Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can you change your accent / people’s perception of your background?

81 replies

Canicani · 21/06/2022 18:49

I truly feel my career would be more successful if people thought I was ‘posh’, in a nutshell. And probably if I was a man tbh.

I know I should think f them and I know it shouldn’t matter but essentially, it does - in my industry anyway. I love my job and I have worked so hard and don’t want to do anything else.

I’m not looking to convince people I’m aristocratic but I’d like to blend in more.

Any tips? Please don’t tear me to shreds!

OP posts:
summermornings · 21/06/2022 20:15

The problem is keeping up the pretence, you will inevitably mispronounce or use the wrong vowel sound. It will be exhausting try to keep that up and worrying if someone will question you.

Forcing any change in your voice, you are likely to slip up somewhere. Think Elizabeth Holmes who lowered her voice to sound more authoritative.

Also surely your family will question your new accent and may even feel a little hurt at your rejection of it.

maltravers · 21/06/2022 20:10

While you shouldn’t need to iron out an accent, I can see it might give you confidence to do so. However, I would try to tone down your current accent not adopt a fake posh one. I can hear Rachel Reeves the politician is doing the former, good for her!

123ZYX · 21/06/2022 20:08

Help19376 · 21/06/2022 19:46

The whole idea of 'neutralising' your accent really irritates me - what people mean is adopting a particular SE English accent - not neutral at all, just an accent from a different region to you. The fact it is considered superior in some circles (my job is the same) and that we feel pressured to assimilate in order to get on is cause for further irritation so you have my empathy.

I like the poster above's suggestion - don't aim to be them, you never will be - even if you do perfect their drawling RP, you presumably won't be skiing / yachting / playing polo anytime soon, or suddenly have gone to boarding school. It can be equally grating to be the 'exception to the rule' colleague who gets trotted out as an example of how if you can do it surely so can anyone less fortunate, but it's probably the better of the 2 options.

I don't think this is entirely true. Having moved around the country in adulthood, my accent has naturally got less strong, but definitely isn't SE - my short vowels make it fairly obvious which region I'm from.

It's neutralised enough that a new colleague assumed I was private school educated with a middle class background, and was shocked when she found out I'm from the same city as her, with a compressive school education and with parents who did very similar, working class jobs to hers.

I think drama lessons as a teenager helped with how I come across - even when my accent was stronger, I was confident I could speak clearly and confidently to any size group of people. Something like Toastmasters might help? To be honest, it doesn't feel like my sort of thing, but if public speaking is important to you, it might be worth a look.

LittleSundayTeatime · 21/06/2022 19:48

A colleague has gradually changed/muted her accent over the last two years. Not many people have noticed as it been so gradual but we'd not worked in the same team together since before lockdown, so I noticed, but didn't say anything. She asked one evening though over a glass of wine, if I noticed and I said I had. She told me she'd used www.amazon.co.uk/Get-Rid-Your-Accent-Beginners/dp/B07F19T1QS/ref=mp_s_a_1_3?crid=1QRIQTEZ91M0H&keywords=accent+james&qid=1655836902&sprefix=accent+james%2Caps%2C202&sr=8-3

Help19376 · 21/06/2022 19:46

The whole idea of 'neutralising' your accent really irritates me - what people mean is adopting a particular SE English accent - not neutral at all, just an accent from a different region to you. The fact it is considered superior in some circles (my job is the same) and that we feel pressured to assimilate in order to get on is cause for further irritation so you have my empathy.

I like the poster above's suggestion - don't aim to be them, you never will be - even if you do perfect their drawling RP, you presumably won't be skiing / yachting / playing polo anytime soon, or suddenly have gone to boarding school. It can be equally grating to be the 'exception to the rule' colleague who gets trotted out as an example of how if you can do it surely so can anyone less fortunate, but it's probably the better of the 2 options.

SnackSizeRaisin · 21/06/2022 19:35

It's definitely worth toning down a regional accent to avoid being judged on it. I can instantly tell who's a nurse and who's a doctor by the way they speak. It's a split second judgement - have never been wrong.
As for cultural capital..that's the failing of the state education system where classics and history were out of fashion (perhaps starting to come in again now). I'm sure there are shortcuts to learning this stuff as I doubt the toffs actually know that much more. Maybe watch some documentaries or read some books on specific things that get mentioned?

HandScreen · 21/06/2022 19:32

You can certainly neutralise your accent, yes.

Cyberworrier · 21/06/2022 19:31

Please talk to me about cultural capital... www.mumsnet.com/Talk/_chat/4541675-please-talk-to-me-about-cultural-capital

This was a recent thread, not sure if it's the one I was thinking of but has some interesting thoughts.

You sound like an intelligent and successful person, so please don't feel inadequate around posher colleagues. Despite their cultural capital, chances are many of them are less intelligent and interesting than you, they just went to a different school and had different experiences. (I say this as someone who knows many dull as dishwater people from privileged backgrounds!)

