappyHermit · 23/06/2022 15:02

Ties are completely unnecessary, I agree with simple comfy uniforms, but ties look and are silly for young children.

SummerLobelia · 23/06/2022 14:59

cantkeepawayforever · 21/06/2022 20:25

Not being able to cope with specific restrictive items of uniform is quite common, therefore, and it is wholly unreasonable to say that a child with sensory needs will wear excruciatingly uncomfortable uniform ‘if they have to’. In all inclusive and reasonable schools, they rightly don’t have to.

This, My DS cannot do up his top button. He simply can't. If you want a screaming meltdown with him ending up a vomiting wibbling mess rocking under a table then yes he can do it up.

Thank fuck the school understand this though.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 23/06/2022 14:55

What nonsense. Why are ties "male" other than historically that's who wore them. Either ties for all, or ties for none/optional.
Personally I think uniform should be
Trousers/skirt/shorts and polo top/shirt.
Summer dress.
Jumper

Not just historically. How many women do you see nowadays wearing ties when dressed formally/in workwear? Of course, anybody is free to wear them, but they are not culturally female clothing in the UK. They look even more silly when a woman/girl has a big chest.

Why not tell the boys they have to wear the summer dresses too, explaining to them that it doesn't matter which sex historically/currently wears them? Good luck with that!

Lindy2 · 22/06/2022 14:22

I would actively avoid a Primary school that has shirts and ties as a uniform. I don't like to see young children having to wear such formal uniform. The best learning is done when children are comfortable and Primary aged children should be up and about being active.

Thankfully our local Primary has comfortable but smart polo shirts all year round.

Our Secondary has shirts and ties for Autumn and Spring term but with the option of an open neck polo shirt in the summer. In hot weather blazers and ties can be removed.

Common sense really.

UndertheCedartree · 22/06/2022 14:18

Isaidnoalready · 22/06/2022 10:37

In the 80s children with sensory issues were put in special school children from a poor home life were put into our local special school too special needs children were also locked up in the family home back in those days too we had a cousin somewhere with down syndrome we visited once she was forcibly removed and shut away from us my mother cried on the way home and we never visited again I would like to think society has moved on from this

BTW this was local policy not national before I get the inevitable pile on pretty much any child who acted out was removed from main stream and put in the special school to be "corrected" some came back some didn't

Sorry meant to say that is very sad about your cousin 💐

UndertheCedartree · 22/06/2022 14:17

Isaidnoalready · 22/06/2022 10:37

In the 80s children with sensory issues were put in special school children from a poor home life were put into our local special school too special needs children were also locked up in the family home back in those days too we had a cousin somewhere with down syndrome we visited once she was forcibly removed and shut away from us my mother cried on the way home and we never visited again I would like to think society has moved on from this

BTW this was local policy not national before I get the inevitable pile on pretty much any child who acted out was removed from main stream and put in the special school to be "corrected" some came back some didn't

Absolutely. This is why I can't stand the 'in my day we just gone on with it' well, yes you were able to, those that couldn't were excluded.

UndertheCedartree · 22/06/2022 14:14

riesenrad · 22/06/2022 09:57

When did we first start dictating that schoolgirls must wear male clothes on a daily basis - and be disciplined if they don't

Utter madness.

At ds's ex-secondary the girls don't have to wear ties, which obviously causes resentment among the boys. At least they don't have blazers. It is crazy though - but I think the general silliness about uniforms needs to be sorted out, not just this point. I don't disagree with uniforms in theory, but I think the rules should be simple and stop making a fuss about how big a heel is, for example! Also stop making parents buy expensive branded uniform when supermarket options will do.

I completely agree, it has gone too far in many secondary schools and even some primaries by the sounds of it.

At my DD's primary they wear a polo shirt, school skirt/trousers etc and a jumper/cardigan. They have logoed polos and jumpers/cardigans but plain colour is also fine. Any sensible shoes can be worn (my DD wears trainers) and they don't make a fuss if someone slightly deviates from the official uniform - i e my DD had pink sparkly trainers when she started and she wears leggings sometimes. As long as the DC are in sensible clothes and shoes for their day it's fine. The school does very well academically and behaviour wise so personally I don't see what is wrong with a relaxed/flexible uniform policy.

UndertheCedartree · 22/06/2022 14:05

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 22/06/2022 08:37

We were always told that wearing uniform/smart clothes was good practice for when we were older and in the workplace, but a lot of workplaces now dress more casually and fewer and fewer men wear ties anyway.

What I can't fathom is why so many schools make girls wear ties as well. The tie has never been a standard garment worn by women, so it just seems so very random. It would make as much sense as them expecting boys to wear tights under shorts, or full one-piece costumes during swimming lessons - but nobody would ever stand for that. When did we first start dictating that schoolgirls must wear male clothes on a daily basis - and be disciplined if they don't?

I completely agree with that. I've always thought it very random getting girls to wear ties.

SquatBetty · 22/06/2022 13:20

Ties in primary school are utterly ridiculous.