Also, as someone who sort of floats around people from very varied backgrounds, in my experience many public school types have quite limited knowledge about some issues and can be a little ivory tower, detached from reality. Not to bash public school types, but just to say everyone is human and has areas they are more or less knowledgeable about!

Spinner12345 · 21/06/2022 19:30

My accent has muted a lot over the past ten years - generally because people mocked me because of it. It’s all well and good saying represent your area/heritage but when people see it as a joke it’s difficult to start a career

motogirl · 21/06/2022 19:29

By the way, it really doesn't matter your background, if you come across as confident that is. People at Dp's work and my dp's family all assumed I was public school educated like him, but I'm not, sink London comp! I do have good diction (I sing choral music, it really helps) and I am confident socially. My work all think I'm posh, I'm not at all (nor is dp despite his education)

Headabovetheparakeet · 21/06/2022 19:27

What accent do you have?

motogirl · 21/06/2022 19:26

I think diction matters more than accent. Pronounce words properly without dropping letters and you will be taken more seriously. With clothing wearing timeless classics neither too long or short if a skirt in more muted colours again demonstrates a touch of class without over doing it - and never have the brand of clothing obvious, that's tacky!

Thejoyfulstar · 21/06/2022 19:25

Haven't read the replies. I think the most important thing is to be articulate with a broad vocabulary, and to speak clearly using proper grammar. What you say is more important than your accent.

brookstar · 21/06/2022 19:25

Canicani · 21/06/2022 19:21

@brookstar did you pick things up or just become more secure?

Both really.

I picked things up as i went along and to be honest I'm still doing that!! Cultural capital can definitely be learned but I think there also needs to be a level of confidence to accept that you are who you are ..... but I get that's hard. I suffered from imposter syndrome something shocking and still have my moments!

Canicani · 21/06/2022 19:21

@brookstar did you pick things up or just become more secure?

OP posts:
brookstar · 21/06/2022 19:20

Having read your update it's definitely cultural capital that you're talking about!!

I've been in your position before and it is tricky!

brookstar · 21/06/2022 19:19

My accent has mellowed over the years but that mainly because I've moved around and now live somewhere different to where I was brought up.
I still sound northern but more generic northern rather than a specific accent. I didn't try but just happened naturally.

That, alongside where I live and the job I does often means people think I'm posh when I actually grew up in one of the most deprived areas of the uk.

My DH was privately educated and has a very strong regional accent.

I think it's difficult to completely change who you are though and I don't think you should have to.

FourTeaFallOut · 21/06/2022 19:14

Don't aim for assimilation then, you won't be accepted because the bar for entry was set at birth. Aim for intimidating, or remarkable, or ruthless or whatever marker for success sets you out in your industry.

Canicani · 21/06/2022 19:13

@Cyberworrier maybe cultural capital is it!

books I haven’t read, places I haven’t been, social signifiers I don’t know exist until I’ve got them wrong and the dreaded ‘where did you go to school question’.

my role requires networking etc and I feel somewhat on the backfoot.

OP posts:
Cyberworrier · 21/06/2022 19:11

But OP, regardless of your accent, you are never going to be in the actual ex public school club (which definitely is a thing unfortunately in some places) so why not just work with what you have?
Regarding conversations etc, what do you struggle with? There was a thread a while back about cultural capital, is that what you mean? (radio 4 was a popular suggestion on that thread)

summermornings · 21/06/2022 19:10

I suspect you could neutralise your accent to an extent but not acquire a new one. Unless you grow up with it, it’s hard to mimic and others would always be able to see straight through it

As long as you have a clear speaking voice and a good pace, I honestly would not go down the route of trying to change your accent. Think of those with your accent or other regional accents. Wouldn’t you like to see more of this in your industry? It all starts with someone

Canicani · 21/06/2022 19:07

@catandcoffee the British public school brigade. In my mind - I had to work twice as hard to get to the same place as them but I just don’t feel accepted.

OP posts:
Cyberworrier · 21/06/2022 19:07

I think people can sometimes smell out people trying too hard/trying to be something they are not. You sound like a great and successful person, perhaps your energies would be better spent on raising your self-esteem. I do understand that there can be a bias towards people with certain backgrounds or that people gravitate towards people similar to themselves, and that is annoying and difficult. However, I don't think putting on an accent or trying to change yourself to fit in would be effective. Work on your confidence.

Canicani · 21/06/2022 19:06

Thank you both!

I don’t want pretend to be someone I’m not, perhaps just polish myself up a bit to boost my confidence. There’s lots of chat and etiquette I don’t seem to ‘get’!

OP posts:
catandcoffee · 21/06/2022 19:06

We need more information about who you're trying to fit in with....clothes, accent ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread